House
File
657
-
Introduced
HOUSE
FILE
657
BY
COMMITTEE
ON
GOVERNMENT
OVERSIGHT
(SUCCESSOR
TO
HF
5)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
abortions
including
prohibiting
late-term
1
abortions
with
certain
exceptions,
providing
penalties,
and
2
including
an
effective
date
provision.
3
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
4
TLSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
H.F.
657
Section
1.
FINDINGS.
The
general
assembly
finds
all
of
the
1
following:
2
1.
Abortion
can
cause
serious
short-term
and
long-term
3
physical
and
psychological
complications
for
women
including
4
but
not
limited
to
uterine
perforation,
uterine
scarring,
5
cervical
perforation
or
other
injury,
infection,
bleeding,
6
hemorrhage,
blood
clots,
failure
to
actually
terminate
the
7
pregnancy,
incomplete
abortion
or
retained
tissue,
pelvic
8
inflammatory
disease,
endometritis,
missed
ectopic
pregnancy,
9
cardiac
arrest,
respiratory
arrest,
renal
failure,
metabolic
10
disorder,
shock,
embolism,
coma,
placenta
previa
in
subsequent
11
pregnancies,
preterm
delivery
in
subsequent
pregnancies,
12
free
fluid
in
the
abdomen,
organ
damage,
adverse
reactions
13
to
anesthesia
and
other
drugs,
psychological
or
emotional
14
complications
such
as
depression,
anxiety,
sleeping
disorders,
15
and
death.
16
2.
Abortion
has
a
higher
medical
risk
when
the
procedure
is
17
performed
later
in
the
pregnancy.
Compared
to
an
abortion
at
18
eight
weeks’
gestation
or
earlier,
the
relative
risk
increases
19
exponentially
at
higher
gestations.
The
incidence
of
major
20
complications
is
highest
after
twenty
weeks
of
gestation.
21
3.
The
state
has
a
legitimate
concern
for
the
public’s
22
health
and
safety.
23
4.
The
state
has
a
legitimate
interest
from
the
outset
24
of
pregnancy
in
protecting
the
health
of
the
woman.
More
25
specifically,
the
state
has
a
legitimate
concern
with
the
26
health
of
women
who
undergo
abortions.
27
5.
There
is
substantial
evidence
that
by
at
least
twenty
28
weeks
after
fertilization,
an
unborn
child
has
the
physical
29
structures
necessary
to
experience
pain.
30
6.
There
is
substantial
evidence
that
by
twenty
weeks
31
after
fertilization,
an
unborn
child
seeks
to
evade
certain
32
stimuli
in
a
manner
which,
in
an
infant
or
an
adult,
would
be
33
interpreted
as
a
response
to
pain.
34
7.
Anesthesia
is
routinely
administered
to
an
unborn
child
35
-1-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
1/
10
H.F.
657
twenty
weeks
or
more
after
fertilization
when
the
unborn
child
1
undergoes
prenatal
surgery.
2
8.
Even
before
twenty
weeks
after
fertilization,
the
unborn
3
child
has
been
observed
to
exhibit
hormonal
stress
responses
to
4
painful
stimuli,
and
a
reduction
in
such
response
results
when
5
pain
medication
is
administered
directly
to
the
unborn
child.
6
9.
It
is
the
purpose
of
the
state
of
Iowa
to
assert
a
7
compelling
state
interest
in
protecting
the
unborn
child
from
8
the
stage
at
which
substantial
medical
evidence
indicates
the
9
unborn
child
is
capable
of
feeling
pain.
10
Sec.
2.
NEW
SECTION
.
146A.1
Definitions.
11
As
used
in
this
chapter
unless
the
context
otherwise
12
requires:
13
1.
“Abortion”
means
abortion
as
defined
in
section
146.1.
14
2.
“Attempt
to
perform
or
induce
an
abortion”
means
an
act,
15
or
an
omission
of
a
statutorily
required
act,
that,
under
the
16
circumstances
as
the
actor
believes
them
to
be,
constitutes
a
17
substantial
step
in
a
course
of
conduct
planned
to
culminate
in
18
the
performance
or
inducing
of
an
abortion.
