Senate
File
289
-
Introduced
SENATE
FILE
289
BY
COMMITTEE
ON
STATE
GOVERNMENT
(SUCCESSOR
TO
SF
25)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
open
records
and
public
meetings
and
1
including
effective
date
provisions.
2
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
3
TLSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
S.F.
289
Section
1.
Section
8A.341,
subsection
2,
Code
2011,
is
1
amended
to
read
as
follows:
2
2.
If
money
is
appropriated
for
this
purpose,
by
November
1
3
of
each
year
supply
a
report
which
contains
the
name,
gender,
4
county,
or
city
of
residence
when
possible,
official
title,
5
salary
received
during
the
previous
fiscal
year,
base
salary
as
6
computed
on
July
1
of
the
current
fiscal
year,
and
traveling
7
and
subsistence
expense
of
the
personnel
of
each
of
the
8
departments,
boards,
and
commissions
of
the
state
government
9
except
personnel
who
receive
an
annual
salary
of
less
than
one
10
thousand
dollars.
The
number
of
the
personnel
and
the
total
11
amount
received
by
them
shall
be
shown
for
each
department
in
12
the
report.
All
employees
who
have
drawn
salaries,
fees,
or
13
expense
allowances
from
more
than
one
department
or
subdivision
14
shall
be
listed
separately
under
the
proper
departmental
15
heading.
On
the
request
of
the
director,
the
head
of
each
16
department,
board,
or
commission
shall
furnish
the
data
17
covering
that
agency.
The
report
shall
be
distributed
upon
18
request
without
charge
in
an
electronic
medium
to
each
caucus
19
of
the
general
assembly,
the
legislative
services
agency,
the
20
chief
clerk
of
the
house
of
representatives,
and
the
secretary
21
of
the
senate.
Copies
of
the
report
shall
be
made
available
to
22
other
persons
in
an
electronic
medium
upon
payment
of
a
fee,
23
which
shall
not
exceed
the
cost
of
providing
the
copy
of
the
24
report.
Sections
22.2
through
22.6
22.5
apply
to
the
report.
25
All
funds
from
the
sale
of
the
report
shall
be
deposited
in
the
26
printing
revolving
fund
established
in
section
8A.345
.
27
Sec.
2.
Section
8E.202,
subsection
1,
unnumbered
paragraph
28
1,
Code
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
29
The
department
and
each
agency
shall
provide
for
the
widest
30
possible
dissemination
of
information
between
agencies
and
the
31
public
relating
to
the
enterprise
strategic
plan
and
agency
32
strategic
plans,
including
but
not
limited
to
internet
access.
33
This
section
does
not
require
the
department
or
an
agency
to
34
release
information
which
is
classified
as
a
confidential
35
-1-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
1/
10
S.F.
289
record
under
this
Code,
including
but
not
limited
to
section
1
22.7
law
.
2
Sec.
3.
Section
8E.202,
subsection
3,
Code
2011,
is
amended
3
to
read
as
follows:
4
3.
A
record
which
is
confidential
under
this
Code,
including
5
but
not
limited
to
section
22.7,
law
shall
not
be
released
to
6
the
public
under
this
section
.
7
Sec.
4.
Section
21.4,
subsections
1
and
3,
Code
2011,
are
8
amended
to
read
as
follows:
9
1.
A
Except
as
provided
in
subsection
3,
a
governmental
10
body
,
except
township
trustees,
shall
give
notice
of
the
time,
11
date,
and
place
of
each
meeting
including
a
reconvened
meeting
12
of
the
governmental
body
,
and
its
the
tentative
agenda
of
the
13
meeting
,
in
a
manner
reasonably
calculated
to
apprise
the
14
public
of
that
information.
