Senate
Study
Bill
1115
-
Introduced
SENATE
FILE
_____
BY
(PROPOSED
COMMITTEE
ON
LOCAL
GOVERNMENT
BILL
BY
CHAIRPERSON
WEBSTER)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
approval
requirements
for
city
utilities.
1
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
2
TLSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
S.F.
_____
Section
1.
Section
364.2,
subsection
4,
paragraphs
a,
b,
and
1
c,
Code
2025,
are
amended
to
read
as
follows:
2
a.
A
city
may
grant
to
any
person
a
franchise
to
erect,
3
maintain,
and
operate
plants
and
systems
for
electric
light
4
and
power,
heating,
telegraph,
cable
television,
district
5
telegraph
and
alarm,
motor
bus,
trolley
bus,
street
railway
or
6
other
public
transit,
waterworks,
sewer
services,
or
gasworks
,
7
within
the
city
for
a
term
of
not
more
than
twenty-five
years.
8
When
considering
whether
to
grant,
amend,
extend,
or
renew
a
9
franchise,
a
city
shall
hold
a
public
hearing
on
the
question
10
follow
the
same
procedure
for
approval
as
provided
in
section
11
364.7
.
Notice
of
the
time
and
place
of
the
hearing
shall
be
12
published
as
provided
in
section
362.3
.
The
franchise
may
be
13
granted,
amended,
extended,
or
renewed
only
by
an
ordinance,
14
but
no
exclusive
franchise
shall
be
granted,
amended,
extended,
15
or
renewed.
16
b.
Such
an
ordinance
shall
not
become
effective
unless
17
approved
at
an
election.
The
A
proposal
may
be
submitted
18
by
the
council
on
its
own
motion
to
the
voters
at
any
city
19
election
or
by
petition
of
eligible
electors
.
Upon
receipt
of
20
a
petition
meeting
the
requirements
of
section
362.4
requesting
21
that
a
proposal
be
submitted
to
the
voters,
the
council
shall
22
submit
the
proposal
at
the
next
regular
city
election
or
at
23
a
special
election
called
for
that
purpose
before
the
next
24
regular
city
election.
However,
the
city
council
may
dispense
25
with
such
election
as
to
the
grant,
amendment,
extension,
or
26
renewal
of
an
electric
light
and
power,
heating,
waterworks,
27
sewer
services
under
section
357A.23
,
or
gasworks
franchise
28
unless
there
is
a
valid
petition
requesting
submission
of
the
29
proposal
to
the
voters,
or
the
party
seeking
such
franchise,
30
grant,
amendment,
extension,
or
renewal
requests
an
election.
31
If
a
majority
of
those
voting
approves
the
proposal,
the
city
32
may
proceed
as
proposed.
The
complete
text
of
the
ordinance
33
shall
be
included
on
the
ballot
if
conventional
paper
ballots
34
are
used.
If
an
optical
scan
voting
system
is
used,
the
35
-1-
LSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
1/
7
S.F.
_____
proposal
shall
be
stated
on
the
optical
scan
ballot,
and
the
1
full
text
of
the
ordinance
posted
for
the
voters
pursuant
to
2
section
52.25
.
All
absentee
voters
shall
receive
the
full
text
3
of
the
ordinance
.
4
c.
Notice
of
the
election
shall
be
given
by
publication
5
as
prescribed
in
section
49.53
in
a
newspaper
of
general
6
circulation
in
the
city.
7
Sec.
2.
Section
380.3,
Code
2025,
is
amended
to
read
as
8
follows:
9
380.3
Two
considerations
before
final
passage
——
how
waived.
10
1.
A
proposed
ordinance
or
amendment
must
be
considered
11
and
voted
on
for
passage
at
two
council
meetings
prior
to
12
the
meeting
at
which
it
is
to
be
finally
passed,
unless
this
13
requirement
is
suspended
by
a
recorded
vote
of
not
less
than
14
three-fourths
of
all
of
the
members
of
the
council.
If
a
15
proposed
ordinance,
amendment,
or
resolution
fails
to
receive
16
sufficient
votes
for
passage
at
any
consideration
and
vote
17
thereon,
the
proposed
ordinance,
amendment,
or
resolution
shall
18
be
considered
defeated.
19
2.
