Meeting Public Comments

Subcommittee meeting and times are as follows:

A bill for an act requiring proof of citizenship or lawful presence in the country for a student to be classified for in-state tuition and fees at a regents institution or community college.(See HF 2320.)

Subcommittee members: Collins-CH, Scheetz, Wheeler

Date: Monday, January 29, 2024

Time: 4:30 PM - 5:30 PM

Location: RM 103, Sup. Ct. Chamber

Names and comments are public records. Remaining information is considered a confidential record.

Comments Submitted:

Download Comments

01-26-2024

Mayra Hernandez-Franke []

I am opposed to this bill. This bill will create a lot of harm to students who are seeking higher education as a means to self independence. Students who are non citizens may still have the possibility of become citizens. Hindering their ability to pay instate tuition now will benefit no one as these students will be joining the workforce anyway. Preventing students from higher education will decrease the number of professionals in the workforce in the future. This means less doctors, engineers, lawyers, technicians, policemen, skilled laborers, etc. This bill will hinder Iowa's economy in the long run. Citizens overall will be hurt by this bill.

01-27-2024

Hannah Griggs []

I oppose this bill because it would make Iowa a less inclusive place to live. As a white woman who spent my most formative years in Iowa, I know how the lack of racial diversity has impacted my cross cultural literacy. I lament that I did not have much exposure to multiracial diversity sooner in my life or education. Please do not pass this racist and xenophobic bill. I want to live in an Iowa that grows in diversity and inclusivity.

01-27-2024

Lesly De La Cruz - Luevano []

While the intention behind HF 2128 may seem to prioritize legal residency, its implementation could exacerbate existing inequalities. Denying access to instate tuition rates based on citizenship status limits educational opportunities, hindering socioeconomic mobility. Education should be a tool for empowerment, not exclusion. Additionally, fostering diversity enriches educational experiences and strengthens communities. By embracing inclusivity, Iowa can cultivate a more vibrant and equitable future for all its residents. In addition to promoting inclusivity and equal access to education, rejecting HF 2128 is crucial for several reasons:1. Economic Impact: Restricting access to higher education based on citizenship status could lead to a decline in enrollment, resulting in lost tuition revenue for institutions and decreased economic activity within the state.2. Workforce Development: Access to affordable education allows all residents, regardless of citizenship status, to contribute to Iowa's workforce and economy. Limiting educational opportunities could hinder the state's ability to meet future labor demands and impede economic growth.3. Social Cohesion: Excluding certain groups from educational opportunities fosters division and alienation within communities. Embracing diversity and inclusion in education promotes social cohesion and strengthens the fabric of Iowa's society.4. Legal and Ethical Considerations: Denying instate tuition rates based on citizenship status may raise legal and ethical concerns regarding equal protection under the law and the right to education. Upholding these principles is essential for maintaining the integrity of Iowa's educational system and upholding human rights standards.In summary, rejecting HF 2128 is not only a matter of fairness and justice but also a pragmatic choice that benefits Iowa's economy, society, and future prospects.

01-27-2024

Dafny Hernandez []

I am a Junior at the Univeristy of Iowa and I oppose this bill. As a student who is a US Citizen, I believe all students who have called Iowa their home for many, many years should be entitled to instate tuition just like me. We are all paying taxes to the state of Iowa, and higher education is already expensive enough that many students can not afford. Passing this bill will hurt Iowas economy and its citizens. We can not create even more barriers for students who desire to become professionals and invest in Iowas economy.

01-27-2024

Kay Pence []

If a student with proof of residency, is smart enough and motivated enough to attend college let them have instate tuition. To require proof of citizenship is just mean spirited. Charging out of state tuition to an Iowa resident may cause them to drop out of school or move to a more welcoming state. Don't drive smart young people out of Iowa.

01-27-2024

Susan Meenan [Quad Cities Interfaith ]

This bill seems mean spirited. Why should an Iowa student meeting residency requirements not be granted instate tuition? Why is citizenship even an issue? Just seems to be another barrier to someone who wants an education to better themselves and be a contributing member of society.

01-27-2024

Tyler Franke []

As a citizen myself who received instate tuition, in state tuition should be provided to everyone who lives in the state of Iowa. People who are not citizens also pay taxes, so if the state of Iowa is benefiting from their taxes, they should be entitled to benefit from in state tuition.

01-27-2024

Gabriela Fuentes []

Please VOTE NO on this bill. This is racist, and very harmful to all people who are just trying to get better opportunities in life. Your job as representatives is providing those opportunities instead of taking them away.Rep. CollinsCH, and Rep. Wheeler say they are "prolife", but they are pro birth, since they don't care about the quality of life of people, and add barriers to access education in the state. Please be coherent with your discourses, and if you really care about people's lives, don't take opportunities away from them.

01-28-2024

Sheila Juarez []

this is so unfair nobody should have to go through this.People from other countries come to America to be able to get that further education that they dream of and this law just stops them from that.

01-28-2024

K G [Spanish and ELL teacher]

I oppose HF2128. If we want Iowa to attract workers and see less young people leaving this state, we need to keep giving everyone access to affordable education. Access to quality and affordable education needs to include everyone regardless of citizenship status. The people this would harm are Iowans who will stay in this state and contribute to its growth and contribute their community. I strongly oppose this bill.

01-28-2024

Patricia Welch []

This is a bad bill. What is your point in introducing it, except to play to antiimmigrant prejudice?I am an ESL teacher, who has worked with newcomers to this country for the past 25 years. My students have been hardworking, highly motivated and, almost without exception, assets to this country.How do you expect them to acquire English and job skills at community colleges, if you put tuition costs out of reach? Iowa needs workers, and workers need education and/or training.Rejecting this cruel bill seems like a nobrainer to me.

01-28-2024

Fatima Najar []

Students that live within the state they are applying for higher education should be entitled to in state tuition regardless of their citizenship status. Providing equity in education for immigrant students helps provide a path out of poverty as well as open opportunities. Immigrant students should NOT be targeted by passing bills that make it difficult to obtain a career.

01-28-2024

Loxi Hopkins []

Please drop this bill. Iowa needs these educated workers. There is no reason not to let students that save to go to College. Be and work hard to stay there. There is no valid reason for this bill. Many of these students would be DACA if they could be.

01-28-2024

Carolina Diaz []

I oppose this bill. Students want an opportunity to educate themselves. By passing this law, it creates further barriers they must face. These student are educated and some will strive to be citizens.

01-28-2024

Alek Jok []

Understandably, immigration is not only apart of U.S culture, it is the foundation. All immigrants should be protected and provided equal opportunities. Most importantly education so they too can invest back into the economy. Everyone is an immigrant, whether first or 10th generation. I oppose of any Bill that does not protect Immigrants, especially children and dependent young adults.

01-28-2024

Alma Puga []

Dear Mr. CollinsCH,Mr. Scheetz, and Mr. Wheeler:House File 2128 has the potential to dissuade students from pursuing higher education, impeding both societal advancement and economic growth. The verification process may result in discriminatory practices, including bias or profiling. Furthermore, the bill goes against the principals of providing an equitable and diverse learning environment.

01-28-2024

Vanessa Marcano-Kelly []

I oppose this bill because it's aimed to exclude even more people from our already exclusionary and restrictive higher education systems. If Iowa wants to keep and attract talent, and produce a competitive workforce, we need to make education accessible to all those who have an interest in it. If we want a workforce that is ready to also buy homes, get married and have children in our state, why make it more difficult and saddle them with more unnecessary debt right after college due to an unequal tuition system being imposed to students who because of different reasons may have different immigration statuses even though they have lived in Iowa most of their life? This bill is unfairly aimed at a very specific community, and it's aiming to rob Iowa of workforce, it's aiming to take away economic activity and taxes from Iowa by driving away potential students, and it's seeking to impose more debt on students, thus contributing to the current student debt crisis. I urge legislators to vote against this counterproductive bill.

