Senate
File
2380
-
Introduced
SENATE
FILE
2380
BY
COMMITTEE
ON
TECHNOLOGY
(SUCCESSOR
TO
SSB
3174)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
abusive
litigation
alleging
internet
site
1
accessibility
violations,
and
including
applicability
2
provisions.
3
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
4
TLSB
6910SV
(1)
91
lh/jh
S.F.
2380
Section
1.
NEW
SECTION
.
685A.1
Definitions.
1
As
used
in
this
chapter,
unless
the
context
otherwise
2
requires:
3
1.
“Access
violation”
means
any
allegation
that
a
public
4
accommodation
does
not
provide
sufficient
access
under
Tit.
5
III
of
the
federal
Americans
with
Disabilities
Act
of
1990,
42
6
U.S.C.
§12181
et
seq.,
under
chapter
216,
or
under
any
other
7
similar
state
or
federal
law
relating
to
accessibility.
8
2.
“Public
accommodation”
means
the
same
as
defined
in
9
42
U.S.C.
§2000a
et
seq.
“Public
accommodation”
includes
an
10
internet
site
operated
by
a
resident.
11
3.
“Resident”
means
an
individual
domiciled
in
this
12
state,
or
an
entity
organized
under
the
laws
of
this
state
or
13
authorized
to
transact
business
in
this
state
and
registered
14
with
the
secretary
of
state.
15
Sec.
2.
NEW
SECTION
.
685A.2
Civil
action
for
determination
16
of
abusive
litigation.
17
1.
The
attorney
general,
on
behalf
of
a
class
of
residents
18
pursuant
to
rule
1.261
of
the
Iowa
rules
of
civil
procedure,
19
that
is
subject
to
litigation
alleging
an
internet
site
access
20
violation,
or
any
resident
who
is
subject
to
such
litigation,
21
may
file
a
civil
action
against
the
party,
attorney,
or
22
law
firm
that
initiated
such
litigation
for
a
determination
23
of
whether
the
litigation
alleging
an
internet
site
access
24
violation
constitutes
abusive
litigation.
25
2.
In
determining
whether
litigation
alleging
an
internet
26
site
access
violation
constitutes
abusive
litigation,
the
court
27
shall
consider
the
totality
of
the
circumstances
to
determine
28
whether
the
primary
purpose
of
the
litigation
alleging
an
29
internet
site
access
violation
is
to
obtain
payment
from
the
30
defendant
due
to
the
cost
of
defending
the
action
rather
than
31
to
remedy
the
internet
site
access
violation.
In
making
this
32
determination,
the
court
may
consider,
but
is
not
limited
to,
33
the
following
factors:
34
a.
The
number
of
substantially
similar
actions
filed
by
the
35
-1-
LSB
6910SV
(1)
91
lh/jh
1/
5
S.F.
2380
same
plaintiff,
attorney,
or
law
firm,
and
any
history
of
such
1
plaintiff,
attorney,
or
law
firm
filing
frivolous
litigation
or
2
litigation
declared
abusive
by
a
court
in
the
past
ten
years.
3
b.
The
number
of
full-time
employees
employed
by
the
4
defendant
and
the
resources
available
to
the
defendant
to
5
engage
in
litigation.
6
c.
The
resources
available
to
the
defendant
to
correct
the
7
alleged
internet
site
access
violation.
8
d.
Whether
the
jurisdiction
or
venue
where
the
action
9
is
brought
creates
a
substantial
obstacle
to
defending
the
10
litigation.
11
e.
Whether
the
filing
party
or
attorney
is
a
resident
or
is
12
licensed
to
practice
law
in
this
state.
13
f.
The
nature
of
settlement
discussions
and
the
14
reasonableness
of
settlement
offers
and
refusals
to
settle.
15
Such
settlement
information
shall
be
used
only
for
purposes
of
16
this
chapter
and
shall
not
otherwise
alter
applicable
rules
of
17
evidence.
18
g.
