Senate
Study
Bill
3091
-
Introduced
SENATE/HOUSE
FILE
_____
BY
(PROPOSED
DEPARTMENT
OF
NATURAL
RESOURCES
BILL)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
the
duties
of
and
programs
administered
by
1
the
department
of
natural
resources,
and
making
penalties
2
applicable.
3
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
4
TLSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
Section
1.
Section
455A.4,
subsection
1,
paragraph
b,
Code
1
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
2
b.
Provide
overall
supervision,
direction,
and
coordination
3
of
functions
to
be
administered
by
the
administrators
under
4
chapters
321G
,
321I
,
455B
,
455C
,
456
,
456A
,
456B
,
457A
,
458A
,
5
459
,
459A
,
459B
,
461A
,
462A
,
462B
,
464A
,
465C
,
473
,
481A
,
481B
,
6
483A
,
484A
,
and
484B
.
7
Sec.
2.
Section
455B.105,
subsection
5,
Code
2018,
is
8
amended
to
read
as
follows:
9
5.
Make
a
concise
annual
biennial
report
to
the
governor
and
10
the
general
assembly,
which
report
shall
contain
information
11
relating
to
the
accomplishments
and
status
of
the
programs
12
administered
by
the
department
and
include
recommendations
13
for
legislative
action
which
may
be
required
to
protect
or
14
enhance
the
environment
or
to
modernize
the
operation
of
the
15
department
or
any
of
the
programs
or
services
assigned
to
the
16
department
and
recommendations
for
the
transfer
of
powers
and
17
duties
of
the
department
as
deemed
advisable
by
the
commission.
18
The
annual
biennial
report
shall
conform
to
the
provisions
of
19
section
7A.3
.
20
Sec.
3.
Section
455B.174,
subsection
5,
paragraph
a,
Code
21
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
22
a.
Conduct
random
inspections
of
work
done
Periodically
23
review
permits
and
reports
submitted
by
city
and
county
24
public
works
departments
in
accordance
with
section
455B.183,
25
subsection
3,
to
ensure
such
public
works
departments
are
26
complying
with
this
part
of
this
division
.
If
a
city
or
county
27
public
works
department
is
not
complying
with
section
455B.183
28
in
reviewing
plans
and
specifications
or
in
granting
permits
29
or
both,
the
department
shall
perform
these
functions
in
that
30
jurisdiction
until
the
city
or
county
public
works
department
31
is
able
to
perform
them.
Performance
of
these
functions
in
a
32
jurisdiction
by
a
local
public
works
department
shall
not
be
33
suspended
or
revoked
until
after
notice
and
opportunity
for
34
hearing
as
provided
in
chapter
17A
.
35
-1-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
1/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
Sec.
4.
Section
455B.301,
subsection
23,
Code
2018,
is
1
amended
by
adding
the
following
new
paragraph:
2
NEW
PARAGRAPH
.
f.
Material
that
is
legitimately
recycled
3
pursuant
to
section
455D.4A.
4
Sec.
5.
Section
455D.1,
subsection
5,
Code
2018,
is
amended
5
to
read
as
follows:
6
5.
“Recycling”
means
any
process
by
which
waste,
or
7
materials
which
that
would
otherwise
become
waste,
are
8
collected,
separated,
or
processed
and
revised
or
returned
9
to
use
in
the
form
of
raw
materials
or
products
pursuant
to
10
section
455D.4A
.
“Recycling”
includes
but
is
not
limited
to
the
11
composting
of
yard
waste
which
has
been
previously
separated
12
from
other
waste,
but
does
not
include
any
form
of
energy
13
recovery.
14
Sec.
6.
NEW
SECTION
.
455D.4A
Recycling.
15
1.
For
the
purpose
of
this
section,
“recycling
facility”
16
means
any
facility,
business,
or
operation
that
has
the
primary
17
purpose
of
facilitating
the
recycling
of
materials
that
would
18
otherwise
be
solid
waste.
19
2.