Notwithstanding
subsection
1,
a
proposed
ordinance
under
20
section
364.2,
subsection
4,
may
be
passed
following
the
same
21
procedure
for
approval
as
provided
in
section
364.7.
22
Sec.
3.
Section
388.2,
Code
2025,
is
amended
to
read
as
23
follows:
24
388.2
Submission
to
voters
council
.
25
1.
a.
The
proposal
of
a
city
to
establish,
acquire,
26
lease,
or
dispose
of
a
city
utility,
except
a
sanitary
sewage
27
or
storm
water
drainage
system,
in
order
to
undertake
or
to
28
discontinue
the
operation
of
the
city
utility,
or
the
proposal
29
to
establish
or
dissolve
a
combined
utility
system,
or
the
30
proposal
to
establish
or
discontinue
a
utility
board,
is
31
subject
to
the
approval
of
the
voters
of
the
city,
except
that
32
a
same
procedure
for
approval
as
provided
in
section
364.7.
33
Additionally,
a
board
may
be
discontinued
by
resolution
of
the
34
council
when
the
city
utility,
city
utilities,
or
combined
35
-2-
LSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
2/
7
S.F.
_____
utility
system
it
administers
is
disposed
of
or
leased
for
a
1
period
of
over
five
years.
2
b.
Upon
the
council’s
own
motion,
the
proposal
may
be
3
submitted
to
the
voters
at
the
general
election,
the
regular
4
city
election,
or
at
a
special
election
called
for
that
5
purpose.
Upon
receipt
of
a
valid
petition
as
defined
in
6
section
362.4
,
requesting
that
a
proposal
be
submitted
to
the
7
voters,
the
council
shall
submit
the
proposal
at
the
next
8
regular
city
election.
9
c.
If
the
special
election
is
to
establish
a
gas
or
electric
10
utility
pursuant
to
this
section
,
or
if
such
a
proposal
is
11
to
be
included
on
the
ballot
at
the
regular
city
or
general
12
election,
the
mayor
or
council
shall
give
notice
as
required
by
13
section
376.1
to
the
county
commissioner
of
elections
and
to
14
any
utility
whose
property
would
be
affected
by
such
election
15
not
less
than
sixty
days
before
the
proposed
date
of
the
16
special,
regular
city,
or
general
election.
17
d.
A
proposal
for
the
establishment
of
a
utility
board
must
18
specify
a
board
of
either
three
or
five
members.
19
2.
a.
If
a
majority
of
those
voting
for
and
against
20
the
proposal
approves
the
proposal,
the
city
may
proceed
as
21
proposed.
22
b.
If
a
majority
of
those
voting
for
and
against
the
23
proposal
does
not
approve
the
proposal,
the
same
or
a
similar
24
proposal
may
not
be
submitted
to
the
voters
of
the
city
for
at
25
least
four
years
from
the
date
of
the
election
at
which
the
26
proposal
was
defeated.
27
Sec.
4.
Section
388.2A,
Code
2025,
is
amended
to
read
as
28
follows:
29
388.2A
Procedure
for
disposal
of
city
utility
by
sale.
30
1.
A
proposal
to
discontinue
a
city
utility
and
dispose
of
31
such
utility
by
sale,
whether
upon
the
council’s
own
motion
32
or
upon
the
receipt
of
a
valid
petition
pursuant
to
section
33
388.2,
subsection
1,
paragraph
“b”
,
shall
not
be
submitted
34
to
the
voters
of
the
city
pursuant
to
section
388.2
at
any
35
-3-
LSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
3/
7
S.F.
_____
election
unless
the
governing
body
of
the
city
utility
meets
1
the
requirements
of
this
section
shall
meet
the
requirements
of
2
this
section
before
a
final
determination
is
made
.
3
2.
a.
(1)
The
governing
body
of
the
city
utility
shall
4
determine
the
fair
market
value
of
the
utility
system
after
5
obtaining
two
appraisals
of
the
system’s
fair
market
value.
6
One
appraisal
shall
be
obtained
from
an
independent
appraiser
7
selected
by
the
governing
body,
and
the
other
appraisal
shall
8
be
obtained
from
an
independent
appraiser
approved
by
the
Iowa
9
utilities
commission.
Both
appraisals
shall
be
conducted
10
in
conformance
with
the
uniform
standards
of
professional
11
appraisal
practice
or
substantially
similar
standards.
