Senate Study Bill 1260 SENATE FILE BY (PROPOSED COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY INDEPENDENCE BILL BY CHAIRPERSON BLACK) Passed Senate, Date Passed House, Date Vote: Ayes Nays Vote: Ayes Nays Approved A BILL FOR 1 An Act relating to antidegradation protection for surface waters. 2 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF IOWA: 3 TLSB 2137SC 83 4 tm/nh/8 PAG LIN 1 1 Section 1. NEW SECTION. 455B.176B ANTIDEGRADATION. 1 2 1. The department shall establish and administer a 1 3 four=tiered antidegradation policy which is in accordance with 1 4 the federal Water Pollution Control Act and the federal rule 1 5 governing state antidegradation policies in 40 C.F.R. } 1 6 131.12. The department shall not establish an antidegradation 1 7 policy more stringent than that required by 40 C.F.R. } 1 8 131.12. 1 9 2. Tier one review shall protect instream water uses and 1 10 the level of water quality necessary to protect those uses, as 1 11 required by 40 C.F.R. } 131.12. 1 12 3. For purposes of a tier two review and tier two 1 13 requirements compliance, the department shall not require 1 14 consideration or implementation of alternatives with costs 1 15 greater than one hundred ten percent of the base cost of 1 16 pollution control measures for the discharge. 1 17 4. For purposes of a tier three review, the department 1 18 shall comply with the following: 1 19 a. The department shall prohibit permanent degradation of 1 20 water quality in a water designated for a tier three level of 1 21 protection. Any proposed activity that would result in a 1 22 permanent new or expanded direct source of pollutants of 1 23 concern to any segment which has been classified as a tier 1 24 three level protected water is prohibited. Temporary and 1 25 limited degradation of a water receiving tier three protection 1 26 may be allowed by the department on a case=by=case basis. A 1 27 water receiving tier three review shall be assessed against 1 28 the existing water quality data or other appropriate reference 1 29 stream data, accounting for existing permitted discharges. 1 30 b. Any person may nominate a surface water for a tier 1 31 three level of protection by filing a nomination with the 1 32 department. The department shall consider such nominations 1 33 during a triennial review of surface water quality standards. 1 34 (1) The nomination shall include a map and description of 1 35 the surface water, a statement in support of the nomination, 2 1 supporting evidence that the applicable criteria are met, and 2 2 available relevant water quality data for establishing 2 3 existing water quality. 2 4 (2) The nominating party has the burden of establishing 2 5 the basis for classifying a surface water for a tier three 2 6 level of protection. 2 7 (3) The department shall hold at least one public meeting 2 8 in the local area of a surface water nominated for tier three 2 9 level protection to solicit public comment and to educate the 2 10 public on the classification process and potential impacts of 2 11 the designation. The department shall notify the public 2 12 officials in the affected community about the classification 2 13 process and potential impacts of the designation. 2 14 (4) The department may classify a surface water as a tier 2 15 three level protected water based on all of the following 2 16 criteria: 2 17 (a) The surface water is perennial and in a free=flowing 2 18 condition. 2 19 (b) The unique location of the surface water such as on 2 20 federal lands, national parks, or national wildlife refuges. 2 21 (c) The surface water has pristine water quality. 2 22 (d) The surface water is of exceptional recreational or 2 23 ecological significance because of its unique attributes. 2 24 (e) The surface water serves as habitat for threatened or 2 25 endangered species and classification is necessary for the 2 26 protection of the species. 2 27 (5) The department shall consider all of the following 2 28 factors when making a decision as to whether to classify a 2 29 nominated surface water as a tier three level protected water: 2 30 (a) Whether there is an ability to manage the water and 2 31 its watershed to maintain and protect existing water quality. 2 32 (b) The social and economic impact of tier three 2 33 antidegradation protection. 2 34 (c) Public comments in support of or opposition to the 2 35 tier three level classification for the water. 3 1 (d) The consistency of a tier three level classification 3 2 with applicable water quality management plans. 3 3 (e) Whether the nominated surface water is located within 3 4 a national or state park, national monument, national 3 5 recreation area, wilderness area, riparian conservation area, 3 6 wildlife management area, area of critical environmental 3 7 concern, or has another special use or unique attributes. 3 8 5. Tier four review shall apply to thermal discharges, as 3 9 required by 40 C.F.R. } 131.12(a)(4). 3 10 6. In support of antidegradation objectives, the 3 11 department shall promote implementation of best management 3 12 practices for nonpoint sources as necessary to comply with 3 13 federal and state law. Implementation of best management 3 14 practices shall not be a prerequisite to approval of an 3 15 expanded point source discharge. 3 16 7. Rules adopted by the department shall apply to 3 17 regulated activities after July 1, 2009, which result in new 3 18 or expanded discharges of pollutants of concern that will 3 19 degrade water quality in designated stream segments of surface 3 20 waters of the state. 