House
File
2133
-
Introduced
HOUSE
FILE
2133
BY
SALMON
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
censorship
of
expression
on
interactive
1
computer
services
and
social
media
platforms
and
including
2
retroactive
applicability
provisions.
3
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
4
TLSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
H.F.
2133
Section
1.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.1
Definitions.
1
As
used
in
this
chapter,
unless
the
context
otherwise
2
requires:
3
1.
“Censor”
means
any
action
to
edit,
alter,
block,
ban,
4
delete,
remove,
deplatform,
demonetize,
de-boost,
regulate,
5
restrict,
inhibit
the
publication
or
reproduction
of,
deny
6
equal
access
or
visibility
to,
suspend
the
right
to
post,
7
remove,
or
otherwise
discriminate
against
expression.
“Censor”
8
also
includes
actions
that
deplatform
a
person
or
that
inhibit
9
or
restrict
an
interactive
computer
service
or
social
media
10
user’s
ability
to
be
viewed
by
or
interact
with
another
user
of
11
the
platform.
12
2.
“Expression”
means
any
word,
music,
sound,
still
or
13
moving
image,
number,
or
other
perceivable
communication.
14
3.
“Interactive
computer
service”
means
an
information
15
service,
system,
or
access
software
provider
that
provides
16
or
enables
computer
access
by
multiple
users
to
a
computer
17
server.
“Interactive
computer
service”
does
not
include
a
18
person
providing
connectivity
to
the
internet
or
another
wide
19
area
network.
20
4.
“Receive”
,
with
respect
to
an
expression,
means
to
read,
21
hear,
look
at,
access,
or
gain
access
to
the
expression.
22
5.
“Social
media
platform”
means
an
internet
search
engine,
23
internet
website,
internet
system,
access
software
provider,
24
or
application
that
is
open
to
the
public,
allows
a
user
25
of
the
platform
to
create
an
account,
and
enables
users
to
26
communicate
with
one
another
for
the
primary
purpose
of
posting
27
information,
comments,
messages,
or
images.
“Social
media
28
platform”
does
not
include
any
of
the
following:
29
a.
An
internet
service
provider.
30
b.
Electronic
mail.
31
c.
An
online
service,
application,
or
website
that
consists
32
primarily
of
news,
sports,
entertainment,
or
other
information
33
or
content
that
is
not
user
generated
but
is
preselected
by
34
the
provider
and
for
which
any
chat,
comments,
or
interactive
35
-1-
LSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
1/
7
H.F.
2133
functionality
is
incidental
to,
directly
related
to,
or
1
dependent
on
the
content.
2
6.
“Unlawful
expression”
means
an
expression
that
is
3
unlawful
under
the
Constitution
of
the
United
States,
federal
4
law,
the
Constitution
of
the
State
of
Iowa,
or
the
laws
of
this
5
state,
including
expression
that
constitutes
a
tort
under
the
6
laws
of
this
state
or
the
United
States.
7
7.
“User”
means
a
person
who
posts,
uploads,
transmits,
8
shares,
or
otherwise
publishes
or
receives
expression,
through
9
a
social
media
platform.
“User”
includes
a
person
who
has
a
10
social
media
platform
account
that
the
social
media
platform
11
has
disabled
or
locked.
12
Sec.
2.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.2
Prohibited
actions.
13
1.
An
interactive
computer
service
or
social
media
platform
14
shall
not
censor
a
user,
a
user’s
expression,
or
a
user’s
15
ability
to
receive
the
expression
of
another
person
based
on
16
any
of
the
following:
17
a.
The
viewpoint
of
the
user
or
another
person.
18
b.
The
viewpoint
represented
in
the
user’s
expression
or
19
another
person’s
expression.
20
c.
The
geographic
location
of
a
user
in
the
state.
21
2.
This
section
applies
regardless
of
whether
the
viewpoint
22
is
expressed
on
an
interactive
computer
service,
a
social
media
23
platform,
or
through
any
other
medium.
24
Sec.
3.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.3
Waiver
prohibited.
25
1.
A
waiver
or
purported
waiver
of
the
protections
provided
26
by
this
chapter
is
void
as
unlawful
and
against
public
policy,
27
and
a
court
or
arbitrator
shall
not
enforce
or
give
effect
28
to
the
waiver,
including
in
an
action
brought
under
section
29
659B.7,
notwithstanding
any
contract
or
choice-of-law
provision
30
in
a
contract.
31
2.
The
waiver
prohibition
shall
not
apply
to
contractual
32
waivers
to
the
extent
such
application
would
impair
the
33
obligation
of
contract
in
violation
of
the
Constitution
of
the
34
State
of
Iowa.
35
-2-
LSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
2/
7
H.F.
2133
3.
The
waiver
prohibition
is
a
public
policy
limitation
1
on
contractual
and
other
waivers
of
the
highest
importance
2
and
interest
to
the
state,
and
the
state
is
exercising
and
3
enforcing
this
limitation
to
the
full
extent
permitted
by
the
4
Constitution
of
the
United
States
and
the
Constitution
of
the
5
State
of
Iowa.