01-28-2024

Ashlyn Ruiz []

I do not support bill HF 2128, and I will not be supporting your campaign for reelection in any shape way or form. Every Iowan deserves an equal chance to attend a college and university for the betterment of their community, this state and most of all this country. Attending college as a low income student is difficult enough as it is. Increasing the cost will only make it harder. Is this truly the legacy you want to leave behind? Making the lives of your constituents harder and more difficult, stripping them of their right to attend college at an affordable cost?

01-28-2024

Mercedes Guevara Yepez []

This bill is absolutely ridiculous and invasive. Politicians seem to forget that the country was founded on IMMIGRANTS. This country used to be great, now its not even a place I would like to have my own children in.

01-28-2024

Fabiola Schirrmeister []

I oppose the house file 2128:Why do we want to exclude non citizens or undocumented immigrants to affordable education? This is a hateful bill targeting the immigrant community and the next generation of professionals. Did you know that Iowa thrives with the help of immigrants: Immigrants in lowa have contributed more than a billion dollars in taxes: * Immigrantled households in the state paid $859.2 million in federal taxes and $521.8 million in state and local taxes in 2018.* Undocumented immigrants in lowa paid an estimated $82.5 million in federal taxes and $58.3 million in state and local taxes in 2018.* lowa DACA recipients and DACAeligible individuals paid an estimated $6.3 million in state and local taxes in 2018.As consumers, immigrants add billions of dollars to lowa's economy: lowa residents in immigrantled households had $3.9 billion in spending power (aftertax income) in 2018.Immigrant entrepreneurs in lowa generate tens of millions of dollars in business revenue. 10,918 immigrant business owners accounted for 6 percent of all selfemployed lowa residents in 2018 and generated $172.7 million in business income.Its s important to mention that an undocumented immigrant/worker cant qualify for social security, healthcare, 401k, retirement, medicaid, etc. Why do we want to remove a resident benefit? Its the only thing we can do for them. Help them to get affordable education.I really hope you can discard this awful and hateful bill. Thank you for your attention and I look forward to having an open and honest discussion about this bill. Best Regards, Fabiola Schirrmeister

01-28-2024

Christopher Weihe Vazquez []

I oppose the house file 2128:This proposal is divisive, hateful and makes no sense. Immigrants pay taxes just like you and me. Immigrants live in our community, our neighbors and are the person we sit next to at church. Lets focus on practicing compassion.Why do we want to exclude non citizens or undocumented immigrants to affordable education? This is a hateful bill targeting the immigrant community and the next generation of professionals. Did you know that Iowa thrives with the help of immigrants: Immigrants in lowa have contributed more than a billion dollars in taxes: * Immigrantled households in the state paid $859.2 million in federal taxes and $521.8 million in state and local taxes in 2018.* Undocumented immigrants in lowa paid an estimated $82.5 million in federal taxes and $58.3 million in state and local taxes in 2018.* lowa DACA recipients and DACAeligible individuals paid an estimated $6.3 million in state and local taxes in 2018.As consumers, immigrants add billions of dollars to lowa's economy: lowa residents in immigrantled households had $3.9 billion in spending power (aftertax income) in 2018.Immigrant entrepreneurs in lowa generate tens of millions of dollars in business revenue. 10,918 immigrant business owners accounted for 6 percent of all selfemployed lowa residents in 2018 and generated $172.7 million in business income.Its s important to mention that an undocumented immigrant/worker cant qualify for social security, healthcare, 401k, retirement, medicaid, etc. Why do we want to remove a resident benefit? Its the only thing we can do for them. Help them to get affordable education.I really hope you can discard this awful and hateful bill. Thank you for your attention and I look forward to having an open and honest discussion about this bill. Best Regards, Christopher Weihe Vazquez

01-28-2024

Fatima Rodriguez []

This bill is made to target groups and create more barriers for them. How can we flourish as an economy when people are setting rules like this to prevent diversity and inclusion? Its hard enough as it is. Let the people who actually want to move forward with their lives suffer a little more (this sentence was sarcastic).

01-28-2024

Sister M. Johanna Rickl [Congregation of the Humility of Mary]

Please oppose this bill: HF 2128. It is unfair and unjust to penalize people for the failures of bureaucracy. The terrible dysfunction of the U.S. immigration system makes it nearly impossible for many people to get this documentation despite their good will, effort and expenditure of lots of money. Education for any residents of our state will make it easier for them to contribute to the good of the whole community. We need to help everyone get educated rather than erecting barriers to education. Their money is as good as anyone's to help our education system survive, too. Educated workers are needed for the success of our state's services and a healthy economy. Please encourage education for all and do away with HF 2128!

01-28-2024

Alexa Rodriguez []

I oppose HF 2128 and urge you to as well. College campuses and regent universities already have the ability and DO verify residency for the purpose of instate tuition for ALL applicants. To begin requiring proof of citizenship in addition to all verifying documentation already requested during the application process is xenophobic. ALL RESIDENTS of the state of Iowa deserve to benefit from same instate tuition as citizens.

01-28-2024

Natalia Guerra-Ceron []

Hello, I am a student at North High, and I am tired of constantly having to fight for human rights. One of the reasons why families migrate to the United States is for a better education. Please consider how this will affect future generations. Without a college degree being accessible to undocumented folks, the workforce percentage of immigrants will decrease. Evidence has shown on the data collection "Immigrants in Iowa" americanimmigrationcouncil.org that "126,469 immigrant workers comprised 7 percent of the labor force in 2018. They have also quoted, "Immigrants are vital members of the Iowa labor force across industries." American Immigration Council also establishes that Immigrant workers were most numerous in industries like health care and social assistance, retail trade, educational services, and more. These numbers will no longer be displayed if you pass this bill because of your ignorance. There will be a significant decrease in the workforce. Subcommittee members CollinsCH, Scheetz, and Wheeler, you guys are not the future for upcoming generations; undocumented folks are. They are the future workforce and can continue if you do not pass this bill. Please consider that you will not create a positive impact in the state of Iowa, and acknowledge that you guys can focus on actual issues reoccurring in Iowa. You will not only give more power to white people, although you might not care, but this will also mean there will be less diversity in schools. Without having access to a college degree, many folks will not have financial security as those with a college degree. This has been established on cbs.news.com https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjc6JXZ1YGEAxWfmYkEHRsqBZsQFnoECBEQAw&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cbsnews.com%2Fnews%2Fcollegebestchanceforagoodjobpay20s30s%2F%23%3A%3Atext%3DThat%27s%2520not%2520to%2520say%2520that%2Cdegrees%252C%2520the%2520Georgetown%2520analysis%2520found.&usg=AOvVaw0fugKNQ87FrD9zTQNFGHds&opi=89978449Please consider the lives you will affect for a lifetime, and do not pass this bill.

01-28-2024

Nathalia Pizarro []

There is no need to be depriving students without a citizenship from their education. Those without citizenship are still paying their taxes and are a big contribution to the united states. Not allowing them to get instate tuition makes it harder to attend any college or university. It takes away their privileges of being a resident in the state especially when the individual is being taxed for their physical presence in the state. Those students are still residents in this state.

01-29-2024

Monica Reyes []

I am an undocumented Iowan that graduated from New Hampton High School in 2008. I went to NICC and UNI by paying out of pocket for instate tuition. I had to work 60+ hours to pay for school and I can testify that it was a heavy economic stress, but manageable. If undocumented Iowa high school students were stripped of the opportunity to have access to instate tuition, there would be far less chances of these students to contribute to Iowa's socioeconomic wellness. I highly encourage the subcommittee members to consider the future of our state of Iowa. Access to instate tuition for undocumented students is crucial for the livelihood of all Iowans.