12
(2)
Any
appraisal
obtained
pursuant
to
this
paragraph
13
shall
consider
the
depreciated
value
of
the
capital
assets
14
to
be
sold,
the
loss
of
future
revenues
to
the
city
utility,
15
including
the
right
to
generate
surpluses,
and
the
cost
of
any
16
capital
improvements
reasonably
necessary
to
provide
adequate
17
service
and
facilities
to
the
city
utility’s
customers.
18
b.
After
considering
the
appraisals
obtained
pursuant
to
19
paragraph
“a”
,
the
governing
body
shall
establish
the
city
20
utility’s
fair
market
value.
The
fair
market
value
shall
be
21
the
greater
of
any
of
the
following:
22
(1)
The
average
of
the
two
appraisals
obtained
pursuant
to
23
paragraph
“a”
.
24
(2)
The
depreciated
value
of
the
capital
assets
to
be
sold.
25
(3)
The
amount
necessary
to
retire
all
of
the
city’s
26
outstanding
revenue
and
general
obligations
issued
for
purposes
27
of
the
city
utility.
28
c.
The
governing
body’s
determination
of
a
city
utility’s
29
fair
market
value
pursuant
to
this
subsection
shall
not
be
30
dispositive
of
the
city
utility’s
system
price,
which
shall
be
31
subject
to
negotiation
by
the
governing
body.
32
d.
The
governing
body
shall
prepare
an
inventory
of
the
33
city
utility’s
real
and
personal
property,
and
a
statement
of
34
net
position
or
balance
sheet
of
the
city
utility,
including
35
-4-
LSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
4/
7
S.F.
_____
all
assets,
liabilities,
outstanding
revenue
and
general
1
obligations
used
to
finance
the
city
utility
system.
2
e.
The
governing
body
shall
prepare
a
financial
information
3
statement
of
the
city
utility
that
includes
current
and
4
projected
rate
schedules
for
the
next
five
fiscal
years,
as
5
well
as
the
five
most
recent
fiscal
year
revenue
statements,
if
6
such
statements
exist,
and
a
projection
of
the
city
utility’s
7
revenue
statements
for
the
next
five
fiscal
years.
8
f.
The
governing
body
shall
consider
alternatives
to
9
disposing
of
the
city
utility
system
by
sale,
including
10
entering
into
an
agreement
pursuant
to
chapter
28E
,
or
into
a
11
finance
agreement,
purchase
agreement,
or
lease
agreement
with
12
another
entity
described
in
section
476.1,
subsection
3
.
13
g.
(1)
The
governing
body
shall
make
available
on
its
14
internet
site,
at
least
sixty
thirty
days
prior
to
submitting
a
15
proposal
for
election
pursuant
to
section
388.2
,
a
copy
of
each
16
item
listed
in
paragraphs
“a”
through
“f”
of
this
subsection
.
17
(2)
If,
at
the
time
of
posting
information
pursuant
to
18
subparagraph
(1),
the
governing
body
has
received
any
offers
or
19
appraisals
of
fair
market
value
from
any
prospective
purchasers
20
of
the
city
utility
system
in
connection
with
a
proposal
to
21
discontinue
the
city
utility
and
dispose
of
such
utility
by
22
sale,
then
the
governing
body
shall
make
available
on
its
23
internet
site
each
offer
and
appraisal
then
in
existence.
24
Proprietary
information
of
a
rate-regulated
public
utility
25
under
chapter
476
that
is
exempt
from
disclosure
pursuant
to
26
section
22.7
may
be
withheld
from
disclosure
on
the
governing
27
body’s
internet
site.
The
governing
body
may
continue
to
28
receive
new
or
revised
offers
or
appraisals
thereafter.
29
(3)
The
governing
body
shall
make
a
good-faith
effort
to
30
provide,
by
regular
mail
to
each
property
owner
of
the
city
and
31
each
ratepayer
of
the
city
utility,
a
notice
of
the
proposal
to
32
dispose
of
the
city
utility
by
sale,
a
summary
of
the
proposal,
33
a
summary
of
the
information
described
in
subparagraphs
(1)
and
34
(2),
and
instructions
for
locating
the
information
described
35
-5-
LSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
5/
7
S.F.
_____
in
subparagraphs
(1)
and
(2)
on
the
governing
body’s
internet
1
site.
2
3.