6
Sec.
4.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.4
Applicability.
7
1.
This
chapter
applies
only
to
a
user
who
does
any
of
the
8
following:
9
a.
Resides
in
this
state.
10
b.
Engages
in
business
in
this
state.
11
c.
Shares
or
receives
expression
in
this
state.
12
2.
This
chapter
applies
only
to
expression
that
is
shared
or
13
received
in
this
state.
14
3.
This
chapter
applies
only
to
a
social
media
platform
that
15
functionally
has
more
than
fifty
million
active
users
in
the
16
United
States
in
a
calendar
month.
17
4.
This
chapter
applies
to
the
maximum
extent
permitted
18
by
the
Constitution
of
the
United
States
and
the
laws
of
the
19
United
States
but
no
further
than
the
maximum
extent
permitted
20
by
the
Constitution
of
the
United
States
and
the
laws
of
the
21
United
States.
22
Sec.
5.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.5
Limitations.
23
1.
This
chapter
does
not
subject
an
interactive
computer
24
service
or
a
social
media
platform
to
any
cause
of
action
or
25
liability
to
the
extent
the
interactive
computer
service
or
26
social
media
platform
is
protected
from
causes
of
action
or
27
liability
by
federal
law.
28
2.
This
chapter
does
not
prohibit
an
interactive
computer
29
service
or
social
media
platform
from
any
of
the
following:
30
a.
Censoring
expression
that
the
interactive
computer
31
service
or
social
media
platform
is
specifically
authorized
to
32
censor
by
federal
law.
33
b.
Censoring
unlawful
expression,
including
expression
that
34
unlawfully
harasses
individuals
or
unlawfully
incites
violence.
35
-3-
LSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
3/
7
H.F.
2133
3.
This
chapter
does
not
prohibit
an
interactive
computer
1
service
or
a
social
media
platform
from
authorizing
or
2
facilitating
a
user’s
ability
to
do
any
of
the
following:
3
a.
Limit
the
user’s
reception
of
obscene,
lewd,
lascivious,
4
filthy,
excessively
violent,
harassing,
or
otherwise
5
objectionable
expression
at
the
specific
active
request
of
that
6
user.
7
b.
Censor
obscene,
lewd,
lascivious,
filthy,
excessively
8
violent,
harassing,
or
otherwise
objectionable
expression
on
a
9
specific
active
request
of
the
user.
10
Sec.
6.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.6
Construction
of
chapter.
11
1.
This
chapter
shall
not
be
construed
to
apply
to
an
12
interactive
computer
service
or
a
social
media
platform
13
to
the
extent
the
interactive
computer
service
or
social
14
media
platform
is
merely
providing
expression
to
a
user
in
a
15
particular
instance
in
response
to
that
user’s
express
request
16
in
that
particular
instance
for
expression
limited
on
the
basis
17
of
viewpoint
or
geographic
location.
18
2.
This
chapter
shall
not
be
construed
to
apply
to
19
commentary
by
an
interactive
computer
service
or
a
social
media
20
platform,
except
to
the
extent
the
commentary
is
presented
in
a
21
manner
that
delays
or
diminishes
the
visibility
of
expression,
22
delays
or
denies
the
equal
access
to
the
commentary,
or
23
otherwise
censors
the
commentary
in
violation
of
section
24
659B.2.
25
3.
This
chapter
shall
not
be
construed
to
limit
or
expand
26
intellectual
property
law.
27
4.
This
chapter
shall
not
be
construed
to
apply
to
actions
28
in
which
this
chapter
would
violate
the
doctrine
on
the
dormant
29
commerce
clause
enunciated
by
the
supreme
court
of
the
United
30
States.
31
Sec.
7.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.7
User
remedies.
32
1.
A
user
may
bring
an
action
against
an
interactive
33
computer
service
or
a
social
media
platform
that
violates
this
34
chapter
with
respect
to
the
user.
35
-4-
LSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
4/
7
H.F.
2133
2.
If
the
user
proves
that
the
interactive
computer
1
service
or
a
social
media
platform
violated
this
chapter
with
2
respect
to
the
user,
the
user
is
entitled
to
recover
all
of
the
3
following:
4
a.
Declaratory
relief,
including
costs
and
reasonable
and
5
necessary
attorney
fees.
6
b.
Injunctive
relief.
7
c.
Civil
damages
for
each
act
of
censorship
of
seventy-five
8
thousand
dollars.
9
3.
If
an
interactive
computer
service
or
a
social
media
10
platform
fails
to
promptly
comply
with
a
court
order
in
an
11
action
brought
under
this
section,
the
court
shall
hold
the
12
interactive
computer
service
or
social
media
platform
in
13
contempt
and
shall
use
all
lawful
measures
to
secure
immediate
14
compliance
with
the
order,
including
daily
penalties
sufficient
15
to
secure
immediate
compliance.
