Senate
File
2306
-
Reprinted
SENATE
FILE
2306
BY
COMMITTEE
ON
JUDICIARY
(SUCCESSOR
TO
SF
2171)
(As
Amended
and
Passed
by
the
Senate
February
25,
2010
)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
grandparent
and
great-grandparent
1
visitation.
2
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
3
SF
2306
(3)
83
pf/nh/jh
S.F.
2306
Section
1.
Section
600C.1,
Code
2009,
is
amended
by
striking
1
the
section
and
inserting
in
lieu
thereof
the
following:
2
600C.1
Grandparent
and
great-grandparent
visitation.
3
1.
The
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
of
a
minor
child
4
may
petition
the
court
for
grandchild
or
great-grandchild
5
visitation
when
the
parent
of
the
minor
child,
who
is
the
child
6
of
the
grandparent
or
the
grandchild
of
the
great-grandparent,
7
is
deceased.
8
2.
The
court
shall
consider
a
fit
parent’s
objections
9
to
granting
visitation
under
this
section.
A
rebuttable
10
presumption
arises
that
a
fit
parent’s
decision
to
deny
11
visitation
to
a
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
is
in
the
best
12
interest
of
a
minor
child.
13
3.
The
court
may
grant
visitation
to
the
grandparent
or
14
great-grandparent
under
this
section
if
the
court
finds
all
of
15
the
following
by
clear
and
convincing
evidence:
16
a.
It
is
in
the
best
interest
of
the
child
to
grant
such
17
visitation.
18
b.
The
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
has
established
a
19
substantial
relationship
with
the
child
prior
to
the
filing
of
20
the
petition.
21
c.
That
the
presumption
that
the
parent
who
is
being
22
asked
to
temporarily
relinquish
care,
custody,
and
control
of
23
the
child
to
provide
visitation
is
fit
to
make
the
decision
24
regarding
visitation
is
overcome
by
demonstrating
one
of
the
25
following:
26
(1)
The
parent
is
unfit
to
make
such
decision.
27
(2)
The
parent’s
judgment
has
been
impaired
and
the
relative
28
benefit
to
the
child
of
granting
visitation
greatly
outweighs
29
any
effect
on
the
parent-child
relationship.
Impaired
judgment
30
of
a
parent
may
be
evidenced
by
any
of,
but
not
limited
to,
the
31
following:
32
(a)
Neglect
of
the
child.
33
(b)
Abuse
of
the
child.
34
(c)
Violence
toward
the
child.
35
-1-
SF
2306
(3)
83
pf/nh/jh
1/
4
S.F.
2306
(d)
Indifference
or
absence
of
feeling
toward
the
child.
1
(e)
Demonstrated
unwillingness
and
inability
to
promote
the
2
emotional
and
physical
well-being
of
the
child.
3
(f)
Drug
abuse.
4
(g)
A
diagnosis
of
mental
illness.
5
4.
In
determining
the
best
interest
of
the
child,
the
court
6
shall
consider
all
of
the
following:
7
a.
The
prior
interaction
and
interrelationships
of
the
8
child
with
the
child’s
parents,
siblings,
and
other
persons
9
related
by
consanguinity
or
affinity,
compared
to
the
child’s
10
relationship
with
the
grandparent
or
great-grandparent.
11
b.
The
geographical
location
of
the
grandparent’s
or
12
great-grandparent’s
residence
and
the
distance
between
the
13
grandparent’s
or
great-grandparent’s
residence
and
the
child’s
14
residence.
15
c.
The
child’s
and
parent’s
available
time,
including
but
16
not
limited
to
the
parent’s
employment
schedule,
the
child’s
17
school
schedule,
the
amount
of
time
that
will
be
available
18
for
the
child
to
spend
with
siblings,
and
the
child’s
and
the
19
parent’s
holiday
and
vacation
schedules.
20
d.
The
age
of
the
child.
21
e.
If
the
court
has
interviewed
the
child
in
chambers
22
as
provided
in
this
section
regarding
the
wishes
and
23
concerns
of
the
child
as
to
visitation
by
the
grandparent
or
24
great-grandparent
or
as
to
a
specific
visitation
schedule,
the
25
wishes
and
concerns
of
the
child,
as
expressed
to
the
court.
26
f.
The
health
and
safety
of
the
child.
27
g.
The
mental
and
physical
health
of
all
parties.
28
h.
Whether
the
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
previously
29
has
been
convicted
of
or
pleaded
guilty
to
any
criminal
30
offense
involving
any
act
that
resulted
in
a
child
being
an
31
abused
child
or
a
neglected
child;
whether
the
grandparent
32
or
great-grandparent
previously
has
been
convicted
of
or
33
pleaded
guilty
to
a
crime
involving
a
victim
who
at
the
time
34
of
the
commission
of
the
offense
was
a
member
of
the
family
35
-2-
SF
2306
(3)
83
pf/nh/jh
2/
4
S.F.
