House
Study
Bill
84
-
Introduced
HOUSE
FILE
_____
BY
(PROPOSED
COMMITTEE
ON
LABOR
BILL
BY
CHAIRPERSON
DEYOE)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
employment
matters
involving
public
1
employees
including
collective
bargaining,
educator
2
employment
matters,
personnel
records
and
settlement
3
agreements,
city
civil
service
requirements,
and
health
4
insurance
matters,
making
penalties
applicable,
and
5
including
effective
date,
applicability,
and
transition
6
provisions.
7
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
8
TLSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
H.F.
_____
DIVISION
I
1
PUBLIC
EMPLOYEE
COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING
2
Section
1.
Section
20.3,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
the
3
following
new
subsections:
4
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
10A.
“Public
safety
employee”
means
a
5
public
employee
who
is
employed
as
one
of
the
following:
6
a.
A
sheriff
or
a
sheriff’s
regular
deputy.
7
b.
A
marshal
or
police
officer
of
a
city,
township,
or
8
special-purpose
district
or
authority
who
is
a
member
of
a
paid
9
police
department.
10
c.
A
member,
except
a
non-peace
officer
member,
of
the
11
division
of
state
patrol,
narcotics
enforcement,
state
fire
12
marshal,
or
criminal
investigation,
including
but
not
limited
13
to
a
gaming
enforcement
officer,
who
has
been
duly
appointed
14
by
the
department
of
public
safety
in
accordance
with
section
15
80.15.
16
d.
A
conservation
officer
or
park
ranger
as
authorized
by
17
section
456A.13.
18
e.
A
permanent
or
full-time
fire
fighter
of
a
city,
19
township,
or
special-purpose
district
or
authority
who
is
a
20
member
of
a
paid
fire
department.
21
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
12.
“Supplemental
pay”
means
a
payment
22
of
moneys
or
other
thing
of
value
that
is
in
addition
to
23
compensation
received
pursuant
to
any
other
permitted
subject
24
of
negotiation
specified
in
section
20.9
and
is
related
to
the
25
employment
relationship.
26
Sec.
2.
Section
20.6,
subsection
1,
Code
2017,
is
amended
27
to
read
as
follows:
28
1.
Interpret,
apply,
and
administer
Administer
the
29
provisions
of
this
chapter
.
30
Sec.
3.
Section
20.6,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
the
31
following
new
subsections:
32
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
6.
Appoint
a
certified
shorthand
reporter
33
to
report
state
employee
grievance
and
discipline
resolution
34
proceedings
pursuant
to
section
8A.415
and
fix
a
reasonable
35
-1-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
1/
68
H.F.
_____
amount
of
compensation
for
such
service
and
for
any
transcript
1
requested
by
the
board,
which
amounts
shall
be
taxed
as
other
2
costs.
3
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
7.
Contract
with
a
vendor
as
the
board
may
4
deem
necessary
to
conduct
elections
required
by
section
20.15
5
on
behalf
of
the
board.
The
board
shall
establish
fees
by
rule
6
pursuant
to
chapter
17A
to
cover
the
cost
of
elections
required
7
by
section
20.15.
Such
fees
shall
be
paid
in
advance
of
an
8
election
and
shall
be
paid
by
each
employee
organization
listed
9
on
the
ballot.
10
Sec.
4.
Section
20.7,
subsections
2
and
3,
Code
2017,
are
11
amended
to
read
as
follows:
12
2.
Hire,
evaluate,
promote,
demote,
transfer,
assign
and
13
retain
public
employees
in
positions
within
the
public
agency.
14
3.
Suspend
or
discharge
public
employees
for
proper
cause
.
15
Sec.
5.
Section
20.8,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
the
16
following
new
subsection:
17
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
5.
Exercise
any
right
or
seek
any
remedy
18
provided
by
law,
including
but
not
limited
to
those
rights
and
19
remedies
available
under
sections
70A.28
and
70A.29,
chapter
20
8A,
subchapter
IV,
and
chapters
216
and
400.
21
Sec.
6.
Section
20.9,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
22
follows:
23
20.9
Scope
of
negotiations.
24
1.
The
For
negotiations
regarding
a
bargaining
unit
with
25
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
safety
employees,
the
26
public
employer
and
the
employee
organization
shall
meet
at
27
reasonable
times,
including
meetings
reasonably
in
advance
of
28
the
public
employer’s
budget-making
process,
to
negotiate
in
29
good
faith
with
respect
to
wages,
hours,
vacations,
insurance,
30
holidays,
leaves
of
absence,
shift
differentials,
overtime
31
compensation,
supplemental
pay,
seniority,
transfer
procedures,
32
job
classifications,
health
and
safety
matters,
evaluation
33
procedures,
procedures
for
staff
reduction,
in-service
34
training
,
grievance
procedures
for
resolving
any
questions
35
-2-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
2/
68
H.F.
_____
arising
under
the
agreement,
and
other
matters
mutually
agreed
1
upon.
Negotiations
shall
also
include
terms
authorizing
2
dues
checkoff
for
members
of
the
employee
organization
and
3
grievance
procedures
for
resolving
any
questions
arising
under
4
the
agreement,
which
shall
be
embodied
in
a
written
agreement
5
and
signed
by
the
parties.
If
an
agreement
provides
for
dues
6
checkoff,
a
member’s
dues
may
be
checked
off
only
upon
the
7
member’s
written
request
and
the
member
may
terminate
the
dues
8
checkoff
at
any
time
by
giving
thirty
days’
written
notice.
9
For
negotiations
regarding
a
bargaining
unit
that
does
not
10
have
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
safety
employees,
11
the
public
employer
and
the
employee
organization
shall
meet
12
at
reasonable
times,
including
meetings
reasonably
in
advance
13
of
the
public
employer’s
budget-making
process,
to
negotiate
14
in
good
faith
with
respect
to
base
wages
and
other
matters
15
mutually
agreed
upon.
Such
obligation
to
negotiate
in
good
16
faith
does
not
compel
either
party
to
agree
to
a
proposal
17
or
make
a
concession.
Mandatory
subjects
of
negotiation
18
specified
in
this
subsection
shall
be
interpreted
narrowly
and
19
restrictively.
20
2.
Nothing
in
this
section
shall
diminish
the
authority
21
and
power
of
the
department
of
administrative
services,
board
22
of
regents’
merit
system,
Iowa
public
broadcasting
board’s
23
merit
system,
or
any
civil
service
commission
established
by
24
constitutional
provision,
statute,
charter
,
or
special
act
to
25
recruit
employees,
prepare,
conduct
,
and
grade
examinations,
26
rate
candidates
in
order
of
their
relative
scores
for
27
certification
for
appointment
or
promotion
or
for
other
matters
28
of
classification,
reclassification
,
or
appeal
rights
in
the
29
classified
service
of
the
public
employer
served.
30
3.
All
retirement
systems
,
dues
checkoffs,
and
other
31
payroll
deductions
for
political
action
committees
or
other
32
political
contributions
or
political
activities
shall
be
33
excluded
from
the
scope
of
negotiations.
For
negotiations
34
regarding
a
bargaining
unit
that
does
not
have
a
majority
of
35
-3-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
3/
68
H.F.
_____
members
who
are
public
safety
employees,
insurance,
leaves
of
1
absence
for
political
activities,
supplemental
pay,
transfer
2
procedures,
evaluation
procedures,
procedures
for
staff
3
reduction,
release
time,
subcontracting
public
services,
4
grievance
procedures
for
resolving
any
questions
arising
under
5
the
agreement,
and
seniority
and
any
wage
increase,
employment
6
benefit,
or
other
employment
advantage
based
on
seniority
shall
7
also
be
excluded
from
the
scope
of
negotiations.
8
4.
The
term
of
a
contract
entered
into
pursuant
to
this
9
chapter
shall
not
exceed
five
years.
10
Sec.
7.
Section
20.10,
subsection
3,
Code
2017,
is
amended
11
by
adding
the
following
new
paragraph:
12
NEW
PARAGRAPH
.
j.
Negotiate
or
attempt
to
negotiate
13
directly
with
a
member
of
the
governing
board
of
a
public
14
employer
if
the
public
employer
has
appointed
or
authorized
15
a
bargaining
representative
for
the
purpose
of
bargaining
16
with
the
public
employees
or
their
representative,
unless
the
17
member
of
the
governing
board
is
the
designated
bargaining
18
representative
of
the
public
employer.
19
Sec.
8.
Section
20.12,
subsection
5,
Code
2017,
is
amended
20
to
read
as
follows:
21
5.
If
an
employee
organization
or
any
of
its
officers
22
is
held
to
be
in
contempt
of
court
for
failure
to
comply
23
with
an
injunction
pursuant
to
this
section
,
or
is
convicted
24
of
violating
this
section
,
the
employee
organization
shall
25
be
immediately
decertified,
shall
cease
to
represent
the
26
bargaining
unit,
shall
cease
to
receive
any
dues
by
checkoff,
27
and
may
again
be
certified
only
after
twelve
twenty-four
months
28
have
elapsed
from
the
effective
date
of
decertification
and
29
only
after
if
a
new
compliance
with
petition
for
certification
30
pursuant
to
section
20.14
is
filed
and
a
new
certification
31
election
pursuant
to
section
20.15
is
held
.
The
penalties
32
provided
in
this
section
may
be
suspended
or
modified
by
the
33
court,
but
only
upon
request
of
the
public
employer
and
only
34
if
the
court
determines
the
suspension
or
modification
is
in
35
-4-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
4/
68
H.F.
_____
the
public
interest.
1
Sec.
9.
Section
20.15,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
2
follows:
3
20.15
Elections
——
agreements
with
the
state
.
4
1.
Initial
certification
elections.
5
a.
Upon
the
filing
of
a
petition
for
certification
of
an
6
employee
organization,
the
board
shall
submit
a
question
to
7
the
public
employees
at
an
election
in
the
bargaining
unit
8
found
appropriate
by
the
board.
The
question
on
the
ballot
9
shall
permit
the
public
employees
to
vote
for
no
bargaining
10
representation
or
for
any
employee
organization
which
has
11
petitioned
for
certification
or
which
has
presented
proof
12
satisfactory
to
the
board
of
support
of
ten
thirty
percent
or
13
more
of
the
public
employees
in
the
appropriate
unit.
14
2.
b.
(1)
If
a
majority
of
the
votes
cast
on
the
15
question
is
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
unit
vote
for
16
no
bargaining
representation,
the
public
employees
in
the
17
bargaining
unit
found
appropriate
by
the
board
shall
not
be
18
represented
by
an
employee
organization.
19
(2)
If
a
majority
of
the
votes
cast
on
the
question
is
20
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
unit
vote
for
a
listed
21
employee
organization,
then
that
employee
organization
shall
22
represent
the
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
unit
found
23
appropriate
by
the
board.
24
3.
(3)
If
none
of
the
choices
on
the
ballot
receive
the
25
vote
of
a
majority
of
the
public
employees
voting
in
the
26
bargaining
unit
,
the
board
shall
conduct
a
runoff
election
27
among
the
two
choices
receiving
the
greatest
number
of
votes
28
the
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
unit
found
appropriate
29
by
the
board
shall
not
be
represented
by
an
employee
30
organization
.
31
c.
The
board
shall
not
consider
a
petition
for
certification
32
of
an
employee
organization
as
the
exclusive
representative
33
of
a
bargaining
unit
unless
a
period
of
two
years
has
34
elapsed
from
the
date
of
the
last
certification
election
35
-5-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
5/
68
H.F.
_____
in
which
an
employee
organization
was
not
certified
as
the
1
exclusive
representative
of
that
bargaining
unit,
of
the
2
last
retention
and
recertification
election
in
which
an
3
employee
organization
was
not
retained
and
recertified
as
the
4
exclusive
representative
of
that
bargaining
unit,
or
of
the
5
last
decertification
election
in
which
an
employee
organization
6
was
decertified
as
the
exclusive
representative
of
that
7
bargaining
unit.
The
board
shall
also
not
consider
a
petition
8
for
certification
as
the
exclusive
bargaining
representative
9
of
a
bargaining
unit
if
the
bargaining
unit
is
at
that
time
10
represented
by
a
certified
exclusive
bargaining
representative.
11
2.
Retention
and
recertification
elections.
12
a.
The
board
shall
conduct
an
election
to
retain
and
13
recertify
the
bargaining
representative
of
a
bargaining
unit
14
prior
to
the
expiration
of
the
bargaining
unit’s
collective
15
bargaining
agreement.
The
question
on
the
ballot
shall
be
16
whether
the
bargaining
representative
of
the
public
employees
17
in
the
bargaining
unit
shall
be
retained
and
recertified
as
18
the
bargaining
representative
of
the
public
employees
in
the
19
bargaining
unit.
For
collective
bargaining
agreements
with
a
20
June
30
expiration
date,
the
election
shall
occur
between
June
21
1
and
November
1,
both
dates
included,
in
the
year
prior
to
22
that
expiration
date.
For
collective
bargaining
agreements
23
with
a
different
expiration
date,
the
election
shall
occur
24
between
three
hundred
sixty-five
and
two
hundred
seventy
days
25
prior
to
the
expiration
date.
26
b.
(1)
If
a
majority
of
the
public
employees
in
27
the
bargaining
unit
vote
to
retain
and
recertify
the
28
representative,
the
board
shall
retain
and
recertify
the
29
bargaining
representative
and
the
bargaining
representative
30
shall
continue
to
represent
the
public
employees
in
the
31
bargaining
unit.
32
(2)
If
a
majority
of
the
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
33
unit
do
not
vote
to
retain
and
recertify
the
representative,
34
the
board,
after
the
period
for
filing
written
objections
35
-6-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
6/
68
H.F.
_____
pursuant
to
subsection
4
has
elapsed,
shall
immediately
1
decertify
the
representative
and
the
public
employees
shall
2
not
be
represented
by
an
employee
organization
except
pursuant
3
to
the
filing
of
a
subsequent
petition
for
certification
of
4
an
employee
organization
as
provided
in
section
20.14
and
an
5
election
conducted
pursuant
to
such
petition.