Whether
factors
supporting
sanctions
exist
under
19
rule
1.413
of
the
Iowa
rules
of
civil
procedure
and
whether
20
sanctions
would
be
appropriate.
21
3.
a.
If
a
defendant
in
litigation
alleging
an
internet
22
site
access
violation
makes
a
good-faith
attempt
to
correct
the
23
alleged
violation
within
thirty
days
after
receiving
written
24
notice
or
being
served
with
a
petition
containing
sufficient
25
detail
to
identify
and
correct
the
alleged
violation,
26
there
shall
be
a
rebuttable
presumption
that
the
subsequent
27
initiation
or
continuation
of
litigation
constitutes
abusive
28
litigation.
29
b.
The
rebuttable
presumption
shall
not
apply
if
the
alleged
30
internet
site
access
violation
is
not
corrected,
as
determined
31
by
the
court,
within
ninety
days
after
written
notice
or
32
service
of
the
petition.
33
c.
The
court
shall
not
determine
whether
the
litigation
is
34
abusive
until
the
expiration
of
the
ninety-day
period
or
until
35
-2-
LSB
6910SV
(1)
91
lh/jh
2/
5
S.F.
2380
the
alleged
violation
is
corrected,
whichever
occurs
first.
1
Sec.
3.
NEW
SECTION
.
685A.3
Attorney
general
determination.
2
If
the
attorney
general
issues
a
written
determination
that
3
litigation
alleging
an
internet
site
access
violation
is
not
4
abusive
and
such
written
determination
is
attached
to
the
5
petition
in
the
litigation
alleging
an
internet
site
access
6
violation,
there
shall
be
a
rebuttable
presumption
that
the
7
litigation
is
not
abusive.
8
Sec.
4.
NEW
SECTION
.
685A.4
Remedies.
9
1.
If
the
court
determines
that
litigation
alleging
an
10
internet
site
access
violation
constitutes
abusive
litigation,
11
the
court
may
award
to
the
prevailing
party
reasonable
attorney
12
fees
and
costs
incurred
in
bringing
the
action
under
this
13
chapter
and
in
defending
against
the
underlying
abusive
14
litigation.
15
2.
In
addition
to
attorney
fees
and
costs,
the
court
may
16
award
punitive
damages
or
impose
sanctions
not
to
exceed
three
17
times
the
amount
of
attorney
fees
awarded
under
subsection
1.
18
3.
At
the
conclusion
of
the
underlying
litigation
alleging
19
an
internet
site
access
violation,
the
court
shall
review
any
20
determination
of
whether
the
litigation
is
abusive
and
any
21
award
of
attorney
fees
to
determine
the
reasonableness
of
the
22
award
prior
to
entry
of
judgment.
The
results
obtained
in
the
23
litigation
alleging
an
internet
site
access
violation
shall
be
24
weighed
heavily,
particularly
if
the
plaintiff
prevailed.
25
Sec.
5.
NEW
SECTION
.
685A.5
Repeal.
26
If
the
federal
department
of
justice
issues
standards
27
concerning
internet
site
accessibility
under
Tit.
III
of
the
28
federal
Americans
with
Disabilities
Act
of
1990,
42
U.S.C.
29
§12181
et
seq.,
the
attorney
general
shall
notify
the
Iowa
Code
30
editor.
Upon
receipt
of
such
notification,
this
chapter
shall
31
be
repealed.
32
Sec.
6.
APPLICABILITY.
This
Act
applies
to
actions
33
commenced
on
or
after
July
1,
2026.
34
EXPLANATION
35
-3-
LSB
6910SV
(1)
91
lh/jh
3/
5
S.F.
2380
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
1
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
2
This
bill
relates
to
abusive
litigation
alleging
internet
3
site
accessibility
violations.
4
The
bill
defines
“access
violation”
as
an
allegation
5
that
a
public
accommodation
does
not
provide
sufficient
6
access
under
Tit.
III
of
the
federal
Americans
with
7
Disabilities
Act
of
1990,
Code
chapter
216,
or
similar
state
8
or
federal
accessibility
laws.
