Senate
File
639
-
Introduced
SENATE
FILE
639
BY
COMMITTEE
ON
WAYS
AND
MEANS
(SUCCESSOR
TO
SF
570)
(SUCCESSOR
TO
SSB
1203)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
creating
a
specialty
business
court,
and
including
1
effective
date
provisions.
2
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
3
TLSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
S.F.
639
Section
1.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6801
Establishment
of
business
1
court.
2
The
supreme
court
shall
establish
and
maintain
a
business
3
court
as
authorized
by
the
general
assembly
in
this
part.
4
Sec.
2.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6802
Purpose.
5
The
purpose
of
the
business
court
is
to
expeditiously
6
resolve
complex
commercial
and
business
litigation
through
the
7
court
system.
8
Sec.
3.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6803
Jurisdiction.
9
1.
The
business
court
shall
have
jurisdiction,
concurrent
10
with
the
district
court,
over
cases
where
compensatory
damages
11
totaling
five
hundred
thousand
dollars
or
more
are
alleged,
12
and
cases
that
involve
claims
seeking
primarily
injunctive
or
13
declaratory
relief,
that
meet
at
least
one
of
the
following
14
conditions:
15
a.
Arise
from
technology
licensing
agreements,
including
16
software
and
biotechnology
licensing
agreements,
or
any
17
agreement
involving
the
licensing
of
any
intellectual
property
18
right,
including
patent
rights.
19
b.
Relate
to
the
internal
affairs
of
business
entities,
20
including
corporations
created
under
chapter
490
or
504,
21
limited
liability
companies
created
under
chapter
489,
general
22
partnerships
created
under
chapter
486A,
limited
partnerships
23
created
under
chapter
488,
sole
proprietorships,
professional
24
associations,
real
estate
investment
trusts,
and
joint
25
ventures,
including
the
rights
or
obligations
between
or
26
among
business
participants,
or
the
liability
or
indemnity
of
27
business
participants,
officers,
directors,
managers,
trustees,
28
or
partners,
among
themselves
or
to
the
business
entity.
29
c.
Involve
claims
of
breach
of
contract,
fraud,
30
misrepresentation,
or
statutory
violations
between
businesses
31
arising
out
of
business
transactions
or
relationships.
32
d.
Is
a
shareholder
derivative
action
or
commercial
class
33
action.
34
e.
Arise
from
commercial
bank
transactions.
35
-1-
LSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
1/
7
S.F.
639
f.
Relate
to
trade
secrets,
or
noncompete,
nonsolicitation,
1
or
confidentiality
agreements.
2
g.
Involve
commercial
real
property
disputes
other
than
3
residential
landlord-tenant
disputes
and
foreclosures.
4
h.
Is
a
trade
secret,
antitrust,
or
securities-related
5
action.
6
i.
Involve
business
tort
claims
between
or
among
two
or
7
more
business
entities
or
individuals
as
to
their
business
or
8
investment
activities
relating
to
contracts,
transactions,
or
9
relationships
between
or
among
them.
10
2.
The
business
court
shall
not
have
jurisdiction
over
any
11
of
the
following:
12
a.
A
civil
action
brought
by
or
against
a
governmental
13
entity,
unless
the
governmental
entity
invokes
or
consents
to
14
the
jurisdiction
of
the
business
court.
15
b.
Any
claim
in
which
a
party
seeks
recovery
of
monetary
16
damages
for
personal
injury
or
death
or
any
claim
arising
17
under
section
714.16,
chapter
633,
or
chapter
633A,
unless
all
18
parties
and
a
judge
of
the
business
court
agree
that
the
claim
19
may
proceed
in
the
business
court.
20
c.
Actions
arising
out
of
professional
negligence
unless
the
21
underlying
claim
alleges
negligence
in
a
transaction
within
the
22
jurisdiction
of
the
business
court
under
this
section.
23
Sec.
4.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6804
Initial
filing
——
removal
and
24
remand
——
transfer
and
dismissal.
25
1.
An
action
authorized
in
section
602.6803
may
be
filed
26
in
the
business
court.
If
the
business
court
does
not
have
27
subject
matter
jurisdiction
over
the
action,
or
part
of
the
28
action,
the
court
shall,
at
the
option
of
the
party
filing
the
29
action,
do
one
of
the
following:
30
a.
Transfer
the
action
or
part
of
the
action
to
an
31
appropriate
district
court.
32
b.
Dismiss
the
action
or
part
of
the
action
without
33
prejudice
to
the
parties’
rights.
34
c.
Retain
jurisdiction
of
the
action
not
subject
to
35
-2-
LSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
2/
7
S.F.
639
the
jurisdiction
of
the
business
court
if
the
court
has
1
jurisdiction
of
a
portion
of
the
action.
2
2.
A
party
to
an
action
filed
in
a
district
court
that
is
3
within
the
subject
matter
jurisdiction
of
the
business
court
4
may
file
a
motion
to
transfer
the
action
to
the
business
court
5
in
the
district
court
where
the
action
was
initially
filed.