Reasonable
notice
shall
include
15
advising
the
news
media
who
have
filed
a
request
for
notice
16
with
the
governmental
body
and
posting
the
notice
on
a
bulletin
17
board
or
other
prominent
place
which
is
easily
accessible
to
18
the
public
and
clearly
designated
for
that
purpose
at
the
19
principal
office
of
the
body
holding
the
meeting,
or
if
no
such
20
office
exists,
at
the
building
in
which
the
meeting
is
to
be
21
held.
22
3.
Subsection
1
does
not
apply
to
any
of
the
following:
23
a.
A
meeting
reconvened
within
four
hours
of
the
start
of
24
its
recess,
where
an
announcement
of
the
time,
date,
and
place
25
of
the
reconvened
meeting
is
made
at
the
original
meeting
in
26
open
session
and
recorded
in
the
minutes
of
the
meeting
and
27
there
is
no
change
in
the
agenda.
28
b.
A
meeting
held
by
a
formally
constituted
subunit
of
a
29
parent
governmental
body
may
conduct
a
meeting
without
notice
30
as
required
by
this
section
during
a
lawful
meeting
of
the
31
parent
governmental
body
,
or
during
a
recess
in
that
meeting
32
of
up
to
four
hours
,
or
a
meeting
of
that
subunit
immediately
33
following
that
the
meeting
of
the
parent
governmental
body
,
if
34
the
meeting
of
the
that
subunit
is
publicly
announced
in
open
35
-2-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
2/
10
S.F.
289
session
at
the
parent
meeting
and
the
subject
of
the
meeting
1
reasonably
coincides
with
the
subjects
discussed
or
acted
upon
2
by
the
parent
governmental
body.
3
Sec.
5.
Section
21.5,
subsection
1,
paragraph
j,
Code
2011,
4
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
5
j.
To
discuss
the
purchase
or
sale
of
particular
real
estate
6
only
where
premature
disclosure
could
be
reasonably
expected
to
7
increase
the
price
the
governmental
body
would
have
to
pay
for
8
that
property
or
reduce
the
price
the
governmental
body
would
9
receive
for
that
property
.
The
minutes
and
the
tape
audio
10
recording
of
a
session
closed
under
this
paragraph
shall
be
11
available
for
public
examination
when
the
transaction
discussed
12
is
completed.
13
Sec.
6.
Section
21.5,
subsection
4,
Code
2011,
is
amended
14
to
read
as
follows:
15
4.
A
governmental
body
shall
keep
detailed
minutes
of
all
16
discussion,
persons
present,
and
action
occurring
at
a
closed
17
session,
and
shall
also
tape
audio
record
all
of
the
closed
18
session.
The
detailed
minutes
and
tape
audio
recording
of
a
19
closed
session
shall
be
sealed
and
shall
not
be
public
records
20
open
to
public
inspection.
However,
upon
order
of
the
court
21
in
an
action
to
enforce
this
chapter
,
the
detailed
minutes
22
and
tape
audio
recording
shall
be
unsealed
and
examined
by
23
the
court
in
camera.
The
court
shall
then
determine
what
24
part,
if
any,
of
the
minutes
should
be
disclosed
to
the
25
party
seeking
enforcement
of
this
chapter
for
use
in
that
26
enforcement
proceeding.
In
determining
whether
any
portion
of
27
the
minutes
or
recording
shall
be
disclosed
to
such
a
party
for
28
this
purpose,
the
court
shall
weigh
the
prejudicial
effects
29
to
the
public
interest
of
the
disclosure
of
any
portion
of
30
the
minutes
or
recording
in
question,
against
its
probative
31
value
as
evidence
in
an
enforcement
proceeding.
After
such
a
32
determination,
the
court
may
permit
inspection
and
use
of
all
33
or
portions
of
the
detailed
minutes
and
tape
audio
recording
by
34
the
party
seeking
enforcement
of
this
chapter
.
A
governmental
35
-3-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
3/
10
S.F.
289
body
shall
keep
the
detailed
minutes
and
tape
audio
recording
1
of
any
closed
session
for
a
period
of
at
least
one
year
from
the
2
date
of
that
meeting
,
except
as
otherwise
required
by
law
.
