Senate
Study
Bill
3207
-
Introduced
SENATE
FILE
_____
BY
(PROPOSED
COMMITTEE
ON
COMMERCE
BILL
BY
CHAIRPERSON
WARNSTADT)
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
prohibiting
price
discrimination
in
the
provision
of
1
television
services,
and
providing
remedies.
2
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
3
TLSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
S.F.
_____
Section
1.
NEW
SECTION
.
553A.1
Definitions.
1
As
used
in
this
chapter,
unless
the
context
otherwise
2
requires:
3
1.
“Distributor”
means
a
person
who
is
engaged
in
the
4
business
of
making
available
to
subscribers
or
other
customers,
5
for
a
fee,
multiple
channels
of
television
programming.
6
“Distributor”
includes
any
buying
group
of
which
a
distributor
7
is
a
member,
or
an
agent
of
a
distributor.
8
2.
“Price”
means
the
effective
net
cost
to
the
distributor,
9
calculated
on
a
per
subscriber
or
per
customer
basis,
for
10
permission
to
transmit
the
television
service
in
question,
11
taking
into
account
all
compensation,
agreements
not
to
12
collect,
concessions,
or
other
consideration,
whether
13
guaranteed
or
contingent,
directly
or
indirectly
promised
to
or
14
received
by
the
distributor
or
any
of
its
affiliates
from
or
15
on
behalf
of
the
programmer
and
also
taking
into
account
all
16
fees
and
charges
imposed
upon
such
distributor
or
any
of
its
17
affiliates
for
such
permission.
If
the
distributor
and
its
18
affiliates
pay
different
fees
or
charges
in
different
systems
19
or
markets
for
the
same
television
service
pursuant
to
one
or
20
more
contemporaneous
license
agreements,
then
the
price
shall
21
be
the
subscriber-weighted
average
price
per
subscriber
or
22
customer
unless
use
of
an
average
price
would
be
inconsistent
23
with
the
purposes
of
this
chapter.
24
3.
“Programmer”
means
a
person
who
is
engaged
in
the
25
licensing
or
sale
of
television
programming
to
distributors
and
26
who
owns
or
operates,
or
is
an
affiliate
or
agent
of
the
owner
27
or
operator
of,
one
or
more
of
the
following:
28
a.
A
national
broadcast
television
network.
29
b.
Multiple
television
broadcast
stations.
30
c.
Two
or
more
nonbroadcast
networks,
at
least
one
of
which
31
was
among
the
fifty
highest
rated
nonbroadcast
networks
during
32
prime-time
hours
for
any
four
weeks
during
the
immediately
33
preceding
six
months.
34
4.
“Television
service”
means
programming
intended
for
35
-1-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
1/
8
S.F.
_____
license
for
transmission
by
a
distributor,
regardless
of
1
whether
the
programming
is
packaged
for
viewing
on
a
single
2
television
channel
as
a
discrete
network,
station,
or
service,
3
or
is
to
be
transmitted
by
the
distributor
on
a
pay-per-view,
4
on-demand,
or
other
basis.
5
Sec.
2.
NEW
SECTION
.
553A.2
Prohibited
conduct.
6
1.
a.
A
programmer
shall
not
discriminate,
either
directly
7
or
indirectly,
in
the
price
it
requires
to
be
paid
by
a
8
distributor
for
a
license
or
other
permission
to
transmit
one
9
or
more
television
services
in
this
state
as
compared
to
either
10
of
the
following:
11
(1)
The
price
paid
by
any
other
distributor
for
a
license
12
or
other
permission
to
transmit
such
television
service
or
13
services
in
this
state.
14
(2)
The
price
paid
by
any
other
distributor
for
a
license
15
or
other
permission
to
transmit
such
television
service
16
or
services
in
any
other
state
pursuant
to
any
contract
or
17
agreement
entered
into
on
or
after
July
1,
2010,
or
any
renewal
18
or
extension
of
any
such
agreement.
19
b.
The
prohibition
in
paragraph
“a”
shall
not
prevent
the
20
programmer
from
taking
into
account
differences
in
transmission
21
technologies
and
systems
or
other
similar
objective
differences
22
between
distributors
when
those
differences
have
an
actual
23
effect
on
the
programmer’s
direct
costs
in
making
television
24
services
available
to
a
distributor.
25
2.
When
a
programmer,
either
alone
or
in
combination
26
with
one
or
more
of
its
affiliates,
enters
into
a
license,
27
agreement,
or
arrangement
which
allows
a
distributor
to
28
transmit
two
or
more
television
services
in
this
state,
the
29
price
for
each
television
service
must
be
separately
stated
30
in
writing.