Such
written
6
objections
and
decertifications
shall
be
subject
to
applicable
7
administrative
and
judicial
review.
8
3.
Decertification
elections.
9
a.
Upon
the
filing
of
a
petition
for
decertification
of
an
10
employee
organization,
the
board
shall
submit
a
question
to
the
11
public
employees
at
an
election
in
the
bargaining
unit
found
12
appropriate
by
the
board.
The
question
on
the
ballot
shall
be
13
whether
the
bargaining
representative
of
the
public
employees
14
in
the
bargaining
unit
shall
be
decertified
as
the
bargaining
15
representative
of
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
unit.
16
b.
(1)
If
a
majority
of
the
public
employees
in
17
the
bargaining
unit
vote
to
decertify
the
bargaining
18
representative,
the
board,
after
the
period
for
filing
19
written
objections
pursuant
to
subsection
4
has
elapsed,
20
shall
immediately
decertify
the
representative
and
the
public
21
employees
shall
not
be
represented
by
an
employee
organization
22
except
pursuant
to
the
filing
of
a
subsequent
petition
for
23
certification
of
an
employee
organization
as
provided
in
24
section
20.14
and
an
election
conducted
pursuant
to
such
25
petition.
Such
written
objections
and
decertifications
shall
26
be
subject
to
applicable
administrative
and
judicial
review.
27
(2)
If
a
majority
of
the
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
28
unit
do
not
vote
to
decertify
the
bargaining
representative,
29
the
bargaining
representative
shall
continue
to
represent
the
30
public
employees
in
the
bargaining
unit.
31
c.
The
board
shall
not
consider
a
petition
for
32
decertification
of
an
employee
organization
unless
a
33
bargaining
unit’s
collective
bargaining
agreement
exceeds
34
two
years
in
length.
The
board
shall
not
schedule
a
35
-7-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
7/
68
H.F.
_____
decertification
election
for
a
bargaining
unit
within
one
1
year
of
a
prior
certification,
retention
and
recertification,
2
or
decertification
election
involving
the
bargaining
unit.
3
Unless
otherwise
prohibited
by
this
paragraph,
the
board
shall
4
schedule
a
decertification
election
not
less
than
one
hundred
5
fifty
days
before
the
expiration
date
of
the
bargaining
unit’s
6
collective
bargaining
agreement.
7
4.
Invalidation
of
elections.
Upon
written
objections
8
filed
by
any
party
to
public
employee,
public
employer,
or
9
employee
organization
involved
in
the
election
within
ten
days
10
after
notice
of
the
results
of
the
election,
if
the
board
11
finds
that
misconduct
or
other
circumstances
prevented
the
12
public
employees
eligible
to
vote
from
freely
expressing
their
13
preferences,
the
board
may
invalidate
the
election
and
hold
a
14
second
election
for
the
public
employees.
15
5.
Results
certified.
Upon
completion
of
a
valid
election
16
in
which
the
majority
choice
of
the
public
employees
voting
in
17
the
bargaining
unit
is
determined,
the
board
shall
certify
the
18
results
of
the
election
and
shall
give
reasonable
notice
of
the
19
order
to
all
employee
organizations
listed
on
the
ballot,
the
20
public
employers,
and
the
public
employees
in
the
appropriate
21
bargaining
unit.
22
6.
State
agreements.
a.
A
petition
for
certification
as
23
exclusive
bargaining
representative
of
a
bargaining
unit
shall
24
not
be
considered
by
the
board
for
a
period
of
one
year
from
25
the
date
of
the
noncertification
of
an
employee
organization
26
as
the
exclusive
bargaining
representative
of
that
bargaining
27
unit
following
a
certification
election.
A
petition
for
28
certification
as
the
exclusive
bargaining
representative
of
a
29
bargaining
unit
shall
also
not
be
considered
by
the
board
if
30
the
bargaining
unit
is
at
that
time
represented
by
a
certified
31
exclusive
bargaining
representative.
32
b.
A
petition
for
the
decertification
of
the
exclusive
33
bargaining
representative
of
a
bargaining
unit
shall
not
be
34
considered
by
the
board
for
a
period
of
one
year
from
the
date
35
-8-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
8/
68
H.F.
_____
of
its
certification,
or
within
one
year
of
its
continued
1
certification
following
a
decertification
election,
or
during
2
the
duration
of
a
collective
bargaining
agreement
which,
for
3
purposes
of
this
section
,
shall
be
deemed
not
to
exceed
two
4
years.
However,
if
a
petition
for
decertification
is
filed
5
during
the
duration
of
a
collective
bargaining
agreement,
the
6
board
shall
award
an
election
under
this
section
not
more
than
7
one
hundred
eighty
days
and
not
less
than
one
hundred
fifty
8
days
prior
to
the
expiration
of
the
collective
bargaining
9
agreement.
If
an
employee
organization
is
decertified,
the
10
board
may
receive
petitions
under
section
20.14
,
provided
that
11
no
such
petition
and
no
election
conducted
pursuant
to
such
12
petition
within
one
year
from
decertification
shall
include
as
13
a
party
the
decertified
employee
organization.
14
c.
A
collective
bargaining
agreement
with
the
state,
its
15
boards,
commissions,
departments,
and
agencies
shall
be
for
16
two
years
.
and
the
The
provisions
of
a
collective
bargaining
17
agreement
or
arbitrator’s
award
affecting
state
employees
18
shall
not
provide
for
renegotiations
which
would
require
the
19
refinancing
of
salary
and
fringe
benefits
subjects
within
the
20
scope
of
negotiations
under
section
20.9
for
the
second
year
21
of
the
term
of
the
agreement,
except
as
provided
in
section
22
20.17,
subsection
6
,
and
the
.
The
effective
date
of
any
such
23
agreement
shall
be
July
1
of
odd-numbered
years,
provided
24
that
if
an
exclusive
bargaining
representative
is
certified
25
on
a
date
which
will
prevent
the
negotiation
of
a
collective
26
bargaining
agreement
prior
to
July
1
of
odd-numbered
years
for
27
a
period
of
two
years,
the
certified
collective
bargaining
28
representative
may
negotiate
a
one-year
contract
with
the
29
public
employer
which
shall
be
effective
from
July
1
of
the
30
even-numbered
year
to
July
1
of
the
succeeding
odd-numbered
31
year
when
new
contracts
agreements
shall
become
effective.
32
Sec.
10.
Section
20.17,
subsection
8,
Code
2017,
is
amended
33
to
read
as
follows:
34
8.
a.
The
salaries
of
all
public
employees
of
the
state
35
-9-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
9/
68
H.F.
_____
under
a
merit
system
and
all
other
fringe
benefits
which
are
1
granted
to
all
subjects
within
the
scope
of
negotiations
2
pursuant
to
the
provisions
of
section
20.9
regarding
public
3
employees
of
the
state
shall
be
negotiated
with
the
governor
4
or
the
governor’s
designee
on
a
statewide
basis,
except
those
5
benefits
which
are
not
subject
to
subjects
excluded
from
the
6
scope
of
negotiations
pursuant
to
the
provisions
of
section
7
20.9
,
subsection
3
.
8
b.
For
the
negotiation
of
such
a
proposed,
statewide
9
collective
bargaining
agreement
to
become
effective
in
the
year
10
following
an
election
described
in
section
39.9,
a
ratification
11
election
referred
to
in
section
20.17,
subsection
4,
shall
12
not
be
held,
and
the
parties
shall
not
request
arbitration
as
13
provided
in
section
20.22,
subsection
1,
until
at
least
two
14
weeks
after
the
date
of
the
beginning
of
the
term
of
office
of
15
the
governor
in
that
year
as
prescribed
in
the
Constitution
16
of
the
State
of
Iowa.
On
or
after
the
beginning
of
the
term
17
of
office
of
the
governor
in
that
year
as
prescribed
in
the
18
Constitution
of
the
State
of
Iowa,
the
governor
shall
have
19
the
authority
to
reject
such
a
proposed
statewide
collective
20
bargaining
agreement.
If
the
governor
does
so,
the
parties
21
shall
commence
collective
bargaining
in
accordance
with
section
22
20.17.
Such
negotiation
shall
be
complete
not
later
than
23
March
15
of
that
year,
unless
the
parties
mutually
agree
to
24
a
different
deadline.
The
board
shall
adopt
rules
pursuant
25
to
chapter
17A
providing
for
alternative
deadlines
for
the
26
completion
of
the
procedures
provided
in
sections
20.17,
20.19,
27
20.20,
and
20.22
for
negotiation
of
such
statewide
collective
28
bargaining
agreements
in
such
years,
which
deadlines
may
be
29
waived
by
mutual
agreement
of
the
parties.
30
Sec.
11.
Section
20.17,
subsection
9,
Code
2017,
is
amended
31
by
striking
the
subsection.
32
Sec.
12.
Section
20.18,
subsection
1,
Code
2017,
is
amended
33
to
read
as
follows:
34
1.
An
agreement
with
an
employee
organization
which
35
-10-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
10/
68
H.F.
_____
is
the
exclusive
representative
of
public
employees
in
an
1
appropriate
unit
with
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
2
safety
employees
may
provide
procedures
for
the
consideration
3
of
public
employee
and
employee
organization
grievances
over
4
the
interpretation
and
application
of
agreements.
Negotiated
5
Such
negotiated
procedures
may
provide
for
binding
arbitration
6
of
public
employee
and
employee
organization
grievances
over
7
the
interpretation
and
application
of
existing
agreements.
An
8
arbitrator’s
decision
on
a
grievance
may
shall
not
change
or
9
amend
the
terms,
conditions,
or
applications
of
the
collective
10
bargaining
agreement.
Such
procedures
shall
provide
for
the
11
invoking
of
arbitration
only
with
the
approval
of
the
employee
12
organization
in
all
instances,
and
in
the
case
of
an
employee
13
grievance,
only
with
the
additional
approval
of
the
public
14
employee.
The
costs
of
arbitration
shall
be
shared
equally
by
15
the
parties.
16
Sec.
13.
Section
20.22,
subsections
2,
3,
7,
8,
and
9,
Code
17
2017,
are
amended
to
read
as
follows:
18
2.
Each
party
shall
serve
its
final
offer
on
each
of
19
the
impasse
items
upon
the
other
party
within
four
days
of
20
the
board’s
receipt
of
the
request
for
arbitration
,
or
by
a
21
deadline
otherwise
agreed
upon
by
the
parties
.
The
parties
may
22
continue
to
negotiate
all
offers
until
an
agreement
is
reached
23
or
an
award
is
rendered
by
the
arbitrator.
The
full
costs
of
24
arbitration
under
this
section
shall
be
shared
equally
by
the
25
parties
to
the
dispute.
26
3.
The
submission
of
the
impasse
items
to
the
arbitrator
27
shall
be
limited
to
those
items
upon
which
the
parties
have
28
not
reached
agreement.
With
respect
to
each
such
item,
the
29
arbitrator’s
award
shall
be
restricted
to
the
final
offers
on
30
each
impasse
item
submitted
by
the
parties
to
the
arbitrator
,
31
except
as
provided
in
subsection
9,
paragraph
“b”
.
32
7.
The
For
an
arbitration
to
which
a
bargaining
unit
that
33
has
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
safety
employees
is
a
34
party,
the
arbitrator
shall
consider
and
specifically
address
35
-11-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
11/
68
H.F.
_____
in
the
arbitrator’s
decision
,
in
addition
to
any
other
relevant
1
factors,
the
following
factors:
2
a.
Past
collective
bargaining
contracts
between
the
parties
3
including
the
bargaining
that
led
up
to
such
contracts.
4
b.
Comparison
of
wages,
hours
and
conditions
of
employment
5
of
the
involved
public
employees
with
those
of
other
public
6
employees
doing
comparable
work,
giving
consideration
to
7
factors
peculiar
to
the
area
and
the
classifications
involved.
8
c.
The
interests
and
welfare
of
the
public,
the
ability
of
9
the
public
employer
to
finance
economic
adjustments
and
the
10
effect
of
such
adjustments
on
the
normal
standard
of
services.
11
d.
The
power
of
the
public
employer
to
levy
taxes
and
12
appropriate
funds
for
the
conduct
of
its
operations.
13
8.
a.
The
arbitrator
may
administer
oaths,
examine
14
witnesses
and
documents,
take
testimony
and
receive
evidence,
15
and
issue
subpoenas
to
compel
the
attendance
of
witnesses
and
16
the
production
of
records.
The
arbitrator
may
petition
the
17
district
court
at
the
seat
of
government
or
of
the
county
18
in
which
the
hearing
is
held
to
enforce
the
order
of
the
19
arbitrator
compelling
the
attendance
of
witnesses
and
the
20
production
of
records.
21
b.
The
parties
shall
not
introduce,
and
the
arbitrator
22
shall
not
accept
or
consider,
any
direct
or
indirect
evidence
23
regarding
any
subject
excluded
from
negotiations
pursuant
to
24
section
20.9.
25
9.
a.
The
arbitrator
shall
select
within
fifteen
days
after
26
the
hearing
the
most
reasonable
offer,
in
the
arbitrator’s
27
judgment,
of
the
final
offers
on
each
impasse
item
submitted
28
by
the
parties.
29
b.
(1)
However,
for
an
arbitration
to
which
a
bargaining
30
unit
that
does
not
have
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
31
safety
employees
is
a
party,
with
respect
to
any
increase
in
32
base
wages,
the
arbitrator’s
award
shall
not
exceed
the
lesser
33
of
the
following
percentages
in
any
one-year
period
in
the
34
duration
of
the
bargaining
agreement:
35
-12-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
12/
68
H.F.
_____
(a)
Three
percent.