The
bill
also
defines
“public
9
accommodation”
and
“resident”.
10
The
bill
provides
that
the
attorney
general,
on
behalf
of
11
a
class
of
residents
or
any
resident
subject
to
litigation
12
alleging
an
internet
site
access
violation,
may
file
a
civil
13
action
against
the
party,
attorney,
or
law
firm
that
initiated
14
the
underlying
litigation
to
determine
whether
the
litigation
15
constitutes
abusive
litigation.
16
The
bill
provides
that,
in
determining
whether
litigation
17
is
abusive,
the
court
must
consider
the
totality
of
the
18
circumstances
and
determine
whether
the
primary
purpose
of
19
the
litigation
is
to
obtain
payment
from
the
defendant
due
to
20
the
cost
of
defending
the
action
rather
than
to
remedy
the
21
alleged
internet
site
access
violation.
The
bill
provides
a
22
list
of
factors
the
court
may
consider,
including
the
number
23
of
substantially
similar
actions
filed
by
the
same
plaintiff
24
or
counsel
and
any
history
of
frivolous
or
abusive
litigation
25
within
the
past
10
years;
the
size
and
resources
of
the
26
defendant;
the
defendant’s
resources
to
correct
the
alleged
27
violation;
whether
the
chosen
jurisdiction
or
venue
creates
a
28
substantial
obstacle
to
defense;
whether
the
filing
party
or
29
attorney
is
a
resident
or
licensed
to
practice
law
in
Iowa;
30
the
nature
and
reasonableness
of
settlement
discussions;
and
31
whether
sanctions
would
be
appropriate.
32
The
bill
establishes
a
rebuttable
presumption
that
33
litigation
is
abusive
if
the
defendant
makes
a
good-faith
34
attempt
to
correct
the
alleged
internet
site
access
violation
35
-4-
LSB
6910SV
(1)
91
lh/jh
4/
5
S.F.
2380
within
30
days
after
receiving
written
notice
or
service
of
1
a
sufficiently
detailed
petition.
The
presumption
does
not
2
apply
if
the
internet
site
access
violation
is
not
corrected
3
within
90
days,
as
determined
by
the
court.
The
court
is
4
prohibited
from
determining
whether
litigation
is
abusive
until
5
the
expiration
of
the
90-day
period
or
until
the
internet
site
6
access
violation
is
corrected,
whichever
occurs
first.
7
The
bill
provides
that
if
the
attorney
general
issues
a
8
written
determination
that
litigation
alleging
an
internet
9
site
access
violation
is
not
abusive
and
the
determination
is
10
attached
to
the
petition
in
the
underlying
litigation,
there
is
11
a
rebuttable
presumption
that
the
litigation
is
not
abusive.
12
The
bill
provides
that
if
the
court
determines
that
13
litigation
constitutes
abusive
litigation,
the
court
may
award
14
reasonable
attorney
fees
and
costs
incurred
in
bringing
the
15
action
and
in
defending
against
the
underlying
litigation.
The
16
court
may
also
award
punitive
damages
or
impose
sanctions
not
17
to
exceed
three
times
the
amount
of
attorney
fees
awarded.
At
18
the
conclusion
of
the
underlying
litigation,
the
court
must
19
review
any
determination
of
abusive
litigation
and
any
attorney
20
fee
award
for
reasonableness
before
entry
of
judgment,
and
21
must
weigh
heavily
the
results
obtained
in
the
underlying
22
litigation,
particularly
if
the
plaintiff
prevailed.
23
The
bill
provides
that
if
the
federal
department
of
justice
24
issues
standards
concerning
internet
site
accessibility
under
25
Tit.
III
of
the
federal
Americans
with
Disabilities
Act
of
26
1990,
the
attorney
general
shall
notify
the
Iowa
Code
editor,
27
and
upon
such
notification,
the
bill
is
repealed.
28
The
bill
applies
to
actions
commenced
on
or
after
July
1,
29
2026.
30
-5-
LSB
6910SV
(1)
91
lh/jh
5/
5