House
Study
Bill
604
-
Introduced
SENATE/HOUSE
FILE
_____
BY
(PROPOSED
STATE
PUBLIC
DEFENDER
BILL)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
the
confidentiality
of
juvenile
court
1
records.
2
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
3
TLSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
Section
1.
Section
232.19,
subsection
4,
Code
2016,
is
1
amended
by
striking
the
subsection.
2
Sec.
2.
Section
232.147,
subsection
2,
Code
2016,
is
amended
3
by
striking
the
subsection.
4
Sec.
3.
Section
232.147,
subsection
3,
unnumbered
paragraph
5
1,
Code
2016,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
6
Official
juvenile
court
records
in
all
cases
except
those
7
alleging
delinquency
shall
be
confidential
and
are
not
public
8
records
but
may
be
inspected
and
their
contents
shall
be
9
disclosed
to
the
following
without
court
order:
10
Sec.
4.
Section
232.149,
subsection
2,
Code
2016,
is
amended
11
to
read
as
follows:
12
2.
Records
and
files
of
a
criminal
or
juvenile
justice
13
agency
concerning
a
child
involved
in
a
delinquent
act
are
14
public
records,
except
that
release
of
criminal
history
data,
15
intelligence
data,
and
law
enforcement
investigatory
files
is
16
subject
to
the
provisions
of
section
22.7
and
chapter
692
,
17
and
juvenile
court
social
records,
as
defined
in
section
18
232.2,
subsection
31
,
shall
be
deemed
confidential
criminal
19
identification
files
under
section
22.7,
subsection
9
20
confidential
.
The
records
are
subject
to
sealing
under
section
21
232.150
unless
the
juvenile
court
waives
its
jurisdiction
over
22
the
child
so
that
the
child
may
be
prosecuted
as
an
adult
for
23
a
public
offense.
24
Sec.
5.
Section
232.149A,
Code
2016,
is
amended
to
read
as
25
follows:
26
232.149A
Confidentiality
Public
records
orders.
27
1.
Notwithstanding
any
other
provision
of
the
Code
to
28
the
contrary
A
rebuttable
presumption
exists
that
official
29
juvenile
court
records
in
delinquency
proceedings
shall
remain
30
confidential.
However
,
upon
application
of
a
any
person
who
31
was
taken
into
custody
for
a
delinquent
act
or
was
the
subject
32
of
a
complaint
alleging
delinquency
or
was
the
subject
of
a
33
delinquency
petition
,
or
upon
the
court’s
own
motion,
the
court
34
after
a
hearing
held
prior
to
disposition
,
shall
order
official
35
-1-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
1/
8
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
juvenile
court
records
in
the
case
delinquency
proceedings
to
1
be
kept
confidential
and
no
longer
made
public
records
under
2
sections
232.147
and
232.149
,
if
the
court
finds
both
of
the
3
following
apply:
4
a.
The
case
has
been
dismissed
and
the
person
is
no
longer
5
subject
to
the
jurisdiction
of
the
juvenile
court.
6
b.
Making
that
making
the
records
confidential
public
is
in
7
the
best
interests
of
the
person
child
and
the
public.
8
2.
The
records
subject
to
a
confidentiality
public
records
9
order
may
be
sealed
at
a
later
date
if
section
232.150
applies.
10
3.
Official
juvenile
court
records
subject
to
a
11
confidentiality
order
which
are
confidential
under
section
12
232.147
may
be
inspected
and
their
contents
shall
be
disclosed
13
to
the
following
without
court
order:
14
a.
The
judge
and
professional
court
staff,
including
15
juvenile
court
officers.
16
b.
The
child
and
the
child’s
counsel.
17
c.
The
child’s
parent,
guardian
,
or
custodian,
court
18
appointed
special
advocate,
and
guardian
ad
litem,
and
19
the
members
of
the
child
advocacy
board
created
in
section
20
237.16
or
a
local
citizen
foster
care
review
board
created
in
21
accordance
with
section
237.19
who
are
assigning
or
reviewing
22
the
child’s
case.
23
d.
The
county
attorney
and
the
county
attorney’s
assistants.
24
e.
An
agency,
association,
facility,
or
institution
which
25
has
custody
of
the
child,
or
is
legally
responsible
for
the
26
care,
treatment,
or
supervision
of
the
child,
including
but
not
27
limited
to
the
department
of
human
services.
28
f.