Illegal
price
discrimination
occurs
if
a
price
31
differential
not
otherwise
justifiable
under
this
chapter
32
exists
between
the
price
charged
to
a
distributor
for
any
one
33
or
any
combination
of
the
television
services
covered
by
the
34
agreement
or
arrangement
and
the
price
charged
to
another
35
-2-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
2/
8
S.F.
_____
distributor,
as
described
in
subsection
1,
paragraph
“a”
,
for
1
such
services.
2
3.
When
a
programmer,
either
alone
or
in
combination
3
with
one
or
more
of
its
affiliates,
enters
into
a
license,
4
agreement,
or
arrangement
with
a
distributor
for
transmission
5
of
one
or
more
television
services
in
this
state
and
6
contemporaneously
enters
into
a
separate
transaction
or
7
license,
agreement,
or
arrangement
which
has
the
effect
of
8
reducing
the
net
price
paid
by
the
distributor
below
the
level
9
paid
by
other
distributors
for
permission
to
transmit
the
same
10
television
services
in
this
state,
a
prima
facie
case
of
price
11
discrimination
exists.
12
4.
A
programmer
shall
not,
either
directly
or
indirectly,
13
through
its
affiliates
or
otherwise,
give
to
any
distributor
14
that
transmits
the
programmer’s
television
services
in
15
this
state,
or
to
any
affiliate
of
any
such
distributor,
an
16
advertising
or
launch
support
payment,
channel
positioning
17
payment
or
discount,
penetration
discount
or
allowance,
or
18
similar
compensation
in
exchange
for
the
distributor’s
or
19
affiliate’s
services,
facilities,
performance,
or
achievement
20
relating
to
the
transmission
of
the
programmer’s
television
21
services
in
this
state,
unless
the
programmer
makes
the
same
22
type
or
types
of
compensation
available
on
equal
terms
to
other
23
distributors
who
transmit
the
programmer’s
television
services
24
in
this
state.
25
5.
A
programmer
shall
not,
as
a
condition
to
purchasing
a
26
license
or
other
permission
to
transmit
one
of
the
programmer’s
27
television
services
in
this
state,
either
directly
or
28
indirectly,
through
unjustifiable
price
differentials
or
29
otherwise,
require
that
a
distributor
also
purchase
a
license
30
or
other
permission
to
transmit
one
or
more
additional
31
television
services
of
the
programmer
or
its
affiliates,
or
to
32
dictate
the
level,
package,
or
tier
of
distributor
services
in
33
which
any
such
television
service
must
be
included.
34
6.
In
an
action
brought
for
a
violation
of
this
section,
35
-3-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
3/
8
S.F.
_____
the
programmer
shall
bear
the
burden
of
proving
any
of
the
1
following,
as
applicable:
2
a.
That
the
programmer
experiences
actual
differences,
as
3
described
in
subsection
1,
paragraph
“b”
,
in
its
direct
costs
in
4
making
television
services
available
to
distributors.
5
b.
That
the
contemporaneous
transaction
or
agreement
6
otherwise
prohibited
under
subsection
3
was
the
result
of
bona
7
fide,
independent
negotiation
and
was
not
for
the
purpose
of
8
reducing
the
net
price
to
be
paid
by
the
distributor.
9
c.
That
the
programmer
makes
the
types
of
compensation
10
described
in
subsection
4
available
on
equal
terms
to
all
11
distributors
who
transmit
its
television
services
in
this
12
state.
13
Sec.
3.
NEW
SECTION
.
553A.3
Disclosure
of
information.
14
1.
Beginning
July
1,
2010,
a
programmer
shall
not
enforce
15
against
a
distributor
any
duty
of
confidentiality
regarding
16
the
terms
and
conditions
under
which
the
distributor
transmits
17
the
programmer’s
television
services
in
this
state,
regardless
18
of
whether
the
duty
of
confidentiality
is
express
or
implied,
19
oral
or
written,
or
absolute
or
conditional
and,
if
the
duty
20
is
written,
regardless
of
whether
the
duty
appears
in
the
same
21
writing
that
grants
the
license
or
permission
for
transmission
22
or
instead
appears
in
an
unrelated
writing.
A
contract
23
provision
is
void
if
it
imposes
a
duty
of
confidentiality
that
24
cannot
be
enforced
under
this
subsection.
25
2.