6
The
motion
to
transfer
shall
be
assigned
to
a
business
court
7
judge
to
determine
if
the
business
court
has
subject
matter
8
jurisdiction.
If
the
business
court
does
not
have
jurisdiction
9
of
the
action
or
part
of
the
action,
the
action
or
part
of
10
the
action
shall
remain
in
the
district
court
where
it
was
11
initially
filed.
12
3.
Removal
of
an
action
to
the
business
court
is
not
subject
13
to
rule
of
civil
procedure
1.441.
14
Sec.
5.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6805
Appeals.
15
The
procedure
governing
an
appeal
or
original
proceeding
16
from
the
business
court
is
the
same
as
the
procedure
for
an
17
appeal
or
original
proceeding
from
a
district
court.
18
Sec.
6.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6806
Composition
of
business
19
court.
20
1.
The
governor
shall
appoint
not
fewer
than
two
nor
21
more
than
three
judges
to
serve
exclusively
on
the
business
22
court.
On
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
and
thereafter
23
upon
the
occurrence
of
any
vacancy
on
the
business
court,
the
24
governor
shall
announce
each
vacancy.
The
state
judicial
25
nominating
commission
shall,
applying
the
same
procedure
used
26
by
a
district
judicial
nominating
commission
under
chapter
27
46,
nominate
for
each
vacancy
two
candidates
meeting
the
28
qualifications
for
appointment
to
district
court.
The
governor
29
shall
appoint
one
of
the
two
nominees
to
fill
the
vacancy.
30
2.
In
addition
to
the
judges
appointed
under
subsection
1,
31
the
supreme
court
may
assign
as
visiting
judges
of
the
business
32
court
district
court
judges
and
senior
judges.
33
Sec.
7.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6807
Business
court
judge
assigned
34
to
facilitate
settlement
conference.
35
-3-
LSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
3/
7
S.F.
639
The
state
court
administrator
or
the
administrator’s
1
designee
shall
assign
one
business
court
judge
or
visiting
2
judge
to
preside
over
every
action
filed
or
transferred
to
the
3
business
court
and
a
second
business
court
judge
or
visiting
4
judge
to
serve
as
a
settlement
conference
judge.
5
Sec.
8.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6808
Salary
——
conditions
of
6
office.
7
1.
A
judge
of
the
business
court
shall
receive
the
annual
8
salary
set
for
a
district
judge
under
section
602.1501.
9
2.
A
judge
of
the
business
court
shall
be
subject
to
10
retention
election
under
chapter
46.
11
3.
A
judge
of
the
business
court
shall
be
subject
to
12
disqualification
under
section
602.1606.
13
4.
A
judge
of
the
business
court
shall
be
subject
to
the
14
authority
of
the
supreme
court
and
the
commission
on
judicial
15
qualifications
under
article
2.
16
5.
A
judge
of
the
business
court
shall
be
subject
to
17
impeachment
under
section
602.2201.
18
6.
A
judge
of
the
business
court
shall
be
subject
to
the
19
Iowa
code
of
judicial
conduct.
20
Sec.
9.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6809
Jury
practice
and
procedure.
21
1.
A
jury
trial
of
the
business
court
shall
be
held
in
a
22
county
in
which
venue
is
proper
under
the
Iowa
rules
of
civil
23
procedure.
24
2.
Subject
to
subsection
1,
a
jury
trial
in
an
action
25
removed
to
the
business
court
shall
be
held
in
the
county
in
26
which
the
action
was
originally
filed.
27
3.
Subject
to
subsection
1,
a
jury
trial
in
an
action
filed
28
initially
in
the
business
court
shall
be
held
in
any
county,
as
29
chosen
by
the
plaintiff,
in
which
the
action
could
have
been
30
filed
under
the
Iowa
rules
of
civil
procedure.
31
4.
The
parties
and
the
judge
of
the
business
court
may
agree
32
to
hold
the
jury
trial
in
any
other
county.
However,
a
party
33
shall
not
be
required
to
agree
to
hold
the
jury
trial
in
a
34
different
county.
35
-4-
LSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
4/
7
S.F.
639
5.
The
drawing
of
jury
panels,
selection
of
jurors,
and
1
other
jury
practice
and
procedure
in
the
business
court
shall
2
follow
the
standards
for
juries
provided
in
chapter
607A.
3
6.
Practice,
procedure,
rules
of
evidence,
issuance
of
4
process
and
writs,
and
all
other
matters
pertaining
to
the
5
conduct
of
trials,
hearings,
and
other
business
in
the
business
6
court
are
governed
by
the
laws
and
rules
prescribed
for
7
district
courts,
unless
otherwise
provided
under
this
part.
8
Sec.
10.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6810
Written
opinions.
9
To
facilitate
the
establishment
of
a
coherent
body
of
law,
a
10
judge
of
the
business
court
shall
issue
a
written
opinion
when
11
deciding
issues
of
law
by
order
or
judgment,
unless
any
of
the
12
following
apply:
13
1.
The
court
has
a
well-developed
body
of
law
on
the
issue.
