Senate
File
328
-
Introduced
SENATE
FILE
328
BY
PETERSEN
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
providing
for
the
confinement
of
agricultural
animals
1
and
the
storage
of
manure
or
washwater
on
karst
terrain
2
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole,
and
making
3
penalties
applicable.
4
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
5
TLSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
S.F.
328
DIVISION
I
1
ANIMAL
FEEDING
OPERATIONS
2
Section
1.
Section
459.102,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
3
the
following
new
subsections:
4
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
29A.
“
Formed
egg
washwater
storage
5
structure”
means
an
egg
washwater
storage
structure
that
has
6
walls
and
a
floor
constructed
of
concrete,
concrete
block,
7
wood,
steel,
or
similar
materials.
8
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
57A.
“Unformed
egg
washwater
storage
9
structure”
means
an
egg
washwater
storage
structure
other
than
10
a
formed
egg
washwater
storage
structure.
11
Sec.
2.
Section
459.307,
subsection
4,
Code
2017,
is
amended
12
by
striking
the
subsection.
13
Sec.
3.
Section
459.308,
subsection
3,
Code
2017,
is
amended
14
by
striking
the
subsection.
15
Sec.
4.
NEW
SECTION
.
459.309
Construction
and
expansion
of
16
animal
feeding
operation
structures
——
karst
terrain
or
terrain
17
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
18
1.
A
person
shall
not
construct
or
expand
an
animal
feeding
19
operation
structure
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
20
into
a
known
sinkhole.
21
2.
Subsection
1
does
not
apply
to
any
of
the
following:
22
a.
The
construction
of
a
formed
manure
storage
structure
23
that
is
constructed
to
replace
an
unformed
manure
storage
24
structure.
The
formed
manure
storage
structure
must
25
be
constructed
in
a
manner
that
complies
with
upgraded
26
construction
design
standards
necessary
to
ensure
that
the
27
structure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
sources.
However,
the
28
capacity
of
all
replacement
formed
manure
storage
structures
29
shall
not
exceed
the
capacity
required
to
store
all
manure
from
30
the
animal
feeding
operation
on
the
effective
date
of
this
Act.
31
b.
The
construction
of
a
formed
egg
washwater
storage
32
structure
that
is
constructed
to
replace
an
unformed
egg
33
washwater
storage
structure.
The
formed
egg
washwater
storage
34
structure
must
be
constructed
in
a
manner
that
complies
with
35
-1-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
1/
10
S.F.
328
upgraded
construction
design
standards
necessary
to
ensure
that
1
the
structure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
sources.
However,
2
the
capacity
of
all
replacement
formed
egg
washwater
storage
3
structures
shall
not
exceed
the
capacity
required
to
store
4
all
egg
washwater
from
the
animal
feeding
operation
on
the
5
effective
date
of
this
Act.
6
3.
a.
If
an
unformed
manure
storage
structure
was
7
constructed
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
8
known
sinkhole
prior
to
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
there
9
must
be
a
twenty-five-foot
vertical
separation
distance
between
10
the
bottom
of
the
unformed
manure
storage
structure
and
any
11
underlying
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
soluble
rock.
The
12
unformed
manure
storage
structure
must
have
been
constructed
13
according
to
construction
design
standards
necessary
to
ensure
14
that
the
structure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
sources.
15
b.
A
formed
manure
storage
structure
constructed
on
karst
16
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
prior
to
17
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
must
have
been
constructed
18
according
to
construction
design
standards
necessary
to
ensure
19
that
the
structure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
sources.
20
Sec.
5.
Section
459.311D,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
striking
21
the
section
and
inserting
in
lieu
thereof
the
following:
22
459.311D
Stockpiling
dry
manure
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
23
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
24
1.
Except
as
provided
in
this
section,
a
person
shall
not
25
stockpile
dry
manure
on
karst
terrain
or
in
an
area
that
drains
26
into
a
known
sinkhole.
27
2.
A
person
who
stockpiled
dry
manure
on
karst
terrain
28
or
in
an
area
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
prior
to
the
29
effective
date
of
this
Act
may
continue
to
stockpile
the
dry
30
manure
at
the
same
location
so
long
as
the
person
complies
with
31
all
of
the
following:
32
a.