When
a
distributor
seeks
a
license
or
other
permission
to
26
transmit
television
service
within
this
state,
the
programmer
27
at
the
request
of
the
distributor
shall
promptly
disclose
28
to
the
distributor
such
information,
including
information
29
relating
to
or
in
the
possession
of
the
programmer’s
30
affiliates,
as
is
necessary
for
the
distributor
to
determine
31
whether
the
terms
and
conditions
being
offered
by
the
32
programmer
to
the
distributor
comply
with
this
chapter.
33
Sec.
4.
NEW
SECTION
.
553A.4
Withholding
of
programming
——
34
prohibition.
35
-4-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
4/
8
S.F.
_____
A
person
who
licenses
or
otherwise
makes
available
to
1
a
television
station
with
a
transmitter
in
this
state
for
2
broadcast
to
viewers
within
this
state
the
satellite
or
3
terrestrial
feed
of
a
live
sporting
event
or
a
program
that
4
is
part
of
the
prime-time
programming
of
a
national
broadcast
5
network
and
that
is
not
produced
and
owned
by
such
station
6
shall
not
refuse
to
make
such
feed
available,
to
the
maximum
7
extent
permitted
by
applicable
federal
law,
on
reasonable
terms
8
to
any
distributor
in
this
state
who
does
not
carry
the
signal
9
of
such
television
station
or
does
not
have
a
license
or
other
10
right
to
provide
such
telecast
to
its
subscribers
or
other
11
customers.
Any
contractual
or
other
prohibition
or
restriction
12
inconsistent
with
this
section
is
void.
13
Sec.
5.
NEW
SECTION
.
553A.5
Civil
remedies.
14
1.
The
state
or
a
person
who
is
injured
or
threatened
with
15
injury
by
conduct
prohibited
by
this
chapter
may
bring
suit
to
16
prevent
or
enjoin
the
prohibited
conduct.
17
2.
A
person
who
is
injured
by
conduct
prohibited
by
this
18
chapter
may
recover
actual
damages
resulting
from
the
conduct,
19
and
upon
a
finding
that
the
conduct
was
willful
or
flagrant,
20
may
recover
punitive
damages
up
to
three
times
the
amount
of
21
actual
damages.
22
3.
A
person
other
than
the
state
who
obtains
a
remedy
23
under
this
section
may
recover
its
costs
of
bringing
suit
and
24
reasonable
attorney
fees.
25
EXPLANATION
26
This
bill
prohibits
price
discrimination
in
the
provision
27
of
television
services.
28
The
bill
provides
that
a
programmer
shall
not
discriminate,
29
either
directly
or
indirectly,
in
the
price
it
requires
30
a
distributor
to
pay
for
a
license
or
other
permission
to
31
transmit
one
or
more
television
services
in
Iowa,
when
that
32
price
is
compared
to
prices
applicable
to
other
distributors.
33
The
bill
provides,
however,
that
the
price
established
by
a
34
programmer
can
take
into
account
differences
in
transmission
35
-5-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
5/
8
S.F.
_____
technologies
and
systems
or
other
similar
objective
differences
1
between
distributors
when
those
differences
have
an
actual
2
effect
on
the
programmer’s
direct
costs
in
making
television
3
services
available.
4
The
bill
provides
that
when
a
programmer
enters
into
a
5
license,
agreement,
or
arrangement
which
allows
a
distributor
6
to
transmit
two
or
more
television
services
in
Iowa,
the
7
price
for
each
television
service
must
be
separately
stated
8
in
writing,
and
that
illegal
price
discrimination
will
be
9
considered
to
have
occurred
if
a
price
differential
not
10
otherwise
justifiable
pursuant
to
the
bill’s
provisions
exists
11
between
the
price
charged
for
any
one
or
any
combination
12
of
the
television
services
and
the
price
charged
to
other
13
distributors.
The
bill
further
provides
that
when
a
programmer
14
enters
into
a
license,
agreement,
or
arrangement
with
a
15
distributor
for
transmission
of
one
or
more
television
16
services
in
Iowa
and
contemporaneously
enters
into
a
separate
17
transaction
or
license,
agreement,
or
arrangement
which
has
the
18
effect
of
reducing
the
net
price
paid
by
the
distributor
below
19
the
level
paid
by
other
distributors
for
permission
to
transmit
20
the
same
television
services
in
Iowa,
a
prima
facie
case
of
21
price
discrimination
will
be
considered
to
exist.