01-29-2024

Monica Reyes []

I oppose this bill. I am an undocumented Iowan that graduated from New Hampton High School in 2008. I went to NICC and UNI by paying out of pocket for instate tuition. I had to work 60+ hours to pay for school and I can testify that it was a heavy economic stress, but manageable. If undocumented Iowa high school students were stripped of the opportunity to have access to instate tuition, there would be far less chances of these students to contribute to Iowa's socioeconomic wellness. I highly encourage the subcommittee members to consider the future of our state of Iowa. Access to instate tuition for undocumented students is crucial for the livelihood of all Iowans.

01-29-2024

Jocelyn Mena [University of Northern Iowa]

Undocumented students who are living in the state of Iowa should not have to prove their citizenship. Instate tuition should be for everybody who lives in the state of Iowa. One can easily show this by providing ones address and showing that they receive important mail to the address. This bill is discriminatory and unnecessary. It is discriminatory because it makes it difficult for undocumented students who statistically are people of color to receive an education especially if they can't receive instate tuition.

01-29-2024

Maxwell Tensen []

I strongly oppose HF 2128. As we all know, undocumented persons are woven into the fabric of or Iowan communities and our culture. To strictly deny them access to higher education via outrageous tuition fees is nothing short of discrimination. This bill systemically prevents a certain minoritized group from receiving benefits available to all other Iowans, and that is inherently wrong.

01-29-2024

Joyce Weddeh []

honestly, a very strange thing to even draw up. very random too. itll be much more understandable if whoever thought of this to require citizenship for private universities but public universities and community colleges? thats not okay. usually, a lot of individuals attend community colleges and public universities because its more affordable for them and their families, lets not take that away. what is it going to do for you guys taking that away for them anyways? especially immigrants?

01-29-2024

John Bowman [former combat veteran]

I have been in Iowa since 1963. I served in the US Army, to include combat in Vietnam, from 1968 to 1970. I graduated from the U of I law school in 1972 and practiced in Iowa until retiring in 2016. I knew of US Army soldiers who were not US citizens, in combat zones who could apply for us citizenship if they were still alive after serving. They would not be able, under this bill, to be granted in state tuition. There is a process for naturalization through US military service. They would not be able to be granted instate tuition while this process took place. Please do not prevent them from paying in state tuition after they have served in the US Armed Forces.

01-29-2024

Nilvia Reyes Rodriguez [DREAM Iowa]

I am fundamentally opposed to this bill, which would not only hurt students like me, but would also hurt Iowa's community colleges and universities, and further amplify an already dire labor market situation. My primary concern is humanitarian. I was undocumented when I started college in 2011. Despite graduating at the top of my class, I did not qualify for any government aid or student loans. I decided to attend the University of Northern Iowa because it was affordable. With instate tuition and a handful of private scholarships, I only had to pay around $500 a month for 10 months a year. Even at this rate, I had to hold 2 jobs in college, working over 60 hours a week at times to afford tuition. This would have been impossible if I had to pay outofstate or even international rates. After leaving and returning several times, I graduated in May 2022 with a B.A. in Public Administration and a minor in History. At this point, I had DACA for almost 10 years, but was still not a citizen. In this time, I worked for a mortgage servicing company, for the State of Iowa, working with Migrant and Seasonal Farmworkers, and most recently and currently, as the Director of Community Impact & Engagement for a philanthropic organization that supports health and human service programs in local communities. I am a tremendous asset to the State of Iowa. I am also not an anomaly. My sister, my friends, people I've met along my professional journey, share a similar story to mine. We were able to obtain higher education because of affordable instate tuition. We have gone on, postgraduation, to serve our state in various capacities. We are tradesmen, social workers, educational counselors, teachers, attorneys, directors, and CEOs. We make up the foundation of Iowa. If you continue to make the State of Iowa an unwelcoming state for immigrants, many of us will leave. You will lose some of the best talent in the state, and you will destroy the ability of younger students hoping to attend Iowa's Community Colleges and Public Universities.That said, I fear that the state of our current state political system doesn't listen to the humanitarian aspects anymore. I urge you to look at the financial toll this will take on Iowa's economy. Let's start with the regent schools, alone. Combined, the three regent schools are down almost 12,000 students. While all three did report a slight uptick in enrollment this year, it is nowhere near enough to reverse years of a downward fall. This bill will further amplify these enrollment issues. On top of this, this bill further burdens higher education institutions with finding the resources to implement a system to keep track of documentation they previously didn't need to. With the budget cuts that are sure to come with declining enrollment, how does the state justify placing an additional burden on our schools?Finally, I cannot overstress how troubling this bill is for our labor market. Iowa needs immigrants. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Iowa had 88,000 job openings as of November 2023. I worked for Iowa Workforce Development for 16 months. During that time, I had an intimate look at how hard this state agency was working to fill employers' needs. We are seeing the biggest shortages in key midskill industries the very same industries that require community colleges and 4year colleges to keep enrollment up and keep graduates here. Iowa needs nurses and healthcare workers. Iowa needs teachers and education workers. Iowa needs trade and manufacturing workers. The list goes on and on. A quick glance at Iowa's Labor Market Information website shows us that these gaps are not going to be filled with our current workforce. This bill would move Iowa in the exact opposite direction that our economy needs us to be moving. Instead of taking control of immigration through licensing reform, you are proposing legislation that will further lead to Iowa's economic downfall. The Iowa Business Council has been urging both the state and federal government to pass immigration reform for years in order grow the states economy and keep employers in the area. If you pass this and other antiimmigrant legislation, you are putting the nail in the coffin for Iowa's economy.

01-29-2024

Glenn Leach [Retired]

This bill is a negative bill that accomplishes no good for anyone, and punishes many. Enrollments at both our community colleges and universities have not reached a level that they can afford to turn away any student at the instate tuition rates, already a challenge for many US citizens. DACA registrants for 12 years have been able to follow their citizen schoolmates into post high school careers, open businesses or become valued employees will no longer be able to obtain the education necessary to increase their skills as they have fewer scholarship opportunities. Hopefully, Congress will finally act and grant citizenship to our DACA registrants, and we need them! According to the State Data Center and the Bureau of Labor statistics, 18% of the Iowa workforce is 55 or older in occupations across the board, and these folks are beginning to retire. The fertility rate (number of babies per woman over her life time) needed to keep the population steady is 2.1. The national rate is 1.9 and Iowas is 1.7, so at the same time our workforce is retiring, there will be fewer new folks to replace them. A look at the Iowa Workforce Development Laborshed reports used to paint a picture of the availability and other characteristics of the workforce show shortages in virtually every occupational category. Ironically, one of those is medical support personnel, nurses aides, critical care and rehabilitation center workers and others needed to support the growing number of retirees. This bill has no positive effects and would be a factor in depriving Iowa of needed growth opportunities.

01-29-2024

Alan Guss []

On the face of it, this bill, as described in local media, reeks of exclusivism , exclusionism and, really, a type of hate.An education is, in most evidence, that which reasoned thinking evolves from. The creation, the basic tenants, of this proposal may well be showing the last refuge of hope for a global community, global education, is itself manipulated by those skilled in disruption via a quality education! Many factors seem evident: profit margins, research funds, developmental costs of our colleges and universities. For what rational reason would proof of citizenship improve the financial security of the state's colleges and universities? The logic fails.However, as this type of legislation points out, the gift of an affordable education may well be egregious. Need it be explained? Those with whom an education was available created this conflict.

01-29-2024

Bev Heidgerken []

Any one who wants to receive instate tuition, must prove they are residents of the state. Why as a taxpayer, should I pay for a students tuition if they dont live here legally. Become a citizen of the state and then they qualify.

01-29-2024

Emily Elliott []

As an Iowan, a mental health therapist, and a graduate of the University of Iowa, I am opposed to HF2128. People with AND without US citizenship deserve affordable education. Full stop. Those without citizenship are worthy of education and an education that prepares them for their future. Why would we gatekeep this precious resource and force out our brightest students?