Recycling
of
materials
for
the
purpose
of
being
excluded
20
from
the
solid
waste
provisions
of
chapter
455B,
division
21
IV,
part
1,
must
be
legitimate.
A
material
that
is
not
22
legitimately
recycled
is
discarded
material
and
is
a
solid
23
waste.
In
determining
if
recycling
is
legitimate,
recycling
24
facilities
must
establish
all
of
the
following:
25
a.
The
material
is
potentially
recyclable
and
has
a
feasible
26
means
of
being
recycled
into
a
valuable
product.
27
b.
The
material
is
being
managed
as
a
valuable
commodity
28
while
under
their
control.
29
c.
The
material
is
not
being
accumulated
speculatively
30
pursuant
to
subsection
7.
31
3.
If
the
department
determines
that
a
facility
is
not
32
legitimately
recycling
material,
the
department
may
allow
the
33
facility
owner
or
operator
an
opportunity
to
comply
with
the
34
criteria
in
subsection
2,
or
may
immediately
deem
the
facility
35
-2-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
2/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
subject
to
the
solid
waste
provisions
of
chapter
455B,
division
1
IV,
part
1.
2
4.
The
criteria
in
subsection
2
are
intended
to
mitigate
3
the
risk
posed
by
facilities
that
accumulate
materials
4
speculatively
prior
to
recycling
by
preventing
materials
that
5
are
not
otherwise
regulated
under
chapter
455B,
division
IV,
6
part
1,
from
being
stored
indefinitely
and
potentially
causing
7
a
public
health
nuisance
or
adverse
environmental
impact.
8
In
response
to
enforcement
initiated
by
the
department
for
9
alleged
violations
of
this
section,
the
burden
of
proof
falls
10
on
the
recycling
facility
owner
or
operator
to
establish
that
11
materials
are
being
legitimately
recycled.
12
5.
To
establish
that
a
material
is
potentially
recyclable
13
and
has
a
feasible
means
of
being
recycled
into
a
valuable
14
product,
a
recycling
facility
owner
or
operator
shall
maintain
15
with
an
end
user
at
least
one
purchase
contract,
a
letter
of
16
understanding,
or
other
formal
agreement.
Such
documentation
17
must
be
provided
to
the
department
upon
request.
In
addition,
18
if
the
material
is
going
to
be
recycled
in
an
unusual
manner,
19
the
owner
or
operator
may
use
technical
specifications
from
the
20
end
user
or
other
documentation
to
prove
recycling
the
material
21
in
such
manner
will
result
in
a
valuable
product.
22
6.
To
establish
that
a
material
is
being
managed
as
a
23
valuable
commodity
while
under
their
control,
a
recycling
24
facility
owner
or
operator
shall
ensure
that
stockpiled
25
material
is
not
speculatively
accumulated
by
maintaining
26
current
inventory
records
and
is
managed
in
a
manner
consistent
27
with
comparable
recyclable
materials
or
products
in
an
equally
28
protective
manner.
29
7.
To
establish
that
a
material
is
not
being
accumulated
30
speculatively,
the
recycling
facility
owner
or
operator
must
31
document
that,
during
a
given
calendar
year,
the
amount
of
32
material
that
is
recycled,
or
transferred
to
a
different
33
site
for
recycling,
equals
at
least
seventy-five
percent
by
34
weight
or
volume
of
the
amount
of
material
accumulated
at
35
-3-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
3/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
the
beginning
of
the
period.
Materials
must
be
placed
in
a
1
storage
unit
with
a
label
indicating
the
first
date
that
the
2
material
began
to
be
accumulated.
If
placing
a
label
on
the
3
storage
unit
is
not
practicable,
the
accumulation
period
must
4
be
documented
through
an
inventory
log
or
other
appropriate
5
method.
6
8.
Failure
to
provide
documentation
upon
request
to
the
7
department
relative
to
the
requirements
of
this
section
is
8
grounds
for
the
department
to
immediately
deem
the
facility
not
9
in
compliance
with
this
section.
