House File 2128 - Introduced HOUSE FILE BY TOMENGA, CLUTE, R. OLSON, MAY, JACOBY, HOFFMAN, BUKTA, FOEGE, ANDERSON, BAILEY, MASCHER, and WIENCEK Passed House, Date Passed Senate, Date Vote: Ayes Nays Vote: Ayes Nays Approved A BILL FOR 1 An Act establishing a state health insurance mandate commission. 2 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF IOWA: 3 TLSB 5301HH 82 4 av/nh/8 PAG LIN 1 1 Section 1. NEW SECTION. 514C.23 STATE HEALTH INSURANCE 1 2 MANDATE COMMISSION. 1 3 1. DEFINITIONS. As used in this section, unless the 1 4 context otherwise requires: 1 5 a. "Carrier" means an entity subject to the insurance laws 1 6 and regulations of this state, or subject to the jurisdiction 1 7 of the commissioner, that contracts or offers to contract to 1 8 provide, deliver, arrange for, pay for, or reimburse any of 1 9 the costs of health care services, including an insurance 1 10 company offering sickness and accident plans, a health 1 11 maintenance organization, a nonprofit health service 1 12 corporation, an organized delivery system, or any other entity 1 13 that provides a plan of health insurance, health benefits, or 1 14 health services. 1 15 b. "Commissioner" means the Iowa commissioner of 1 16 insurance. 1 17 c. "Mandated health care benefit" means coverage that is 1 18 required or required to be offered under this chapter or other 1 19 state law in an individual or group hospital or health care 1 20 service contract if the law mandating coverage does any of the 1 21 following: 1 22 (1) Stipulates coverage for specific health care services, 1 23 benefits, technologies, or treatments. 1 24 (2) Places limitations or restrictions on deductibles, 1 25 coinsurance, copayments, or annual or lifetime maximum benefit 1 26 amounts. 1 27 (3) Designates a specific category of health care provider 1 28 from whom an insured is entitled to receive care. 1 29 (4) Requires coverage for all services that a health care 1 30 provider recommends that are consistent with "generally 1 31 accepted principles of professional medicine" or a similar 1 32 standard. 1 33 (5) Requires a specific level of payment or rate of 1 34 reimbursement. 1 35 d. "Small employer" means a person actively engaged in 2 1 business who, on at least fifty percent of the employer's 2 2 working days during the preceding year, employed not less than 2 3 two and not more than fifty full=time equivalent eligible 2 4 employees, as defined in section 513B.2. 2 5 2. EVALUATION BY COMMISSION. 2 6 a. When a bill is requested, the legislative services 2 7 agency shall make an initial determination of whether the bill 2 8 contains a requirement for a mandated health care benefit. If 2 9 a mandated health care benefit may be required as a result of 2 10 the bill, that fact shall be included in the explanation of 2 11 the bill. 2 12 b. A bill containing a notice that the bill contains a 2 13 requirement for a mandated health care benefit shall not be 2 14 voted out of a standing committee of the house of 2 15 representatives or the senate until the chairperson of the 2 16 committee has referred the bill to the commissioner for review 2 17 and evaluation by the state health insurance mandate 2 18 commission created in this section and a report has been 2 19 received from the commission by the speaker of the house of 2 20 representatives and the president of the senate. 2 21 c. Upon referral of such a bill to the commissioner, the 2 22 commissioner shall convene the state health insurance mandate 2 23 commission to conduct a review and evaluation of the bill. 2 24 The commission shall prepare a written report, with the 2 25 assistance of the commissioner, that sets forth the 2 26 commission's findings, evaluations, and recommendations. The 2 27 completed report shall be transmitted to the speaker of the 2 28 house of representatives and to the president of the senate 2 29 within ninety days from the date the commissioner receives 2 30 referral of the bill. The report shall include a financial 2 31 impact analysis performed by an actuary who is a member of the 2 32 American academy of actuaries and who certifies that the 2 33 analysis is consistent with accepted actuarial techniques. 2 34 d. The report shall include but is not limited to a review 2 35 and evaluation of all of the following, to the extent that the 3 1 information is available: 3 2 (1) Public impact, including all of the following: 3 3 (a) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 3 4 is generally utilized by a significant portion of the 3 5 population. 