01-29-2024

Samara Torres []

How would people be able to get jobs that are worth more without the educational background that instate tuition or a community college would be able to provide. Moreover, Morally unjust from the perspective of a United States citizen. This is supposed to be the land of the free where people flee to when strife and poverty reach its max. Dont pass this law! Millions of people are working on their citizenship and being full time students. They are working towards what they want their future to look like.

01-29-2024

patricia bird []

I oppose HF 2128. I am amazed at the efforts the state of Iowa in general and its governor in particular are making to gouge our intellectual community. Starting with the cuts to Area Education Agencies, the redirecting of funds from public schools and now an attempt to exclude individuals from community college our state is well on its way to dumbing down the population. It is disheartening to see the move towards restricting quality education when we should be heading in the opposite direction.

01-29-2024

Maria Rocha []

I must express my strong opposition to HF 2128. First and foremost, enacting this bill would create barriers to education for many deserving students who contribute positively to our society. Denying access to affordable education based on citizenship status contradicts the principles of inclusivity and equal opportunity that our educational institutions should strive to uphold. Furthermore, implementing these requirements could lead to unintended consequences, including a decrease in enrollment rates and diversity within our educational institutions. By excluding a significant portion of our student population from access to instate tuition, we risk undermining the diversity and vibrancy of our campuses, hindering our ability to foster an inclusive learning environment.I urge the subcommittee to reconsider its support for HF 2128 and instead focus on initiatives that promote accessibility and affordability in higher education for all students. By embracing policies that foster diversity, equity, and inclusion, we can ensure that our educational system remains a beacon of opportunity for generations to come.

01-29-2024

Dennis Platt [None]

I do not support this bill. Iowa needs to be working to remove and eliminate barriers to postsecondary education training and college, not further restricting indiscriminate access to this essential public good.

01-29-2024

Diana Echeverria []

I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposed bill that mandates proof of citizenship or lawful presence for students to qualify for instate tuition at regents institutions or community colleges.This bill could have detrimental effects on the accessibility of education. It may disproportionately impact individuals, including undocumented students, who have been residing in our communities and contributing positively to society.Education is a fundamental right that should be accessible to all residents, regardless of their immigration status. Denying instate tuition based on citizenship criteria could hinder the educational aspirations of promising students and create barriers to upward mobility.I urge you to reconsider the potential consequences of this bill and allow universities and colleges to continue their admission processes. Recent data shows low college admission rates, and this bill might worsen the situation by adding more obstacles for students.

01-29-2024

gale francione []

I oppose HF 2128. If a person lives in the state, they should qualify for instate tuition. There is no reason to complicate this requirement. It simply makes life for folks who are seeking a good education. Please do not pass this bill.

01-29-2024

Caleb Knutson []

If Iowa wants to grow, then it should welcome all students that choose to attend any of our esteemed community colleges or public universities. Iowa has not grown at the same rate as our Midwest neighbors to the north? Why is that? If students feel welcomed & encouraged in colleges they have a higher chance of making Iowa their home. Putting up roadblocks for the youth is reductive & counterproductive if we want the state to grow.

01-29-2024

Kim Hopp []

I pray this bill is never passed. Our immigration system may be broken, but the truth of the matter is we have thousands of undocumented immigrants here by a choice their parents made years ago in attempt to provide their children a better life. I me to many Hispanic families in a smallNortheastern Iowa town. It would seem that by allowing these undocumented individuals to better their education, if would not only improve their future , help our society and to help ensure a more likely lhealthy and legal lifestyle for these individuals . I am opposed to this bill . Thank you for allowing me to voice my opinion.

01-29-2024

Luis Fernández []

I dont like how you are trying to take opportunities away from undocumented Hispanics cause they are taking opportunities away from American born people when they are just trying to help their families out while American born people dont work for their opportunities

01-29-2024

Enya Cid []

Most universities and community colleges already charge undocumented students international student tuition regardless of how long they have resided in the state. In addition to this being redundant and profusely unnecessary this proposal only aims to further restrict undocumented students from pursuing higher education. Higher education should be accessible to all, just like public education is, regardless of immigration status. On average, undocumented college students pay about 50% more than their citizen peers and this proposal would exacerbate that number. Hispanic college enrollment and graduation rates are much lower than White, Black, and Asian enrollment rates and this proposal would widen that discrepancy. Iowa has limited access to tuition and financial aid equity for undocumented students. This restrictive policy would widen the Hispanic education gap and encourage students to enroll in neighboring states like Minnesota and Illinois that have comprehensive access to education, taking their money with them. Additionally, the vague language of this file would restrict those currently in immigration proceedings from pursing higher education out of fear.

01-29-2024

Paul Vasquez []

I believe education or aid for anyone applying for it should not be based on citizenship or any other prerequisite. I feel it is discriminatory and goes against the concept of the " Great American melting pot" that built our country.

01-29-2024

Sergio Hermosillo []

Im an immigrant my self and this law doesnt help anyone, its detrimental to build an educated society. Most of this kids have been living long enough to call Iowa home and their parents being part of the economic impact.

01-29-2024

Heather Stancil []

I SUPPORT this bill. American citizens should not be subsidizing the education of foreign nationals who do not respect our laws. Criminality by illegal residency should not be rewarded.Those that wish to do so can use their own money to subsidize foreigners here illegally, instead of using the force of government to make the rest of us do so.

01-29-2024

Patrisia Aguilar []

People should have a right to study in colleges without having to proof Citizenship. They are working hard to better their lives and financial status. Some of these stydents are first time generations making a difference for their families.

01-29-2024

Patrisia Aguilar []

I oppose this bill. People should have a right to study in colleges without having to proof Citizenship. They are working hard to better their lives and financial status. Some of these stydents are first time generations making a difference for their families.

01-29-2024

Barb Clayton []

I am in support of this bill. Iowa has no tuition reciprocity with surrounding states, why would we give instate tuition to illegal citizens who are legally residents of another country. Please vote to require proof of citizenship and Iowa residency.

01-29-2024

Jacob Onken []

I am opposed to in state tuition or any other kind of tuition assistance for illegal aliens. It is not fair to foreign students who came to the state legally and have student visas and it is not fair to the taxpayer.

01-29-2024

Matt Wells [Constitution Action Network]

No person in this country and in Iowa illegally should get in state tuition at an Iowa public university. We must stop all incentives for people in the country illegally. ICE should be notified if someone in the nation illegally applies to a state funded college.

01-29-2024

Jennifer Anhalt []

I support this bill. To have in state tuition each potential student should have to show proof of citizenship and then proof of state residency. My children are all legal citizens of the US, but they would be required to pay out of state tuition if they chose to attend a college in a state other than Iowa. Why should others get to skip this part?

01-29-2024

BJ James McLaughlin [Warroom Iowa]

As a single mom struggling to pay for her boys education and to add college into the mix next year. I oppose instate tuition for illegals.I would rather see more aid for Iowa students or opportunities for reciprocity!

01-29-2024

Kathy Pietraszewski []

I approve of this bill. Putting Americans first is not mean spirited. We will never be able to help others when we are broke. Our debt has reached a serious tipping point. We are struggling as a nation because of a wide open border. Funding illegals living here when legal citizens can hardly put food on the table should not even be up for discussion. Please use common sense and support this.

01-29-2024

Carla Sams []

I support this bill. My kids had to have legal documents to attend college. And they paid for their degrees. I don't support anything for illegal aliens. If they come legally, yes but not illegals. I'm on a fixed income and can't get ANY help but the illegals get everything free on my tax dollars.

01-29-2024

Laura Garcia []

Education should be a right, not a privilege. Students who have attended school and plan for a secondary education should be allowed and given the opportunity to do so. Most of immigrant children know the importance of education and want to create a path for a better life for not only themselves but their families as well. Students deserve the right continue their studies. This bill would add another barrier for some. Without a citizenship, students already dont qualify for government funds or financial assistance, they have to work to pay full tuition, paying out of stay tuition might make impossible for some to afford their education. Educated citizens are most likely to obtain better jobs, help their families, their community, and help local wealth grow. Thank you for considering this. Local high school teacher.