1
(b)
A
percentage
equal
to
the
increase
in
the
consumer
2
price
index
for
all
urban
consumers
for
the
midwest
region,
3
if
any,
as
determined
by
the
United
States
department
of
4
labor,
bureau
of
labor
statistics,
or
a
successor
index.
Such
5
percentage
shall
be
the
change
in
the
consumer
price
index
6
for
the
twelve-month
period
beginning
eighteen
months
prior
7
to
the
month
in
which
the
impasse
item
regarding
base
wages
8
was
submitted
to
the
arbitrator
and
ending
six
months
prior
to
9
the
month
in
which
the
impasse
item
regarding
base
wages
was
10
submitted
to
the
arbitrator.
11
(2)
To
assist
the
parties
in
the
preparation
of
their
final
12
offers
on
an
impasse
item
regarding
base
wages,
the
board
13
shall
provide
information
to
the
parties
regarding
the
change
14
in
the
consumer
price
index
for
all
urban
consumers
for
the
15
midwest
region
for
any
twelve-month
period.
The
department
of
16
workforce
development
shall
assist
the
board
in
preparing
such
17
information
upon
request.
18
Sec.
14.
Section
20.22,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
the
19
following
new
subsection:
20
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
7A.
For
an
arbitration
to
which
a
21
bargaining
unit
that
does
not
have
a
majority
of
members
who
22
are
public
safety
employees
is
a
party,
the
following
shall
23
apply:
24
a.
The
arbitrator
shall
consider
and
specifically
address
25
in
the
arbitrator’s
determination,
in
addition
to
any
other
26
relevant
factors,
the
following
factors:
27
(1)
Comparison
of
base
wages,
hours,
and
conditions
of
28
employment
of
the
involved
public
employees
with
those
of
other
29
public
employees
doing
comparable
work,
giving
consideration
to
30
factors
peculiar
to
the
area
and
the
classifications
involved.
31
To
the
extent
adequate,
applicable
data
is
available,
32
the
arbitrator
shall
also
compare
base
wages,
hours,
and
33
conditions
of
employment
of
the
involved
public
employees
34
with
those
of
private
sector
employees
doing
comparable
work,
35
-13-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
13/
68
H.F.
_____
giving
consideration
to
factors
peculiar
to
the
area
and
the
1
classifications
involved.
2
(2)
The
interests
and
welfare
of
the
public.
3
(3)
The
financial
ability
of
the
employer
to
meet
the
cost
4
of
an
offer
in
light
of
the
current
economic
conditions
of
the
5
public
employer.
The
arbitrator
shall
give
substantial
weight
6
to
evidence
that
the
public
employer’s
authority
to
utilize
7
funds
is
restricted
to
special
purposes
or
circumstances
8
by
state
or
federal
law,
rules,
regulations,
or
grant
9
requirements.
10
b.
The
arbitrator
shall
not
consider
the
following
factors:
11
(1)
Past
collective
bargaining
agreements
between
the
12
parties
or
bargaining
that
led
to
such
agreements.
13
(2)
The
public
employer’s
ability
to
fund
an
award
through
14
the
increase
or
imposition
of
new
taxes,
fees,
or
charges,
or
15
to
develop
other
sources
of
revenues.
16
Sec.
15.
Section
20.26,
unnumbered
paragraph
4,
Code
2017,
17
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
18
Nothing
in
this
section
shall
be
construed
to
prohibit
19
voluntary
contributions
by
individuals
to
political
parties
20
or
candidates
,
provided
that
such
contributions
are
not
made
21
through
payroll
deductions
.
22
Sec.
16.
Section
20.29,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
23
follows:
24
20.29
Filing
agreement
——
public
access
——
internet
site
.
25
1.
Copies
of
collective
bargaining
agreements
entered
26
into
between
the
state
and
the
state
employees’
bargaining
27
representatives
and
made
final
under
this
chapter
shall
be
28
filed
with
the
secretary
of
state
and
be
made
available
to
the
29
public
at
cost.
30
2.
The
board
shall
maintain
an
internet
site
that
allows
31
searchable
access
to
a
database
of
collective
bargaining
32
agreements
and
other
collective
bargaining
information.
33
Sec.
17.
Section
20.30,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
striking
34
the
section
and
inserting
in
lieu
thereof
the
following:
35
-14-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
14/
68
H.F.
_____
20.30
Supervisory
member
——
no
reduction
before
retirement.
1
A
supervisory
member
of
any
department
or
agency
employed
by
2
the
state
of
Iowa
shall
not
be
granted
a
voluntary
reduction
3
to
a
nonsupervisory
rank
or
grade
during
the
thirty-six
4
months
preceding
retirement
of
the
member.
A
member
of
any
5
department
or
agency
employed
by
the
state
of
Iowa
who
retires
6
in
less
than
thirty-six
months
after
voluntarily
requesting
and
7
receiving
a
reduction
in
rank
or
grade
from
a
supervisory
to
a
8
nonsupervisory
position
shall
be
ineligible
for
a
benefit
to
9
which
the
member
is
entitled
as
a
nonsupervisory
member
but
is
10
not
entitled
as
a
supervisory
member.
11
Sec.
18.
Section
20.31,
subsection
2,
unnumbered
paragraph
12
1,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
13
A
mediator
shall
not
be
required
to
testify
in
any
judicial,
14
administrative,
arbitration,
or
grievance
proceeding
regarding
15
any
matters
occurring
in
the
course
of
a
mediation,
including
16
any
verbal
or
written
communication
or
behavior,
other
than
17
facts
relating
exclusively
to
the
timing
or
scheduling
of
18
mediation.
A
mediator
shall
not
be
required
to
produce
or
19
disclose
any
documents,
including
notes,
memoranda,
or
other
20
work
product,
relating
to
mediation,
other
than
documents
21
relating
exclusively
to
the
timing
or
scheduling
of
mediation.
22
This
subsection
shall
not
apply
in
any
of
the
following
23
circumstances:
24
Sec.
19.
Section
22.7,
subsection
69,
Code
2017,
is
amended
25
to
read
as
follows:
26
69.
The
evidence
of
public
employee
support
for
27
the
certification
,
retention
and
recertification,
or
28
decertification
of
an
employee
organization
as
defined
in
29
section
20.3
that
is
submitted
to
the
public
employment
30
relations
board
as
provided
in
sections
section
20.14
and
or
31
20.15
.
32
Sec.
20.
Section
22.7,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
the
33
following
new
subsection:
34
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
70.
Information
indicating
whether
35
-15-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
15/
68
H.F.
_____
a
public
employee
voted
in
a
certification,
retention
and
1
recertification,
or
decertification
election
held
pursuant
to
2
section
20.15
or
how
the
employee
voted
on
any
question
on
a
3
ballot
in
such
an
election.
4
Sec.
21.
Section
70A.17A,
subsection
3,
Code
2017,
is
5
amended
by
striking
the
subsection.
6
Sec.
22.
Section
70A.19,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
striking
7
the
section
and
inserting
in
lieu
thereof
the
following:
8
70A.19
Payroll
deduction
for
employee
organization
dues
9
prohibited.
10
The
state,
a
state
agency,
a
regents
institution,
a
board
of
11
directors
of
a
school
district,
a
community
college,
or
an
area
12
education
agency,
a
county
board
of
supervisors,
a
governing
13
body
of
a
city,
or
any
other
public
employer
as
defined
in
14
section
20.3
shall
not
authorize
or
administer
a
deduction
from
15
the
salaries
or
wages
of
its
employees
for
membership
dues
to
16
an
employee
organization
as
defined
in
section
20.3.
17
Sec.
23.
Section
412.2,
subsection
1,
Code
2017,
is
amended
18
to
read
as
follows:
19
1.
From
the
proceeds
of
the
assessments
on
the
wages
20
and
salaries
of
employees,
of
any
such
waterworks
system,
21
or
other
municipally
owned
and
operated
public
utility,
22
eligible
to
receive
the
benefits
thereof.
Notwithstanding
23
any
provisions
of
section
20.9
to
the
contrary,
a
council,
24
board
of
waterworks,
or
other
board
or
commission
which
25
establishes
a
pension
and
annuity
retirement
system
pursuant
to
26
this
chapter
,
shall
negotiate
in
good
faith
with
a
certified
27
employee
organization
as
defined
in
section
20.3
,
which
is
the
28
collective
bargaining
representative
of
the
employees,
with
29
respect
to
the
amount
or
rate
of
the
assessment
on
the
wages
30
and
salaries
of
employees
and
the
method
or
methods
for
payment
31
of
the
assessment
by
the
employees.
32
Sec.
24.
Section
602.1401,
subsection
3,
paragraph
b,
Code
33
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
34
b.
For
purposes
of
chapter
20
,
the
certified
representative,
35
-16-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
16/
68
H.F.
_____
which
on
July
1,
1983,
represents
employees
who
become
judicial
1
branch
employees
as
a
result
of
1983
Iowa
Acts,
ch.
186,
shall
2
remain
the
certified
representative
when
the
employees
become
3
judicial
branch
employees
and
thereafter,
unless
the
public
4
employee
organization
is
not
retained
and
recertified
or
is
5
decertified
in
an
election
held
under
section
20.15
or
amended
6
or
absorbed
into
another
certified
organization
pursuant
to
7
chapter
20
.
Collective
bargaining
negotiations
shall
be
8
conducted
on
a
statewide
basis
and
the
certified
employee
9
organizations
which
engage
in
bargaining
shall
negotiate
on
a
10
statewide
basis,
although
bargaining
units
shall
be
organized
11
by
judicial
district.
The
public
employment
relations
board
12
shall
adopt
rules
pursuant
to
chapter
17A
to
implement
this
13
subsection
.
14
Sec.
25.
TRANSITION
PROCEDURES
——
EMERGENCY
RULES.
15
1.
As
of
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
this
Act,
16
parties,
mediators,
and
arbitrators
engaging
in
any
collective
17
bargaining
procedures
provided
for
in
chapter
20,
Code
2017,
18
who
have
not,
before
the
effective
date
of
this
division
19
of
this
Act,
completed
such
procedures,
shall
immediately
20
terminate
any
such
procedures
in
process.
A
collective
21
bargaining
agreement
negotiated
pursuant
to
such
procedures
in
22
process
shall
not
become
effective.
Parties,
mediators,
and
23
arbitrators
shall
not
engage
in
further
collective
bargaining
24
procedures
except
as
provided
in
this
section.
Such
parties,
25
on
or
after
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
this
Act,
26
may
commence
collective
bargaining
in
accordance
with
section
27
20.17,
as
amended
in
this
division
of
this
Act.
If
such
28
parties
include
a
state
public
employer
and
a
state
employee
29
organization,
negotiation
of
a
proposed
collective
bargaining
30
agreement
to
become
effective
during
the
remainder
of
calendar
31
year
2017
shall
be
complete
not
later
than
March
15,
2017,
32
unless
the
parties
mutually
agree
to
a
different
deadline.
33
If
such
parties
include
public
employees
represented
by
a
34
certified
employee
organization
who
are
employed
by
a
public
35
-17-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
17/
68
H.F.
_____
employer
which
is
a
school
district,
area
education
agency,
1
or
community
college,
negotiation
of
a
proposed
collective
2
bargaining
agreement
to
become
effective
during
the
remainder
3
of
calendar
year
2017
shall
be
complete
not
later
than
June
4
30,
2017,
unless
the
parties
mutually
agree
to
a
different
5
deadline.
6
2.
The
public
employment
relations
board
shall
adopt
7
emergency
rules
under
section
17A.4,
subsection
3,
and
section
8
17A.5,
subsection
2,
paragraph
“b”,
to
provide
for
procedures
9
as
deemed
necessary
to
implement
the
provisions
of
this
section
10
and
the
rules
shall
be
effective
immediately
upon
filing
11
unless
a
later
date
is
specified
in
the
rules.
Such
rules
12
shall
include
but
are
not
limited
to
alternative
deadlines
for
13
completion
of
the
procedures
provided
in
sections
20.17
and
14
20.22,
as
amended
by
this
division
of
this
Act,
and
sections
15
20.19
and
20.20,
which
deadlines
may
be
waived
by
mutual
16
agreement
of
the
parties.
17
Sec.
26.
EFFECTIVE
UPON
ENACTMENT.
This
division
of
this
18
Act,
being
deemed
of
immediate
importance,
takes
effect
upon
19
enactment.
20
Sec.
27.
APPLICABILITY.
21
1.
With
the
exception
of
the
section
of
this
division
of
22
this
Act
amending
section
20.6,
subsection
1,
this
division
of
23
this
Act
does
not
apply
to
collective
bargaining
agreements
24
which
have
been
ratified
in
a
ratification
election
referred
25
to
in
section
20.17,
subsection
4,
for
which
an
arbitrator
26
has
made
a
final
determination
as
described
in
section
20.22,
27
subsection
11,
or
which
have
become
effective,
where
such
28
events
occurred
before
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
29
this
Act.
This
division
of
this
Act
applies
to
all
collective
30
bargaining
procedures
provided
for
in
chapter
20
occurring
31
on
and
after
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
this
Act
32
and
collective
bargaining
agreements
for
which
a
ratification
33
election
referred
to
in
section
20.17,
subsection
4,
is
34
held,
for
which
an
arbitrator
makes
a
final
determination
as
35
-18-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
18/
68
H.F.
_____
described
in
section
20.22,
subsection
11,
or
which,
unless
1
otherwise
provided
in
this
section,
become
effective
on
or
2
after
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
this
Act.
3
2.
The
provision
of
this
division
of
this
Act
amending
4
section
70A.19
does
not
apply
to
dues
deductions
required
by
5
collective
bargaining
agreements
which
have
been
ratified
in
a
6
ratification
election
referred
to
in
section
20.17,
subsection
7
4,
for
which
an
arbitrator
has
made
a
final
determination
as
8
described
in
section
20.22,
subsection
11,
or
which
have
become
9
effective,
where
such
events
occurred
before
the
effective
date
10
of
this
division
of
this
Act.