There
is
a
vertical
separation
distance
of
at
least
five
33
feet
between
the
bottom
of
the
stockpile
and
the
underlying
34
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
soluble
rock.
35
-2-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
2/
10
S.F.
328
b.
The
dry
manure
is
stockpiled
in
a
qualified
stockpile
1
structure.
2
c.
The
person
does
not
expand
the
volume
or
weight
of
dry
3
manure.
4
d.
A
person
shall
discontinue
stockpiling
dry
manure
at
5
that
same
location
on
and
after
July
1,
2027,
unless
the
6
person
obtains
a
waiver
by
the
department
upon
such
terms
and
7
conditions
required
by
the
department.
The
department
shall
8
only
grant
a
waiver
if
the
department
is
satisfied
that
the
9
stockpiled
dry
manure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
sources.
10
Sec.
6.
Section
459.319,
subsection
2,
Code
2017,
is
amended
11
by
adding
the
following
new
paragraph:
12
NEW
PARAGRAPH
.
c.
A
person
who
stockpiles
dry
manure
on
13
karst
terrain
or
in
an
area
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
14
DIVISION
II
15
OPEN
FEEDLOT
OPERATIONS
AND
ANIMAL
TRUCK
WASH
FACILITIES
16
Sec.
7.
Section
459A.102,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
17
the
following
new
subsection:
18
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
31A.
“Qualified
stockpile
structure”
means
19
the
same
as
defined
in
section
459.102.
20
Sec.
8.
Section
459A.205,
subsection
8,
paragraph
e,
21
subparagraph
(2),
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
22
(2)
If
an
a
formed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structure
23
is
to
be
constructed
on
karst
terrain
as
provided
in
section
24
459A.406A
,
the
engineering
report
must
establish
that
the
25
construction
complies
with
the
requirements
of
section
26
459A.404
.
27
Sec.
9.
Section
459A.403,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
28
the
following
new
subsection:
29
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
3.
A
person
shall
not
stockpile
solids
on
30
karst
terrain
or
in
an
area
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
31
except
as
provided
in
section
459A.403A.
32
Sec.
10.
NEW
SECTION
.
459A.403A
Stockpiling
solids
on
karst
33
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
——
open
34
feedlots
and
animal
truck
wash
facility.
35
-3-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
3/
10
S.F.
328
1.
Except
as
provided
in
this
section,
a
person
shall
not
1
stockpile
solids
on
karst
terrain
or
in
an
area
that
drains
2
into
a
known
sinkhole.
3
2.
A
person
who
stockpiled
solids
on
karst
terrain
or
in
an
4
area
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
prior
to
the
effective
5
date
of
this
Act
may
continue
to
stockpile
the
solids
at
the
6
same
location
so
long
as
the
person
complies
with
all
of
the
7
following:
8
a.
There
is
a
vertical
separation
distance
of
at
least
five
9
feet
between
the
bottom
of
the
stockpile
and
any
underlying
10
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
soluble
rock.
11
b.
The
solids
are
stockpiled
in
a
qualified
stockpile
12
structure.
13
c.
The
person
does
not
expand
the
volume
or
weight
of
14
stockpiled
solids.
15
d.
A
person
stockpiling
solids
shall
remove
the
solids
and
16
apply
them
in
accordance
with
the
provisions
of
chapter
459,
17
including
section
459.311
within
six
months
after
the
solids
18
are
first
stockpiled.
A
person
shall
discontinue
stockpiling
19
the
solids
at
that
same
location
on
and
after
July
1,
2027,
20
unless
the
person
obtains
a
waiver
by
the
department
upon
21
such
terms
and
conditions
required
by
the
department.
The
22
department
shall
only
grant
a
waiver
if
the
department
is
23
satisfied
that
the
stockpiled
solids
do
not
pollute
groundwater
24
sources.
25
Sec.
11.
Section
459A.404,
subsection
5,
Code
2017,
is
26
amended
by
striking
the
subsection.
27
Sec.
12.
NEW
SECTION
.