01-29-2024

Sara Ferneding []

I am in support of this bill. Why would in state tuition be permitted to someone without proof of citizenship or lawful presence over legal citizens of the United States? Why do our laws continue to be ignored when it comes to illegal immigration? This is detrimental to our state & our country. If I am not an Iowan I do not get in state tuition. So why does that law then not apply to someone who is not even a legal citizen? If I am not a legal citizen of the United States & I live in Iowa that does not make me an Iowan it makes me an illegal. Why have laws on citizenship & legal entry to our country if we are not going to abide by them & respect the law abiding citizen & immigrants by enforcing those laws? Not supporting this bill would be grossly irrespective of law abiding, legal citizens & residents of Iowa. Please pass this bill out of common sense, respect for our immigration laws already in place & for the respect of our citizens who are being pushed aside by the abuse of our current laws.

01-29-2024

Alissa Ward []

I support this bill. It have known literally hundreds of people who have come to the US as foreign exchange students or au pairs in order to legally participate in our education students. Why are we motivating people to skirt the law and not be contributing members of our society? If I cant send my kids to another state and receive instate tuition prices, why should I welcome illegals to do that here in Iowa?

01-29-2024

Kehde Campbell [University of Northern Iowa]

What are you doing to our state institutions? No college student wants this change. You are taking your power too far. Stop dictating our colleges. We dont need to be schools for only white students. Attacking DEI and now this. You are tyrants.

01-29-2024

Annchi Shaw [None]

I am opposed to this bill. This will take away advantages that could have been given to disadvantaged youth. There are many other bills that could benefit and promote education, instead they must keep creating bills targeting a harmless group, rather than concerning improvement.

01-29-2024

Juan Hernandez []

I was an undocumented student here in Iowa 20 years ago. Because of the in state tuition, i was able to afford education in iowa. I would not have been able otherwise. I am now married to my wife who was raised here in Iowa and i have two children, a home and i am now a us citizen. We are seriously considering moving to another states. Stop this bill before more harm is done to the future of iowa.

01-29-2024

Maria Maher []

I am in favor of and support HF2128 to require proof of citizenship to receive in state tuition. We must return to sound monetary policies and common sense with these most basic matters if we are going to be able to help anyone. Iowa helps many, but not if we run the state to the ground!

01-29-2024

Isaac Carr [The Liberian Community in the Quad Cites]

Dear Senators, and RepsI was a refugee Liberia who was resettled to the United States and later resided in the Quad Cities. It took me 7 to 8 years to become a US Citizen, unlike me, there are so many immigrants and refugees who may have low level of education, as well as language barrier. I was a high school graduate in Liberia, and did some ESL in the United States, and persuaded college. I was blessed to be accorded the opportunity for fafsa, and other scholarship when I wasn't a citizen yet. I, along with many other immigrants and refugees have had the opportunity to attend the St. Ambrose University, in Davenport, Iowa, University of Iowa, in Iowa City, Drake in Des Moines and my son and daughter were also privileged.To our Senators, and Representatives, if I and my kids, as well as other immigrants and refugees did not persuade higher education, how would we have better ourselves for the better America, and achieve the American dreams? Not only that we could not work certain jobs without education, but our growth and development have extended far beyond.Please note that psychologically, if you start to deny any first generation of immigrants and refugees' better education, their next generation will not look beyond the scope, limiting the rest which will also put our nation at more risk of lowrate higher educated nation in the world.I would request the opportunity to meet with you, if I am giving to opportunity to speak on behalf of the immigrants and refugees' community, who are not citizens yet.My many thanks and appreciation to you for taking your time to discuss this issue and let's put the future of this nation first. When you educate a nation, the society gets stronger, and the Nation is the most powerful and strongest nation everyone looks up to. May God bless our Governor, our Senators, and Reps, and safe this program.

01-29-2024

Doc Zortman []

Rather than passing this today let's take a step back and look at this closer like the numbers this involves, the costs to taxpayers and how it affects all of us. If the student is not legal in this country, but their home country believes they need to be here; maybe that country can pick up the fees. Are American students studying abroad offered the same options?

01-29-2024

Giselle Moreno Alfaro []

The amount of hard work it takes a student to get an education is by far hard enough. Imagine not getting the support for in state tuition and fees, thats bare minimum. By diminishing these students you are only allowing certain groups of people to get an education and afford it. This simply isnt right.

01-29-2024

Xiuh Sanabria []

This is a disservice to the State of Iowa and its people. Hardworking families pay taxes to the state so their children can have a better future. These students had no choice on their status, all they want is to have access to education to keep chasing the so called American dream. Being part of a better workforce, entrepreneurs, innovators , professionals helps the state to be more prosperous.Enrollment is already in decline in many of the private and public universities and colleges. This bill just helps to make that worst.The economy of this state and the country depends on the work of many undocumented immigrants, who do not want hand outs but just a chance to be a productive member of society.

01-29-2024

Sophie Banegas []

I am strongly opposed to this bill. Public Universities are supposed to be a place of innovation and inclusivity for all prospective students. Undocumented students already are not eligible for federal student aid, and many of these students are here seeking asylum or political refuge from their countries since childhood. Do not criminalize students for wanting to learn.

01-29-2024

Gerardo Duron []

As a representative of the Latino community and a concerned naturalized citizen, I strongly oppose the proposed bill requiring proof of citizenship for instate tuition at public universities and community colleges. This bill, if passed, would unjustly place a significant financial burden on immigrant students, many of whom are integral members of our community.Firstly, education is a fundamental right and a cornerstone of the American dream. This bill threatens to put this dream out of reach for many hardworking students simply because of their citizenship status. Many immigrant students, particularly those from Latino backgrounds, have spent most of their lives in this country, contributing positively to our society and economy. Denying them instate tuition based on citizenship is not only unfair but also very discriminatory.Secondly, the diversity brought by immigrant students enriches our educational institutions. These students bring unique perspectives and experiences that enhance the learning environment for all. More and More Companies are looking to have a diverse group to be able to reach out to more potential audiences as well. By imposing additional financial barriers, we risk creating homogenous educational spaces that do not reflect the diversity of our nation.Moreover, higher education is a pathway to better job opportunities and economic advancement. By limiting access to affordable education, we are hindering the potential of an entire generation of young people, which can have longterm detrimental effects on our economy and society.We must also consider the message this bill sends to our young people. It tells them that despite their efforts, contributions, or aspirations, they will be treated differently because of their citizenship status. This is not the message we want to send as a community or as a nation.In conclusion, I urge lawmakers to consider the farreaching consequences of this bill. Education should definitely unite us, not divide us. It should be used as a tool for empowerment, not exclusion. I stand with the immigrant students and their families in calling for the rejection of this bill as well as many American citizen families who believe in this countries values, in favor of policies that are inclusive, equitable, and reflective of the values of our diverse community.I believe that the people will do what's right within their hearts. Remember that a lot of people who would agree with this law might even be enjoying of the benefits of having immigrants who have built a business with the education they have had in this country. Immigrants are here to work hard, help their families and those around them. That includes you.a

01-29-2024

Jessica Hobbs [1791]

Please vote yes! I am tired of seeing illegals given so many more economical advantages over our own citizens! My daughters cannot receive instate tuition anywhere but Iowa. Why should people here illegally get this benefit!?!?

01-29-2024

Rafaela Cadena [ILN]

As a Latina and whos family came from Mexico and his other side of the family came from Romania I strongly support this bill. Right now with the border invasion basically questioning whether or not we even have a country. We have to protect our citizens and the grants and scholarships and make sure that those who were here legally have access to those funds. Once again, I strongly support this bill in this current climate we are in this is something we have to do.

01-29-2024

Jordyn L []

I SUPPORT THIS BILL! I am a University of Iowa grad who had to pay out of state tuition since I am originally from out of state. Noncitizens should not qualify for in state tuition, same as anyone from out of state do not qualify. Thank you for proposing this bill!!