11
3.
Section
20.15,
subsection
2,
as
enacted
by
this
division
12
of
this
Act,
does
not
apply
to
collective
bargaining
agreements
13
with
expiration
dates
occurring
before
April
1,
2018.
14
DIVISION
II
15
EDUCATOR
EMPLOYMENT
MATTERS
16
Sec.
28.
Section
279.13,
subsections
2
and
5,
Code
2017,
are
17
amended
to
read
as
follows:
18
2.
The
contract
shall
remain
in
force
and
effect
for
the
19
period
stated
in
the
contract
and
shall
be
automatically
20
continued
for
equivalent
periods
except
as
modified
or
21
terminated
by
mutual
agreement
of
the
board
of
directors
and
22
the
teacher
or
as
modified
or
terminated
in
accordance
with
23
the
provisions
specified
in
this
chapter
.
A
contract
shall
24
not
be
offered
by
the
employing
board
to
a
teacher
under
its
25
jurisdiction
prior
to
March
15
of
any
year.
A
teacher
who
has
26
not
accepted
a
contract
for
the
ensuing
school
year
tendered
27
by
the
employing
board
may
resign
effective
at
the
end
of
the
28
current
school
year
by
filing
a
written
resignation
with
the
29
secretary
of
the
board.
The
resignation
must
be
filed
not
30
later
than
the
last
day
of
the
current
school
year
or
the
date
31
specified
by
the
employing
board
for
return
of
the
contract,
32
whichever
date
occurs
first.
However,
a
teacher
shall
not
be
33
required
to
return
a
contract
to
the
board
or
to
resign
less
34
than
twenty-one
days
after
the
contract
has
been
offered.
35
-19-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
19/
68
H.F.
_____
5.
Notwithstanding
the
other
provisions
of
this
section
,
a
1
temporary
contract
may
be
issued
to
a
teacher
for
a
period
of
2
up
to
six
months.
Notwithstanding
the
other
provisions
of
this
3
section,
a
temporary
contract
may
also
be
issued
to
a
teacher
4
to
fill
a
vacancy
created
by
a
leave
of
absence
in
accordance
5
with
the
provisions
of
section
29A.28
,
which
contract
shall
6
automatically
terminate
upon
return
from
military
leave
of
the
7
former
incumbent
of
the
teaching
position
and
which
contract
.
8
Temporary
contacts
shall
not
be
subject
to
the
provisions
of
9
sections
279.15
through
279.19
,
or
section
279.27
.
A
separate
10
extracurricular
contract
issued
pursuant
to
section
279.19A
to
11
a
person
issued
a
temporary
contract
under
this
section
shall
12
automatically
terminate
with
the
termination
of
the
temporary
13
contract
as
required
under
section
279.19A,
subsection
8
.
14
Sec.
29.
Section
279.13,
subsection
4,
unnumbered
paragraph
15
1,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
16
For
purposes
of
this
section
,
sections
279.14
,
279.15
17
through
279.17
,
279.16,
279.19
,
and
279.27
,
unless
the
context
18
otherwise
requires,
“teacher”
includes
the
following
individuals
19
employed
by
a
community
college:
20
Sec.
30.
Section
279.14,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
21
follows:
22
279.14
Evaluation
criteria
and
procedures.
23
1.
The
board
shall
establish
evaluation
criteria
and
shall
24
implement
evaluation
procedures.
If
an
exclusive
bargaining
25
representative
has
been
certified,
the
board
shall
negotiate
26
in
good
faith
with
respect
to
evaluation
procedures
pursuant
27
to
chapter
20
.
28
2.
The
determination
of
standards
of
performance
expected
29
of
school
district
personnel
shall
be
reserved
as
an
exclusive
30
management
right
of
the
school
board
and
shall
not
be
subject
31
to
mandatory
negotiations
under
chapter
20
.
Notwithstanding
32
chapter
20
,
objections
to
the
procedures,
use,
or
content
of
33
an
evaluation
in
a
teacher
termination
proceeding
brought
34
before
the
school
board
in
a
hearing
held
in
accordance
with
35
-20-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
20/
68
H.F.
_____
section
279.16
or
279.27
shall
not
be
subject
to
the
grievance
1
procedures
negotiated
in
accordance
with
chapter
20
.
A
school
2
district
shall
not
be
obligated
to
process
any
evaluation
3
grievance
after
service
of
a
notice
and
recommendation
to
4
terminate
an
individual’s
continuing
teaching
contract
in
5
accordance
with
this
chapter
.
6
Sec.
31.
Section
279.15,
subsection
2,
paragraph
c,
Code
7
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
8
c.
Within
five
days
of
the
receipt
of
the
written
notice
9
that
the
superintendent
is
recommending
termination
of
the
10
contract,
the
teacher
may
request,
in
writing
to
the
secretary
11
of
the
board,
a
private
hearing
with
the
board.
The
private
12
hearing
shall
not
be
subject
to
chapter
21
and
shall
be
held
13
no
sooner
than
ten
twenty
days
and
no
later
than
twenty
forty
14
days
following
the
receipt
of
the
request
unless
the
parties
15
otherwise
agree.
The
secretary
of
the
board
shall
notify
the
16
teacher
in
writing
of
the
date,
time,
and
location
of
the
17
private
hearing,
and
at
least
five
ten
days
before
the
hearing
18
shall
also
furnish
to
the
teacher
any
documentation
which
19
may
be
presented
to
the
board
at
the
private
hearing
and
a
20
list
of
persons
who
may
address
the
board
in
support
of
the
21
superintendent’s
recommendation
at
the
private
hearing.
At
22
least
three
seven
days
before
the
hearing,
the
teacher
shall
23
provide
any
documentation
the
teacher
expects
to
present
at
24
the
private
hearing,
along
with
the
names
of
any
persons
who
25
may
address
the
board
on
behalf
of
the
teacher.
This
exchange
26
of
information
shall
be
at
the
time
specified
unless
otherwise
27
agreed.
28
Sec.
32.
Section
279.16,
subsections
1,
2,
6,
7,
8,
9,
and
29
10,
Code
2017,
are
amended
to
read
as
follows:
30
1.
The
participants
at
the
private
hearing
shall
be
at
31
least
a
majority
of
the
members
of
the
board
,
and
their
32
legal
representatives,
if
any,
the
and
the
witnesses
for
the
33
parties.
The
superintendent,
the
superintendent’s
designated
34
representatives,
if
any,
the
teacher’s
immediate
supervisor,
35
-21-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
21/
68
H.F.
_____
the
teacher,
and
the
teacher’s
representatives,
if
any,
and
the
1
witnesses
for
the
parties
may
participate
in
the
hearing
as
2
well
.
The
evidence
at
the
private
hearing
shall
be
limited
to
3
the
specific
reasons
stated
in
the
superintendent’s
notice
of
4
recommendation
of
termination.
No
A
participant
in
the
hearing
5
shall
not
be
liable
for
any
damages
to
any
person
if
any
6
statement
at
the
hearing
is
determined
to
be
erroneous
as
long
7
as
the
statement
was
made
in
good
faith.
The
superintendent
8
shall
present
evidence
and
argument
on
all
issues
involved
and
9
the
teacher
may
cross-examine,
respond
,
and
present
evidence
10
and
argument
in
the
teacher’s
behalf
relevant
to
all
issues
11
involved.
Evidence
may
be
by
stipulation
of
the
parties
and
12
informal
settlement
may
be
made
by
stipulation,
consent,
or
13
default
or
by
any
other
method
agreed
upon
by
the
parties
in
14
writing.
The
board
shall
employ
a
certified
shorthand
reporter
15
to
keep
a
record
of
the
private
hearing.
The
proceedings
16
or
any
part
thereof
shall
be
transcribed
at
the
request
of
17
either
party
with
the
expense
of
transcription
charged
to
the
18
requesting
party.
19
2.
The
presiding
officer
of
the
board
may
administer
oaths
20
in
the
same
manner
and
with
like
effect
and
under
the
same
21
penalties
as
in
the
case
of
magistrates
exercising
criminal
22
or
civil
jurisdiction.
The
board
shall
cause
subpoenas
to
be
23
issued
for
such
witnesses
and
the
production
of
such
books
24
and
papers
as
either
the
board
or
the
teacher
may
designate.
25
The
subpoenas
shall
be
signed
by
the
presiding
officer
of
the
26
board.
27
6.
If
the
teacher
fails
to
timely
request
a
private
hearing
28
or
does
not
appear
at
the
private
hearing,
the
board
may
29
proceed
and
make
a
determination
upon
the
superintendent’s
30
recommendation.
If
the
teacher
fails
to
timely
file
a
request
31
for
a
private
hearing,
the
determination
shall
be
not
later
32
than
May
31.
If
the
teacher
fails
to
appear
at
the
private
33
hearing,
the
determination
shall
be
not
later
than
five
days
34
after
the
scheduled
date
for
the
private
hearing.
The
board
35
-22-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
22/
68
H.F.
_____
shall
convene
in
open
session
and
by
roll
call
vote
determine
1
the
termination
or
continuance
of
the
teacher’s
contract
2
and,
if
the
board
votes
to
continue
the
teacher’s
contract,
3
whether
to
suspend
the
teacher
with
or
without
pay
for
a
4
period
specified
by
the
board
or
issue
the
teacher
a
one-year,
5
nonrenewable
contract
.
6
7.
Within
five
days
after
the
private
hearing,
the
board
7
shall,
in
executive
session,
meet
to
make
a
final
decision
8
upon
the
recommendation
and
the
evidence
as
herein
provided.
9
The
board
shall
also
consider
any
written
brief
and
arguments
10
submitted
by
the
superintendent
and
the
teacher.
11
8.
a.
The
record
for
a
private
hearing
shall
include:
12
a.
(1)
All
pleadings,
motions
,
and
intermediate
rulings.
13
b.
(2)
All
evidence
received
or
considered
and
all
other
14
submissions.
15
c.
(3)
A
statement
of
all
matters
officially
noticed.
16
d.
(4)
All
questions
and
offers
of
proof,
objections
,
and
17
rulings
thereon.
18
e.
(5)
All
findings
and
exceptions.
19
f.
(6)
Any
decision,
opinion,
or
conclusion
by
the
board.
20
g.
Findings
of
fact
21
b.
The
decision
of
the
board
shall
be
based
solely
on
the
22
evidence
in
the
record
and
on
matters
officially
noticed
in
the
23
record.
24
9.
The
decision
of
the
board
shall
be
in
writing
and
shall
25
include
findings
of
fact
and
conclusions
of
law,
separately
26
stated
.
Findings
of
fact,
if
set
forth
in
statutory
language,
27
shall
be
accompanied
by
a
concise
and
explicit
statement
of
the
28
underlying
facts
and
supporting
the
findings.
Each
conclusion
29
of
law
shall
be
supported
by
cited
authority
or
by
reasoned
30
opinion.
31
10.
When
the
board
has
reached
a
decision,
opinion,
or
32
conclusion,
it
shall
convene
in
open
meeting
and
by
roll
33
call
vote
determine
the
continuance
or
discontinuance
of
34
the
teacher’s
contract
and,
if
the
board
votes
to
continue
35
-23-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
23/
68
H.F.
_____
the
teacher’s
contract,
whether
to
suspend
the
teacher
with
1
or
without
pay
for
a
period
specified
by
the
board
or
issue
2
the
teacher
a
one-year,
nonrenewable
contract
.
The
record
3
of
the
private
conference
hearing
and
findings
of
fact
and
4
exceptions
written
decision
of
the
board
shall
be
exempt
from
5
the
provisions
of
chapter
22
.
The
secretary
of
the
board
shall
6
immediately
mail
notice
of
the
board’s
action
to
the
teacher.
7
Sec.
33.
Section
279.16,
subsections
3
and
5,
Code
2017,
are
8
amended
by
striking
the
subsections.
9
Sec.
34.
Section
279.18,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
10
follows:
11
279.18
Appeal
by
either
party
teacher
to
court.
12
1.
If
either
party
a
teacher
rejects
the
adjudicator’s
13
board’s
decision,
the
rejecting
party
teacher
shall,
within
14
thirty
days
of
the
initial
filing
of
such
decision,
appeal
to
15
the
district
court
of
the
county
in
which
the
administrative
16
office
of
the
school
district
is
located.
The
notice
of
17
appeal
shall
be
immediately
mailed
by
certified
mail
to
the
18
other
party
board
.
The
adjudicator
secretary
of
the
board
19
shall
transmit
to
the
reviewing
court
the
original
or
a
20
certified
copy
of
the
entire
record
which
may
be
the
subject
21
of
the
petition.
By
stipulation
of
all
parties
to
the
review
22
proceedings,
the
record
of
such
a
case
may
be
shortened.
A
23
party
unreasonably
refusing
to
stipulate
to
limit
the
record
24
may
be
taxed
by
the
court
for
the
additional
cost.
The
court
25
may
require
or
permit
subsequent
corrections
or
additions
to
26
the
shortened
record.
27
2.
In
proceedings
for
judicial
review
of
the
adjudicator’s
28
board’s
decision,
the
court
shall
not
hear
any
further
evidence
29
but
shall
hear
the
case
upon
the
certified
record.
In
such
30
judicial
review,
especially
when
considering
the
credibility
31
of
witnesses,
the
court
shall
give
weight
to
the
fact
findings
32
decision
of
the
board
;
,
but
shall
not
be
bound
by
them
it
.
33
The
court
may
affirm
the
adjudicator’s
board’s
decision
or
34
remand
to
the
adjudicator
or
the
board
for
further
proceedings
35
-24-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
24/
68
H.F.
_____
upon
conditions
determined
by
the
court.
The
court
shall
1
reverse,
modify,
or
grant
any
other
appropriate
equitable
or
2
legal
relief
from
the
board
decision
,
or
the
adjudicator’s
3
decision
equitable
or
legal
and
including
declaratory
relief
,
4
if
substantial
rights
of
the
petitioner
have
been
prejudiced
5
because
the
action
is
any
of
the
following
:
6
a.