16
4.
A
user
may
bring
an
action
under
this
section
regardless
17
of
whether
another
court
has
declared
any
provision
of
this
18
chapter
unconstitutional
unless
that
court
decision
is
binding
19
on
the
court
in
which
the
action
is
brought.
20
5.
Nonmutual
issue
preclusion
and
nonmutual
claim
21
preclusion
are
not
defenses
to
an
action
brought
under
this
22
section.
23
Sec.
8.
NEW
SECTION
.
659B.8
Limitations
on
public
24
enforcement.
25
Notwithstanding
any
other
law,
the
requirements
of
this
26
chapter
shall
be
enforced
exclusively
through
the
private
27
civil
actions
described
in
section
659B.7.
Enforcement
of
28
this
chapter
shall
not
be
taken
or
threatened
by
the
state,
a
29
political
subdivision,
a
county
attorney,
or
any
executive
or
30
administrative
officer
or
employee
of
the
state
or
political
31
subdivision
against
any
person,
except
as
provided
by
section
32
659B.7.
33
Sec.
9.
RETROACTIVE
APPLICABILITY.
This
Act
applies
34
retroactively
to
a
user
before
the
effective
date
of
this
Act
35
-5-
LSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
5/
7
H.F.
2133
to
remedy
censorship
of
the
user’s
ability
to
share
or
receive
1
expression
that
occurred
before
the
effective
date
of
this
Act
2
if
censorship
continues
after
this
Act
takes
effect.
3
EXPLANATION
4
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
5
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
6
This
bill
relates
to
censorship
of
expression
on
interactive
7
computer
services
and
social
media
platforms.
The
bill
8
defines
“censor”,
“expression”,
“interactive
computer
service”,
9
“receive”,
“social
media
platform”,
“unlawful
expression”,
and
10
“user”.
11
The
bill
prohibits
an
interactive
computer
service
or
social
12
media
platform
from
censoring
a
user’s
expression
based
upon
13
the
viewpoint
of
the
user
or
another
person,
the
viewpoint
14
represented,
or
the
geographic
location
of
a
user
in
the
state.
15
The
bill
does
not
allow
an
interactive
computer
service
or
16
social
media
platform
to
create
a
waiver
of
the
protection
17
provided
within
the
bill.
18
The
bill
applies
only
to
users
who
reside,
do
business
19
within,
or
share
within
the
state
and
the
expression
is
done
on
20
a
50-million
user
interactive
computer
service
or
social
media
21
platform
within
the
state.
22
The
bill
does
not
subject
an
interactive
computer
service
23
or
a
social
media
platform
to
any
cause
of
action
or
liability
24
that
the
interactive
computer
service
or
social
media
platform
25
is
protected
from
by
federal
law.
An
interactive
computer
26
service
or
social
media
platform
may
censor
expression
that
27
the
interactive
computer
service
or
social
media
platform
is
28
specifically
authorized
to
censor
by
federal
law
and
that
29
unlawfully
harasses
individuals
or
unlawfully
incites
violence.
30
An
interactive
computer
service
or
a
social
media
platform
may
31
authorize
a
user’s
ability
to
receive
objectionable
expression
32
at
the
specific
active
request
of
that
user.
33
The
bill
does
not
apply
to
an
interactive
computer
service
or
34
a
social
media
platform
that
is
providing
expression
to
a
user
35
-6-
LSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
6/
7
H.F.
2133
in
a
particular
instance
in
response
to
that
user’s
express
1
request
or
to
commentary
by
an
interactive
computer
service
or
2
a
social
media
platform.
The
bill
does
not
change
existing
3
intellectual
property
law
or
violate
doctrine
on
the
dormant
4
commerce
clause.
5
The
bill
provides
remedies
for
a
user’s
expression
that
6
was
unlawfully
limited.
The
bill
authorizes
a
user
to
bring
7
an
action
for
a
violation
of
the
provisions
of
the
bill
and
a
8
prevailing
user
is
entitled
to
declaratory
relief,
including
9
costs
and
reasonable
and
necessary
attorney
fees,
injunctive
10
relief,
and
civil
damages
for
each
act
of
censorship
of
11
$75,000.
A
court
must
hold
an
interactive
computer
service
or
12
a
social
media
platform
in
contempt
if
it
fails
to
promptly
13
comply
with
a
court
order.
The
bill
may
only
be
enforced
14
through
private
civil
action
and
not
by
public
officials
or
15
entities.
16
The
bill
applies
retroactively
to
a
user
before
the
17
effective
date
of
the
bill
to
remedy
censorship
of
the
user’s
18
ability
to
share
or
receive
expression
that
occurred
before
the
19
effective
date
if
censorship
continues
after
the
bill
takes
20
effect.
21
-7-
LSB
5299YH
(4)
89
cm/jh
7/
7