01-29-2024

Erin Billings [Private citizen]

I am strongly in favor of this bill. As a tax payer in this state, I believe it is not the right of an illegal alien to even be in our state. Individuals who come to the US illegally SHOULD NOT be able to attend public schools. They are breaking the law and should be treated as such. I attended a public university in a different state and was required to pay out of state tuition until I established residency. Let me remind you that and ILLEGAL alien is illegally here. An illegal alien should not be given special rights.

01-29-2024

Layne Billings [Private citizen ]

I am in favor of this bill. Illegal aliens do NOT have the same rights as citizens. I am a tax payer they are not. They are breaking the law by being here. They have every right to go to school in the country they are citizens of, or apply for a student visa. The US and Iowa should be places of law and order. We should not be in the business of encouraging ILLEGAL behavior.

01-29-2024

Joe Enriquez Henry [League of United Latin American Citizens]

We are opposed to this bill. It takes rights away from hard working Iowans who live hear, pay taxes and are presently undocumented immigrants. Immigrants work difficult jobs in the state and make major contributions to the economy and pay their fair share of taxes and should not be treated as outsiders.

01-29-2024

Raul Roman []

I do not agree with this new bill trying to pass against immigrants. It is disappointing and concerning to see time being wasted given that there are so many other import issues on hand in this state.

01-29-2024

Aura Garcia []

Non Citizens already dont qualify for any government financial assistance such as loans. Providing students who have Iowa residency state tuition is a basic right. Citizenship has never been a reason to provide in state tuition only residency has. This bill is another way to keep people of color from higher education.

01-29-2024

LINDA STICKLE []

I am in favor of this bill, as I think all would have been in an Era with more common sense. If we charge non Iowans additional tuition, it only makes sense that even more so a non citizen would be included in that tuition scale. Let's keep special tuition rates for our legal Iowa citizens, and others have a different scale.

01-29-2024

Loree Horn []

I support this bill. People in the country ILLEGALLY should not receive favorable treatment over US citizens. It makes no sense that a US citizen in Illinois, Texas, etc should have to pay more to go to an Iowa university than an individual that is not even a US citizen.

01-29-2024

Valeria Cano Camacho []

Seriously? Folks that have lived and been part of an Iowa public school system since kindergarten would be considered nonIowa resident??? How does that make sense? Put yourself in others shoes for one single minute and think if that really makes any sense?? Since when is education only accessible to US citizens??? Do better Iowa. Do fucking better.

01-29-2024

Emanuel Nativi []

I firmly oppose this bill as it stands to further marginalize and limit the educational opportunities for undocumented students. Education should be a basic human right, not a privilege based on one's citizenship status. This bill, if passed, would not only create a financial strain on students who are already in a vulnerable position, but also hinder diversity and cultural exchange in our educational institutions. Additionally, it sends a harmful message that our education system is exclusive, rather than inclusive. It is crucial that we foster a society that values and supports education for all, regardless of immigration status.

01-29-2024

Brandon Roman []

I am strongly opposed to this bill. It is a detrimental bill that would only hard the community. This community does NOT qualify any type of grants, as they have to pay their tuition out of pocket in cash. Passing this bill would only make it more difficult for them. Please reconsider as they are only trying to learn and advance and are not harming anyone.

01-29-2024

Laura Castro []

Dear subcommittee members, I am strongly against HF 2128. I am a us citizen and feel that this is a dehumanizing bill to pass against residents of Iowa that contribute to the economy and have not broken any law. All Iowa residents who are wanting to further their education should be able to do so. I urge you to oppose HF 2128 and any further bill similar to this. Thank you for your time.Sincerely, Laura Castro

01-29-2024

Denise Mitchell [CAN]

I strongly support this bill! Allowing education or any other benefits, to illegals at taxpayers' expense is completely wrong. Iowa should be a sovereign state and passing this would go against that. PLEASE vote in favor of HF2128!

01-29-2024

Glenn Leach [Retired]

Many comments in support of this unfortunate bill include a number of misperceptions. Enrolling a student at the instate rate does not increase anyone's taxes, and if enough additional enrollments were made at the instate rate, the increased tuition money might result in the university or community college to reduce fees for all students or decrease the dependence on state money to operate the school. Our community colleges and Universities are not oversubscribed and there is plenty of room for more students to the benefit of all. Also, many commentators have mistaken noncitizen for nontaxpayers. Not true and everyone should get the full benefits of the taxes they pay. Like US labor law that includes all workers regardless of immigration status, tuition based on residency should depend only on residency. In Iowa's search for bright minds to fuel its future prosperity, a winning tactic might be to eliminate outofstate or international tuition for any student that agrees to settle here rather than taking their education to another state or country to benefit them. The fact that there are alternative ways of thinking about tuition fees reveals that the concern that led this bill indicates that its only purpose is to add additional handicaps for DACA and others who are here, not to benefit anyone in Iowa.

01-29-2024

Sergio Perez [Loras College]

I stand against any measure that could have a chilling effect on college access. This bill is only adding to barriers that could help Iowa educate it's students. I urge our law makers to vote against HF 2128.

01-29-2024

Edgar Arechiga []

I do not support this bill. Education should be accessible for everyone, these individuals do not qualify for any student grants, they are not taking anything from citizens. This bill targets an already marginalized group. Please reconsider this bill and the other few that are only here to hard our community.

01-29-2024

Monica McHugh []

I support this bill. It accomplishes 2 things it should make universities reduce their tuition rates and it gives an incentive for immigrants to assimilate and become citizens. Although I may add that if the student has started the process to become a citizen, tuition at instate rates would apply.

01-29-2024

Ilima Young-Dunn []

I find it deplorable that such a bill was even drafted. As a college professor I have had hard working, intelligent, and gifted undocumented students paying out of pocket for their education due to not be eligible for Pell grants. Iowa now wants to make it even more difficult by requiring out of state tuition? We have a shortage of workers and the idea of making an even larger hurdle for those that want to give back to our state is ridiculous and racist.

01-29-2024

Rosie Rios []

Distinguished committee members,Greetings my name is Rosie and I am opposed to HF2128. I have experienced first hand the detrimental effects of having instate tuition denied for non citizens. Iowa boasts of being a welcoming state, but this bill shows otherwise. We need diverse community members to uplift our state and offering in state tuition is one step we can take in that direction. Why should we punish students who only want to better their lives? They mostly do not have a say in what their legal status is.

01-29-2024

Michelle Veach []

I am in favor of this bill. Requiring documentation of residency is a necessary step in enrolling college students. Tax payer dollars subsidize the tuition of in state colleges, therefore only Iowa residents should pay instate tuition. Note: to not require this discriminates against other students who honestly and willing pay out of state tuition.

01-29-2024

Jennifer Correa []

This is an unjust bill, it will limit the access to education for those students who may not have proof of citizenship or lawful presence. Its important to consider the impacts this will have on individuals and their opportunities. None of this is something our community should stand for its simply unfair and non inclusive.

01-29-2024

Dalila Solis []

To Whom It May Concern,As you consider H.F. 2128, I urge you to reconsider supporting this bill. Education is a fundamental right that should be accessible to all residents of Iowa, regardless of their immigration status. By imposing strict citizenship requirements, this bill risks excluding a significant portion of our community, including undocumented immigrants who have grown up in Iowa and contribute to our state's diversity and prosperity.Denying access to affordable education goes against the principles of fairness and equal opportunity that our society values. Rather than erecting barriers, let us focus on policies that promote inclusivity and support all students in their pursuit of higher education.I urge you to prioritize educational equity and access for all residents of Iowa by opposing H.F. 2128. Let us work together to ensure that our educational system remains a beacon of opportunity for all, regardless of background or circumstance.Thank you for considering my perspective.

01-29-2024

Amy Meyer []

I support the bill. The purpose of in state tuition lower than out of state is to recognize the contributions Iowan's make to local institutions through their tax dollars. This should not apply to noncitizens. Thank you.