Upon
the
governing
body
meeting
the
requirements
3
of
subsection
2
,
a
city
council
may
submit
a
proposal
to
4
discontinue
and
dispose
of
a
city
utility
pursuant
to
section
5
388.2
.
6
4.
If
a
proposal
to
discontinue
and
dispose
of
a
city
7
utility
is
to
be
submitted
to
voters
following
the
receipt
8
of
a
valid
petition
pursuant
to
section
388.2,
subsection
1
,
9
paragraph
“b”
,
the
council
shall
submit
the
proposal
at
the
next
10
general
election,
regular
city
election,
or
a
special
election
11
called
for
that
purpose,
within
one
hundred
twenty
days
after
12
the
governing
body
of
the
city
utility
meets
the
requirements
13
of
subsection
2
.
14
5.
4.
A
proposal
to
discontinue
and
dispose
of
a
city
15
utility
by
sale
that
is
approved
by
the
voters
pursuant
to
16
section
388.2
,
subsection
2,
paragraph
“a”
,
shall
not
require
17
the
governing
body
or
any
purchasing
entity
to
finalize
a
sale
18
of
the
city
utility.
19
6.
No
action
may
be
brought
which
questions
the
legality
of
20
the
election
or
the
city
and
governing
body’s
compliance
with
21
this
section
,
except
as
provided
in
section
57.1
,
within
twenty
22
days
of
the
canvass
of
votes
for
the
election
by
the
county
23
board
of
supervisors.
24
EXPLANATION
25
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
26
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
27
This
bill
relates
to
approval
requirements
for
city
28
utilities.
29
Under
current
law,
when
a
city
is
considering
whether
to
30
grant,
amend,
extend,
or
renew
a
franchise
within
the
city,
a
31
public
hearing
must
be
held.
After
the
public
hearing,
the
32
franchise
may
be
granted,
amended,
extended,
or
renewed
only
33
by
an
ordinance,
and
is
not
effective
unless
approved
at
an
34
election.
Generally,
an
ordinance
must
be
considered
and
voted
35
-6-
LSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
6/
7
S.F.
_____
on
for
passage
at
two
council
meetings
prior
to
the
meeting
at
1
which
the
ordinance
is
to
be
finally
passed.
The
bill
provides
2
that
after
the
public
hearing,
the
city
council
may
make
the
3
final
determination
on
whether
to
grant,
amend,
extend,
or
4
renew
the
franchise.
The
bill
allows
the
city
council
to
make
5
the
final
determination
in
a
single
meeting.
6
Under
current
law,
a
proposal
of
a
city
to
establish,
7
acquire,
lease,
or
dispose
of
a
city
utility,
in
order
to
8
undertake
or
to
discontinue
the
operation
of
the
city
utility,
9
or
the
proposal
to
establish
or
dissolve
a
combined
utility
10
system,
or
the
proposal
to
establish
or
discontinue
a
utility
11
board,
is
subject
to
the
approval
of
the
voters
of
the
city.
12
Under
the
bill,
the
approval
requirement
is
changed
to
require
13
the
city
council
to
set
forth
its
proposal
in
a
resolution
and
14
publish
notice
of
the
resolution
and
of
a
date,
time,
and
place
15
of
a
public
hearing
on
the
proposal.
The
bill
provides
that
16
after
the
public
hearing,
the
city
council
may
make
the
final
17
determination
on
the
proposal
by
resolution.
18
Under
current
law,
a
proposal
to
discontinue
a
city
utility
19
and
dispose
of
such
utility
by
sale,
whether
upon
the
city
20
council’s
motion
or
upon
the
receipt
of
a
valid
petition
is
21
subject
to
the
approval
of
the
voters
of
the
city.
The
city
22
must
make
the
proposal
available
at
least
60
days
before
23
submitting
a
proposal
for
the
election.
Under
the
bill,
the
24
approval
requirement
is
changed
to
require
the
city
council
25
to
set
forth
the
proposal
in
a
resolution
and
publish
notice
26
of
the
resolution
and
of
a
date,
time,
and
place
of
a
public
27
hearing
on
the
proposal
at
least
30
days
before
the
hearing.
28
The
bill
also
provides
that
after
the
public
hearing,
the
city
29
council
may
make
the
final
determination
on
the
proposal
by
30
resolution.
31
-7-
LSB
2373XC
(2)
91
sb/js
7/
7