459A.406
Construction
and
expansion
28
of
open
feedlot
operation
structures
——
karst
terrain
or
terrain
29
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
30
1.
A
person
shall
not
construct
or
expand
an
open
feedlot
31
operation
structure
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
32
into
a
known
sinkhole.
33
2.
If
an
open
feedlot
operation
structure
was
constructed
34
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
35
-4-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
4/
10
S.F.
328
prior
to
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
there
must
be
a
1
twenty-five-foot
vertical
separation
distance
between
the
2
bottom
of
the
open
feedlot
operation
structure
and
any
3
underlying
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
soluble
rock.
The
4
open
feedlot
operation
structure
must
have
been
constructed
5
according
to
construction
design
standards
necessary
to
ensure
6
the
structure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
sources.
7
Sec.
13.
NEW
SECTION
.
459A.406A
Construction
and
expansion
8
of
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structures
——
karst
terrain
or
9
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
10
1.
A
person
shall
not
construct
or
expand
an
animal
truck
11
wash
effluent
structure
on
karst
terrain
on
and
after
the
12
effective
date
of
this
Act.
13
2.
Subsection
1
does
not
apply
to
the
construction
14
of
a
formed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structure
that
is
15
constructed
to
replace
an
unformed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
16
structure
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
17
sinkhole.
The
formed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structure
18
must
be
constructed
in
a
manner
that
complies
with
upgraded
19
construction
design
standards
necessary
to
ensure
that
the
20
structure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
sources.
However,
the
21
capacity
of
all
replacement
formed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
22
structures
shall
not
exceed
the
capacity
required
to
store
all
23
animal
truck
wash
effluent
from
the
animal
truck
wash
facility
24
on
the
effective
date
of
this
Act.
25
3.
a.
If
an
unformed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structure
26
was
constructed
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
27
known
sinkhole
prior
to
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
there
28
must
be
a
twenty-five-foot
vertical
separation
distance
between
29
the
bottom
of
the
unformed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structure
30
and
any
underlying
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
soluble
rock.
31
The
unformed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structure
must
have
32
been
constructed
according
to
construction
design
standards
33
necessary
to
ensure
the
structure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
34
sources.
35
-5-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
5/
10
S.F.
328
b.
A
formed
animal
truck
wash
effluent
structure
constructed
1
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
2
prior
to
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
must
have
been
3
constructed
according
to
construction
design
standards
4
necessary
to
ensure
that
the
structure
does
not
pollute
5
groundwater
sources.
6
DIVISION
III
7
DRY
BEDDED
CONFINEMENT
FEEDING
OPERATIONS
8
Sec.
14.
Section
459B.201,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
9
follows:
10
459B.201
Construction
design
standards.
11
A
person
constructing
a
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
12
operation
structure
on
karst
terrain
or
in
an
alluvial
aquifer
13
area
shall
comply
with
all
of
the
following:
14
1.
The
person
must
construct
the
dry
bedded
confinement
15
feeding
operation
structure
at
a
location
where
there
is
a
16
vertical
separation
distance
of
at
least
five
feet
between
17
the
bottom
of
the
floor
of
the
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
18
operation
structure
and
the
underlying
limestone,
dolomite,
or
19
other
soluble
rock
in
karst
terrain
or
the
underlying
sand
and
20
gravel
aquifer
in
an
alluvial
aquifer
area.
21
2.
The
person
must
construct
the
dry
bedded
confinement
22
feeding
operation
structure
with
a
floor
consisting
of
23
reinforced
concrete
at
least
five
inches
thick.
24
Sec.
15.
NEW
SECTION
.
459B.203
Karst
terrain
and
terrain
25
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
——
construction
and
expansion
26
of
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
operation
structures.
27
1.
A
person
shall
not
construct
or
expand
a
dry
bedded
28
confinement
feeding
operation
structure
on
karst
terrain
or
29
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
30
2.
If
a
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
operation
structure
31
was
constructed
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
32
a
known
sinkhole
prior
to
the
effective
date
of
this
Act,
33
there
must
be
a
five-foot
vertical
separation
distance
between
34
the
bottom
of
the
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
operation
35
-6-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
6/
10
S.F.