A
court,
court
professional
staff,
and
adult
probation
29
officers
in
connection
with
the
preparation
of
a
presentence
30
report
concerning
a
person
who
had
been
the
subject
of
a
31
juvenile
court
proceeding.
32
g.
The
child’s
foster
parent
or
an
individual
providing
33
preadoptive
care
to
the
child.
34
h.
A
state
or
local
law
enforcement
agency.
35
-2-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
2/
8
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
i.
The
state
public
defender.
1
4.
If
the
child
has
been
discharged
from
the
jurisdiction
2
of
the
juvenile
court
due
to
reaching
the
age
of
eighteen
and
3
restitution
remains
unpaid,
the
name
of
the
court,
the
title
4
of
the
action,
and
the
court’s
file
number
shall
not
be
kept
5
confidential,
and
the
restitution
amount
shall
be
a
judgment
6
and
lien
as
provided
in
sections
910.7A
,
910.8
,
910.10
,
and
7
915.28
until
the
restitution
is
paid.
8
5.
Pursuant
to
court
order,
official
juvenile
court
records
9
subject
to
a
confidentiality
order
which
are
confidential
under
10
section
232.147
may
be
inspected
by
and
their
contents
may
be
11
disclosed
to:
12
a.
A
person
conducting
bona
fide
research
for
research
13
purposes
under
whatever
conditions
the
court
may
deem
proper,
14
provided
that
no
personal
identifying
data
shall
be
disclosed
15
to
such
a
person.
16
b.
Persons
who
have
a
direct
interest
in
a
proceeding
or
in
17
the
work
of
the
court.
18
6.
Notwithstanding
any
other
provision
of
this
section,
19
upon
application
of
any
person
and
order
of
the
court
at
any
20
time
prior
to
the
termination
of
juvenile
court
jurisdiction
21
over
the
child,
the
court,
after
a
hearing,
may
order
the
22
official
juvenile
court
records
in
delinquency
proceedings
to
23
be
public
records
if
any
of
the
following
apply:
24
a.
The
child
has
been
subsequently
convicted
of
a
felony
25
or
an
aggravated
or
serious
misdemeanor
or
adjudicated
a
26
delinquent
child
for
an
act
which
if
committed
by
an
adult
27
would
be
a
felony
or
an
aggravated
or
serious
misdemeanor.
28
b.
The
child
was
placed
on
youthful
offender
status,
29
transferred
back
to
the
district
court
after
the
youthful
30
offender’s
eighteenth
birthday,
and
sentenced
for
the
offense
31
which
precipitated
the
youthful
offender
placement.
32
Sec.
6.
NEW
SECTION
.
232.149B
Right
to
counsel
in
a
public
33
records
order
hearing.
34
1.
A
person
who
is
or
is
not
a
child
shall
have
the
right
35
-3-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
3/
8
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
to
be
represented
by
counsel
at
a
public
records
order
hearing
1
held
under
section
232.149A.
2
2.
Such
person’s
right
to
be
represented
by
counsel
under
3
subsection
1
shall
not
be
waived
by
the
person
if
the
person
4
is
a
child
less
than
sixteen
years
of
age
without
the
written
5
consent
of
such
child’s
parent,
guardian,
or
custodian.
6
3.
If
the
person
is
a
child
and
is
not
represented
by
7
counsel
as
required
under
subsection
1,
counsel
shall
be
8
provided
as
follows:
9
a.
If
the
court
determines,
after
giving
the
child’s
parent,
10
guardian,
or
custodian
an
opportunity
to
be
heard,
that
such
11
person
has
the
ability
in
whole
or
in
part
to
pay
for
the
12
employment
of
counsel,
the
court
shall
either
order
that
person
13
to
retain
an
attorney
to
represent
the
child
or
shall
appoint
14
counsel
for
the
child
and
order
the
parent,
guardian,
or
15
custodian
to
pay
for
that
counsel
as
provided
in
subsection
5.
16
b.
If
the
court
determines
that
the
parent,
guardian,
or
17
custodian
cannot
pay
any
part
of
the
expenses
of
counsel
to
18
represent
the
child,
the
court
shall
appoint
counsel,
who
19
shall
be
reimbursed
according
to
section
232.141,
subsection
20
2,
paragraph
“b”
.
21
c.
The
court
may
appoint
counsel
to
represent
the
child
22
and
reserve
the
determination
of
payment
until
the
parent,
23
guardian,
or
custodian
has
an
opportunity
to
be
heard.