3
Sec.
7.
Section
21.6,
subsection
3,
paragraph
a,
Code
2011,
4
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
5
a.
Shall
assess
each
member
of
the
governmental
body
who
6
participated
in
its
violation
damages
in
the
amount
of
not
more
7
than
five
hundred
dollars
nor
and
not
less
than
one
hundred
8
dollars.
However,
if
a
member
of
a
governmental
body
knowingly
9
participated
in
such
a
violation,
damages
shall
be
in
the
10
amount
of
not
more
than
two
thousand
five
hundred
dollars
11
and
not
less
than
one
thousand
dollars.
These
damages
shall
12
be
paid
by
the
court
imposing
it
to
the
state
of
Iowa,
if
13
the
body
in
question
is
a
state
governmental
body,
or
to
the
14
local
government
involved
if
the
body
in
question
is
a
local
15
governmental
body.
A
member
of
a
governmental
body
found
to
16
have
violated
this
chapter
shall
not
be
assessed
such
damages
17
if
that
member
proves
that
the
member
did
any
of
the
following:
18
(1)
Voted
against
the
closed
session.
19
(2)
Had
good
reason
to
believe
and
in
good
faith
believed
20
facts
which,
if
true,
would
have
indicated
compliance
with
all
21
the
requirements
of
this
chapter
.
22
(3)
Reasonably
relied
upon
a
decision
of
a
court
,
or
a
23
formal
opinion
of
the
attorney
general
,
or
the
attorney
for
24
the
governmental
body
,
given
in
writing,
or
as
memorialized
in
25
the
minutes
of
the
meeting
at
which
a
formal
oral
opinion
was
26
given,
or
an
advisory
opinion
of
the
attorney
general
or
the
27
attorney
for
the
governmental
body,
given
in
writing
.
28
Sec.
8.
Section
22.7,
subsection
7,
Code
2011,
is
amended
29
to
read
as
follows:
30
7.
Appraisals
or
appraisal
information
concerning
the
sale
31
or
purchase
of
real
or
personal
property
for
public
purposes,
32
prior
to
public
announcement
of
a
project
the
execution
of
any
33
contract
for
such
sale
or
the
submission
of
the
appraisal
to
34
the
property
owner
or
other
interest
holders
as
provided
in
35
-4-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
4/
10
S.F.
289
section
6B.45
.
1
Sec.
9.
Section
22.7,
subsection
10,
Code
2011,
is
amended
2
by
striking
the
subsection.
3
Sec.
10.
Section
22.7,
subsection
11,
Code
2011,
is
amended
4
to
read
as
follows:
5
11.
a.
Personal
information
in
confidential
personnel
6
records
of
public
government
bodies
including
but
not
limited
7
to
cities,
boards
of
supervisors
and
school
districts
relating
8
to
identified
or
identifiable
individuals
who
are
officials,
9
officers,
or
employees
of
the
government
bodies
.
However,
the
10
following
information
relating
to
such
individuals
contained
in
11
personnel
records
shall
be
public
records:
12
(1)
The
name
and
compensation
of
the
individual
including
13
any
written
agreement
establishing
compensation
or
any
other
14
terms
of
employment
excluding
any
information
otherwise
15
excludable
from
public
information
pursuant
to
this
section
or
16
any
other
applicable
provision
of
law.
For
purposes
of
this
17
paragraph,
“compensation”
means
payment
of,
or
agreement
to
pay,
18
any
money,
thing
of
value,
or
financial
benefit
conferred
in
19
return
for
labor
or
services
rendered
by
an
official,
officer,
20
or
employee
plus
the
value
of
benefits
conferred
including
but
21
not
limited
to
casualty,
disability,
life,
or
health
insurance,
22
other
health
or
wellness
benefits,
vacation,
holiday,
and
sick
23
leave,
severance
payments,
retirement
benefits,
and
deferred
24
compensation.
