House File 2206 - Introduced HOUSE FILE BY GASKILL Passed House, Date Passed Senate, Date Vote: Ayes Nays Vote: Ayes Nays Approved A BILL FOR 1 An Act relating to postelection audits of voting systems. 2 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF IOWA: 3 TLSB 5935HH 82 4 sc/nh/24 PAG LIN 1 1 Section 1. NEW SECTION. 47.10 ELECTION AUDIT BOARD. 1 2 1. The state commissioner of elections shall appoint a 1 3 three=member election audit board. 1 4 2. The election audit board shall receive reports of the 1 5 postelection audits required in section 50.51 and filed by 1 6 each county commissioner of elections. 1 7 3. The election audit board shall, after each general 1 8 election, conduct a review of no more than five counties 1 9 selected by lot. The board shall review the county 1 10 commissioner's conduct of the general election to determine 1 11 whether the county commissioner's conduct of the election 1 12 conformed to Iowa law. The review shall include a review of 1 13 the procedures followed for absentee voting. 1 14 Sec. 2. Section 50.12, Code 2007, is amended to read as 1 15 follows: 1 16 50.12 RETURN AND PRESERVATION OF BALLOTS. 1 17 Immediately after making the proclamation, and before 1 18 separating, the board members of each precinct in which votes 1 19 have been received by paper ballot shall enclose in an 1 20 envelope or other container all ballots which have been 1 21 counted by them, except those endorsed "Rejected as double", 1 22 "Defective", or "Objected to", and securely seal the envelope. 1 23 The signatures of all board members of the precinct shall be 1 24 placed across the seal or the opening of the container so that 1 25 it cannot be opened without breaking the seal. The precinct 1 26 election officials shall return all the ballots to the 1 27 commissioner, who shall carefully preserve them for six 1 28 months. Ballots from elections for federal offices shall be 1 29 preserved for twenty=two months. The sealed packages 1 30 containing voted ballots shall be opened only for an official 1 31 recount authorized by section 50.48, 50.49, or 50.50, for an 1 32 election contest held pursuant to chapters 57 through 62, for 1 33 a postelection audit required by section 50.51, or to destroy 1 34 the ballots pursuant to section 50.19. 1 35 Sec. 3. Section 50.48, subsection 1, unnumbered paragraph 2 1 1, Code Supplement 2007, is amended to read as follows: 2 2 The county board of canvassers shall order a recount of the 2 3 votes cast for a particular office or nomination in one or 2 4 more specified election precincts in that county if a written 2 5 requestthereforfor a recount is made not later than five 2 6o'clockp.m. on the third day following the county board's 2 7 canvass of the election in question or not later than five 2 8 p.m. on the third day following conclusion of a postelection 2 9 audit if the audit necessitates a correction to the official 2 10 canvass resulting in the apparent winner being other than the 2 11 apparent winner declared after the canvass of votes. The 2 12 request shall be filed with the commissioner of that county, 2 13 or with the commissioner responsible for conducting the 2 14 election if section 47.2, subsection 2 is applicable, and 2 15 shall be signed by either of the following: 2 16 Sec. 4. Section 50.49, unnumbered paragraph 1, Code 2007, 2 17 is amended to read as follows: 2 18 A recount for any public measure shall be ordered by the 2 19 board of canvassers if a petition requesting a recount is 2 20 filed with the county commissioner not later thanthree days 2 21 afterfive p.m. on the third day following the completion of 2 22 the canvass of votes for the election at which the question 2 23 appeared on the ballot or not later than five p.m. on the 2 24 third day following conclusion of a postelection audit if the 2 25 audit necessitates a correction to the official canvass 2 26 causing a different result to be declared on the public 2 27 measure. The petition shall be signed by the greater of not 2 28 less than ten eligible electors or a number of eligible 2 29 electors equaling one percent of the total number of votes 2 30 cast upon the public measure. Each petitioner must be a 2 31 person who was entitled to vote on the public measure in 2 32 question or would have been so entitled if registered to vote. 2 33 Sec. 5. NEW SECTION. 50.51 POSTELECTION AUDIT OF VOTING 2 34 SYSTEMS. 2 35 1. After each general election, a postelection audit of 3 1 voting systems shall be conducted as provided in this section. 3 2 However, if a request for recount is filed under section 3 3 50.48, 50.49, or 50.50 prior to or during the postelection 3 4 audit, an audit of the office or measure in question for which 3 5 the recount was requested shall not be conducted or shall be 3 6 terminated, as the case may be. 3 7 2. At the canvass of the primary election, the board of 3 8 supervisors shall set the date, time, and place for the 3 9 postelection audit required by this section. 