3 21 8. A new discharge into tier two waters that replaces an 3 22 existing septic system is not subject to antidegradation 3 23 review. Such new discharges to tier three waters are only 3 24 allowable if the analysis shows that treatment and discharge 3 25 of existing septic system flows will result in a net 3 26 improvement in water quality for such waters. Combined sewer 3 27 overflow control projects resulting in a net decrease in the 3 28 combined sewer overflow related pollutant loadings to surface 3 29 waters shall be excluded from review requirements when these 3 30 loadings are included in department=approved plans in 3 31 accordance with federal guidance or policies. 3 32 9. A regulated activity shall not be considered to result 3 33 in degradation if activity is occurring within the design 3 34 capacity of the treatment plant as specified in the existing 3 35 construction permit or a permit for an existing facility does 4 1 not propose less stringent permit limits, or when treatment is 4 2 added to a previously unpermitted discharge resulting in 4 3 improvements to the receiving water, or when the activity will 4 4 only result in temporary and limited degradation of water 4 5 quality. 4 6 10. In the approval process for a regulated activity that 4 7 would degrade surface water, the department shall ensure 4 8 appropriate public and interagency participation in the 4 9 process and shall act in accordance with the following: 4 10 a. The applicant shall provide public notice and 4 11 opportunity for public comment on the alternatives analysis 4 12 and the social and economic importance review, before the 4 13 alternatives analysis is finalized by the applicant. If the 4 14 applicant is a municipal facility, rural water association, or 4 15 rural water district, public notice shall conform to notice 4 16 procedures required by section 362.3. 4 17 b. The department shall carry out an intergovernmental 4 18 coordination and review process in tandem with the public 4 19 comment period held by the applicant pursuant to paragraph 4 20 "a", prior to approving a regulated activity that would 4 21 degrade surface water. 4 22 11. For purposes of this section, "pollutants of concern" 4 23 for antidegradation reviews shall include only those 4 24 pollutants for which specific numeric water quality criteria 4 25 are established or where an implementation methodology 4 26 approved by the United States environmental protection agency 4 27 has been developed for narrative criteria application, and 4 28 that are reasonably expected to be present in the discharge at 4 29 a level that could negatively affect the beneficial uses of 4 30 the receiving water. 4 31 EXPLANATION 4 32 This bill relates to antidegradation of surface waters. 4 33 The bill requires the department of natural resources to 4 34 establish and administer a four=tiered antidegradation 4 35 procedure which is in accordance with the federal Water 5 1 Pollution Control Act and federal rules on antidegradation. 5 2 The bill provides that for purposes of a tier two review 5 3 and tier two requirements compliance, the department shall not 5 4 require consideration or implementation of alternatives with 5 5 costs greater than 110 percent of the base cost of pollution 5 6 control measures for the discharge. 5 7 The bill provides that for purposes of a tier three review, 5 8 the department shall prohibit permanent degradation of water 5 9 quality in a water designated for a tier three level of 5 10 protection. Any proposed activity that would result in a 5 11 permanent new or expanded direct source of pollutants of 5 12 concern to any segment which has been classified as a tier 5 13 three level protected water is prohibited. Temporary and 5 14 limited degradation of a water receiving tier three protection 5 15 may be allowed by the department on a case=by=case basis. A 5 16 water receiving tier three review shall be assessed against 5 17 the existing water quality data or other appropriate reference 5 18 stream data, accounting for existing permitted discharges. 5 19 The bill allows any person to nominate a surface water for a 5 20 tier three level of protection by filing a nomination with the 5 21 department. The bill provides a nomination and approval 5 22 process for a tier three level protection including factors 5 23 and criteria for approval. 5 24 The bill provides that tier four review shall apply to 5 25 thermal discharges. 5 26 The bill provides that the department shall promote 5 27 implementation of best management practices for nonpoint 5 28 sources as necessary to comply with federal and state law and 5 29 that implementation of best management practices shall not be 5 30 a prerequisite to approval of an expanded point source 5 31 discharge. 5 32 The bill provides that rules adopted by the department 5 33 shall apply to regulated activities after July 1, 2009, which 5 34 result in new or expanded discharges of pollutants of concern 5 35 that will degrade water quality in designated stream segments 6 1 of surface waters of the state. 6 2 The bill provides that a new discharge into tier two waters 6 3 that replaces an existing septic system is not subject to 6 4 antidegradation review. Such new discharges to tier three 6 5 waters are only allowable if the analysis shows that treatment 6 6 and discharge of existing septic system flows will result in a 6 7 net improvement in water quality for such waters. 6 8 The bill provides that a regulated activity shall not be 6 9 considered to result in degradation if activity is occurring 6 10 within the design capacity of the treatment plant as specified 6 11 in the existing construction permit or a permit for an 6 12 existing facility does not propose less stringent permit 6 13 limits, or when treatment is added to a previously unpermitted 6 14 discharge resulting in improvements to the receiving water, or 6 15 when the activity will only result in temporary and limited 6 16 degradation of water quality. 6 17 The bill provides public notice and comment requirements as 6 18 part of the approval process for a regulated activity that 6 19 would degrade surface water. 6 20 LSB 2137SC 83 6 21 tm/nh/8