In
violation
of
constitutional
or
statutory
provisions
;
7
or
.
8
b.
In
excess
of
the
statutory
authority
of
the
board
or
the
9
adjudicator;
or
.
10
c.
In
violation
of
a
board
rule
or
policy
or
contract
;
or
.
11
d.
Made
upon
unlawful
procedure
;
or
.
12
e.
Affected
by
other
error
of
law
;
or
.
13
f.
Unsupported
by
a
preponderance
of
the
competent
evidence
14
in
the
record
made
before
the
board
and
the
adjudicator
when
15
that
record
is
viewed
as
a
whole
;
or
.
16
g.
Unreasonable,
arbitrary
,
or
capricious
or
characterized
17
by
an
abuse
of
discretion
or
a
clearly
unwarranted
exercise
of
18
discretion.
19
3.
An
aggrieved
or
adversely
affected
party
to
the
judicial
20
review
proceeding
may
obtain
a
review
of
any
final
judgment
of
21
the
district
court
by
appeal
to
the
supreme
court.
The
appeal
22
shall
be
taken
as
in
other
civil
cases,
although
the
appeal
may
23
be
taken
regardless
of
the
amount
involved.
24
4.
For
purposes
of
this
section
,
unless
the
context
25
otherwise
requires,
“rejecting
party”
“teacher”
shall
include,
26
but
not
be
limited
to,
an
instructor
employed
by
a
community
27
college.
28
Sec.
35.
Section
279.19,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
29
follows:
30
279.19
Probationary
period.
31
1.
The
first
three
consecutive
years
of
employment
of
32
a
teacher
in
the
same
school
district
are
a
probationary
33
period.
However,
if
the
teacher
has
successfully
completed
a
34
probationary
period
of
employment
for
another
school
district
35
-25-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
25/
68
H.F.
_____
located
in
Iowa,
the
probationary
period
in
the
current
1
district
of
employment
shall
not
exceed
one
year
two
years
.
2
A
board
of
directors
may
waive
the
probationary
period
for
3
any
teacher
who
previously
has
served
a
probationary
period
4
in
another
school
district
and
the
board
may
extend
the
5
probationary
period
for
an
additional
year
with
the
consent
of
6
the
teacher.
7
2.
In
the
case
of
the
termination
of
a
probationary
8
teacher’s
contract,
the
contract
may
be
terminated
by
the
board
9
of
directors
effective
at
the
end
of
a
school
year
without
10
cause.
The
superintendent
or
the
superintendent’s
designee
11
shall
notify
the
teacher
not
later
than
April
30
that
the
12
board
has
voted
to
terminate
the
contract
effective
at
the
13
end
of
the
school
year.
The
notice
shall
be
in
writing
by
14
letter,
personally
delivered,
or
mailed
by
certified
mail.
The
15
notification
shall
be
complete
when
received
by
the
teacher.
16
Within
ten
days
after
receiving
the
notice,
the
teacher
may
17
request
a
private
conference
with
the
school
board
to
discuss
18
the
reasons
for
termination.
The
provisions
of
sections
279.15
19
and
279.16
shall
not
apply
to
such
a
termination
.
However,
20
if
the
probationary
teacher
is
a
beginning
teacher
who
fails
21
to
demonstrate
competence
in
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
in
22
accordance
with
chapter
284
,
the
provisions
of
sections
279.17
23
and
279.18
shall
also
apply.
24
3.
The
board’s
decision
shall
be
final
and
binding
unless
25
the
termination
was
based
upon
an
alleged
violation
of
a
26
constitutionally
guaranteed
right
of
the
teacher
or
an
alleged
27
violation
of
public
employee
rights
of
the
teacher
under
28
section
20.10
.
29
Notwithstanding
any
provision
to
the
contrary,
the
30
grievance
procedures
of
section
20.18
relating
to
job
31
performance
or
job
retention
shall
not
apply
to
a
teacher
32
during
the
first
two
years
of
the
teacher’s
probationary
33
period.
However,
this
paragraph
shall
not
apply
to
a
teacher
34
who
has
successfully
completed
a
probationary
period
in
a
35
-26-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
26/
68
H.F.
_____
school
district
in
Iowa.
1
Sec.
36.
Section
279.19A,
subsections
1,
2,
7,
and
8,
Code
2
2017,
are
amended
to
read
as
follows:
3
1.
School
districts
employing
individuals
to
coach
4
interscholastic
athletic
sports
shall
issue
a
separate
5
extracurricular
contract
for
each
of
these
sports.
An
6
extracurricular
contract
offered
under
this
section
shall
be
7
separate
from
the
contract
issued
under
section
279.13
.
Wages
8
for
employees
who
coach
these
sports
shall
be
paid
pursuant
9
to
established
or
negotiated
supplemental
pay
schedules.
10
An
extracurricular
contract
shall
be
in
writing,
and
shall
11
state
the
number
of
contract
days
for
that
sport,
the
annual
12
compensation
to
be
paid,
and
any
other
matters
as
may
be
13
mutually
agreed
upon.
The
contract
shall
be
for
a
single
14
school
year.
15
2.
a.
An
extracurricular
contract
shall
be
continued
16
automatically
in
force
and
effect
for
equivalent
periods,
17
except
as
modified
or
terminated
by
mutual
agreement
of
18
the
board
of
directors
and
the
employee,
or
terminated
in
19
accordance
with
this
section
.
An
extracurricular
contract
20
shall
initially
be
offered
by
the
employing
board
to
an
21
individual
on
the
same
date
that
contracts
are
offered
to
22
teachers
under
section
279.13
.
An
extracurricular
contract
23
may
be
terminated
at
the
end
of
a
school
year
pursuant
to
24
sections
279.15
through
279.19
.
If
the
school
district
offers
25
an
extracurricular
contract
for
a
sport
for
the
subsequent
26
school
year
to
an
employee
who
is
currently
performing
27
under
an
extracurricular
contract
for
that
sport,
and
the
28
employee
does
not
wish
to
accept
the
extracurricular
contract
29
for
the
subsequent
year,
the
employee
may
resign
from
the
30
extracurricular
contract
within
twenty-one
days
after
it
has
31
been
received.
32
b.
Section
279.13,
subsection
3
,
applies
to
this
section
.
33
If
the
provisions
of
an
extracurricular
contract
executed
34
under
this
section
conflict
with
a
collective
bargaining
35
-27-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
27/
68
H.F.
_____
agreement
negotiated
under
chapter
20
and
effective
when
the
1
extracurricular
contract
is
executed
or
renewed,
the
provisions
2
of
the
collective
bargaining
agreement
shall
prevail.
3
7.
An
extracurricular
contract
may
be
terminated
prior
to
4
the
expiration
of
that
contract
pursuant
to
section
279.27
for
5
any
lawful
reason
following
an
informal,
private
hearing
before
6
the
board
of
directors
.
The
decision
of
the
board
to
terminate
7
an
extracurricular
contract
shall
be
final.
8
8.
a.
A
termination
proceeding
of
regarding
an
9
extracurricular
contract
either
by
the
board
pursuant
to
10
subsection
2
or
pursuant
to
section
279.27
does
shall
not
11
affect
a
contract
issued
pursuant
to
section
279.13
.
12
b.
A
termination
of
a
contract
entered
into
pursuant
to
13
section
279.13
,
or
a
resignation
from
that
contract
by
the
14
teacher,
constitutes
an
automatic
termination
or
resignation
of
15
the
extracurricular
contract
in
effect
between
the
same
teacher
16
and
the
employing
school
board.
17
Sec.
37.
Section
279.23,
subsection
1,
paragraph
c,
Code
18
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
19
c.
The
rate
of
compensation
per
week
of
five
consecutive
20
days
or
month
of
four
consecutive
weeks
.
21
Sec.
38.
Section
279.23,
subsection
5,
Code
2017,
is
amended
22
to
read
as
follows:
23
5.
Notwithstanding
the
other
provisions
of
this
section
,
24
a
temporary
contract
may
be
issued
to
an
administrator
for
25
up
to
nine
months.
Notwithstanding
the
other
provisions
of
26
this
section,
a
temporary
contract
may
also
be
issued
to
27
an
administrator
to
fill
a
vacancy
created
by
a
leave
of
28
absence
in
accordance
with
the
provisions
of
section
29A.28
,
29
which
contract
shall
automatically
terminate
upon
return
from
30
military
leave
of
the
former
incumbent
of
the
administrator
31
position
and
which
contract
.
Temporary
contracts
shall
not
be
32
subject
to
the
provisions
of
sections
279.24
and
279.25
.
33
Sec.
39.
Section
279.24,
subsections
2
and
4,
Code
2017,
are
34
amended
to
read
as
follows:
35
-28-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
28/
68
H.F.
_____
2.
If
the
board
of
directors
is
considering
termination
of
1
an
administrator’s
contract,
prior
to
any
formal
action,
the
2
board
may
arrange
to
meet
in
closed
session,
in
accordance
with
3
the
provisions
of
section
21.5
,
with
the
administrator
and
the
4
administrator’s
representative.
The
board
shall
review
the
5
administrator’s
evaluation,
review
the
reasons
for
nonrenewal,
6
and
give
the
administrator
an
opportunity
to
respond.
If,
7
following
the
closed
session,
the
board
of
directors
and
the
8
administrator
are
unable
to
mutually
agree
to
a
modification
or
9
termination
of
the
administrator’s
contract,
or
the
board
of
10
directors
and
the
administrator
are
unable
to
mutually
agree
11
to
enter
into
may
issue
a
one-year
nonrenewable
contract
,
12
to
the
administrator.
If
the
board
of
directors
decides
to
13
terminate
the
administrator’s
contract,
the
board
shall
follow
14
the
procedures
in
this
section
.
15
4.
Administrators
employed
in
a
school
district
for
16
less
than
two
three
consecutive
years
are
probationary
17
administrators.
However,
a
school
board
may
waive
the
18
probationary
period
for
any
administrator
who
has
previously
19
served
a
probationary
period
in
another
school
district
and
20
the
school
board
may
extend
the
probationary
period
for
an
21
additional
year
with
the
consent
of
the
administrator.
If
a
22
school
board
determines
that
it
should
terminate
a
probationary
23
administrator’s
contract,
the
school
board
shall
notify
the
24
administrator
not
later
than
May
15
that
the
contract
will
not
25
be
renewed
beyond
the
current
year.
The
notice
shall
be
in
26
writing
by
letter,
personally
delivered,
or
mailed
by
certified
27
mail.
The
notification
shall
be
complete
when
received
by
the
28
administrator.
Within
ten
days
after
receiving
the
notice,
the
29
administrator
may
request
a
private
conference
with
the
school
30
board
to
discuss
the
reasons
for
termination.
The
school
31
board’s
decision
to
terminate
a
probationary
administrator’s
32
contract
shall
be
final
unless
the
termination
was
based
upon
33
an
alleged
violation
of
a
constitutionally
guaranteed
right
of
34
the
administrator.
35
-29-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
29/
68
H.F.
_____
Sec.
40.
Section
279.24,
subsection
5,
paragraphs
c,
d,
e,
1
f,
g,
and
h,
Code
2017,
are
amended
to
read
as
follows:
2
c.
Within
five
days
after
receipt
of
the
written
notice
3
that
the
school
board
has
voted
to
consider
termination
of
4
the
contract,
the
administrator
may
request
a
private
hearing
5
in
writing
to
the
secretary
of
the
school
board
that
.
The
6
board
shall
then
forward
the
notification
be
forwarded
to
7
the
board
of
educational
examiners
along
with
a
request
that
8
the
board
of
educational
examiners
submit
a
list
of
five
9
qualified
administrative
law
judges
to
the
parties.
Within
10
three
days
from
receipt
of
the
list
the
parties
shall
select
an
11
administrative
law
judge
by
alternately
removing
a
name
from
12
the
list
until
only
one
name
remains.
The
person
whose
name
13
remains
shall
be
the
administrative
law
judge.
The
parties
14
shall
determine
by
lot
which
party
shall
remove
the
first
15
name
from
the
list.
The
private
hearing
shall
be
held
no
16
sooner
than
ten
twenty
days
and
not
later
than
thirty
forty
17
days
following
the
administrator’s
request
unless
the
parties
18
otherwise
agree.
If
the
administrator
does
not
request
a
19
private
hearing,
the
school
board,
not
later
than
May
31,
may
20
determine
the
continuance
or
discontinuance
of
the
contract
21
and,
if
the
board
determines
to
continue
the
administrator’s
22
contract,
whether
to
suspend
the
administrator
with
or
without
23
pay
for
a
period
specified
by
the
board.
School
board
action
24
shall
be
by
majority
roll
call
vote
entered
on
the
minutes
of
25
the
meeting.
Notice
of
school
board
action
shall
be
personally
26
delivered
or
mailed
to
the
administrator.
27
d.
The
administrative
law
judge
selected
shall
notify
28
the
secretary
of
the
school
board
and
the
administrator
in
29
writing
concerning
the
date,
time,
and
location
of
the
private
30
hearing.
The
school
board
may
be
represented
by
a
legal
31
representative,
if
any,
and
the
administrator
shall
appear
and
32
may
be
represented
by
counsel
or
by
representative,
if
any.
33
Any
witnesses
for
the
parties
at
the
private
hearing
shall
be
34
sequestered.
A
transcript
or
recording
shall
be
made
of
the
35
-30-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
30/
68
H.F.
_____
proceedings
at
the
private
hearing.
A
school
board
member
or
1
administrator
is
not
liable
for
any
damage
to
an
administrator
2
or
school
board
member
if
a
statement
made
at
the
private
3
hearing
is
determined
to
be
erroneous
as
long
as
the
statement
4
was
made
in
good
faith.
5
e.