19
3.
“Department”
means
the
department
of
public
health.
20
4.
“Fertilization”
means
the
fusion
of
a
human
spermatozoon
21
with
a
human
ovum.
22
5.
“Medical
emergency”
means
a
condition
which,
in
23
reasonable
medical
judgment,
so
complicates
the
medical
24
condition
of
a
pregnant
woman
as
to
necessitate
the
immediate
25
abortion
of
the
human
pregnancy
to
avert
the
woman’s
death
or
26
for
which
a
delay
will
create
a
serious
risk
of
substantial
and
27
irreversible
physical
impairment
of
a
major
bodily
function.
28
“Medical
emergency”
does
not
include
a
condition
which
is
based
29
on
a
claim
or
diagnosis
that
the
pregnant
woman
will
engage
in
30
conduct
which
would
result
in
the
pregnant
woman’s
death
or
in
31
substantial
and
irreversible
physical
impairment
of
a
major
32
bodily
function.
33
6.
“Medical
facility”
means
any
public
or
private
hospital,
34
clinic,
center,
medical
school,
medical
training
institution,
35
-2-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
2/
10
H.F.
657
health
care
facility,
physician’s
office,
infirmary,
1
dispensary,
ambulatory
surgical
center,
or
other
institution
or
2
location
where
medical
care
is
provided
to
any
person.
3
7.
“Physician”
means
a
person
licensed
under
chapter
148.
4
8.
“Postfertilization
age”
means
the
age
of
the
unborn
child
5
as
calculated
from
the
fertilization
of
the
human
ovum.
6
9.
“Probable
postfertilization
age”
means
what,
in
7
reasonable
medical
judgment,
will
with
reasonable
probability
8
be
the
postfertilization
age
of
the
unborn
child
at
the
time
9
the
abortion
is
to
be
performed.
10
10.
“Reasonable
medical
judgment”
means
a
medical
judgment
11
made
by
a
reasonably
prudent
physician
who
is
knowledgeable
12
about
the
case
and
the
treatment
possibilities
with
respect
to
13
the
medical
conditions
involved.
14
11.
“Unborn
child”
means
an
individual
organism
of
the
15
species
homo
sapiens
from
fertilization
until
live
birth.
16
Sec.
3.
NEW
SECTION
.
146A.2
Determination
of
17
postfertilization
age
prior
to
abortion
——
abortion
prohibited
18
at
twenty
or
more
weeks
postfertilization
age
——
exceptions
——
19
reporting
requirements
——
penalties.
20
1.
Except
in
the
case
of
a
medical
emergency,
an
abortion
21
shall
not
be
performed
or
induced
or
be
attempted
to
be
22
performed
or
induced
unless
the
physician
performing
or
23
inducing
the
abortion
has
first
made
a
determination
of
the
24
probable
postfertilization
age
of
the
unborn
child
or
relied
25
upon
such
a
determination
made
by
another
physician.
In
making
26
such
a
determination,
a
physician
shall
make
such
inquiries
27
of
the
pregnant
woman
and
perform
or
cause
to
be
performed
28
such
medical
examinations
and
tests
the
physician
considers
29
necessary
in
making
a
reasonable
medical
judgment
to
accurately
30
determine
the
postfertilization
age
of
the
unborn
child.
31
2.
a.
A
physician
shall
not
perform
or
induce
or
attempt
32
to
perform
or
induce
an
abortion
upon
a
pregnant
woman
when
it
33
has
been
determined,
by
the
physician
performing
or
inducing
34
the
abortion
or
by
another
physician
upon
whose
determination
35
-3-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
3/
10
H.F.
657
that
physician
relies,
that
the
probable
postfertilization
age
1
of
the
unborn
child
is
twenty
or
more
weeks
unless,
in
the
2
physician’s
reasonable
medical
judgment,
any
of
the
following
3
applies:
4
(1)
The
pregnant
woman
has
a
condition
which
the
physician
5
deems
a
medical
emergency.
6
(2)
It
is
necessary
to
preserve
the
life
of
an
unborn
child.
7
b.
