Senate
Study
Bill
1043
-
Introduced
SENATE
FILE
_____
BY
(PROPOSED
COMMITTEE
ON
JUDICIARY
BILL
BY
CHAIRPERSON
FRAISE)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
the
placement
of
a
juvenile
on
youthful
1
offender
status
in
district
court.
2
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
3
TLSB
1594SC
(2)
84
jm/rj
S.F.
_____
Section
1.
Section
232.8,
subsection
3,
paragraph
a,
Code
1
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
2
a.
The
juvenile
court,
after
a
hearing
and
in
accordance
3
with
the
provisions
of
section
232.45
,
may
waive
jurisdiction
4
of
a
child
alleged
to
have
committed
a
public
offense
so
5
that
the
child
may
be
prosecuted
as
an
adult
or
youthful
6
offender
for
such
offense
in
another
court.
If
the
child
,
7
except
a
child
being
prosecuted
as
a
youthful
offender,
pleads
8
guilty
or
is
found
guilty
of
a
public
offense
other
than
a
9
class
“A”
felony
in
another
court
of
this
state,
that
court
10
may
suspend
the
sentence
or,
with
the
consent
of
the
child,
11
defer
judgment
and
without
regard
to
restrictions
placed
upon
12
deferred
judgments
for
adults,
place
the
child
on
probation
for
13
a
period
of
not
less
than
one
year
upon
such
conditions
as
it
14
may
require.
Upon
fulfillment
of
the
conditions
of
probation,
15
a
child
who
receives
a
deferred
judgment
shall
be
discharged
16
without
entry
of
judgment.
17
Sec.
2.
Section
232.45,
subsection
7,
paragraph
a,
18
subparagraph
(1),
Code
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
19
(1)
The
child
is
thirteen,
fourteen,
or
fifteen
years
of
age
20
or
younger
.
21
Sec.
3.
Section
232.50,
subsection
1,
Code
2011,
is
amended
22
to
read
as
follows:
23
1.
As
soon
as
practicable
following
the
entry
of
an
order
24
of
adjudication
pursuant
to
section
232.47
or
notification
25
that
the
child
has
received
a
youthful
offender
deferred
26
sentence
pursuant
to
section
907.3A
,
the
court
shall
hold
a
27
dispositional
hearing
in
order
to
determine
what
disposition
28
should
be
made
of
the
matter.
29
Sec.
4.
Section
232.52,
subsection
1,
Code
2011,
is
amended
30
to
read
as
follows:
31
1.
Pursuant
to
a
hearing
as
provided
in
section
232.50
,
the
32
court
shall
enter
the
least
restrictive
dispositional
order
33
appropriate
in
view
of
the
seriousness
of
the
delinquent
act,
34
the
child’s
culpability
as
indicated
by
the
circumstances
of
35
-1-
LSB
1594SC
(2)
84
jm/rj
1/
5
S.F.
_____
the
particular
case,
the
age
of
the
child,
the
child’s
prior
1
record,
or
the
fact
that
the
child
has
received
a
youthful
2
offender
deferred
sentence
under
section
907.3A
.
The
order
3
shall
specify
the
duration
and
the
nature
of
the
disposition,
4
including
the
type
of
residence
or
confinement
ordered
and
the
5
individual,
agency,
department
,
or
facility
in
whom
custody
is
6
vested.
In
the
case
of
a
child
who
has
received
a
youthful
7
offender
deferred
sentence,
the
initial
duration
of
the
8
dispositional
order
shall
be
until
the
child
reaches
the
age
9
of
eighteen.
10
Sec.
5.
Section
232.54,
subsection
1,
paragraph
g,
Code
11
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
12
g.
With
respect
to
a
juvenile
court
dispositional
order
13
entered
regarding
a
child
who
has
received
a
youthful
offender
14
deferred
sentence
under
section
907.3A
,
the
dispositional
15
order
may
be
terminated
prior
to
the
child
reaching
the
age
16
of
eighteen
upon
motion
of
the
child,
the
person
or
agency
to
17
whom
custody
of
the
child
has
been
transferred,
or
the
county
18
attorney
following
a
hearing
before
the
juvenile
court
if
it
19
is
shown
by
clear
and
convincing
evidence
that
it
is
in
the
20
best
interests
of
the
child
and
the
community
to
terminate
21
the
order.