24
4.
If
the
person
is
a
child
and
is
represented
by
counsel
25
and
the
court
determines
that
there
is
a
conflict
of
interest
26
between
the
child
and
the
child’s
parent,
guardian,
or
27
custodian
and
that
the
retained
counsel
could
not
properly
28
represent
the
child
as
a
result
of
the
conflict,
the
court
29
shall
appoint
other
counsel
to
represent
the
child
and
order
30
the
parent,
guardian,
or
custodian
to
pay
for
such
counsel
as
31
provided
in
subsection
5.
32
5.
If
the
person
is
a
child
and
the
court
determines,
after
33
an
inquiry
which
includes
notice
and
reasonable
opportunity
34
to
be
heard,
that
the
parent,
guardian,
or
custodian
has
the
35
-4-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
4/
8
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
ability
to
pay
in
whole
or
in
part
for
the
attorney
appointed
1
for
the
child,
the
court
may
order
that
person
to
pay
such
sums
2
as
the
court
finds
appropriate
in
the
manner
and
to
whom
the
3
court
directs.
If
that
person
so
ordered
fails
to
comply
with
4
the
order
without
good
reason,
the
court
shall
enter
judgment
5
against
the
person.
6
6.
If
the
person
is
not
a
child
and
is
not
represented
7
by
counsel
as
required
under
subsection
1,
counsel
shall
be
8
provided
as
follows:
9
a.
If
the
court
determines,
after
giving
the
person
an
10
opportunity
to
be
heard,
that
such
person
has
the
ability
in
11
whole
or
in
part
to
pay
for
the
employment
of
counsel,
the
12
court
shall
either
allow
the
person
to
retain
an
attorney
or
13
shall
appoint
counsel
for
the
person
and
order
the
person
to
14
pay
such
sums
as
the
court
finds
appropriate
in
the
manner
and
15
to
whom
the
court
directs.
If
the
person
so
ordered
fails
to
16
comply
with
the
order
without
good
reason,
the
court
shall
17
enter
judgment
against
the
person.
18
b.
If
the
court
determines
that
the
person
cannot
pay
19
any
part
of
the
expenses
of
counsel,
the
court
shall
appoint
20
counsel,
who
shall
be
reimbursed
according
to
section
232.141,
21
subsection
2,
paragraph
“b”
.
22
c.
The
court
may
appoint
counsel
to
represent
the
person
and
23
reserve
the
determination
of
payment
until
the
person
has
an
24
opportunity
to
be
heard.
25
Sec.
7.
Section
815.9,
subsection
9,
Code
2016,
is
amended
26
to
read
as
follows:
27
9.
Notwithstanding
subsections
3
and
6
,
a
minor
granted
28
a
court-appointed
attorney
or
guardian
ad
litem
under
29
section
232.11
in
a
juvenile
proceeding
or
a
person
granted
a
30
court-appointed
attorney
under
section
232.149B
in
a
public
31
records
order
hearing
shall
not
be
ordered
to
reimburse
costs
32
and
fees
incurred
for
legal
assistance
except
as
otherwise
33
provided
in
chapter
232
.
34
Sec.
8.
REPEAL.
Section
915.25,
Code
2016,
is
repealed.
35
-5-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
5/
8
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
Sec.
9.
APPLICABILITY.
The
sections
of
this
Act
amending,
1
enacting,
or
repealing
sections
232.19,
232.147,
232.149,
2
232.149A,
232.149B,
815.9,
and
915.25
apply
to
juvenile
3
delinquency
proceedings
which
are
pending
or
arise
on
or
after
4
July
1,
2016.
5
EXPLANATION
6
The
inclusion
of
this
explanation
does
not
constitute
agreement
with
7
the
explanation’s
substance
by
the
members
of
the
general
assembly.
8
This
bill
relates
to
the
confidentiality
of
juvenile
court
9
records.
10
Under
current
law,
juvenile
court
records
in
cases
alleging
11
delinquency
are
public
records
unless
a
judge
grants
a
request
12
to
make
the
records
confidential
or
seals
the
records.
13
The
bill
amends
current
law
and
provides
that
juvenile
14
court
records
in
cases
alleging
delinquency
are
confidential
15
unless
a
judge
grants
a
request
to
make
the
juvenile
court
16
records
public
if
the
court
finds,
after
a
hearing
held
prior
17
to
disposition,
that
making
the
records
public
is
in
the
18
best
interests
of
the
juvenile
and
the
public.