The
administrative
law
judge
shall,
within
ten
days
6
following
the
date
of
the
private
hearing,
make
a
proposed
7
decision
as
to
whether
or
not
the
administrator
should
be
8
dismissed,
and
shall
give
a
copy
of
the
proposed
decision
to
9
the
administrator
and
the
school
board.
Findings
of
fact
shall
10
be
prepared
by
the
administrative
law
judge.
The
proposed
11
decision
of
the
administrative
law
judge
shall
become
the
final
12
decision
of
the
school
board
unless
within
ten
thirty
days
13
after
the
filing
of
the
decision
the
administrator
files
a
14
written
notice
of
appeal
with
the
school
board,
or
the
school
15
board
on
its
own
motion
determines
to
review
the
decision.
16
f.
If
the
administrator
appeals
to
the
school
board,
or
if
17
the
school
board
determines
on
its
own
motion
to
review
the
18
proposed
decision
of
the
administrative
law
judge,
a
private
19
hearing
shall
be
held
before
the
school
board
within
five
ten
20
days
after
the
petition
for
review,
or
motion
for
review,
has
21
been
made
or
at
such
other
time
as
the
parties
agree.
The
22
private
hearing
is
not
subject
to
chapter
21
.
The
school
board
23
may
hear
the
case
de
novo
upon
the
record
as
submitted
before
24
the
administrative
law
judge.
In
cases
where
there
is
an
25
appeal
from
a
proposed
decision
or
where
a
proposed
decision
26
is
reviewed
on
motion
of
the
school
board,
an
opportunity
27
shall
be
afforded
to
each
party
to
file
exceptions,
present
28
briefs,
and
present
oral
arguments
to
the
school
board
which
29
is
to
render
the
final
decision.
The
secretary
of
the
school
30
board
shall
give
the
administrator
written
notice
of
the
time,
31
place,
and
date
of
the
private
hearing.
The
school
board
shall
32
meet
within
five
days
after
the
private
hearing
to
determine
33
the
question
of
continuance
or
discontinuance
of
the
contract
34
and,
if
the
board
determines
to
continue
the
administrator’s
35
-31-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
31/
68
H.F.
_____
contract,
whether
to
suspend
the
administrator
with
or
1
without
pay
for
a
period
specified
by
the
board
or
issue
the
2
administrator
a
one-year,
nonrenewable
contract
.
The
school
3
board
shall
make
findings
of
fact
which
shall
be
based
solely
4
on
the
evidence
in
the
record
and
on
matters
officially
noticed
5
in
the
record.
6
g.
The
decision
of
the
school
board
shall
be
in
writing
7
and
shall
include
findings
of
fact
and
conclusions
of
law,
8
separately
stated
.
Findings
of
fact,
if
set
forth
in
statutory
9
language,
shall
be
accompanied
by
a
concise
and
explicit
10
statement
of
the
underlying
facts
supporting
the
findings.
11
Each
conclusion
of
law
shall
be
supported
by
cited
authority
12
or
by
reasoned
opinion.
13
h.
When
the
school
board
has
reached
a
decision,
opinion,
14
or
conclusion,
it
shall
convene
in
open
meeting
and
by
roll
15
call
vote
determine
the
continuance
or
discontinuance
of
16
the
administrator’s
contract
and,
if
the
board
votes
to
17
continue
the
administrator’s
contract,
whether
to
suspend
the
18
administrator
with
or
without
pay
for
a
period
specified
by
19
the
board
or
issue
the
administrator
a
one-year,
nonrenewable
20
contract
.
The
record
of
the
private
conference
hearing
21
and
findings
of
fact
and
exceptions
written
decision
of
the
22
board
shall
be
exempt
from
the
provisions
of
chapter
22
.
The
23
secretary
of
the
school
board
shall
immediately
personally
24
deliver
or
mail
notice
of
the
school
board’s
action
to
the
25
administrator.
26
Sec.
41.
Section
279.27,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
27
follows:
28
279.27
Discharge
of
teacher.
29
1.
A
teacher
may
be
discharged
at
any
time
during
the
30
contract
year
for
just
cause.
The
superintendent
or
the
31
superintendent’s
designee,
shall
notify
the
teacher
immediately
32
that
the
superintendent
will
recommend
in
writing
to
the
board
33
at
a
regular
or
special
meeting
of
the
board
held
not
more
34
than
fifteen
days
after
notification
has
been
given
to
the
35
-32-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
32/
68
H.F.
_____
teacher
that
the
teacher’s
continuing
contract
be
terminated
1
effective
immediately
following
a
decision
of
the
board.
The
2
procedure
for
dismissal
shall
be
as
provided
in
section
279.15,
3
subsection
2
,
and
sections
279.16
to
through
279.19
.
The
4
superintendent
may
suspend
a
teacher
under
this
section
pending
5
hearing
and
determination
by
the
board.
6
2.
For
purposes
of
this
section,
“just
cause”
includes
7
but
is
not
limited
to
a
violation
of
the
code
of
professional
8
conduct
and
ethics
of
the
board
of
educational
examiners
if
9
the
board
has
taken
disciplinary
action
against
a
teacher,
10
during
the
six
months
following
issuance
by
the
board
of
a
11
final
written
decision
and
finding
of
fact
after
a
disciplinary
12
proceeding.
13
Sec.
42.
Section
284.3,
subsection
2,
Code
2017,
is
amended
14
to
read
as
follows:
15
2.
A
school
board
shall
provide
for
the
following:
16
a.
For
purposes
of
comprehensive
evaluations,
standards
17
and
criteria
which
measure
a
beginning
teacher’s
performance
18
against
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
specified
in
subsection
1
,
19
and
the
criteria
for
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
developed
by
20
the
department
in
accordance
with
section
256.9,
to
determine
21
whether
the
teacher’s
practice
meets
the
requirements
specified
22
for
a
career
teacher.
These
standards
and
criteria
shall
be
23
set
forth
in
an
instrument
provided
by
the
department.
The
24
comprehensive
evaluation
and
instrument
are
not
subject
to
25
negotiations
or
grievance
procedures
pursuant
to
chapter
20
or
26
determinations
made
by
the
board
of
directors
under
section
27
279.14
.
A
local
school
board
and
its
certified
bargaining
28
representative
may
negotiate,
pursuant
to
chapter
20
,
29
evaluation
and
grievance
procedures
for
beginning
teachers
that
30
are
not
in
conflict
with
this
chapter
.
If,
in
accordance
with
31
section
279.19
,
a
beginning
teacher
appeals
the
determination
32
of
a
school
board
to
an
adjudicator
under
section
279.17
,
the
33
adjudicator
selected
shall
have
successfully
completed
training
34
related
to
the
Iowa
teacher
standards,
the
criteria
adopted
35
-33-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
33/
68
H.F.
_____
by
the
state
board
in
accordance
with
subsection
3
,
and
any
1
additional
training
required
under
rules
adopted
by
the
public
2
employment
relations
board
in
cooperation
with
the
state
board.
3
b.
For
purposes
of
performance
reviews
for
teachers
other
4
than
beginning
teachers,
evaluations
that
contain,
at
a
5
minimum,
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
specified
in
subsection
6
1
,
as
well
as
the
criteria
for
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
7
developed
by
the
department
in
accordance
with
section
8
256.9,
subsection
42
.
A
local
school
board
and
its
certified
9
bargaining
representative
may
negotiate,
pursuant
to
chapter
10
20
,
additional
teaching
standards
and
criteria.
A
local
11
school
board
and
its
certified
bargaining
representative
shall
12
negotiate,
pursuant
to
chapter
20
,
evaluation
and
grievance
13
procedures
for
teachers
other
than
beginning
teachers
that
are
14
not
in
conflict
with
this
chapter
.
15
Sec.
43.
Section
284.4,
subsection
1,
paragraph
c,
16
subparagraphs
(2)
and
(5),
Code
2017,
are
amended
to
read
as
17
follows:
18
(2)
Monitor
the
evaluation
requirements
of
this
chapter
19
to
ensure
evaluations
are
conducted
in
a
fair
and
consistent
20
manner
throughout
the
school
district
or
agency.
In
addition
21
to
any
negotiated
evaluation
procedures,
The
committee
shall
22
develop
model
evidence
for
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
and
23
criteria.
The
model
evidence
will
minimize
paperwork
and
focus
24
on
teacher
improvement.
The
model
evidence
will
determine
25
which
standards
and
criteria
can
be
met
with
observation
and
26
which
evidence
meets
multiple
standards
and
criteria.
27
(5)
Ensure
the
agreement
negotiated
pursuant
to
chapter
28
20
determines
Determine
the
compensation
for
teachers
on
the
29
committee
for
work
responsibilities
required
beyond
the
normal
30
work
day.
31
Sec.
44.
Section
284.8,
subsections
2
and
4,
Code
2017,
are
32
amended
to
read
as
follows:
33
2.
If
a
supervisor
or
an
evaluator
determines,
at
any
time,
34
as
a
result
of
a
teacher’s
performance
that
the
teacher
is
not
35
-34-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
34/
68
H.F.
_____
meeting
district
expectations
under
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
1
specified
in
section
284.3,
subsection
1
,
paragraphs
“a”
2
through
“h”
,
and
the
criteria
for
the
Iowa
teaching
standards
3
developed
by
the
department
in
accordance
with
section
256.9,
4
subsection
42
,
and
any
other
standards
or
criteria
established
5
in
the
collective
bargaining
agreement,
the
evaluator
shall,
6
at
the
direction
of
the
teacher’s
supervisor,
recommend
to
7
the
district
that
the
teacher
participate
in
an
intensive
8
assistance
program.
The
intensive
assistance
program
and
its
9
implementation
are
not
subject
to
negotiation
and
grievance
10
procedures
established
pursuant
to
chapter
20
.
All
school
11
districts
shall
be
prepared
to
offer
an
intensive
assistance
12
program.
13
4.
A
teacher
who
is
not
meeting
the
applicable
standards
and
14
criteria
based
on
a
determination
made
pursuant
to
subsection
2
15
shall
participate
in
an
intensive
assistance
program.
However,
16
a
teacher
who
has
previously
participated
in
an
intensive
17
assistance
program
relating
to
particular
Iowa
teaching
18
standards
or
criteria
shall
not
be
entitled
to
participate
19
in
another
intensive
assistance
program
relating
to
the
same
20
standards
or
criteria
and
shall
be
subject
to
the
provisions
of
21
subsection
5.
22
Sec.
45.
Section
284.8,
subsection
3,
Code
2017,
is
amended
23
by
striking
the
subsection.
24
Sec.
46.
Section
284.8,
Code
2017,
is
amended
by
adding
the
25
following
new
subsection:
26
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
5.
Following
a
teacher’s
participation
27
in
an
intensive
assistance
program,
the
teacher
shall
be
28
reevaluated
to
determine
whether
the
teacher
successfully
29
completed
the
intensive
assistance
program
and
is
meeting
30
district
expectations
under
the
applicable
Iowa
teaching
31
standards
or
criteria.
If
the
teacher
did
not
successfully
32
complete
the
intensive
assistance
program
or
continues
not
to
33
meet
the
applicable
Iowa
teaching
standards
or
criteria,
the
34
board
may
do
any
of
the
following:
35
-35-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
35/
68
H.F.
_____
a.
Terminate
the
teacher’s
contract
immediately
pursuant
to
1
section
279.27.
2
b.
Terminate
the
teacher’s
contract
at
the
end
of
the
school
3
year
pursuant
to
section
279.15.
4
c.
Continue
the
teacher’s
contract
for
a
period
not
to
5
exceed
one
year.
However,
the
contract
shall
not
be
renewed
6
and
shall
not
be
subject
to
section
279.15.
7
Sec.
47.
REPEAL.
Section
279.17,
Code
2017,
is
repealed.
8
Sec.
48.
EFFECTIVE
UPON
ENACTMENT.
This
division
of
this
9
Act,
being
deemed
of
immediate
importance,
takes
effect
upon
10
enactment.
11
Sec.
49.
APPLICABILITY.
This
division
of
this
Act
applies
12
to
employment
contracts
of
school
employees
entered
into
13
pursuant
to
chapter
279
on
and
after
the
effective
date
of
this
14
division
of
this
Act.
This
division
of
this
Act
does
not
apply
15
to
collective
bargaining
agreements
pursuant
to
chapter
20
16
which
have
been
ratified
in
a
ratification
election
referred
17
to
in
section
20.17,
subsection
4,
for
which
an
arbitrator
18
has
made
a
final
determination
as
described
in
section
20.22,
19
subsection
11,
or
which
have
become
effective,
where
such
20
events
occurred
before
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
21
this
Act.
This
division
of
this
Act
applies
to
all
collective
22
bargaining
procedures
provided
for
in
chapter
20
occurring
on
23
and
after
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
this
Act
and
24
collective
bargaining
agreements
pursuant
to
chapter
20
for
25
which
a
ratification
election
referred
to
in
section
20.17,
26
subsection
4,
is
held,
for
which
an
arbitrator
makes
a
final
27
determination
as
described
in
section
20.22,
subsection
11,
28
or
which,
unless
otherwise
provided
in
this
section,
become
29
effective
on
or
after
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
30
this
Act.
31
DIVISION
III
32
PERSONNEL
RECORDS
AND
SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENTS
33
Sec.
50.
Section
22.7,
subsection
11,
paragraph
a,
34
subparagraph
(5),
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
35
-36-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
36/
68
H.F.
_____
(5)
The
fact
that
the
individual
resigned
in
lieu
of
1
termination,
was
discharged
,
or
was
demoted
as
the
result
2
of
a
final
disciplinary
action
upon
the
exhaustion
of
all
3
applicable
contractual,
legal,
and
statutory
remedies
,
and
the
4
documented
reasons
and
rationale
for
the
resignation
in
lieu
5
of
termination,
the
discharge,
or
the
demotion
.