If
an
abortion
is
performed
or
induced
under
this
8
subsection,
the
physician
shall
terminate
the
human
pregnancy
9
in
the
manner
which,
in
the
physician’s
reasonable
medical
10
judgment,
provides
the
best
opportunity
for
the
unborn
child
11
to
survive,
unless,
in
the
physician’s
reasonable
medical
12
judgment,
termination
of
the
human
pregnancy
in
that
manner
13
would
pose
a
greater
risk
than
any
other
available
method
of
14
the
death
of
the
pregnant
woman
or
of
the
substantial
and
15
irreversible
physical
impairment
of
a
major
bodily
function.
16
A
greater
risk
shall
not
be
deemed
to
exist
if
it
is
based
on
17
a
claim
or
diagnosis
that
the
pregnant
woman
will
engage
in
18
conduct
which
would
result
in
the
pregnant
woman’s
death
or
in
19
substantial
and
irreversible
physical
impairment
of
a
major
20
bodily
function.
21
c.
An
abortion
performed
or
induced
under
this
subsection
22
shall
be
performed
or
induced
in
a
medical
facility
that
23
provides
the
appropriate
level
of
perinatal
care
as
specified
24
in
641
IAC
150.
25
3.
A
physician
who
performs
or
induces
or
attempts
to
26
perform
or
induce
an
abortion
shall
report
to
the
department,
27
on
a
schedule
and
in
accordance
with
forms
and
rules
adopted
by
28
the
department,
all
of
the
following:
29
a.
If
a
determination
of
probable
postfertilization
age
of
30
the
unborn
child
was
made,
the
probable
postfertilization
age
31
determined
and
the
method
and
basis
of
the
determination.
32
b.
If
a
determination
of
probable
postfertilization
age
of
33
the
unborn
child
was
not
made,
the
basis
of
the
determination
34
that
a
medical
emergency
existed.
35
-4-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
4/
10
H.F.
657
c.
If
the
probable
postfertilization
age
of
the
unborn
1
child
was
determined
to
be
twenty
or
more
weeks,
the
basis
of
2
the
determination
of
a
medical
emergency,
or
the
basis
of
the
3
determination
that
the
abortion
was
necessary
to
preserve
the
4
life
of
an
unborn
child.
5
d.
The
method
used
for
the
abortion
and,
in
the
case
of
6
an
abortion
performed
when
the
probable
postfertilization
age
7
was
determined
to
be
twenty
or
more
weeks,
whether
the
method
8
of
abortion
used
was
one
that,
in
the
physician’s
reasonable
9
medical
judgment,
provided
the
best
opportunity
for
the
unborn
10
child
to
survive
or,
if
such
a
method
was
not
used,
the
basis
11
of
the
determination
that
termination
of
the
human
pregnancy
12
in
that
manner
would
pose
a
greater
risk
than
would
any
other
13
available
method
of
the
death
of
the
pregnant
woman
or
of
the
14
substantial
and
irreversible
physical
impairment
of
a
major
15
bodily
function.
16
4.
a.
By
June
30,
annually,
the
department
shall
issue
a
17
public
report
providing
statistics
for
the
previous
calendar
18
year,
compiled
from
the
reports
for
that
year
submitted
in
19
accordance
with
subsection
3.
The
department
shall
ensure
that
20
none
of
the
information
included
in
the
public
reports
could
21
reasonably
lead
to
the
identification
of
any
woman
upon
whom
an
22
abortion
was
performed.
23
b.
(1)
A
physician
who
fails
to
submit
a
report
by
the
end
24
of
thirty
days
following
the
due
date
shall
be
subject
to
a
25
late
fee
of
five
hundred
dollars
for
each
additional
thirty-day
26
period
or
portion
of
a
thirty-day
period
the
report
is
overdue.
27
(2)
A
physician
required
to
report
in
accordance
with
28
subsection
3
who
has
not
submitted
a
report
or
who
has
29
submitted
only
an
incomplete
report
more
than
one
year
30
following
the
due
date,
may,
in
an
action
brought
in
the
31
manner
in
which
actions
are
brought
to
enforce
chapter
148,
32
be
directed
by
a
court
of
competent
jurisdiction
to
submit
a
33
complete
report
within
a
time
period
stated
by
court
order
or
34
be
subject
to
contempt
of
court.