01-29-2024

Frank Dunn-Young []

Dear subcommittee members, the bill filed, HF, 2128 is flawed in a number of ways and really does know more than treat a symptom rather than address the issue at hand. In fact, I would argue that the bill targets limiting education, so that a select few can continue to control and manipulate the system of democracy. As subcommittee members you are bound by the Constitution of the State of Iowa however, you do nothing to strengthen the free will of the people, but target the most vulnerable. Bill HF 2128 clearly targets the Rights of Persons, article I, section 1 which states All men and women are, by nature, free and equal, and have certain inalienable rights of which your erroneously are compelled to trample on. Is the state of the union, all be it an imperfect democracy, not enough for you to be proud? Is life liberty and the pursuit of happiness something you should strive to represent at such a standard, that no others in the world would not wish to emulate? I ask you, in your honorable position, to take a step back, and do what you are expected to do, and affirm respect for every man, woman, and child, rather than finding ways to divide us, for the sake of our democracy. An educated and informed population, although not easily controlled, with free will can uphold the fundamentals of what our State and Nation is all about of which this bill denies. Sincerely, Frank Dunn

01-29-2024

Holly Rozenboom []

Why block vulnerable students who are trying to better themselves and our country? This is how we go backwards as a society. These students are just trying to become productive members of society and many come from homes with severe lack of resources and are the first in their families to go to college. Do not make it harder for them!!

01-29-2024

Amy Daly []

These are kids who are trying to better themselves by taking college courses. Why should they be treated differently for the sake of being born & brought to this country or this state? Lets integrate them as we do our own citizens & foster their needs for an education as we do our own. Lets give them social security. Give them an opportunity to develop. Pay taxes & earn wages like we do so they dont live in fear of deportation or prejudice.

01-29-2024

Annie Tucker []

Please vote against HF2128.Any resident here is paying sales tax, property tax (directly as a property owner or indirectly as a renter), and if they or a family member work, they are paying state and federal income tax. They are supporting the common good. They should be allowed to be classified for instate tuition and fees at a regents institution or community college.Period. Thank you.

01-29-2024

Leland Schipper []

This bill will not achieve the intended purpose. Instead, it will create an additional barrier to prevent young adults from obtaining an education. All this law will do is result in fewer people in Iowa paying for tuition at our regent institutions and fewer Iowans obtaining college degrees. Thats bad for all Iowans.

01-29-2024

Michelle Macias []

I strongly oppose this proposal! Undocumented students and families are extremely hard workers both in their jobs and at school. This bill is unfair to them because they are taxpayers and they deserve a chance at education. Taking away their education is going to severely hurt Iowas economy because there will be less educated workers. As a U.S citizen who has been around undocumented students my whole life I have personally seen how hardworking and deserving they are of education. With all that and much more in consideration I respectfully urge that you dont pass this bill. Thank you for your time.

01-29-2024

Autumn Diesburg []

Requiring proof of citizenship or lawful presence for students to be eligible for instate costs of education only makes another barrier for students and families to access education and should not be instituted. Education is a human right that needs to be made accessible to everyone, not just some.

01-29-2024

Laurie Schipper []

Please oppose HF 2128. It is in all Iowan's best interest to allow any child seeking a post secondary education access to resources to go to college. Most undocumented high school students have lived here most of there lives and have worked hard, against many barriers, to get into college. There are no arguments that make any sense to limit opportunities for these kids. Iowa must be better than this! Our state needs these kids to help us be better.

01-29-2024

Magdalena Marceleno []

It is not fair for privileged people to live off the government while other people of different ethnicities are working and they still have to pay for taxes. How fair is that. By passing this law you are killing future generations of teachers, nurses, veterinarians, lawyers and many more. People come to this country for the quote American Dream. The governer and all the people who want to pass this have not have been through the struggle as all the people who come to this country. People will be affected by this. We are one single voice and we as people can do anything to stop this ridiculous bill.

01-29-2024

Hayley Pratt []

As an educator in the state of Iowa, this bill is despicable. I have helped countless undocumented children navigate the complicated and confusing system to even be accepted into high Ed institutions. To make it even more difficult would be a racist and xenophobic mistake. BIPOC are already extremely underrepresented in our state institutions. Trying to remove diversity doesnt only hurt these students, but also the predominantly white student body that will not have the opportunity to experience different cultures. This bill will not lead to students paying more for school, it will eliminate access to education for students across the state.

01-29-2024

Jeffrianne Young []

This bill punishes young students striving to become educated and contribute to Iowa. Iowa can and must rise above this bill which is political theatrics. Iowa does not need braindrain and support motivated students who have lived and grown up, educated in Iowa schools. Iowa benefits from all Iowas children becoming educated at the highest level.

01-29-2024

Joa LaVille []

Why wouldnt we want our Iowa educated students to attend college and give back in our state? This is ridiculous in a state where we so need employees in the very industries that many immigrant students would serve in.

01-29-2024

Sister Kathleen Henneberry []

I am in opposition to House File 2128. I am part of a group that is assisting 3 University students that are from Vietnam to get their B.A. degrees. Why would they need to be citizens of the USA when for hundreds of years the USA has promoted higher Education for foreign students???This bill would put up extra barriers for so many attempting to get higher education.

01-29-2024

Jenn Perez []

No human should be denied education or the opportunity to better themselves. Some people can barely meet their day to day expenses. Some cant afford going to school and by taking away their right to apply for financial help youre taking away a dream. People come to this country looking for a better future.

01-29-2024

Jenn Perez []

I oppose this bill! No human should be denied education or the opportunity to better themselves. Some people can barely meet their day to day expenses. Some cant afford going to school and by taking away their right to apply for financial help youre taking away a dream. People come to this country looking for a better future.

01-29-2024

Rebecca Wallace []

I strongly oppose this bill. Undocumented students do NOT receive any financial aid or welfare. They pay full tuition, unless they qualify for scholarships, which are also limited. They should be allowed to pay instate tuition because they live here and spend their money in those communities. Some people did not choose to come to this country, some people were brought here as children or escaped from their country. There is no reason to create yet another obstacle for higher education.

01-29-2024

Carlos Arreola []

This bill does nothing good for Iowa's economy and good reputation as a welcoming state.. has no aboslutely no benefit behind it. It is hateful and despicable. The parents of these students have one dream, and it is to see their sons and daughters succeed . this bill is beyond redundant

01-29-2024

Paola Nieto []

Why do you want to put more walls up for those who only want to better themselves? Dont you understand that an educated individual is an asset to society? A noncitizen cannot receive federal or state financial aid therefore before even considering attending school they have a plan on how to afford their education. These individuals will already be paying for their education by working multiple jobs while attending college. Dont make it any more difficult for a person to get an education, to be an assent to our community.

01-29-2024

Paloma Gallegos []

Denying instate tuition based on proof of citizenship or lawful presence could have detrimental effects on the educational opportunities of students in Iowa. Education is a fundamental right that should be accessible to all residents, regardless of their immigration status. Such a bill may hinder the pursuit of higher education for talented individuals who contribute to the community and economy. Restricting access to affordable education contradicts the values of inclusivity and equal opportunity. Iowa benefits from a diverse and skilled workforce, and inclusive educational policies foster social and economic growth. It is crucial to consider the longterm impact on the state's prosperity and the principles of fairness and compassion when addressing immigrationrelated issues in education.

01-30-2024

Peg Bouska []

Please allow our state to harvest the potential of many of our immigrants who have experience and grit to greatly contribute to our communities. Better education for all is a way forward to tap into the wealth of resources our citizens and noncitizens offer for our state.Please oppose HF 2128

01-30-2024

Nancy Halder []

Who would monitor this bill? Why would legislators want to harm productivity in the state of Iowa by reducing the already low supply of educated workers, reduce taxes paid to the state, etc. There are enough hurdles for immigrants to jump over, let alone creating more. Remember this, legislators: you mostly all come from immigrant families. Is this how you wish you had been treated when your ancestors arrived?