25
(2)
The
dates
the
individual
was
employed
by
the
government
26
body.
27
(3)
The
positions
the
individual
holds
or
has
held
with
the
28
government
body.
29
(4)
The
educational
institutions
attended
by
the
30
individual,
including
any
diplomas
and
degrees
earned,
and
31
the
names
of
the
individual’s
previous
employers,
positions
32
previously
held,
and
dates
of
previous
employment.
33
(5)
The
fact
that
the
individual
was
discharged
as
the
34
result
of
a
final
disciplinary
action
upon
the
exhaustion
of
35
-5-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
5/
10
S.F.
289
all
applicable
contractual,
legal,
and
statutory
remedies.
1
b.
Personal
information
in
confidential
personnel
records
of
2
government
bodies
relating
to
student
employees
shall
only
be
3
released
pursuant
to
20
U.S.C.
§
1232g.
4
Sec.
11.
Section
22.10,
subsection
3,
paragraph
b,
Code
5
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
6
b.
Shall
assess
the
persons
who
participated
in
its
7
violation
damages
in
the
amount
of
not
more
than
five
hundred
8
dollars
nor
and
not
less
than
one
hundred
dollars.
However,
if
9
a
person
knowingly
participated
in
such
a
violation,
damages
10
shall
be
in
the
amount
of
not
more
than
two
thousand
five
11
hundred
dollars
and
not
less
than
one
thousand
dollars.
These
12
damages
shall
be
paid
by
the
court
imposing
them
to
the
state
13
of
Iowa
if
the
body
in
question
is
a
state
government
body,
14
or
to
the
local
government
involved
if
the
body
in
question
15
is
a
local
government
body.
A
person
found
to
have
violated
16
this
chapter
shall
not
be
assessed
such
damages
if
that
person
17
proves
that
the
person
either
voted
did
any
of
the
following:
18
(1)
Voted
against
the
action
violating
this
chapter
,
19
refused
to
participate
in
the
action
violating
this
chapter
,
or
20
engaged
in
reasonable
efforts
under
the
circumstances
to
resist
21
or
prevent
the
action
in
violation
of
this
chapter
;
had
.
22
(2)
Had
good
reason
to
believe
and
in
good
faith
believed
23
facts
which,
if
true,
would
have
indicated
compliance
with
the
24
requirements
of
this
chapter
;
or
reasonably
.
25
(3)
Reasonably
relied
upon
a
decision
of
a
court
or
an
,
a
26
formal
opinion
of
the
attorney
general
,
or
the
attorney
for
27
the
government
body
,
given
in
writing,
or
as
memorialized
in
28
the
minutes
of
the
meeting
at
which
a
formal
oral
opinion
was
29
given,
or
an
advisory
opinion
of
the
attorney
general
or
the
30
attorney
for
the
government
body,
given
in
writing
.
31
Sec.
12.
Section
22.10,
subsection
5,
Code
2011,
is
amended
32
by
striking
the
subsection.
33
Sec.
13.
Section
22.13,
Code
2011,
is
amended
by
striking
34
the
section
and
inserting
in
lieu
thereof
the
following:
35
-6-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
6/
10
S.F.
289
22.13
Settlements
——
government
bodies.
1
When
a
government
body
or
a
unit
or
official
of
a
government
2
body
reaches
a
final,
binding,
written
settlement
agreement
3
that
resolves
a
legal
dispute
claiming
monetary
damages,
4
equitable
relief,
or
a
violation
of
a
rule
or
statute,
the
5
government
body
shall,
upon
request
and
to
the
extent
allowed
6
under
applicable
law,
prepare
a
brief
summary
of
the
resolution
7
of
the
dispute
indicating
the
identity
of
the
parties
involved,
8
the
nature
of
the
dispute,
and
the
terms
of
the
settlement,
9
including
any
payments
made
by
or
on
behalf
of
the
government
10
body
and
any
actions
to
be
taken
by
the
government
body.