3 6 (b) The extent to which insurance coverage for the 3 7 mandated health care benefit is already generally available, 3 8 and if coverage is not generally available, the extent to 3 9 which the lack of coverage results in persons forgoing 3 10 necessary health care treatments or results in unreasonable 3 11 financial hardship to patients. 3 12 (c) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 3 13 is covered by self=funded employers' groups. 3 14 (d) The level of public demand for the mandated health 3 15 care benefit. 3 16 (e) The level of public demand for insurance coverage of 3 17 the mandated health care benefit. 3 18 (f) The level of interest of collective bargaining agents 3 19 in negotiating privately for inclusion of the coverage in 3 20 group health insurance contracts. 3 21 (2) Medical impact, including all of the following: 3 22 (a) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 3 23 is recognized by the medical community as being effective in 3 24 the treatment of patients. 3 25 (b) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 3 26 is recognized by the medical community as being effective as 3 27 demonstrated by a review of scientific and peer=reviewed 3 28 literature. 3 29 (c) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 3 30 is available and utilized by health care providers in the 3 31 state. 3 32 (d) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 3 33 makes a positive contribution to the health status of the 3 34 population, including the ramifications of using alternatives 3 35 to or not providing the mandated health care benefit. 4 1 (e) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 4 2 would diminish or eliminate access to currently available 4 3 health care services. 4 4 (3) Financial impact, including all of the following: 4 5 (a) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 4 6 will increase or decrease the cost of health care benefits 4 7 over the next five years. 4 8 (b) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 4 9 will increase the appropriate use of the health care benefit 4 10 over the next five years. 4 11 (c) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 4 12 will be a substitute for a more expensive health care benefit 4 13 over the next five years. 4 14 (d) The impact of the mandated health care benefit on 4 15 small employers. 4 16 (e) The extent to which the costs resulting from lack of 4 17 coverage for the mandated health care benefit are currently 4 18 paid by or will be shifted to other payers, including both 4 19 public and private entities. 4 20 (f) The extent to which the mandated health care benefit 4 21 will increase or decrease the administrative expenses of 4 22 carriers and the premiums and administrative expenses of 4 23 policyholders. 4 24 (g) The impact of the mandated health care benefit on the 4 25 total cost of health care over the next five years. 4 26 3. COMMISSION == ESTABLISHMENT. 4 27 a. A state health insurance mandate commission is 4 28 established to review legislation that proposes to mandate 4 29 health care benefits in this state. 4 30 b. The commission shall consist of the following members: 4 31 (1) The commissioner or the commissioner's designee. 4 32 (2) The chairperson and the ranking member of the senate 4 33 commerce committee or designees of either, both of whom shall 4 34 be ex officio, nonvoting members of the commission. 4 35 (3) The chairperson and the ranking member of the house 5 1 commerce committee or designees of either, both of whom shall 5 2 be ex officio, nonvoting members of the commission. 5 3 (4) Five members appointed by the governor, one of whom 5 4 shall be a representative of a small employer, one a 5 5 representative of a large employer, one a member of a 5 6 collective bargaining unit, one a person who has individual 5 7 health insurance coverage, and one representing the general 5 8 public. 5 9 (5) Four members appointed by the commissioner, one of 5 10 whom shall be an expert in the field of health insurance, one 5 11 an expert in medical research, one an expert in the field of 5 12 social sciences, and one an actuary. 5 13 c. Members of the commission who are appointed shall be 5 14 appointed for three=year terms and shall be balanced as to 5 15 political affiliation as provided in section 69.16. However, 5 16 a member shall serve until a successor has been appointed and 5 17 qualified. A vacancy on the commission shall be filled for 5 18 the unexpired portion of the regular term in the same manner 5 19 as regular appointments are made. 5 20 d. Members of the commission shall receive a per diem and 5 21 mileage, at the same rate that is paid to members of the 5 22 general assembly, when attending to the duties of the 5 23 commission. 