For
purposes
6
of
this
subparagraph,
“demoted”
and
“demotion”
mean
a
change
7
of
an
employee
from
a
position
in
a
given
classification
to
a
8
position
in
a
classification
having
a
lower
pay
grade.
9
Sec.
51.
NEW
SECTION
.
22.13A
Personnel
settlement
10
agreements
——
state
employees
——
confidentiality
——
disclosure.
11
1.
For
purposes
of
this
section:
12
a.
“Personnel
settlement
agreement”
means
a
binding
legal
13
agreement
between
a
state
employee
and
the
state
employee’s
14
employer,
subject
to
section
22.13,
to
resolve
a
personnel
15
dispute
including
but
not
limited
to
a
grievance.
“Personnel
16
settlement
agreement”
does
not
include
an
initial
decision
by
17
a
state
employee’s
employer
concerning
a
personnel
dispute
or
18
grievance.
19
b.
“State
employee”
means
an
employee
of
the
state
who
is
20
an
employee
of
the
executive
branch
as
described
in
sections
21
7E.2
and
7E.5.
22
2.
Personnel
settlement
agreements
shall
not
contain
any
23
confidentiality
or
nondisclosure
provision
that
attempts
to
24
prevent
the
disclosure
of
the
personnel
settlement
agreement.
25
In
addition,
any
confidentiality
or
nondisclosure
provision
in
26
a
personnel
settlement
agreement
is
void
and
unenforceable.
27
3.
The
requirements
of
this
section
shall
not
be
superseded
28
by
any
provision
of
a
collective
bargaining
agreement.
29
4.
All
personnel
settlement
agreements
shall
be
made
easily
30
accessible
to
the
public
on
an
internet
site
maintained
as
31
follows:
32
a.
For
personnel
settlement
agreements
with
an
employee
of
33
the
executive
branch,
excluding
an
employee
of
the
state
board
34
of
regents
or
institution
under
the
control
of
the
state
board
35
-37-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
37/
68
H.F.
_____
of
regents,
by
the
department
of
administrative
services.
1
b.
For
personnel
settlement
agreements
with
an
employee
of
2
the
state
board
of
regents
or
institution
under
the
control
of
3
the
state
board
of
regents,
by
the
state
board
of
regents.
4
5.
a.
A
state
agency
shall
not
enter
into
a
personnel
5
settlement
agreement
with
a
state
employee
on
behalf
of
the
6
state
unless
the
personnel
settlement
agreement
is
first
7
reviewed
by
the
attorney
general
or
the
attorney
general’s
8
designee.
Additionally,
a
state
agency
shall
not
enter
into
a
9
personnel
settlement
agreement
with
a
state
employee
on
behalf
10
of
the
state
unless
the
agreement
has
been
approved
in
writing
11
by
the
following
individuals:
12
(1)
For
a
state
agency
other
than
an
institution
governed
13
by
the
board
of
regents,
the
director
of
the
department
of
14
management,
the
director
of
the
department
of
administrative
15
services,
and
the
head
of
the
state
agency.
16
(2)
For
an
institution
governed
by
the
board
of
regents,
the
17
executive
director
of
the
board
of
regents
and
the
head
of
the
18
institution.
19
b.
If
subparagraph
(1)
or
(2)
is
not
consistent
with
the
20
provision
of
a
collective
bargaining
agreement,
a
state
agency
21
shall
provide
the
individuals
referenced
in
this
subsection,
22
as
applicable,
with
regular
reports
regarding
any
personnel
23
settlement
agreements
entered
into
with
state
employees
by
the
24
state
agency.
25
Sec.
52.
NEW
SECTION
.
22.15
Personnel
records
——
discipline
26
——
employee
notification.
27
A
government
body
that
takes
disciplinary
action
against
an
28
employee
that
may
result
in
information
described
in
section
29
22.7,
subsection
11,
paragraph
“a”
,
subparagraph
(5),
being
30
placed
in
the
employee’s
personnel
record,
prior
to
taking
such
31
disciplinary
action,
shall
notify
the
employee
in
writing
that
32
the
information
placed
in
the
employee’s
personnel
file
as
a
33
result
of
the
disciplinary
action
may
become
a
public
record.
34
Sec.
53.
EFFECTIVE
UPON
ENACTMENT.
This
division
of
this
35
-38-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
38/
68
H.F.
_____
Act,
being
deemed
of
immediate
importance,
takes
effect
upon
1
enactment.
2
Sec.
54.
APPLICABILITY.
The
section
of
this
division
of
3
this
Act
amending
section
22.7,
subsection
11,
applies
to
all
4
information
described
in
section
22.7,
subsection
11,
paragraph
5
“a”,
subparagraph
(5),
as
amended
by
this
division
of
this
Act,
6
relating
to
information
placed
in
an
individual’s
personnel
7
records
on
or
after
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
this
8
Act.
9
DIVISION
IV
10
CITY
CIVIL
SERVICE
REQUIREMENTS
11
Sec.
55.
Section
400.12,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
12
follows:
13
400.12
Seniority.
14
1.
For
the
purpose
of
determining
the
seniority
rights
15
of
civil
service
employees
employed
or
appointed
as
fire
16
fighters
or
police
officers,
fire
chiefs
or
police
chiefs,
or
17
assistant
fire
chiefs
or
assistant
police
chiefs
,
seniority
18
shall
be
computed,
beginning
with
the
date
of
appointment
to
19
or
employment
in
any
positions
for
which
they
were
certified
20
or
otherwise
qualified
and
established
as
provided
in
this
21
chapter
,
but
shall
not
include
any
period
of
time
exceeding
22
sixty
days
in
any
one
year
during
which
they
were
absent
from
23
the
service
except
for
disability.
24
2.
In
the
event
that
a
civil
service
employee
employed
25
or
appointed
as
a
fire
fighter
or
police
officer,
fire
chief
26
or
police
chief,
or
assistant
fire
chief
or
assistant
police
27
chief
has
more
than
one
classification
or
grade,
the
length
of
28
the
employee’s
seniority
rights
shall
date
in
the
respective
29
classifications
or
grades
from
and
after
the
time
the
employee
30
was
appointed
to
or
began
employment
in
each
classification
or
31
grade.
In
the
event
that
an
employee
has
been
promoted
from
32
one
classification
or
grade
to
another,
the
employee’s
civil
33
service
seniority
rights
shall
be
continuous
in
any
department
34
grade
or
classification
that
the
employee
formerly
held.
35
-39-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
39/
68
H.F.
_____
3.
A
list
of
all
civil
service
employees
employed
or
1
appointed
as
fire
fighters
or
police
officers,
fire
chiefs
or
2
police
chiefs,
or
assistant
fire
chiefs
or
assistant
police
3
chiefs
shall
be
prepared
and
posted
in
the
city
hall
by
the
4
civil
service
commission
on
or
before
July
1
of
each
year,
5
indicating
the
civil
service
standing
of
each
employee
as
to
6
the
employee’s
seniority.
7
4.
Seniority
rights
under
this
section
shall
not
be
8
applicable
to
a
civil
service
employee
unless
the
employee
is
9
employed
or
appointed
as
a
fire
fighter
or
police
officer,
fire
10
chief
or
police
chief,
or
assistant
fire
chief
or
assistant
11
police
chief.
Seniority
rights
under
this
section
shall
only
12
accrue
during
employment
or
appointment
as
a
fire
fighter
or
13
police
officer,
fire
chief
or
police
chief,
or
assistant
fire
14
chief
or
assistant
police
chief.
15
Sec.
56.
Section
400.17,
subsection
4,
Code
2017,
is
amended
16
to
read
as
follows:
17
4.
A
person
shall
not
be
appointed,
denied
appointment,
18
promoted,
removed,
discharged,
suspended,
or
demoted
to
or
19
from
a
civil
service
position
or
in
any
other
way
favored
or
20
discriminated
against
in
that
position
because
of
political
21
or
religious
opinions
or
affiliations,
race,
national
origin,
22
sex,
or
age,
or
in
retaliation
for
the
exercise
of
any
right
23
enumerated
in
this
chapter
.
However,
the
maximum
age
for
a
24
police
officer
or
fire
fighter
covered
by
this
chapter
and
25
employed
for
police
duty
or
the
duty
of
fighting
fires
is
26
sixty-five
years
of
age.
27
Sec.
57.
Section
400.18,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
28
follows:
29
400.18
Removal,
discharge,
demotion,
or
suspension.
30
1.
A
person
holding
civil
service
rights
as
provided
in
this
31
chapter
shall
not
be
removed,
discharged,
demoted,
or
suspended
32
arbitrarily,
except
as
otherwise
provided
in
this
chapter
,
33
but
may
be
removed,
discharged,
demoted,
or
suspended
after
a
34
hearing
by
a
majority
vote
of
the
civil
service
commission,
35
-40-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
40/
68
H.F.
_____
for
neglect
of
duty,
disobedience,
misconduct,
or
failure
1
to
properly
perform
the
person’s
duties
due
to
any
act
or
2
failure
to
act
by
the
employee
that
is
in
contravention
of
3
law,
city
policies,
or
standard
operating
procedures,
or
that
4
in
the
judgment
of
the
person
having
the
appointing
power
as
5
provided
in
this
chapter,
or
the
chief
of
police
or
chief
of
6
the
fire
department,
is
sufficient
to
show
that
the
employee
is
7
unsuitable
or
unfit
for
employment
.
8
2.
An
employee
who
is
removed,
discharged,
demoted,
or
9
suspended
may
request
a
hearing
before
the
civil
service
10
commission
to
review
the
appointing
authority’s,
police
11
chief’s,
or
fire
chief’s
decision
to
remove,
discharge,
demote,
12
or
suspend
the
employee.
13
2.
3.
The
party
alleging
neglect
of
duty,
disobedience,
14
misconduct,
or
failure
to
properly
perform
a
duty
city
shall
15
have
the
burden
of
proof
to
prove
that
the
act
or
failure
to
act
16
by
the
employee
was
in
contravention
of
law,
city
policies,
or
17
standard
operating
procedures,
or
is
sufficient
to
show
that
18
the
employee
is
unsuitable
or
unfit
for
employment
.
19
3.
4.
A
person
subject
to
a
hearing
has
the
right
to
20
be
represented
by
counsel
at
the
person’s
expense
or
by
the
21
person’s
authorized
collective
bargaining
representative.
22
5.
A
collective
bargaining
agreement
to
which
a
bargaining
23
unit
that
has
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
safety
24
employees
as
defined
in
section
20.3
is
a
party
shall
provide
25
additional
procedures
not
inconsistent
with
this
section
for
26
the
implementation
of
this
section.
27
Sec.
58.
Section
400.19,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
28
follows:
29
400.19
Removal
,
or
discharge
,
demotion,
or
suspension
of
30
subordinates.
31
The
person
having
the
appointing
power
as
provided
in
32
this
chapter
,
or
the
chief
of
police
or
chief
of
the
fire
33
department,
may
,
upon
presentation
of
grounds
for
such
action
34
to
the
subordinate
in
writing,
peremptorily
remove,
discharge,
35
-41-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
41/
68
H.F.
_____
demote,
or
suspend
,
demote,
or
discharge
a
subordinate
then
1
under
the
person’s
or
chief’s
direction
for
neglect
of
duty,
2
disobedience
of
orders,
misconduct,
or
failure
to
properly
3
perform
the
subordinate’s
duties
due
to
any
act
or
failure
4
to
act
by
the
employee
that
is
in
contravention
of
law,
city
5
policies,
or
standard
operating
procedures,
or
that
in
the
6
judgment
of
the
person
or
chief
is
sufficient
to
show
that
the
7
employee
is
unsuitable
or
unfit
for
employment
.
8
Sec.
59.
Section
400.20,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
9
follows:
10
400.20
Appeal.
11
The
suspension
removal
,
discharge,
demotion,
or
discharge
12
suspension
of
a
person
holding
civil
service
rights
may
be
13
appealed
to
the
civil
service
commission
within
fourteen
14
calendar
days
after
the
suspension
removal
,
discharge,
15
demotion,
or
discharge
suspension
.
16
Sec.
60.
Section
400.21,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
17
follows:
18
400.21
Notice
of
appeal.
19
If
the
appeal
be
taken
by
the
person
suspended
removed
,
20
discharged,
demoted,
or
discharged
suspended
,
notice
thereof,
21
signed
by
the
appellant
and
specifying
the
ruling
appealed
22
from,
shall
be
filed
with
the
clerk
of
commission;
if
by
the
23
person
making
such
suspension
removal
,
discharge,
demotion,
or
24
discharge
suspension
,
such
notice
shall
also
be
served
upon
the
25
person
suspended
removed
,
discharged,
demoted,
or
discharged
26
suspended
.
27
Sec.
61.
Section
400.22,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
28
follows:
29
400.22
Charges.
30
Within
fourteen
calendar
days
from
the
service
of
the
notice
31
of
appeal,
the
person
or
body
making
the
ruling
appealed
32
from
shall
file
with
the
body
to
which
the
appeal
is
taken
a
33
written
specification
of
the
charges
and
grounds
upon
which
the
34
ruling
was
based.
If
the
charges
are
not
filed,
the
person
35
-42-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
42/
68
H.F.
_____
suspended
or
removed,
discharged
,
demoted,
or
suspended
may
1
present
the
matter
to
the
body
to
whom
the
appeal
is
to
be
2
taken
by
affidavit,
setting
forth
the
facts,
and
the
body
to
3
whom
the
appeal
is
to
be
taken
shall
immediately
enter
an
4
order
reinstating
the
person
suspended
or
removed,
discharged
,
5
demoted,
or
suspended
for
want
of
prosecution.
6
Sec.
62.
Section
400.27,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
7
follows:
8
400.27
Jurisdiction
——
attorney
——
appeal
.
9
1.
The
civil
service
commission
has
jurisdiction
to
hear
10
and
determine
matters
involving
the
rights
of
civil
service
11
employees
under
this
chapter
,
and
may
affirm,
modify,
or
12
reverse
any
case
on
its
merits.