22
The
bill
prohibits
a
programmer
to
give
to
any
distributor
23
that
transmits
the
programmer’s
television
services
in
Iowa,
or
24
to
any
affiliate,
specified
payments,
discounts,
allowances,
or
25
compensation
in
exchange
for
the
distributor’s
or
affiliate’s
26
services,
facilities,
performance,
or
achievement
relating
to
27
the
transmission
of
the
programmer’s
television
services
in
28
Iowa,
unless
the
programmer
makes
the
same
type
or
types
of
29
compensation
available
on
equal
terms
to
other
distributors.
30
The
bill
also
prohibits
a
programmer,
as
a
condition
to
31
purchasing
a
license
or
other
permission
to
transmit
one
of
32
the
programmer’s
television
services
in
Iowa
from
requiring
33
that
a
distributor
also
purchase
a
license
or
other
permission
34
to
transmit
one
or
more
additional
television
services
of
the
35
-6-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
6/
8
S.F.
_____
programmer
or
its
affiliates,
or
to
dictate
the
level,
package,
1
or
tier
of
distributor
services
in
which
any
television
service
2
must
be
included.
3
The
bill
states
that
in
an
action
brought
for
a
violation
4
of
the
bill’s
provisions,
the
programmer
shall
bear
the
burden
5
of
proving
that
the
programmer
experiences
actual
differences
6
in
its
direct
costs
in
making
television
services
available
to
7
distributors;
that
a
contemporaneous
transaction
or
agreement
8
otherwise
prohibited
was
the
result
of
bona
fide,
independent
9
negotiation
and
was
not
for
the
purpose
of
reducing
the
net
10
price
to
be
paid
by
the
distributor;
and
that
the
programmer
11
makes
the
types
of
compensation
received
available
on
equal
12
terms
to
all
distributors
who
transmit
its
television
services
13
in
Iowa.
14
Relating
to
the
disclosure
of
information,
the
bill
states
15
that
beginning
July
1,
2010,
a
programmer
shall
not
enforce
16
against
a
distributor
any
duty
of
confidentiality
regarding
the
17
terms
and
conditions
under
which
the
distributor
transmits
the
18
programmer’s
television
services
in
Iowa,
and
that
a
contract
19
provision
is
void
if
it
imposes
a
duty
of
confidentiality
20
that
cannot
be
enforced.
Additionally,
the
bill
states
that
21
when
a
distributor
seeks
a
license
or
other
permission
to
22
transmit
television
programming
in
Iowa,
the
programmer
at
23
the
request
of
the
distributor
shall
promptly
disclose
to
24
the
distributor
information
as
necessary
for
the
distributor
25
to
determine
whether
the
terms
and
conditions
being
offered
26
by
the
programmer
to
the
distributor
comply
with
the
bill’s
27
provisions.
28
The
bill
provides
that
a
person
who
licenses
or
otherwise
29
makes
available
to
a
television
station
with
a
transmitter
in
30
Iowa
for
broadcast
to
Iowa
viewers
the
satellite
or
terrestrial
31
feed
of
a
live
sporting
event
or
a
program
that
is
part
of
the
32
prime-time
programming
of
a
national
broadcast
network
and
that
33
is
not
produced
and
owned
by
the
station
shall
not
refuse
to
34
make
the
feed
available,
to
the
maximum
extent
permitted
by
35
-7-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
7/
8
S.F.
_____
applicable
federal
law,
on
reasonable
terms
to
any
distributor
1
in
Iowa
who
does
not
carry
the
signal
of
the
television
station
2
or
does
not
have
a
license
or
other
right
to
provide
the
3
telecast
to
its
subscribers
or
other
customers.
The
bill
4
adds
that
any
contractual
or
other
prohibition
or
restriction
5
inconsistent
with
this
prohibition
shall
be
considered
void.
6
Regarding
penalties,
the
bill
states
that
the
state
of
Iowa
7
or
a
person
who
is
injured
or
threatened
with
injury
by
conduct
8
prohibited
under
the
bill
may
bring
suit
to
prevent
or
enjoin
9
the
prohibited
conduct,
and
that
a
person
who
is
injured
by
10
prohibited
conduct
may
recover
actual
damages
resulting
from
11
the
conduct,
and
upon
a
finding
that
the
conduct
was
willful
12
or
flagrant,
punitive
damages
up
to
three
times
the
amount
of
13
actual
damages.
Provision
is
also
made
for
recovery
of
court
14
costs
and
attorney
fees
by
a
person
bringing
suit
other
than
15
the
state.
16
-8-
LSB
6003XC
(2)
83
rn/nh
8/
8