A
11
government
body
is
not
required
to
prepare
a
summary
if
the
12
settlement
agreement
includes
the
information
required
to
be
13
included
in
the
summary.
The
settlement
agreement
and
any
14
required
summary
shall
be
a
public
record.
15
Sec.
14.
Section
22.14,
subsection
3,
Code
2011,
is
amended
16
to
read
as
follows:
17
3.
If
a
fiduciary
or
other
third
party
with
custody
of
18
public
investment
transactions
records
fails
to
produce
public
19
records
within
a
reasonable
period
of
time
as
requested
by
the
20
public
body,
the
public
body
shall
make
no
new
investments
21
with
or
through
the
fiduciary
or
other
third
party
and
shall
22
not
renew
existing
investments
upon
their
maturity
with
or
23
through
the
fiduciary
or
other
third
party.
The
fiduciary
or
24
other
third
party
shall
be
liable
for
the
penalties
imposed
25
under
section
22.6
statute,
common
law,
or
contract
due
to
the
26
acts
or
omissions
of
the
fiduciary
or
other
third
party
and
27
any
other
remedies
available
under
statute,
common
law,
or
28
contract
.
29
Sec.
15.
Section
455K.4,
subsection
4,
Code
2011,
is
amended
30
to
read
as
follows:
31
4.
Information
that
is
disclosed
under
subsection
2
,
32
paragraph
“b”
,
is
confidential
and
is
not
subject
to
disclosure
33
under
chapter
22
.
A
governmental
entity,
governmental
34
employee,
or
governmental
official
who
discloses
information
in
35
-7-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
7/
10
S.F.
289
violation
of
this
subsection
is
subject
to
the
penalty
provided
1
in
section
22.6
.
2
Sec.
16.
REPEAL.
Section
22.6,
Code
2011,
is
repealed.
3
Sec.
17.
EFFECTIVE
UPON
ENACTMENT.
This
Act,
being
deemed
4
of
immediate
importance,
takes
effect
upon
enactment.
5
EXPLANATION
6
This
bill
relates
to
Iowa’s
Open
Meetings
Law
(Code
chapter
7
21)
and
Iowa’s
Open
Records
Law
(Code
chapter
22).
8
MEETINGS.
The
bill
provides
that
except
as
otherwise
9
provided,
a
reconvened
meeting
of
a
governmental
body
is
also
10
subject
to
the
meeting
notice
requirements
pursuant
to
Code
11
section
21.4.
This
requirement
does
not
apply
to
a
meeting
of
12
a
governmental
body
that
is
reconvened
within
four
hours
of
the
13
start
of
its
recess,
where
an
announcement
of
the
time,
date,
14
and
place
of
the
reconvened
meeting
is
made
at
the
original
15
meeting
in
open
session
and
recorded
in
the
minutes
of
the
16
meeting
and
there
is
no
change
in
the
agenda.
The
notice
17
requirement
also
does
not
apply
to
a
meeting
held
by
a
formally
18
constituted
subunit
of
a
parent
governmental
body
during
a
19
lawful
meeting
of
the
parent
governmental
body
or
during
a
20
recess
in
that
meeting
of
up
to
four
hours,
or
a
meeting
of
21
that
subunit
immediately
following
the
meeting
of
the
parent
22
governmental
body,
if
the
meeting
of
the
subunit
is
publicly
23
announced
in
open
session
at
the
parent
meeting
and
the
subject
24
of
the
meeting
reasonably
coincides
with
the
subjects
discussed
25
or
acted
upon
by
the
parent
governmental
body.
The
bill
also
26
changes
all
references
relating
to
“tape”
recordings
of
closed
27
meetings
to
“audio”
recordings.
28
CIVIL
AND
CRIMINAL
PENALTY
PROVISIONS.