328
structure
and
any
underlying
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
1
soluble
rock.
The
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
operation
2
structure
must
have
been
constructed
according
to
construction
3
design
standards
necessary
to
ensure
the
structure
does
not
4
pollute
groundwater
sources.
5
Sec.
16.
Section
459B.307,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
6
the
following
new
subsection:
7
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
3.
A
person
shall
only
stockpile
dry
bedded
8
manure
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
9
sinkhole
as
provided
in
section
459B.307A.
10
Sec.
17.
Section
459B.307,
subsection
1,
paragraph
e,
11
unnumbered
paragraph
1,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
12
follows:
13
The
person
shall
not
stockpile
dry
bedded
manure
on
karst
14
terrain
or
in
an
alluvial
aquifer
area
unless
the
person
15
complies
with
all
of
the
following:
16
Sec.
18.
NEW
SECTION
.
459B.307A
Stockpiling
dry
bedded
17
manure
on
karst
terrain
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
18
sinkhole.
19
1.
Except
as
provided
in
this
section,
a
person
shall
not
20
stockpile
dry
bedded
manure
on
karst
terrain
or
in
an
area
that
21
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
22
2.
A
person
who
stockpiled
dry
bedded
manure
on
karst
23
terrain
or
in
an
area
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole
prior
24
to
the
effective
date
of
this
Act
may
continue
to
stockpile
the
25
dry
bedded
manure
at
the
same
location
so
long
as
the
person
26
complies
with
all
of
the
following:
27
a.
There
is
a
vertical
separation
distance
of
at
least
five
28
feet
between
the
bottom
of
the
stockpile
and
any
underlying
29
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
soluble
rock.
30
b.
The
dry
bedded
manure
is
stockpiled
in
a
qualified
31
stockpile
structure.
32
c.
The
person
does
not
expand
the
volume
or
weight
of
33
stockpiled
dry
bedded
manure.
34
d.
A
person
stockpiling
dry
bedded
manure
shall
remove
35
-7-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
7/
10
S.F.
328
the
dry
bedded
manure
and
apply
it
in
accordance
with
the
1
provisions
of
chapter
459,
including
section
459.311
within
2
six
months
after
the
dry
bedded
manure
is
first
stockpiled.
3
A
person
shall
discontinue
stockpiling
dry
bedded
manure
at
4
that
same
location
on
and
after
July
1,
2027,
unless
the
5
person
obtains
a
waiver
by
the
department
upon
such
terms
and
6
conditions
required
by
the
department.
The
department
shall
7
only
grant
a
waiver
if
the
department
is
satisfied
that
the
8
stockpiled
dry
bedded
manure
does
not
pollute
groundwater
9
sources.
10
EXPLANATION
11
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
12
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
13
BILL’S
PROVISIONS.
This
bill
prohibits
the
construction
14
or
expansion
of
an
animal
feeding
operation
structure,
open
15
feedlot
operation
structure,
animal
truck
wash
effluent
16
structure,
or
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
operation
17
structure
from
being
constructed
or
expanded
on
karst
terrain
18
or
terrain
that
drains
into
a
known
sinkhole.
The
bill
19
prohibits
the
stockpiling
of
certain
dry
or
solid
manure
on
20
such
terrain.
The
bill
also
regulates
the
use
of
structures
21
or
stockpiles
existing
on
such
terrain
prior
to
the
bill’s
22
effective
date.
The
bill
retains
or
expands
vertical
23
separation
distances
required
between
the
bottom
of
a
structure
24
or
stockpile
and
any
underlying
limestone,
dolomite,
or
other
25
soluble
rock.
The
bill
requires
that
a
stockpile
located
26
on
the
terrain
be
kept
in
a
qualified
stockpile
structure
27
which
is
a
building
or
other
roofed
structure
(Code
section
28
459.102).
It
provides
for
the
removal
of
manure
or
solids
from
29
the
stockpile.
It
also
requires
that
an
existing
stockpile
be
30
discontinued
on
July
1,
2027,
unless
the
department
of
natural
31
resources
grants
a
waiver.