10
Sec.
7.
Section
455D.16,
subsection
7,
paragraph
c,
Code
11
2018,
is
amended
by
striking
the
paragraph.
12
Sec.
8.
Section
455D.22,
Code
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
13
follows:
14
455D.22
Civil
penalty.
15
A
person
who
violates
section
455D.4A,
455D.6,
subsection
16
4
,
section
455D.11
,
455D.11A
,
455D.11B
,
455D.11I
,
or
455D.19
,
17
or
any
rule,
permit,
or
order
issued
pursuant
thereto
shall
18
be
subject
to
a
civil
penalty
which
shall
be
established,
19
assessed,
and
collected
in
the
same
manner
as
provided
in
20
section
455B.109
.
Any
civil
penalty
collected
shall
be
21
deposited
in
the
general
fund
of
the
state.
22
Sec.
9.
Section
455D.23,
Code
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
23
follows:
24
455D.23
Violations.
25
The
director
may
issue
any
order
necessary
to
secure
26
compliance
with
or
prevent
a
violation
of
the
provisions
of
27
this
chapter
or
any
rule
adopted
or
permit
or
order
issued
28
pursuant
to
this
chapter
.
Any
order
issued
to
enforce
section
29
455D.4A
may
include
a
requirement
to
remove
and
properly
30
dispose
of
materials
being
accumulated
speculatively
from
a
31
property
and
impose
costs
and
penalties
as
determined
by
the
32
department
by
rule.
The
person
to
whom
such
compliance
order
33
is
issued
may
cause
to
be
commenced
a
contested
case
within
the
34
meaning
of
chapter
17A
,
by
filing
within
thirty
days
a
notice
35
-4-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
4/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
of
appeal
to
the
commission.
On
appeal,
the
commission
may
1
affirm,
modify,
or
vacate
the
order
of
the
director.
2
Sec.
10.
Section
455D.25,
subsection
2,
Code
2018,
is
3
amended
to
read
as
follows:
4
2.
Any
person
who
violates
section
455D.4A,
455D.10A
,
5
455D.11
,
455D.11A
,
455D.11B
,
455D.11I
,
or
455D.19
,
or
any
order
6
or
permit
issued
or
rule
adopted
pursuant
to
section
455D.6,
7
subsection
4
,
section
455D.10A
,
455D.11
,
455D.11A
,
455D.11B
,
8
455D.11I
,
or
455D.19
,
shall
be
subject
to
a
civil
penalty,
not
9
to
exceed
ten
thousand
dollars
for
each
day
of
such
violation.
10
Sec.
11.
Section
456.1,
Code
2018,
is
amended
by
striking
11
the
section
and
inserting
in
lieu
thereof
the
following:
12
456.1
Geological
survey
created.
13
A
geological
survey
of
the
state
is
created
within
the
state
14
university
of
Iowa,
under
the
jurisdiction
and
authority
of
the
15
state
board
of
regents.
16
Sec.
12.
Section
456.2,
Code
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
17
follows:
18
456.2
State
geologist
——
qualifications.
19
The
director
state
board
of
regents
shall
appoint
the
state
20
geologist.
The
state
geologist
must
,
at
a
minimum,
have
a
21
master’s
degree
in
geology
from
an
accredited
college
or
22
university
and
must
have
at
least
five
years
of
geological
23
experience.
The
annual
salary
of
the
state
geologist
shall
be
24
determined
by
the
director
state
board
of
regents
.
25
Sec.
13.
Section
456.4,
Code
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
26
follows:
27
456.4
Investigations
——
collection
——
renting
space
.
28
The
state
geologist
shall
investigate
the
characters
of
the
29
various
soils
and
their
capacities
for
agricultural
purposes,
30
the
streams,
and
other
scientific
and
natural
resource
matters
31
that
may
be
of
practical
importance
and
interest.