3 10 3. a. A packet of absentee ballots described in section 3 11 53.23, subsection 5, shall be considered a precinct for 3 12 purposes of a postelection audit and in all cases shall be 3 13 included in the postelection audit. If there is more than one 3 14 packet containing at least five hundred absentee ballots, the 3 15 packet to be audited shall be chosen by lot. If there are no 3 16 packets containing at least five hundred absentee ballots, the 3 17 packet containing the largest number of absentee ballots shall 3 18 be included in the postelection audit. 3 19 The remaining precincts for which a postelection audit 3 20 shall be conducted shall be chosen by lot by the chairperson 3 21 of the board of supervisors, or another supervisor designated 3 22 by the chairperson if the chairperson is unavailable, 3 23 immediately prior to commencement of the postelection audit. 3 24 The selection proceedings shall be open to the public and to 3 25 observers from both political parties. The proceedings shall 3 26 be videotaped, and the videotape shall be considered a report 3 27 of the postelection audit and shall be filed as provided in 3 28 subsection 8. 3 29 b. The number of precincts chosen shall be as follows: 3 30 (1) In counties with fifty thousand or fewer registered 3 31 voters, two precincts or a number equal to five percent of all 3 32 the precincts in the county, whichever is greater. 3 33 (2) In counties with more than fifty thousand registered 3 34 voters but fewer than one hundred thousand registered voters, 3 35 three precincts or a number equal to five percent of all the 4 1 precincts in the county, whichever is greater. 4 2 (3) In counties with one hundred thousand or more 4 3 registered voters, four precincts or a number equal to five 4 4 percent of all precincts in the county, whichever is greater. 4 5 c. The county commissioner of elections shall publish 4 6 notice of the date, time, and place of the postelection audit. 4 7 The commissioner shall also notify, in writing, the county 4 8 chairperson of each political party referred to in section 4 9 49.13 so that they may be present, or have a representative 4 10 present. 4 11 4. The postelection audit shall be conducted for elections 4 12 for the offices of president of the United States or governor, 4 13 United States senator, United States representative, and at 4 14 least a total of two additional partisan offices or public 4 15 measures on the ballot, which shall be chosen by lot at the 4 16 same time, and in the same manner, the precincts are chosen. 4 17 5. For each precinct to be audited, the county 4 18 commissioner of elections shall appoint three to seven members 4 19 of a postelection audit board to conduct the postelection 4 20 audit. The members shall be chosen from the election board 4 21 panel drawn up as provided in section 49.15, except that the 4 22 chairperson of the precinct board of each precinct drawn by 4 23 lot shall be designated the chairperson of the postelection 4 24 audit board for that precinct. The ballots in each precinct 4 25 chosen shall be counted by hand. In precincts where a voting 4 26 machine was used, the ballot images produced from the internal 4 27 audit log shall be the official record used in the 4 28 postelection audit. 4 29 6. a. When all members of the postelection audit board 4 30 have been selected, the board shall undertake and complete the 4 31 required audit as expeditiously as reasonably possible. The 4 32 county commissioner of elections or the commissioner's 4 33 designee shall supervise the handling of ballots or voting 4 34 machine documents to ensure that the ballots and other 4 35 documents are protected from alteration or damage. The board 5 1 shall open only the sealed ballot containers from the 5 2 precincts specified to be audited. The board shall recount 5 3 only the ballots which were voted and counted for the office 5 4 in question, including any disputed ballots returned as 5 5 required in section 50.5. 5 6 b. The ballots or voting machine documents shall be 5 7 resealed by the postelection audit board before adjournment 5 8 and shall be preserved as required by section 50.12. At the 5 9 conclusion of the audit, the postelection audit board shall 5 10 make and file with the county commissioner of elections a 5 11 written report of its findings, which shall be signed by the 5 12 chairperson and at least one other member of the postelection 5 13 audit board. The postelection audit board shall complete the 5 14 audit and file its report not later than the fourth day 5 15 following the election. 5 16 c. If the postelection audit reveals a difference greater 5 17 than one=half of one percent from the results on the tally 5 18 list, the postelection audit board shall, within two days, 5 19 conduct an additional audit of at least three precincts and 5 20 shall report the results immediately to the county 5 21 commissioner of elections. If the second audit also indicates 5 22 a difference in the vote totals that is greater than one=half 5 23 of one percent from the results on the tally list, the county 5 24 commissioner shall conduct an audit of the remaining precincts 5 25 in the county for those same offices and public measures. 5 26 This audit shall be completed no later than six weeks 5 27 following the general election. 