32
BACKGROUND
——
STRUCTURES
ASSOCIATED
WITH
OPERATIONS
AND
33
FACILITIES.
An
animal
feeding
operation
is
a
location
where
34
agricultural
animals
are
confined
for
45
days
or
more
in
35
-8-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
8/
10
S.F.
328
any
12-month
period
and
includes
associated
animal
feeding
1
operation
structures.
The
provisions
regulating
confined
2
agricultural
animals
are
generally
included
in
three
related
3
Code
chapters.
Code
chapter
459
(“Animal
Agriculture
4
Compliance
Act”)
regulates
all
animal
feeding
operations
but
5
primarily
confinement
feeding
operations
where
agricultural
6
animals
are
confined
to
areas
which
are
totally
roofed.
Code
7
chapter
459A
(“Animal
Agriculture
Compliance
Act
for
Open
8
Feedlot
Operations
and
Animal
Truck
Wash
Facilities”)
regulates
9
open
feedlot
operations
which
are
unroofed
or
partially
roofed
10
areas
where
there
is
no
vegetation,
and
where
settleable
solids
11
are
separated
from
liquids;
and
animal
truck
wash
facilities
12
used
to
store
effluent
including
solids
after
truck-trailers
13
or
similar
vehicles
transporting
agricultural
animals
are
14
cleaned.
Code
chapter
459B
(“Animal
Agriculture
Compliance
15
Act
for
Dry
Bedded
Confinement
Feeding
Operations”)
regulates
16
special
confinement
feeding
operations
(hoop
buildings)
in
17
which
the
effluent
is
exclusively
stored
on
a
dry
rather
18
than
liquid
basis.
An
animal
feeding
operation
structure
19
refers
to
a
confinement
building,
manure
storage
structure,
20
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
operation
structure,
or
egg
21
washwater
storage
structure
(Code
chapter
459.102).
An
open
22
feedlot
operation
structure
refers
to
an
open
feedlot
where
23
agricultural
animals
are
maintained,
and
a
basin
or
other
24
constructed
area
where
effluent
and
solids
are
separated
25
(Code
section
459A.102).
A
dry
bedded
confinement
feeding
26
operation
structure
refers
to
a
totally
roofed
building
where
27
agricultural
animals
are
maintained
or
a
structure
storing
dry
28
bedded
manure
(Code
section
459B.102).
29
BACKGROUND
——
STOCKPILING.
Stockpiling
refers
to
that
part
30
of
manure
or
effluent
produced
by
agricultural
animals
which
31
is
“dry”
or
“solid”,
meaning
that
it
does
not
flow
perceptibly
32
under
pressure
and
is
not
capable
of
being
transported
through
33
a
mechanical
pumping
device
designed
to
move
a
liquid
(Code
34
sections
459.102
which
refers
to
dry
manure,
459A.102
which
35
-9-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
9/
10
S.F.
328
refers
to
solids,
and
459B.102
which
refers
to
dry
bedded
1
manure).
2
BACKGROUND
——
KARST
TERRAIN
AND
SINKHOLES.
Karst
terrain
is
3
characterized
by
the
presence
of
bedrock
composed
of
limestone
4
or
dolomite
near
the
ground
surface
which
dissolves
easily.
5
Such
terrain
often
includes
sinkholes
which
are
a
depression
or
6
hole
in
the
ground
caused
by
a
collapse
of
the
ground’s
surface
7
layer.
8
APPLICABLE
CIVIL
PENALTIES.
Each
of
the
three
Code
chapters
9
provide
for
the
imposition
and
assessment
of
civil
penalties
10
for
violations
involving
water
quality.
A
person
who
violates
11
a
water
quality
provision
is
subject
to
an
administratively
12
assessed
civil
penalty
of
not
more
than
$10,000
(Code
sections
13
455B.109,
459.603,
459A.502,
and
459B.402),
or
a
judicially
14
assessed
amount
of
not
more
than
$5,000
per
each
day
of
the
15
violation
(Code
sections
455B.191
and
459.603).
16
-10-
LSB
1180XS
(3)
87
da/rj
10/
10