For
the
32
purpose
of
preserving
well
drilling
samples,
rock
cores,
33
fossils,
and
other
materials
as
may
be
necessary
to
carry
on
34
investigations,
the
state
geologist
shall
have
the
authority
35
-5-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
5/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
to
lease
or
rent
sufficient
space
for
storage
of
these
1
materials
with
the
approval
of
the
director
of
the
department
2
of
administrative
services.
A
complete
cabinet
collection
may
3
shall
be
made
to
illustrate
the
natural
products
of
the
state,
4
and
the
state
geologist
may
also
furnish
suites
of
materials,
5
rocks,
and
fossils
for
colleges
and
public
museums
within
the
6
state,
if
it
can
be
done
without
impairing
the
general
state
7
collection.
8
Sec.
14.
Section
456.7,
Code
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
9
follows:
10
456.7
Annual
report.
11
The
state
geologist
shall,
annually,
at
the
time
provided
12
by
law,
make
to
the
governor
and
the
general
assembly
a
full
13
report
of
the
work
in
the
preceding
year,
which
report
shall
14
be
accompanied
by
such
other
reports
and
papers
as
may
be
15
considered
desirable
for
publication.
16
Sec.
15.
Section
456.10,
Code
2018,
is
amended
to
read
as
17
follows:
18
456.10
Distribution
and
sale
of
reports.
19
All
publications
of
the
geological
survey
shall
be
20
distributed
by
the
state
as
are
other
published
reports
of
21
state
officers
when
no
special
provision
is
made.
When
such
22
distribution
has
been
made
the
state
geologist
shall
retain
23
a
sufficient
number
of
copies
to
supply
probable
future
24
demands
and
any
copies
in
excess
of
such
number
shall
be
sold
25
to
persons
making
application
therefor
at
the
cost
price
of
26
publication,
the
money
thus
accruing
to
be
turned
into
the
27
treasury
of
the
state
made
available
electronically
via
an
28
internet
site
maintained
for
that
purpose
.
29
Sec.
16.
REPEAL.
Section
455C.17,
Code
2018,
is
repealed.
30
EXPLANATION
31
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
32
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
33
This
bill
relates
to
duties
and
programs
administered
by
the
34
department
of
natural
resources.
35
-6-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
6/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
Under
current
law,
the
environmental
protection
commission
1
must
give
an
annual
report
to
the
governor
and
general
assembly
2
about
the
accomplishments
and
status
of
the
programs
of
the
3
department.
The
bill
causes
the
report
to
be
biennial
rather
4
than
annual.
5
The
director
currently
has
the
duty
to
conduct
random
6
inspections
of
work
done
by
city
and
public
works
departments
7
to
ensure
that
such
public
works
departments
are
complying
with
8
permit
issuance
and
records
reporting
criteria
regarding
water
9
and
sewage
projects.
Rather
than
conduct
random
inspections
10
of
on-site
files
of
city
and
county
public
works
departments,
11
the
bill
requires
the
director
to
periodically
review
permits
12
and
reports
submitted
by
those
agencies
in
accordance
with
Code
13
section
455B.183(3).
14
The
current
definition
for
“recycling”
states
that
it
is
a
15
process
involving
the
collecting,
separating,
or
processing
16
of
potential
waste
to
revise
or
return
the
waste
to
use
in
17
the
form
of
raw
materials
or
products.
The
bill
changes
the
18
definition
of
“recycling”
by
stating
that
recycling
occurs
19
pursuant
to
new
Code
section
455D.4A.
The
bill
also
creates
a
20
definition
for
“recycling
facility”.
21
Currently,
the
director
may
issue
a
compliance
order
22
to
secure
compliance
or
prevent
a
violation
of
any
of
the
23
provisions
relating
to
recycling
and
waste
reduction.
A
person
24
who
violates
a
law
that
governs
the
disposal,
storage,
or
25
handling
of
certain
wastes,
or
a
rule,
permit,
or
order
issued
26
pursuant
to
one
of
those
laws,
is
subject
to
a
civil
penalty
27
of
no
more
than
$10,000.
The
department
can
request
that
the
28
attorney
general
pursue
litigation
for
that
violation.