13
2.
The
city
attorney
or
solicitor
shall
be
the
attorney
14
for
the
commission
or
when
requested
by
the
commission
shall
15
present
matters
concerning
civil
service
employees
to
the
16
commission,
except
the
commission
may
hire
a
counselor
or
17
an
attorney
on
a
per
diem
basis
to
represent
it
when
in
the
18
opinion
of
the
commission
there
is
a
conflict
of
interest
19
between
the
commission
and
the
city
council.
The
counselor
or
20
attorney
hired
by
the
commission
shall
not
be
the
city
attorney
21
or
solicitor.
The
city
shall
pay
the
costs
incurred
by
the
22
commission
in
employing
an
attorney
under
this
section
.
23
The
city
or
any
civil
service
employee
shall
have
a
right
to
24
appeal
to
the
district
court
from
the
final
ruling
or
decision
25
of
the
civil
service
commission.
The
appeal
shall
be
taken
26
within
thirty
days
from
the
filing
of
the
formal
decision
of
27
the
commission.
The
district
court
of
the
county
in
which
the
28
city
is
located
shall
have
full
jurisdiction
of
the
appeal
and
29
the
said
appeal
shall
be
a
trial
de
novo
as
an
equitable
action
30
in
the
district
court.
31
The
appeal
to
the
district
court
shall
be
perfected
by
filing
32
a
notice
of
appeal
with
the
clerk
of
the
district
court
within
33
the
time
prescribed
in
this
section
by
serving
notice
of
appeal
34
on
the
clerk
of
the
civil
service
commission,
from
whose
ruling
35
-43-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
43/
68
H.F.
_____
or
decision
the
appeal
is
taken.
1
In
the
event
the
ruling
or
decision
appealed
from
is
reversed
2
by
the
district
court,
the
appellant,
if
it
be
an
employee,
3
shall
then
be
reinstated
as
of
the
date
of
the
said
suspension,
4
demotion,
or
discharge
and
shall
be
entitled
to
compensation
5
from
the
date
of
such
suspension,
demotion,
or
discharge.
6
Sec.
63.
Section
400.28,
Code
2017,
is
amended
to
read
as
7
follows:
8
400.28
Employees
——
number
diminished.
9
1.
When
the
public
interest
requires
A
city
council
may
10
implement
a
diminution
of
employees
in
a
classification
or
11
grade
under
civil
service
,
the
city
council,
acting
in
good
12
faith,
may
do
either
of
the
following:
13
a.
Abolish
the
office
and
remove
the
employee
from
14
the
employee’s
classification
or
grade
thereunder
.
Such
15
a
diminution
shall
be
carried
out
in
accordance
with
any
16
procedures
provided
in
a
collective
bargaining
agreement
to
17
which
a
bargaining
unit
that
has
a
majority
of
members
who
are
18
public
safety
employees
as
defined
in
section
20.3
is
a
party,
19
if
applicable.
20
b.
Reduce
the
number
of
employees
in
any
classification
or
21
grade
by
suspending
the
necessary
number.
22
2.
In
case
it
thus
becomes
necessary
to
so
remove
or
suspend
23
any
such
employees,
the
persons
so
removed
or
suspended
shall
24
be
those
having
seniority
of
the
shortest
duration
in
the
25
classifications
or
grades
affected,
and
such
seniority
shall
be
26
computed
as
provided
in
section
400.12
for
all
persons
holding
27
seniority
in
the
classification
or
grade
affected,
regardless
28
of
their
seniority
in
any
other
classification
or
grade,
but
29
any
such
employee
so
removed
from
any
classification
or
grade
30
shall
revert
to
the
employee’s
seniority
in
the
next
lower
31
grade
or
classification;
if
such
seniority
is
equal,
then
the
32
one
less
efficient
and
competent
as
determined
by
the
person
or
33
body
having
the
appointing
power
shall
be
the
one
affected.
34
3.
In
case
of
removal
or
suspension,
the
civil
service
35
-44-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
44/
68
H.F.
_____
commission
shall
issue
to
each
person
affected
one
certificate
1
showing
the
person’s
comparative
seniority
or
length
of
service
2
in
each
of
the
classifications
or
grades
from
which
the
person
3
is
so
removed
and
the
fact
that
the
person
has
been
honorably
4
removed.
The
certificate
shall
also
list
each
classification
5
or
grade
in
which
the
person
was
previously
employed.
The
6
person’s
name
shall
be
carried
for
a
period
of
not
less
than
7
three
years
after
the
suspension
or
removal
on
a
preferred
list
8
and
appointments
or
promotions
made
during
that
period
to
the
9
person’s
former
duties
in
the
classification
or
grade
shall
10
be
made
in
the
order
of
greater
seniority
from
the
preferred
11
lists.
12
Sec.
64.
Section
411.1,
subsection
14,
Code
2017,
is
amended
13
to
read
as
follows:
14
14.
“Member
in
good
standing”
means
a
member
in
service
who
15
is
not
subject
to
removal
,
discharge,
demotion,
or
suspension
16
by
the
employing
city
of
the
member
pursuant
to
section
400.18
17
or
400.19
,
or
other
comparable
process,
and
who
is
not
the
18
subject
of
an
investigation
that
could
lead
to
such
removal
,
19
discharge,
demotion,
or
suspension
.
Except
as
specifically
20
provided
pursuant
to
section
411.9
,
a
person
who
is
restored
21
to
active
service
for
purposes
of
applying
for
a
pension
under
22
this
chapter
is
not
a
member
in
good
standing.
23
Sec.
65.
SENIORITY
RIGHTS
——
APPLICABILITY.
On
and
after
24
the
effective
date
of
this
division
of
this
Act,
any
seniority
25
rights
of
city
civil
service
employees,
including
but
not
26
limited
to
seniority
accrued,
provided
pursuant
to
section
27
400.12,
Code
2017,
that
are
not
also
provided
pursuant
to
28
section
400.12,
as
amended
by
this
division
of
this
Act,
are
29
extinguished.
30
Sec.
66.
EFFECTIVE
UPON
ENACTMENT.
This
division
of
this
31
Act,
being
deemed
of
immediate
importance,
takes
effect
upon
32
enactment.
33
DIVISION
V
34
HEALTH
INSURANCE
MATTERS
35
-45-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
45/
68
H.F.
_____
Sec.
67.
NEW
SECTION
.
70A.41
Public
employee
health
1
insurance.
2
A
public
employer
shall
offer
health
insurance
to
all
public
3
employees
employed
by
the
public
employer.
All
costs
of
such
4
health
insurance
shall
be
determined
as
otherwise
provided
5
by
law.
For
purposes
of
this
section,
“public
employer”
and
6
“public
employee”
mean
the
same
as
defined
in
section
20.3.
7
Sec.
68.
STATE
AND
REGENTS
EMPLOYEE
HEALTH
INSURANCE
——
8
OPEN
ENROLLMENT
PERIOD.
A
thirty-day
enrollment
and
change
9
period
for
health
insurance
coverage
may
be
established
and
10
administered
for
any
employees
of
the
state
of
Iowa,
the
state
11
board
of
regents,
or
an
institution
governed
by
the
state
board
12
of
regents
eligible
to
participate
in
a
health
insurance
plan
13
offered
by
the
state,
state
board,
or
institution
pursuant
to
14
chapter
509A,
if
the
affected
employees
are
provided
written
15
notice
of
the
period
at
least
thirty
days
before
the
beginning
16
of
the
period
and
if
the
first
day
of
such
a
period
occurs
in
17
calendar
year
2017.
18
Sec.
69.
EFFECTIVE
UPON
ENACTMENT.
This
division
of
this
19
Act,
being
deemed
of
immediate
importance,
takes
effect
upon
20
enactment.
21
EXPLANATION
22
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
23
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
24
This
bill
relates
to
employment
matters
involving
public
25
employees
including
collective
bargaining,
educator
employment
26
matters,
personnel
records
and
settlement
agreements,
and
city
27
civil
service
requirements.
28
DIVISION
I
——
PUBLIC
EMPLOYEE
COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING.
29
This
division
makes
a
variety
of
changes
to
Code
chapter
30
20,
the
public
employment
relations
Act,
as
well
as
other
31
Code
provisions
relating
to
collective
bargaining
by
public
32
employees.
33
SCOPE
OF
NEGOTIATIONS.
The
division
makes
changes
to
34
mandatory
and
prohibited
subjects
which
are
negotiated
through
35
-46-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
46/
68
H.F.
_____
collective
bargaining
between
public
employers
and
public
1
employees
under
Code
section
20.9.
2
Under
current
law,
for
negotiations
regarding
any
public
3
employees,
mandatory
subjects
of
bargaining
are
wages,
hours,
4
vacations,
insurance,
holidays,
leaves
of
absence,
shift
5
differentials,
overtime
compensation,
supplemental
pay,
6
seniority,
transfer
procedures,
job
classifications,
health
and
7
safety
matters,
evaluation
procedures,
procedures
for
staff
8
reduction,
in-service
training,
terms
authorizing
dues
checkoff
9
for
members
of
employee
organizations,
grievance
procedures
10
for
resolving
any
questions
arising
under
the
agreement,
and
11
other
matters
mutually
agreed
upon.
Retirement
systems
are
a
12
prohibited
subject
of
bargaining.
13
The
division
provides
that,
for
negotiations
regarding
a
14
bargaining
unit
with
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
15
safety
employees,
mandatory
subjects
of
bargaining
are
wages,
16
hours,
vacations,
insurance,
holidays,
leaves
of
absence,
17
shift
differentials,
overtime
compensation,
supplemental
pay,
18
seniority,
transfer
procedures,
job
classifications,
health
19
and
safety
matters,
evaluation
procedures,
procedures
for
20
staff
reduction,
in-service
training,
grievance
procedures
21
for
resolving
any
questions
arising
under
the
agreement,
and
22
other
matters
mutually
agreed
upon.
The
division
provides
23
that,
for
negotiations
regarding
a
bargaining
unit
that
does
24
not
have
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
safety
employees,
25
the
mandatory
subjects
of
bargaining
are
base
wages
and
26
other
matters
mutually
agreed
upon.
Mandatory
subjects
of
27
negotiation
specified
in
the
division
shall
be
interpreted
28
narrowly
and
restrictively.
29
The
division
provides
that
prohibited
subjects
of
bargaining
30
for
negotiations
regarding
any
public
employees
are
retirement
31
systems,
dues
checkoffs,
and
other
payroll
deductions
for
32
political
action
committees
or
other
political
contributions
or
33
political
activities.
The
division
provides
that
prohibited
34
subjects
of
bargaining
negotiations
regarding
a
bargaining
unit
35
-47-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
47/
68
H.F.
_____
that
does
not
have
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
safety
1
employees
shall
also
include
insurance,
leaves
of
absence
for
2
political
activities,
supplemental
pay,
transfer
procedures,
3
evaluation
procedures,
procedures
for
staff
reduction,
release
4
time,
subcontracting
public
services,
grievance
procedures
5
for
resolving
any
questions
arising
under
the
agreement,
and
6
seniority
and
any
wage
increase,
employment
benefit,
or
other
7
employment
advantage
based
on
seniority.
8
The
division
provides
that
the
term
of
a
collective
9
bargaining
agreement
entered
into
pursuant
to
Code
chapter
20
10
shall
not
exceed
five
years.
11
The
division
defines
“public
safety
employee”
as
a
public
12
employee
who
is
employed
as
a
sheriff
or
a
sheriff’s
regular
13
deputy;
a
marshal
or
police
officer
of
a
city,
township,
or
14
special-purpose
district
or
authority
who
is
a
member
of
a
15
paid
police
department;
a
member,
except
a
non-peace
officer
16
member,
of
the
division
of
state
patrol,
narcotics
enforcement,
17
state
fire
marshal,
or
criminal
investigation,
including
but
18
not
limited
to
a
gaming
enforcement
officer,
who
has
been
duly
19
appointed
by
the
department
of
public
safety
in
accordance
with
20
Code
section
80.15;
a
conservation
officer
or
park
ranger
as
21
authorized
by
Code
section
456A.13;
or
a
permanent
or
full-time
22
fire
fighter
of
a
city,
township,
or
special-purpose
district
23
or
authority
who
is
a
member
of
a
paid
fire
department.
The
24
division
defines
“supplemental
pay”
as
a
payment
of
moneys
25
or
other
thing
of
value
that
is
in
addition
to
compensation
26
received
pursuant
to
any
other
permitted
subject
of
negotiation
27
specified
in
Code
section
20.9
and
is
related
to
the
employment
28
relationship.
29
ARBITRATION
PROCEDURES.
The
division
makes
changes
to
the
30
procedures
for
arbitration
of
impasses
in
collective
bargaining
31
between
public
employers
and
public
employees
under
Code
32
section
20.22.
33
ARBITRATION
FACTORS.
The
division
modifies
the
factors
that
34
an
arbitrator
is
required
to
consider
in
addition
to
any
other
35
-48-
LSB
1725YC
(20)
87
je/rj
48/
68
H.F.
_____
relevant
factors
in
making
a
final
determination
on
an
impasse
1
item.
2
The
division
requires
an
arbitrator
to
specifically
3
address
in
the
arbitrator’s
final
determination
on
an
impasse
4
item
the
factors
considered
by
the
arbitrator
in
making
the
5
determination.
6
ARBITRATION
FACTORS
——
PUBLIC
SAFETY
EMPLOYEES.
Under
the
7
division,
an
arbitrator
in
an
arbitration
to
which
a
bargaining
8
unit
that
has
a
majority
of
members
who
are
public
safety
9
employees
is
a
party
is
required
to
consider
past
collective
10
bargaining
contracts
between
the
parties
including
the
11
bargaining
that
led
up
to
such
contracts.
12
The
arbitrator
is
required
to
consider
a
comparison
of
13
wages,
hours,
and
conditions
of
employment
of
the
involved