The
bill
increases
29
the
civil
penalty
damage
amounts
for
violations
of
the
open
30
meetings
and
public
records
laws
for
each
member
of
the
31
governmental
body
or
each
person
who
knowingly
participated
in
32
the
violation
from
not
less
than
$100
and
not
more
than
$500
to
33
not
less
than
$1,000
and
not
more
than
$2,500
subject
to
the
34
existing
defenses
contained
in
Code
sections
21.6
and
22.10.
35
-8-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
8/
10
S.F.
289
The
bill
retains
the
current
civil
penalty
damage
amounts
for
1
such
violations
for
each
member
of
the
governmental
body
or
2
each
person
who
participated
in
the
violation
($100
to
$500).
3
The
bill
repeals
the
criminal
penalty
provision
for
knowing
4
violations
or
attempts
to
violate
any
provisions
of
the
public
5
records
law.
6
APPRAISAL
INFORMATION.
Current
law
provides
that
appraisal
7
or
appraisal
information
concerning
the
purchase
of
real
8
or
personal
property
for
public
purposes,
prior
to
public
9
announcement
of
a
project,
shall
be
confidential.
The
bill
10
amends
this
law
to
provide
that
such
information
shall
remain
11
confidential
prior
to
execution
of
any
contract
for
such
sale
12
or
the
submission
of
the
appraisal
to
the
property
owner
or
13
other
interest
holders
as
provided
in
Code
section
6B.45.
14
PERSONAL
INFORMATION
IN
CONFIDENTIAL
PERSONNEL
RECORDS.
15
Current
law
provides
that
personal
information
in
confidential
16
personnel
records
of
government
bodies
shall
be
confidential,
17
unless
otherwise
ordered
by
a
court,
by
the
lawful
custodian,
18
or
by
another
duly
authorized
person
to
release
such
19
information.
The
bill
specifies
that
the
name
and
compensation
20
of
the
individual,
the
date
the
individual
was
employed
by
the
21
government
body,
the
positions
the
individual
holds
or
has
held
22
with
the
government
body,
the
individual’s
qualifications
for
23
the
position
that
the
individual
holds
or
has
held
including
24
but
not
limited
to
educational
background
and
work
experience
25
and
the
fact
that
the
individual
was
discharged
as
a
result
26
of
a
final
disciplinary
action
upon
the
exhaustion
of
all
27
applicable
contractual,
legal,
and
statutory
remedies
shall
be
28
public
records.
29
SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENTS.
Code
chapter
22
currently
provides
30
that
a
written
summary
of
the
terms
of
settlement
or
other
31
disposition
of
any
claim
for
damages
made
against
any
32
government
body
or
against
an
employee,
officer,
or
agent
of
33
a
government
body,
by
an
insurer
pursuant
to
a
contract
of
34
liability
insurance
issued
to
the
government
body,
shall
be
35
-9-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
9/
10
S.F.
289
filed
with
the
government
body
and
shall
be
a
public
record.
1
The
bill
provides
that
when
a
government
body
or
a
unit
or
2
official
of
a
government
body
reaches
a
final,
binding,
written
3
settlement
agreement
that
resolves
a
legal
dispute
claiming
4
monetary
damages,
equitable
relief,
or
a
violation
of
a
rule
5
or
statute,
the
government
body
shall,
upon
request
and
to
the
6
extent
allowed
under
applicable
law,
prepare
a
brief
summary
7
of
the
resolution
of
the
dispute
indicating
the
identity
of
8
the
parties
involved,
the
nature
of
the
dispute,
and
the
terms
9
of
the
settlement,
including
any
payments
made
by
or
on
behalf
10
of
the
government
body
and
any
actions
to
be
taken
by
the
11
government
body.
A
government
body
is
not
required
to
prepare
12
a
summary
if
the
settlement
agreement
includes
the
information
13
required
to
be
included
in
the
summary.
The
settlement
14
agreement
and
any
required
summary
shall
be
a
public
record.
15
EFFECTIVE
DATE.
The
bill
takes
effect
upon
enactment.
16
-10-
LSB
1488SV
(3)
84
rh/rj
10/
10