14
2.
The
court
is
applying
the
precedent
on
the
issue.
15
3.
Another
opinion
on
the
issue
will
not
significantly
16
contribute
to
the
development
of
the
law.
17
Sec.
11.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6811
Business
court
staff.
18
The
state
court
administrator
or
the
administrator’s
19
designee
may
appoint
personnel
necessary
for
the
operation
of
20
the
business
court.
21
Sec.
12.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6812
Seal.
22
The
seal
of
the
business
court
is
the
same
as
that
provided
23
by
law
for
a
district
court
except
the
seal
must
contain
the
24
phrase
“The
Business
Court
of
Iowa”.
25
Sec.
13.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6813
Rules.
26
Subject
to
the
provisions
of
this
part,
the
supreme
court
27
shall
promulgate
rules
for
the
jurisdiction
and
operation
of
28
the
business
court
as
the
supreme
court
determines
necessary,
29
including
rules
providing
for
any
of
the
following:
30
1.
The
timely
and
efficient
transfer
and
remand
of
cases
to
31
and
from
the
business
court.
32
2.
The
assignment
of
cases
to
judges
of
the
business
court.
33
Sec.
14.
NEW
SECTION
.
602.6814
Transition
provision.
34
This
part
applies
to
civil
actions
described
under
section
35
-5-
LSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
5/
7
S.F.
639
602.6803
filed
on
or
after
the
effective
date
of
this
Act.
1
If
an
action
described
under
section
602.6803
was
pending
in
2
a
district
court
before
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
the
3
parties
may
agree
to
have
the
civil
action
transferred
or
4
removed
to
the
business
court
in
accordance
with
this
part.
5
Sec.
15.
EFFECTIVE
DATE.
This
Act
takes
effect
September
6
1,
2025.
7
EXPLANATION
8
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
9
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
10
This
bill
creates
the
business
court
of
Iowa.
11
The
bill
provides
that
the
business
court
has
jurisdiction
12
over
cases
involving
compensatory
damages
of
$500,000
or
13
more
involving
claims
that
arise
from
at
least
one
of
the
14
following:
technology
licensing
agreements;
the
internal
15
affairs
of
business
entities;
breach
of
contract,
fraud,
16
misrepresentation,
or
statutory
violations
between
businesses;
17
shareholder
derivative
actions
or
commercial
class
actions;
18
commercial
bank
transactions;
trade
secrets
or
noncompete
19
agreements;
commercial
real
estate
disputes;
antitrust
or
20
securities-related
actions;
or
business
tort
claims.
21
The
bill
sets
forth
provisions
governing
transfer,
22
dismissal,
retention,
and
removal
of
cases
in
the
business
23
court,
and
specifies
that
the
procedure
for
appeals
is
the
24
same
as
for
proceedings
in
a
district
court.
Removal
of
an
25
action
from
the
business
court
is
not
subject
to
rule
of
civil
26
procedure
1.441
(time
to
move
or
plead).
27
The
bill
requires
the
governor
to
appoint
no
fewer
than
two
28
but
not
more
than
three
judges
to
the
business
court
from
among
29
nominees
selected
by
the
state
judicial
nominating
commission
30
and
provides
that
if
a
vacancy
occurs,
the
vacancy
must
also
be
31
filled
following
the
same
procedure.
32
The
bill
allows
the
supreme
court
to
appoint
district
court
33
judges
and
senior
judges
as
visiting
judges
of
the
business
34
court
and
requires
the
state
administrator
or
designee
to
35
-6-
LSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
6/
7
S.F.
639
assign
one
business
court
judge
or
visiting
judge
to
preside
1
over
every
action
in
the
business
court
and
a
second
judge
to
2
serve
as
settlement
conference
judge.
3
The
bill
provides
that
a
business
court
judge
shall
receive
4
the
same
salary
as
a
district
court
judge
and
further
provides
5
for
the
conditions
of
office
of
a
business
court
judge.
6
The
bill
creates
directions
for
the
jury
practice
and
7
procedure
in
the
business
court,
including
venue
of
jury
8
trials.
9
The
bill
requires
business
court
judges
to
produce
written
10
opinions
to
create
a
coherent
body
of
law.
A
business
court
11
judge
does
not
have
to
issue
a
written
opinion
if
the
court
12
has
a
well-developed
body
of
law
on
the
issue,
the
court
is
13
applying
precedent,
or
another
opinion
on
the
issue
will
not
14
significantly
contribute
to
the
development
of
the
body
of
law.
15
The
bill
authorizes
the
court
to
appoint
personnel
necessary
16
for
operation
of
the
court
and
creates
a
seal
of
the
business
17
court.
The
bill
directs
the
supreme
court
to
establish
court
18
rules
as
necessary
for
the
operation
of
the
business
court.
19
The
bill
takes
effect
September
1,
2025,
and
provides
for
20
the
transfer
of
civil
actions
pending
before
that
date
to
the
21
business
court
by
agreement
of
the
parties.
22
-7-
LSB
2452SZ
(3)
91
cm/ns
7/
7