A
rebuttable
19
presumption
exists
that
the
juvenile
court
delinquency
records
20
shall
remain
confidential.
Even
if
a
child’s
juvenile
court
21
delinquency
records
are
confidential,
a
court
may,
after
a
22
hearing,
order
such
records
to
be
made
public
records
if
the
23
child
is
subsequently
convicted
of
a
felony
or
an
aggravated
24
or
serious
misdemeanor
or
adjudicated
a
delinquent
child
for
25
an
act
which
if
committed
by
an
adult
would
be
a
felony
or
26
an
aggravated
or
serious
misdemeanor,
or
if
the
child
was
27
placed
on
youthful
offender
status,
transferred
back
to
the
28
district
court
after
the
youthful
offender’s
18th
birthday,
29
and
sentenced
for
the
offense
which
precipitated
the
youthful
30
offender
placement.
The
bill
provides
that
a
child
has
the
31
right
to
be
represented
by
counsel
during
a
public
records
32
order
hearing,
even
if
such
hearing
occurs
after
the
child’s
33
18th
birthday.
If
a
judge
orders
such
records
to
be
public,
34
the
records
may
still
be
sealed
at
a
later
date
pursuant
to
35
-6-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
6/
8
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
Code
section
232.150.
1
The
bill
provides
that
juvenile
court
records
in
cases
2
alleging
delinquency
may
be,
without
a
court
order,
inspected
3
by
and
disclosed
to
the
judge
and
professional
court
staff,
the
4
child
and
the
child’s
counsel,
the
child’s
parent,
guardian,
or
5
custodian,
court-appointed
special
advocate,
and
guardian
ad
6
litem,
and
the
members
of
the
child
advocacy
board
created
in
7
Code
section
237.16
or
a
local
citizen
foster
care
review
board
8
created
in
accordance
with
Code
section
237.19,
the
county
9
attorney
and
the
county
attorney’s
assistants,
an
agency,
10
association,
facility,
or
institution
which
has
custody
of
the
11
child,
or
is
legally
responsible
for
the
care,
treatment,
or
12
supervision
of
the
child,
a
court,
court
professional
staff,
13
and
adult
probation
officers
in
connection
with
the
preparation
14
of
a
presentence
report
concerning
a
person
who
prior
thereto
15
had
been
the
subject
of
a
juvenile
court
proceeding,
the
16
child’s
foster
parent
or
an
individual
providing
preadoptive
17
care
to
the
child,
a
law
enforcement
agency,
and
the
state
18
public
defender.
19
Under
current
law,
records
and
files
of
a
criminal
or
20
juvenile
justice
agency
concerning
a
child
involved
in
21
a
delinquent
act
are
public
records,
subject
to
certain
22
exemptions.
The
bill
provides
that
such
records
and
files
are
23
confidential.
24
Under
current
law,
a
complaint
which
alleges
that
a
child
25
who
is
at
least
10
years
of
age
has
committed
a
delinquent
26
act,
which
if
committed
by
an
adult
would
be
a
public
offense,
27
is
a
public
record
and
is
not
confidential
under
Code
section
28
232.147.
The
bill
repeals
Code
section
915.25
and
provides
29
that
such
a
complaint
is
subject
to
Code
section
232.147,
and
30
therefore
is
confidential.
31
The
bill
retains
certain
existing
exemptions
to
32
confidentiality
of
juvenile
court
records.
Pursuant
to
Code
33
section
692A.121(8),
records
concerning
sex
offense
convictions
34
which
are
committed
by
minors
may
be
released
in
the
same
35
-7-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
7/
8
S.F.
_____
H.F.
_____
manner
as
records
of
convictions
of
adults.
Pursuant
to
Code
1
section
915.10A,
information
concerning
a
juvenile
charged
2
with
a
felony
offense
may
be
released
pursuant
to
an
automated
3
victim
notification
system.
Under
the
bill,
these
exemptions
4
to
confidentiality
are
not
amended
and
therefore
still
apply
to
5
juvenile
court
records.
6
The
bill
applies
to
juvenile
delinquency
proceedings
which
7
are
pending
or
arise
on
or
after
July
1,
2016.
8
-8-
LSB
5193XD
(8)
86
jh/rj
8/
8