House
Resolution
3
-
Introduced
HOUSE
RESOLUTION
NO.
3
BY
WATTS
,
MASSIE
,
CHAMBERS
,
BYRNES
,
BAUDLER
,
FORRISTALL
,
L.
MILLER
,
SODERBERG
,
DEYOE
,
S.
OLSON
,
DRAKE
,
RAYHONS
,
SWEENEY
,
BRANDENBURG
,
and
WORTHAN
A
Resolution
relating
to
the
regulation
of
intrastate
1
waters.
2
WHEREAS,
the
Tenth
Amendment
to
the
United
States
3
Constitution
provides
powers
not
granted
to
the
4
federal
government
nor
prohibited
to
the
states
by
the
5
Constitution
are
reserved
to
the
states,
establishing
6
federalism
and
state
sovereignty
as
integral
founding
7
principles
of
American
government;
and
8
WHEREAS,
the
United
States
Supreme
Court
in
Solid
9
Waste
Agency
of
Northern
Cook
County
v.
United
States
10
Army
Corps
of
Engineers,
531
U.S.
159
(2001)
and
in
11
Rapanos
v.
United
States,
547
U.S.
715
(2006)
held
that
12
the
federal
Water
Pollution
Control
Act
(the
Clean
13
Water
Act)
did
not
intend
to
grant
federal
authority
14
over
intrastate
waters
and
that
intrastate
waters
were
15
not
subject
to
regulation
under
the
interstate
commerce
16
clause;
and
17
WHEREAS,
legislation
has
previously
been
introduced
18
in
the
United
States
Congress
to
expand
the
Clean
Water
19
Act’s
jurisdiction
to
include
intrastate
waters;
and
20
WHEREAS,
the
expanded
jurisdiction
under
the
21
proposed
legislation
would
grant
the
United
States
22
Environmental
Protection
Agency
broad
and
vague
23
flexibility
to
interpret
federal
jurisdiction
24
expansively,
which
the
agency
attempted
to
do
under
the
25
current
Clean
Water
Act
and
which
the
United
States
26
-1-
LSB
1636YH
(4)
84
tm/rj
1/
2
H.R.
3
Supreme
Court
prevented
the
agency
from
doing;
and
27
WHEREAS,
the
proposed
expanded
jurisdiction
would
28
severely
diminish
state
sovereignty
over
its
natural
1
resources,
and
would
detrimentally
involve
the
federal
2
government
in
an
inefficient
and
cumbersome
effort
3
to
regulate
highly
localized
water
resources
such
as
4
abandoned
pits
and
ponds;
and
5
WHEREAS,
jurisdiction
over
intrastate
water
6
resources
is
a
role
traditionally
held
by
individual
7
state
governments
in
order
to
promote
efficient
and
8
effective
usage
of
intrastate
water
resources;
NOW
9
THEREFORE,
10
BE
IT
RESOLVED
BY
THE
HOUSE
OF
REPRESENTATIVES,
That
11
the
State
of
Iowa
supports
the
continued
sovereignty
12
and
jurisdiction
of
the
states
to
regulate
intrastate
13
water
resources
and
opposes
any
attempt
by
the
federal
14
government
to
diminish
this
jurisdiction
unnecessarily.
15
-2-
LSB
1636YH
(4)
84
tm/rj
2/
2