2306
or
household
that
is
the
subject
of
the
current
proceeding;
1
and
whether
there
is
reason
to
believe
that
the
grandparent
or
2
great-grandparent
has
acted
in
a
manner
resulting
in
a
child
3
having
ever
been
found
to
be
an
abused
child
or
a
neglected
4
child.
5
i.
The
wishes
and
concerns
of
the
child’s
parent,
as
6
expressed
by
the
parent
to
the
court.
7
j.
Any
other
factor
in
the
best
interest
of
the
child.
8
5.
For
the
purposes
of
this
subsection
“substantial
9
relationship”
includes
but
is
not
limited
to
any
of
the
10
following:
11
a.
The
child
has
lived
with
the
grandparent
or
12
great-grandparent
for
at
least
six
months.
13
b.
The
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
has
voluntarily
and
14
in
good
faith
supported
the
child
financially
in
whole
or
in
15
part
for
a
period
of
not
less
than
six
months.
16
c.
The
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
has
had
frequent
17
visitation
including
occasional
overnight
visitation
with
the
18
child
for
a
period
of
not
less
than
one
year.
19
6.
If
the
court
interviews
any
child
concerning
the
child’s
20
wishes
and
concerns
regarding
parenting
time
or
visitation,
the
21
interview
shall
be
conducted
in
chambers,
and
only
the
child,
22
the
child’s
attorney,
the
judge,
any
necessary
court
personnel,
23
and,
in
the
judge’s
discretion,
the
attorney
of
the
parent
24
shall
be
permitted
to
be
present
in
the
chambers
during
the
25
interview.
A
person
shall
not
obtain
or
attempt
to
obtain
from
26
a
child
a
written
or
recorded
statement
or
affidavit
setting
27
forth
the
wishes
and
concerns
of
the
child
regarding
parenting
28
time
or
visitation.
29
7.
For
the
purposes
of
this
section,
“court”
means
the
30
district
court
or
the
juvenile
court
if
that
court
currently
31
has
jurisdiction
over
the
child
in
a
pending
action.
If
an
32
action
is
not
pending,
the
district
court
has
jurisdiction.
33
8.
Notwithstanding
any
provision
of
this
chapter
to
the
34
contrary,
venue
for
any
action
to
establish,
enforce,
or
modify
35
-3-
SF
2306
(3)
83
pf/nh/jh
3/
4
S.F.
2306
visitation
under
this
section
shall
be
in
the
county
where
the
1
child
resides
if
no
final
custody
order
determination
relating
2
to
the
grandchild
or
great-grandchild
has
been
entered
by
any
3
other
court.
If
a
final
custody
order
has
been
entered
by
any
4
other
court,
venue
shall
be
located
exclusively
in
the
county
5
where
the
most
recent
final
custody
order
was
entered.
If
6
any
other
custodial
proceeding
is
pending
when
an
action
to
7
establish,
enforce,
or
modify
visitation
under
this
section
is
8
filed,
venue
shall
be
located
exclusively
in
the
county
where
9
the
pending
custodial
proceeding
was
filed.
10
9.
Notice
of
any
proceeding
to
establish,
enforce,
or
11
modify
visitation
under
this
section
shall
be
personally
served
12
upon
the
parent
of
the
child
whose
interests
are
affected
13
by
a
proceeding
brought
pursuant
to
this
section
and
all
14
grandparents
or
great-grandparents
who
have
previously
obtained
15
a
final
order
or
commenced
a
proceeding
under
this
section.
16
10.
The
court
shall
not
enter
any
temporary
order
to
17
establish,
enforce,
or
modify
visitation
under
this
section.
18
11.
An
action
brought
under
this
section
is
subject
to
19
chapter
598B,
and
in
an
action
brought
to
establish,
enforce,
20
or
modify
visitation
under
this
section,
each
party
shall
21
submit
in
its
first
pleading
or
in
an
attached
affidavit
all
22
information
required
by
section
598B.209.
23
12.
A
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
shall
not
petition
24
for
visitation
under
this
section
more
than
once
every
two
25
years
absent
a
showing
of
good
cause.
26
13.
The
court
shall
not
issue
an
order
restricting
the
27
movement
of
the
child
if
such
restriction
is
solely
for
the
28
purpose
of
allowing
the
grandparent
or
great-grandparent
29
the
opportunity
to
exercise
the
grandparent’s
or
30
great-grandparent’s
visitation
under
this
section.
31
-4-
SF
2306
(3)
83
pf/nh/jh
4/
4