The
hearing
may
be
waived
if
all
parties
to
the
22
proceeding
agree.
The
dispositional
order
regarding
a
child
23
who
has
received
a
youthful
offender
deferred
sentence
may
24
also
be
terminated
prior
to
the
child
reaching
the
age
of
25
eighteen
upon
motion
of
the
county
attorney,
if
the
waiver
of
26
the
child
to
district
court
was
conditioned
upon
the
terms
of
27
an
agreement
between
the
county
attorney
and
the
child,
and
28
the
child
violates
the
terms
of
the
agreement
after
the
waiver
29
order
has
been
entered.
The
district
court
shall
discharge
the
30
child’s
youthful
offender
status
upon
receiving
a
termination
31
order
under
this
section
.
32
Sec.
6.
Section
232.54,
subsection
1,
paragraph
h,
33
unnumbered
paragraph
1,
Code
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
34
follows:
35
-2-
LSB
1594SC
(2)
84
jm/rj
2/
5
S.F.
_____
With
respect
to
a
dispositional
order
entered
regarding
a
1
child
who
has
received
a
youthful
offender
deferred
sentence
2
under
section
907.3A
,
the
juvenile
court
may,
in
the
case
of
a
3
child
who
violates
the
terms
of
the
order,
modify
or
terminate
4
the
order
in
accordance
with
the
following:
5
Sec.
7.
Section
232.55,
subsection
3,
Code
2011,
is
amended
6
to
read
as
follows:
7
3.
This
section
does
not
apply
to
dispositional
orders
8
entered
regarding
a
child
who
has
received
a
youthful
offender
9
deferred
sentence
under
section
907.3A
who
is
not
discharged
10
from
probation
before
or
upon
the
child’s
eighteenth
birthday.
11
Sec.
8.
Section
232.56,
Code
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
12
follows:
13
232.56
Youthful
offenders
——
transfer
to
district
court
14
supervision.
15
The
juvenile
court
shall
deliver
a
report,
which
includes
16
an
assessment
of
the
child
by
a
juvenile
court
officer
17
after
consulting
with
the
judicial
district
department
of
18
correctional
services,
to
the
district
court
prior
to
the
19
eighteenth
birthday
of
a
child
who
has
received
a
youthful
20
offender
deferred
sentence
under
section
907.3A
.
A
hearing
21
shall
be
held
in
the
district
court
in
accordance
with
section
22
907.3A
to
determine
whether
the
child
should
be
discharged
from
23
youthful
offender
status
or
whether
the
child
shall
continue
24
under
the
supervision
of
the
district
court
after
the
child’s
25
eighteenth
birthday.
26
Sec.
9.
Section
907.3A,
subsection
1,
Code
2011,
is
amended
27
to
read
as
follows:
28
1.
Notwithstanding
section
907.3
but
subject
to
any
29
conditions
of
the
waiver
order,
the
trial
court
shall,
upon
a
30
plea
of
guilty
or
a
verdict
of
guilty,
defer
judgment
or
defer
31
sentence
of
a
youthful
offender
over
whom
the
juvenile
court
32
has
waived
jurisdiction
pursuant
to
section
232.45,
subsection
33
7
,
and
place
the
juvenile
on
youthful
offender
status.
The
34
court
shall
transfer
supervision
of
the
youthful
offender
to
35
-3-
LSB
1594SC
(2)
84
jm/rj
3/
5
S.F.
_____
the
juvenile
court
for
disposition
in
accordance
with
section
1
232.52
.
The
court
shall
require
supervision
of
the
youthful
2
offender
in
accordance
with
section
232.54,
subsection
1
,
3
paragraph
“h”
,
or
subsection
2
of
this
section
.
Notwithstanding
4
section
901.2
,
a
presentence
investigation
shall
not
be
5
ordered
by
the
court
subsequent
to
an
entry
of
a
plea
of
guilty
6
or
verdict
of
guilty
or
prior
to
deferral
of
sentence
of
a
7
youthful
offender
under
this
section
.