01-30-2024

Joselinne gaytan []

Denying instate tuition based on proof of citizenship or lawful presence could have detrimental effects on the educational opportunities of students in lowa.Education is a fundamental right that should be accessible to all residents, regardless of their immigration status. Such a bill may hinder the pursuit of higher education for talented individuals who contribute to the community and economy. Restricting access to affordable education contradicts the values of inclusivity and equal. education for talented individuals who contribute to the community and economy. Restricting access to affordable education contradicts the values of inclusivity and equal opportunity. lowa benefits from a diverse and skilled workforce, and inclusive educational policies foster social and economic growth. It is crucial to consider the longterm impact on the state's prosperity and the principles of fairness and compassion when addressing immigrationrelated issues in education.

01-30-2024

Lindsay Mack []

I oppose this bill! Requiring proof of citizenship for instate tuition unfairly discriminates against students who may be in the process of obtaining legal status or who have temporary protected status. Education should be accessible to all, irrespective of immigration status.This bill may deter talented individuals from pursuing higher education, hindering the state's potential for innovation and growth.

01-30-2024

Deba Leach []

I am concerned about legislative action that makes it difficult or impossible for any child living in our state to have unfettered access to education at any level, including higher education. Any such action is not in the spirit of the state of Iowa I have appreciated and returned to in order to live out my days

01-30-2024

Margaret Kiekhaefer [Citizen ]

People who have been residents of iowa, whether citizen or not should be eligible for in state tuition. There are many people who are trying to achieve citizenship or are living here trying to establish themselves. There are also people who can not prove citizenship because of lack of birth records or other documents.This legislation is overly discriminatory and biased.

01-30-2024

Emily Alvarado []

Everyone should be able to have access to education no matter where youre from. Education should never be limited or denied for any matter & to anyone who wants to learn & have a dream. The USA is known for making dreams & building a future & taking this right away is not up to your words nor should a choice to take away from anyone. Please let them have access to education to build their future & dreams.

01-30-2024

Kristin MacDonald Yorj [Des Moines public schools]

This bill is deliberately harmful to immigrant communities and students who are working hard to advance their own education and contribute productively to our state and economy. Iowa residents deserve in state tuition regardless of their immigration status.

01-30-2024

Karna Bosman [ ]

HF 2128 proposes a new requirement for students attending public universities or community colleges to provide proof of citizenship for instate tuition eligibility. This policy could have significant ramifications for both the immigrant community and taxpayers.Requiring proof of citizenship may create barriers to education for immigrants, limiting their potential for upward mobility and success. With reduced access to education, they may face challenges in acquiring the necessary skills and knowledge to thrive in the workforce and contribute as taxpaying citizens.Denying education opportunities to immigrants not only hampers their own potential success but also undermines the economic growth of our society as a whole. When individuals are unable to secure betterpaying jobs due to limited access to education, they may struggle financially and potentially rely on public assistance programs. This places an additional burden on taxpayers.Moral Imperative and Mutual Benefit:Regardless of one's stance on immigration, we should recognize the moral imperative of ensuring equal access to education. By offering immigrants the chance to pursue higher education, we empower them to contribute fully to our society, both economically and socially. Educated individuals are more likely to find gainful employment and become productive members of society, benefiting everyone.Conclusion: Striving for equal educational opportunities for immigrants not only aligns with principles of fairness and justice but also promises collective prosperity. By investing in their education, we create a path for success not only for immigrants but for all members of society. Let us reject shortsightedness and embrace policies that foster the success of all individuals, for the betterment of our community as a whole.I STAND FIRMLY AGAINST HF2128, and ask you to do the same.Karna BosmanUrbandale, Iowa

01-30-2024

Kim Hughes []

This bill seems to go against the American Dream. We cannot preach to others that coming here allows you to prosper and become successful, then turn around and punish folks who are trying to do just that. In addition to the direct impact on students, this bill will scare young people from the universities in Iowa and make them live elsewhere, hurting our economy and community.

01-30-2024

Andy Montalvo-Martinez [Iowa State University]

I grew up in Des Moines and I currently attend Iowa State University. I take advantage of in state tuition because I live in Iowa. People who are undocumented live in Iowa and should also benefit from in state tuition because thats what it entails, living in state. This bill is harmful, targets a vulnerable population and everyone who helped write this bill should be disgusted of themselves.

01-30-2024

Amy Rutenberg []

Better educated Iowans earn more money for Iowa. Lowering barriers to education more than pays for itself over time. Documented or not, Iowa workers pay taxes and enable our businesses to thrive. The point of this bill is clearly the cruelty, not to save money.

01-30-2024

Brenda Moreno []

I find this bill to be unnecessary, the United States has promised time and time again that it is great and it is good. I don't see how this bill promotes that. This bill is only going to cause more discrimination and hate towards immigrants and that is not the America I want to believe in.

01-30-2024

Selena Gonzalez []

I am expressing my opposition to House File 2128. The provisions within the bill overlook the fact that applying the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment ensures that all individuals must be treated in the same manner and conditions by their governing body. It is crucial to reconsider these aspects to provide a more balanced and effective legislation. Let us strive for policies that address the diverse needs of our community.

01-30-2024

Kaitlyn Bartz []

01-30-2024

Lauren Alt []

This bill ignores the reality that many undocumented college students in Iowa have lived here most of their lives. These are young Iowans. Our state is better if they have access to higher education. If they choose to go to college, earn scholarships, and pay tuition, there is no logical argument for why our state wouldnt want them attending public universities and making our communities stronger.

01-30-2024

Grace Lee []

I'm against this bill because everyone should have access to an education. This access is already restrictive enough without requiring "proof of citizenship or lawful presence." As a US citizen of 12 years and an Iowa resident of 9 years, I say reject this bill. Veto it. Cancel it. Get rid of it. I don't need this bill. No one in this state or country needs this bill except for the authorities who want us to be complacent with their power.

01-30-2024

Wilma Vizcaino []

I believe that I doesn't matter and shouldn't matter to anyone the status of citizenship when it comes to education we should be glad our future generations want to better themselves and become more educated to better the themselves in the country that is stated to be a country of freedom for all us.

01-30-2024

Wilma Vizcaino []

I oppose this bill. I believe that I doesn't matter and shouldn't matter to anyone the status of citizenship when it comes to education we should be glad our future generations want to better themselves and become more educated to better the themselves in the country that is stated to be a country of freedom for all us.

01-30-2024

Michelle Gomez []

There is so many people that is is important to me. And now only for spending time with them and having them on my car thats a crimen thats is insane to be honest. We can not hangout with out the fear of been stop and get in problem just for spending time with friends unbelievable.

01-31-2024

Ginny Kjer []

This bill would prevent a lot of hardworking, motivated students from being able to earn a higher education and make a better life for themselves. Because the citizenship process takes so long to complete, many of these students may have to wait years before they could afford to go to college. Please do not pass this bill. It will create yet another barrier for students whose families are simply trying to live a better life than they left behind.

02-02-2024

Micah Benes []

Oppose no strong argument can support this. Weak arguments include bigotry. Many undocumented youths have called Iowa home a majority of their lives, and their families contribute to the strength of our communities. They should be included in the ways we incentivize young people to attend college in Iowa.

02-06-2024

Nate Holdren []

This bill is a terrible idea. It's out of step with the values declared on the Statue of Liberty. It will make Iowa less welcoming, and in doing so harm undocumented Iowans, their friends and family, Iowa's economy, and Iowa institutions of higher education.

02-07-2024

Bianca Hernandez []

It would be detrimental to the youth to have this stress. Let them get an education. For most of these children the United States is all they know. To stop them from getting an education would hurt them, they deserve to get degrees and be the change to a greater world. Again, for most of these children this is all they know.

02-07-2024

Karina Cruz []