35
-5-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
5/
10
H.F.
657
(3)
A
physician
who
intentionally
or
recklessly
falsifies
1
a
report
required
under
this
section
is
subject
to
a
civil
2
penalty
of
one
hundred
dollars.
3
5.
Any
medical
facility
in
which
a
physician
is
authorized
4
to
perform
an
abortion
shall
implement
written
medical
5
policies
and
procedures
consistent
with
the
requirements
and
6
prohibitions
of
this
chapter.
7
6.
The
department
shall
adopt
rules
to
implement
this
8
section.
9
Sec.
4.
NEW
SECTION
.
146A.3
Civil
and
criminal
actions
10
——
penalties.
11
1.
Failure
of
a
physician
to
comply
with
any
provision
of
12
section
146A.2,
with
the
exception
of
the
late
filing
of
a
13
report
or
failure
to
submit
a
complete
report
in
compliance
14
with
a
court
order,
is
grounds
for
license
discipline
under
15
chapter
148.
16
2.
A
physician
who
intentionally
or
recklessly
performs
or
17
attempts
to
perform
an
abortion
in
violation
of
this
chapter
is
18
guilty
of
a
class
“C”
felony.
19
3.
A
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
has
been
performed
in
20
violation
of
this
chapter
or
the
biological
father
may
maintain
21
an
action
against
the
physician
who
performed
the
abortion
in
22
intentional
or
reckless
violation
of
this
chapter
for
actual
23
damages.
This
subsection
shall
not
be
interpreted
to
apply
to
24
a
biological
father
when
the
pregnancy
is
the
result
of
rape
25
or
incest.
26
4.
A
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
has
been
attempted
in
27
violation
of
this
chapter
may
maintain
an
action
against
the
28
physician
who
attempted
to
perform
the
abortion
in
intentional
29
or
reckless
violation
of
this
chapter
for
actual
damages.
30
5.
A
cause
of
action
for
injunctive
relief
to
prevent
a
31
physician
from
performing
abortions
may
be
maintained
against
a
32
physician
who
has
intentionally
violated
this
chapter
by
the
33
woman
upon
whom
the
abortion
was
performed
or
attempted
to
be
34
performed,
by
the
spouse
of
the
woman,
by
a
parent
or
guardian
35
-6-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
6/
10
H.F.
657
of
the
woman
if
the
woman
is
less
than
eighteen
years
of
age
or
1
unmarried
at
the
time
the
abortion
was
performed
or
attempted
2
to
be
performed,
by
a
current
or
former
licensed
health
care
3
provider
of
the
woman,
by
a
county
attorney
with
appropriate
4
jurisdiction,
or
by
the
attorney
general.
5
6.
A
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
was
performed
or
was
6
attempted
to
be
performed
shall
not
be
subject
to
prosecution
7
for
a
violation
of
this
chapter.
8
7.
If
the
plaintiff
prevails
in
an
action
brought
under
9
this
section,
the
plaintiff
shall
be
entitled
to
an
award
for
10
reasonable
attorney
fees.
11
8.
If
the
defendant
prevails
in
an
action
brought
under
12
this
section
and
the
court
finds
that
the
plaintiff’s
suit
was
13
frivolous
and
brought
in
bad
faith,
the
defendant
shall
be
14
entitled
to
an
award
for
reasonable
attorney
fees.
15
9.
Damages
and
attorney
fees
shall
not
be
assessed
against
16
the
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
was
performed
or
attempted
to
17
be
performed
except
as
provided
in
subsection
8.
18
10.
In
a
civil
or
criminal
proceeding
or
action
brought
19
under
this
chapter,
the
court
shall
rule
whether
the
anonymity
20
of
any
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
has
been
performed
or
21
attempted
shall
be
preserved
from
public
disclosure
if
the
22
woman
does
not
provide
consent
to
such
disclosure.