5 24 e. The commission shall not conduct business until all 5 25 members of the commission have been appointed or selected and 5 26 qualify. A majority of the members of the commission shall 5 27 constitute a quorum. The commissioner or the commissioner's 5 28 designee shall serve as chairperson of the commission. 5 29 f. Staff and administrative support for the commission 5 30 shall be furnished by the insurance division. 5 31 g. The commission may do all of the following: 5 32 (1) Hold public hearings. 5 33 (2) Conduct research. 5 34 (3) Receive testimony from experts. 5 35 (4) Review, for purposes of comparison, the health 6 1 benefits mandated in other states and the jurisdiction and 6 2 effect of such mandates. 6 3 (5) Contract with experts to develop needed data 6 4 concerning a proposed mandate. 6 5 (6) Perform other actions necessary to accomplish the 6 6 commission's assigned tasks. 6 7 4. COMMISSION BUDGET. 6 8 a. The commissioner shall propose a budget for the first 6 9 year of operation of the state health insurance mandate 6 10 commission, subject to the approval of the state health 6 11 insurance mandate commission. 6 12 b. On or after July 1, 2009, and each July 1 thereafter, 6 13 the state health insurance mandate commission shall review the 6 14 costs of the commission's operation for the preceding year and 6 15 develop a budget for the commission's operation for the 6 16 current fiscal year. 6 17 5. RULES. The commissioner shall adopt rules deemed 6 18 necessary for the administration of this section in accordance 6 19 with chapter 17A. 6 20 EXPLANATION 6 21 This bill adds new Code section 514C.23 creating a state 6 22 health insurance mandate commission consisting of 14 specified 6 23 members and chaired by the commissioner of insurance or the 6 24 commissioner's designee. 6 25 The bill provides that when a bill is requested, the 6 26 legislative services agency shall make an initial 6 27 determination of whether the bill contains a requirement that 6 28 a mandated health care benefit be offered in all individual or 6 29 group hospital or health care service contracts in this state, 6 30 and if so, notice of that fact must be included in the 6 31 explanation of the bill. 6 32 The bill further provides that if such a notice is included 6 33 in the explanation of the bill, the bill shall not be voted 6 34 out of a standing committee of the house of representatives or 6 35 the senate until the chairperson of the committee has referred 7 1 the bill to the commissioner of insurance for findings, 7 2 evaluations, and recommendations by the state health insurance 7 3 mandate commission. The bill provides that upon receiving 7 4 such a referral, the insurance commissioner shall convene the 7 5 commission, and after completing its review and evaluation the 7 6 commission shall prepare and transmit a written report to the 7 7 speaker of the house of representatives and to the president 7 8 of the senate setting forth the commission's findings, 7 9 including an evaluation of the public, medical, and financial 7 10 impacts, to the extent that the information is available, of 7 11 the proposed mandated health care benefit within 90 days from 7 12 the date the commissioner receives referral of the bill. The 7 13 report must include a financial impact analysis performed by 7 14 an actuary who is a member of the American academy of 7 15 actuaries and who certifies that the analysis is consistent 7 16 with accepted actuarial techniques. 7 17 The bill provides for the organization of the state health 7 18 insurance mandate commission, including three=year terms for 7 19 appointed members, balance in political affiliation, 7 20 vacancies, compensation for a per diem and mileage, quorums, 7 21 and staff and administrative support from the insurance 7 22 division. The bill specifies that the commission may hold 7 23 public hearings, receive testimony from experts, compare 7 24 health benefits mandated in other states, contract with 7 25 experts to develop needed data, and perform other actions 7 26 necessary to accomplish the commission's assigned tasks. 7 27 The bill also provides that the commissioner of insurance 7 28 shall propose a budget for the first year of operation of the 7 29 new commission subject to approval by the commission. The 7 30 bill provides that on or after July 1, 2009, and each July 1 7 31 thereafter, the commission shall review the costs of the 7 32 preceding year and develop a budget for the commission's 7 33 operation for the current fiscal year. 7 34 The bill allows the commissioner of insurance to adopt 7 35 rules deemed necessary for the administration of the new Code 8 1 section in accordance with Code chapter 17A. 8 2 LSB 5301HH 82 8 3 av/nh/8.3