A
29
person
found
in
violation
after
litigation
shall
be
subject
to
30
a
civil
penalty
of
up
to
$10,000
per
day.
31
The
bill
requires
a
recycling
facility
to
prove
that
32
materials
it
stores
are
potentially
recyclable.
A
person
who
33
fails
to
meet
the
criteria
for
legitimate
recycling
is
subject
34
to
the
provisions
regarding
compliance
orders,
litigation,
and
35
-7-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
7/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
civil
penalties.
1
Since
2010,
the
department
has
had
to
submit
a
written
2
report
to
the
general
assembly
regarding
issues
related
to
the
3
collection
and
recycling
of
mercury-added
thermostats
in
the
4
state.
The
bill
deletes
this
duty.
5
Currently,
a
geological
survey
exists
within
the
department.
6
The
director
of
the
department
must
provide
supervision,
7
direction,
and
coordination
of
functions
of
the
state
8
geologist.
The
director
must
appoint
the
state
geologist,
who
9
must
have
a
degree
in
geology
from
an
accredited
college
or
10
university
and
at
least
five
years
of
geological
experience.
11
The
director
determines
the
state
geologist’s
salary.
The
12
state
geologist
has
the
authority
to
lease
or
rent
sufficient
13
space
for
storage
of
well
drilling
samples,
rock
cores,
14
fossils,
and
other
materials
as
may
be
necessary
to
carry
15
on
investigations,
with
the
approval
of
the
director
of
the
16
department
of
administrative
services.
The
state
geologist
17
may
assemble
a
complete
cabinet
collection
to
illustrate
the
18
natural
products
of
the
state.
19
The
state
geologist
must
give
to
the
governor
an
annual
20
report
that
consists
of
the
work
from
the
preceding
year.
The
21
state
shall
distribute
all
publications
of
the
geological
22
survey
like
any
other
publication
of
state
officers
when
no
23
special
provision
exists.
The
state
geologist
shall
retain
a
24
sufficient
number
of
copies
to
supply
probable
future
demands
25
and
the
state
will
sell
any
extra
copies
to
persons
making
26
application
therefor
at
the
cost
price
of
publication.
27
The
bill
removes
the
geological
survey
from
the
department
28
and
places
it
in
the
state
university
of
Iowa
under
the
29
jurisdiction
and
authority
of
the
state
board
of
regents.
30
The
state
board
of
regents
will
appoint
the
state
geologist,
31
who
must
have
at
least
a
master’s
degree
in
geology
from
an
32
accredited
college
or
university
and
five
years
of
geological
33
experience.
The
state
board
of
regents
will
determine
the
34
salary
for
the
state
geologist.
The
state
geologist
will
no
35
-8-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
8/
9
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
longer
have
the
authority
to
lease
or
rent
sufficient
space
1
for
storage
of
well
drilling
samples,
rock
cores,
fossils,
and
2
other
materials
as
may
be
necessary
to
carry
on
investigations.
3
Additionally,
the
state
geologist
must
assemble
a
complete
4
cabinet
collection
to
illustrate
the
natural
products
of
the
5
state.
6
The
bill
requires
the
state
geologist
to
annually
report
to
7
the
general
assembly
in
addition
to
the
governor.
Geological
8
survey
publications
will
no
longer
be
distributed
or
sold
9
like
other
published
reports
of
state
officers,
but
rather
be
10
available
electronically
on
an
internet
site
maintained
for
the
11
purpose
of
documenting
these
publications.
12
There
currently
exists
an
independent
redemption
center
13
grant
program
that
awards
grants
for
improvements
to
redemption
14
centers
that
are
not
affiliated
with
or
in
any
way
a
subsidiary
15
of
a
dealer,
distributor,
or
manufacturer
and
are
either
16
nonprofit
or
for-profit
but
have
existed
prior
to
July
1,
2008.
17
The
bill
repeals
this
grant
program.
18
-9-
LSB
5233DP
(5)
87
js/rn
9/
9