The
court,
23
upon
motion
or
on
its
own
motion,
shall
make
such
a
ruling
24
and,
upon
determining
that
the
woman’s
anonymity
should
be
25
preserved,
shall
issue
orders
to
the
parties,
witnesses,
26
and
counsel
and
shall
direct
the
sealing
of
the
record
and
27
exclusion
of
individuals
from
courtrooms
or
hearing
rooms
to
28
the
extent
necessary
to
safeguard
the
woman’s
identity
from
29
public
disclosure.
Each
such
order
shall
be
accompanied
by
30
specific
written
findings
explaining
why
the
anonymity
of
the
31
woman
should
be
preserved
from
public
disclosure,
why
the
32
order
is
essential
to
that
end,
how
the
order
is
narrowly
33
tailored
to
serve
that
interest,
and
why
no
reasonable
less
34
restrictive
alternative
exists.
In
the
absence
of
written
35
-7-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
7/
10
H.F.
657
consent
of
the
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
has
been
performed
1
or
attempted,
anyone,
other
than
a
public
official,
who
brings
2
an
action
under
this
section
shall
do
so
under
a
pseudonym.
3
This
subsection
shall
not
be
construed
to
conceal
the
identity
4
of
the
plaintiff
or
of
witnesses
from
the
defendant
or
from
5
attorneys
for
the
defendant.
6
Sec.
5.
NEW
SECTION
.
146A.4
Construction.
7
1.
Nothing
in
this
chapter
shall
be
construed
as
creating
or
8
recognizing
a
right
to
an
abortion.
9
2.
Nothing
in
this
chapter
shall
be
construed
as
determining
10
life
to
begin
at
twenty
weeks’
gestation.
Instead,
it
is
11
recognized
that
life
begins
at
fertilization.
12
Sec.
6.
NEW
SECTION
.
146A.5
Severability
clause.
13
If
any
provision
of
this
chapter
or
its
application
to
any
14
person
or
circumstance
is
held
invalid,
the
invalidity
does
15
not
affect
other
provisions
or
application
of
this
chapter
16
which
can
be
given
effect
without
the
invalid
provision
or
17
application,
and
to
this
end
the
provisions
of
this
chapter
are
18
severable.
19
Sec.
7.
EFFECTIVE
UPON
ENACTMENT.
This
Act,
being
deemed
of
20
immediate
importance,
takes
effect
upon
enactment.
21
EXPLANATION
22
This
bill
relates
to
abortions.
The
bill
provides
findings
23
of
the
general
assembly
and
definitions.
24
The
bill
provides
that,
except
in
the
case
of
a
medical
25
emergency,
an
abortion
shall
not
be
performed
or
induced
26
or
be
attempted
to
be
performed
or
induced
unless
the
27
physician
performing
or
inducing
the
abortion
has
first
made
28
a
determination
of
the
probable
postfertilization
age
of
the
29
unborn
child.
Additionally,
the
bill
prohibits
a
physician
30
from
performing
or
inducing
or
attempting
to
perform
or
induce
31
an
abortion
upon
a
pregnant
woman
when
it
has
been
determined,
32
that
the
probable
postfertilization
age
is
20
or
more
weeks
33
unless,
in
the
physician’s
reasonable
medical
judgment,
either
34
the
pregnant
woman
has
a
condition
which
the
physician
deems
a
35
-8-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
8/
10
H.F.
657
medical
emergency
or
it
is
necessary
to
preserve
the
life
of
1
the
unborn
child.
If
an
abortion
is
performed
or
induced
when
2
the
probable
postfertilization
age
is
20
or
more
weeks,
the
3
physician
is
required
to
terminate
the
pregnancy
in
a
manner
4
which,
in
the
physician’s
reasonable
medical
judgment,
provides
5
the
best
opportunity
for
the
unborn
child
to
survive
unless
6
such
termination
would
pose
a
greater
risk
either
of
the
death
7
of
the
pregnant
woman
or
of
the
substantial
and
irreversible
8
physical
impairment
of
a
major
bodily
function
of
the
woman
9
than
would
another
available
method.