5 28 7. a. If the report from the final postelection audit 5 29 reveals that the abstracts prepared pursuant to the county 5 30 canvassing board's canvass were incorrect as to the number of 5 31 votes cast for any of the offices or public measures audited, 5 32 the county commissioner of elections shall at once so notify 5 33 the county canvassing board. The county canvassing board 5 34 shall reconvene within three days after being so notified, and 5 35 shall correct its previous proceedings. 6 1 b. The county commissioner of elections shall promptly 6 2 notify the state commissioner of any recount of votes for an 6 3 office to which section 50.30 is applicable. If necessary, 6 4 the state canvass required by section 50.38 shall be delayed 6 5 with respect to the office to which the recount pertains. The 6 6 county commissioner of elections shall subsequently inform the 6 7 state commissioner at the earliest possible time whether any 6 8 change in the outcome of the election in that county or 6 9 district resulted from the recount. 6 10 8. All reports pertaining to a postelection audit shall be 6 11 sent to the election audit board created in section 47.10 and 6 12 filed in the office of the state commissioner. 6 13 Sec. 6. Section 53.23, subsection 5, Code Supplement 2007, 6 14 is amended to read as follows: 6 15 5. The special precinct election board shall preserve the 6 16 secrecy of all absentee and provisional ballots. After the 6 17 affidavits on the envelopes have been reviewed and the 6 18 qualifications of the persons casting the ballots have been 6 19 determined, those that have been accepted for counting shall 6 20 be opened. The ballots shall be removed from the affidavit 6 21 envelopes without being unfolded or examined, and then shall 6 22 be thoroughly intermingled, after which they shall be unfolded 6 23 and tabulated. If secrecy folders or envelopes are used with 6 24 provisional paper ballots, the ballots shall be removed from 6 25 the secrecy folders after the ballots have been intermingled. 6 26 Tabulated ballots shall be placed in packets. The packets 6 27 shall contain ballots equal in number to the greater of five 6 28 hundred or five percent of the total number of absentee 6 29 ballots tabulated. 6 30 EXPLANATION 6 31 This bill requires a postelection audit of voting systems 6 32 after each general election. The postelection audit is a hand 6 33 count of the ballots cast in selected precincts. The 6 34 precincts are to be selected publicly by lot by the county 6 35 board of supervisors, and the proceedings are to be 7 1 videotaped. However, at least one of the precincts to be 7 2 audited shall be a precinct comprised of absentee ballots. 7 3 The bill provides that the number of precincts to be audited 7 4 is as follows: 7 5 (1) In counties with fewer than 50,000 registered voters, 7 6 two precincts or a number equal to 5 percent of all the 7 7 precincts in the county, whichever is greater; 7 8 (2) In counties with 50,000 or more registered voters but 7 9 fewer than 100,000, three precincts or a number equal to 5 7 10 percent of all the precincts in the county, whichever is 7 11 greater; and 7 12 (3) In counties with 100,000 or more registered voters, 7 13 four precincts or a number equal to 5 percent of all precincts 7 14 in the county, whichever is greater. 7 15 The bill provides that the postelection audit is to be 7 16 conducted for elections for the offices of president of the 7 17 United States or governor, United States senator, United 7 18 States representative, and at least two additional partisan 7 19 offices or public measures chosen by lot. The bill provides 7 20 that if the postelection audit reveals a difference greater 7 21 than one=half of 1 percent from the tally list for the 7 22 precinct, the postelection audit board shall conduct an 7 23 additional audit of three precincts in the county. The bill 7 24 provides that this procedure is to be completed before the 7 25 county board of supervisors convenes to canvass the votes from 7 26 the election. If the second audit reveals the same 7 27 difference, then the county commissioner of elections shall 7 28 conduct an audit of the ballots cast for the same offices or 7 29 public measures in the remaining precincts in the county. 7 30 This final audit is to be completed no later than six weeks 7 31 following the general election. 7 32 The bill provides that if a recount is requested, the 7 33 postelection audit shall not be conducted or shall be 7 34 terminated, as the case may be. If a postelection audit 7 35 results in a correction to the official canvass that changes 8 1 the outcome of an election, a recount may be requested no 8 2 later than the third day following the conclusion of the 8 3 postelection audit. 8 4 The bill creates an election audit board which shall 8 5 receive reports of postelection audits filed by county 8 6 commissioners of elections. The board shall also, after each 8 7 general election, conduct a review in no more than five 8 8 counties of the conduct of the election, including absentee 8 9 voting procedures. The members of the election audit board 8 10 are appointed by the state commissioner of elections. 8 11 LSB 5935HH 82 8 12 sc/nh/24.2