8
Sec.
10.
Section
907.3A,
subsection
3,
Code
2011,
is
amended
9
to
read
as
follows:
10
3.
Notwithstanding
any
provision
of
the
Code
which
11
prescribes
a
mandatory
minimum
sentence
for
the
offense
12
committed
by
the
youthful
offender,
following
transfer
of
the
13
youthful
offender
from
the
juvenile
court
back
to
the
court
14
having
jurisdiction
over
the
criminal
proceedings
involving
the
15
youthful
offender,
the
court
may
continue
the
youthful
offender
16
deferred
sentence
or
enter
a
sentence,
which
may
be
a
suspended
17
sentence.
Notwithstanding
anything
in
section
907.7
to
the
18
contrary,
if
the
district
court
either
continues
the
youthful
19
offender
deferred
sentence
or
enters
a
sentence,
suspends
the
20
sentence,
and
places
the
youthful
offender
on
probation,
the
21
term
of
formal
supervision
shall
commence
upon
entry
of
the
22
order
by
the
district
court
and
may
continue
for
a
period
not
23
to
exceed
five
years.
If
the
district
court
enters
a
sentence
24
of
confinement,
and
the
youthful
offender
was
previously
placed
25
in
secure
confinement
by
the
juvenile
court
under
the
terms
26
of
the
initial
disposition
order
or
any
modification
to
the
27
initial
disposition
order,
the
person
shall
receive
credit
for
28
any
time
spent
in
secure
confinement.
During
any
period
of
29
probation
imposed
by
the
district
court,
a
youthful
offender
30
who
violates
the
terms
of
probation
is
subject
to
section
31
908.11
.
32
EXPLANATION
33
This
bill
relates
to
the
placement
of
a
juvenile
on
youthful
34
offender
status
in
district
court.
35
-4-
LSB
1594SC
(2)
84
jm/rj
4/
5
S.F.
_____
The
bill
specifies
that
a
juvenile
who
is
13,
14,
or
15
years
1
of
age
is
eligible
to
be
prosecuted
as
a
youthful
offender.
2
Current
law
requires
that
a
juvenile
be
15
years
of
age
or
3
younger
in
order
to
be
eligible
for
prosecution
as
a
youthful
4
offender.
5
A
youthful
offender
is
a
juvenile
who
is
prosecuted
in
6
district
court
but
is
supervised
in
juvenile
court
until
the
7
age
of
18.
Upon
the
youthful
offender
attaining
the
age
of
18,
8
the
district
court
has
discretion
to
discharge
the
sentence
or
9
continue
supervision
of
the
youthful
offender
in
district
court
10
as
provided
Code
section
907.3A.
11
The
bill
also
allows
the
district
court
to
defer
judgment
12
of
a
juvenile
who
has
been
waived
to
district
court
pursuant
13
to
Code
section
232.45,
subsection
7,
for
prosecution
as
a
14
youthful
offender.
Current
law
only
allows
the
district
court
15
to
defer
the
sentence
of
a
juvenile
who
has
been
waived
to
16
district
court
pursuant
to
Code
section
232.45,
subsection
7,
17
for
prosecution
as
a
youthful
offender.
18
A
“deferred
judgment”
means
a
sentencing
option
where
the
19
adjudication
of
guilt
and
the
imposition
of
a
sentence
are
20
deferred
by
the
court.
However,
the
court
retains
the
power
21
to
pronounce
judgment
and
impose
sentence
subject
to
the
22
defendant’s
compliance
with
conditions
set
by
the
court
as
a
23
requirement
of
the
deferred
judgment.
24
A
“deferred
sentence”
means
a
sentencing
option
where
the
25
court
enters
an
adjudication
of
guilt
but
does
not
impose
a
26
sentence.
The
court
does
retain
the
power
to
sentence
the
27
defendant
to
any
sentence
it
originally
could
have
imposed
28
subject
to
the
defendant’s
compliance
with
conditions
set
by
29
the
court
as
a
requirement
of
the
deferred
sentence.
30
-5-
LSB
1594SC
(2)
84
jm/rj
5/
5