10
The
bill
also
requires
certain
reports
to
be
filed
by
a
11
physician
who
performs
or
induces
or
attempts
to
perform
or
12
induce
an
abortion
with
the
department
of
public
health,
on
13
a
schedule
and
in
accordance
with
forms
and
rules
adopted
by
14
the
department.
The
department
is
required
to
compile
the
15
information
collected
annually
and
issue
a
public
report,
16
ensuring
that
none
of
the
information
included
in
the
public
17
reports
could
reasonably
lead
to
the
identification
of
any
18
pregnant
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
was
performed.
The
bill
19
provides
monetary
penalties
for
a
physician
who
fails
to
submit
20
a
report
in
a
timely
manner,
submits
an
incomplete
report,
or
21
intentionally
or
recklessly
falsifies
a
required
report.
22
The
bill
provides
for
civil
and
criminal
actions
and
23
penalties
relating
to
violations
of
the
bill.
Failure
of
a
24
physician
to
comply
with
any
provision,
with
the
exception
of
25
the
late
filing
of
a
report
or
failure
to
submit
a
complete
26
report
in
compliance
with
a
court
order,
is
grounds
for
license
27
discipline.
A
physician
who
intentionally
or
recklessly
28
performs
or
attempts
to
perform
an
abortion
in
violation
of
29
the
bill
is
guilty
of
a
class
“C”
felony,
which
is
punishable
30
by
confinement
for
no
more
than
10
years
and
a
fine
of
at
31
least
$1,000
but
not
more
than
$10,000.
However,
the
woman
32
upon
whom
the
abortion
was
performed
or
was
attempted
to
be
33
performed
is
not
subject
to
prosecution
for
a
violation
of
34
the
bill.
The
bill
provides
for
the
maintaining
of
actions
35
-9-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
9/
10
H.F.
657
by
certain
people
based
on
alleged
violations
of
the
bill.
A
1
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
has
been
performed
in
violation
2
of
the
bill
or
the
biological
father
may
maintain
an
action
3
against
the
physician
who
performed
the
abortion
in
intentional
4
or
reckless
violation
of
the
bill
for
actual
damages.
However,
5
the
bill
is
not
to
be
interpreted
to
apply
to
a
biological
6
father
when
the
pregnancy
is
the
result
of
rape
or
incest.
A
7
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
has
been
attempted
in
violation
8
of
the
bill
may
maintain
an
action
against
the
physician
who
9
attempted
to
perform
the
abortion
in
intentional
or
reckless
10
violation
of
the
bill
for
actual
damages.
Additionally,
a
11
cause
of
action
for
injunctive
relief
to
prevent
a
physician
12
from
performing
abortions
may
be
maintained
against
a
physician
13
who
has
intentionally
violated
the
bill
by
the
woman
upon
whom
14
the
abortion
was
performed
or
attempted
to
be
performed,
by
the
15
spouse
of
the
woman,
by
a
parent
or
guardian
of
the
woman
if
16
the
woman
is
less
than
18
years
of
age
or
unmarried
at
the
time
17
the
abortion
was
performed
or
attempted
to
be
performed,
by
a
18
current
or
former
licensed
health
care
provider
of
the
woman,
19
by
a
county
attorney
with
appropriate
jurisdiction,
or
by
the
20
attorney
general.
21
The
bill
provides
a
process
for
preserving
the
anonymity
of
22
the
woman
upon
whom
an
abortion
has
been
performed
or
attempted
23
from
public
disclosure
if
the
woman
does
not
provide
consent
to
24
such
disclosure
during
any
proceeding
or
action
under
the
bill.
25
The
bill
also
provides
that
the
bill
is
not
to
be
construed
26
as
creating
or
recognizing
a
right
to
an
abortion,
and
the
27
bill
is
not
to
be
construed
as
determining
life
to
begin
at
20
28
weeks’
gestation;
instead,
it
is
recognized
that
life
begins
29
at
fertilization.
30
The
bill
includes
a
severability
clause
as
is
applicable
to
31
every
Act
or
statute
pursuant
to
Code
section
4.12.
32
The
bill
takes
effect
upon
enactment.
33
-10-
LSB
1155HV
(3)
84
pf/nh
10/
10