House File 240 - Introduced HOUSE FILE BY FORD Passed House, Date Passed Senate, Date Vote: Ayes Nays Vote: Ayes Nays Approved A BILL FOR 1 An Act relating to the establishment of law enforcement review 2 boards in certain cities. 3 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF IOWA: 4 TLSB 2315HH 81 5 jm/sh/8 PAG LIN 1 1 Section 1. NEW SECTION. 372.16 BOARD ESTABLISHED == 1 2 MEMBERS == DUTIES == IMMUNITIES. 1 3 1. As used in this section, "law enforcement action" means 1 4 any policy or action taken by a police department or police 1 5 officer or failure to act. 1 6 2. A law enforcement review board is established in each 1 7 city having a population of forty=five thousand or more. The 1 8 review board shall consist of at least three members appointed 1 9 to four=year staggered terms by the mayor. Members appointed 1 10 shall be knowledgeable in the areas of law enforcement, public 1 11 policy, and public administration. At least one=third of the 1 12 members shall be persons active in community affairs to 1 13 represent the general public. As far as possible, the mayor 1 14 shall select members to provide a gender balance, represent 1 15 persons of protected classes, and represent current or former 1 16 peace officers. The chairperson or staff head of the local 1 17 civil or human rights agency may serve as an ex officio 1 18 nonvoting member. A term shall be effective on the first of 1 19 July of the year of appointment and a vacancy shall be filled 1 20 in the same manner as the original appointment for the 1 21 unexpired part of a term. A member of the review board may be 1 22 removed by the mayor for inefficiency, neglect of duty, or 1 23 malfeasance in office. 1 24 3. The review board may do all of the following: 1 25 a. Review, upon request or referral, or upon its own 1 26 motion, the actions of police officers. 1 27 b. Prescribe, by rule, the methods by which complaints are 1 28 to be made, received, and acted upon; determine the scope and 1 29 manner of reviews to be made; and publish its findings, 1 30 conclusions, or recommendations as necessary. The review 1 31 board shall submit a report to the mayor and the city council 1 32 concerning the review board's actions during the preceding 1 33 calendar year. 1 34 c. Request and receive from a police department assistance 1 35 and information as necessary in the performance of the duties 2 1 of the review board. The review board may examine the records 2 2 and documents of a police department. If the review board is 2 3 provided access to a confidential document, the review board 2 4 is subject to the same policies and penalties regarding the 2 5 confidentiality of the document as an employee of the police 2 6 department. The review board or its designee may enter and 2 7 inspect the premises within a police department's control. 2 8 d. Issue a subpoena to compel any person to appear, give 2 9 sworn testimony, or produce documentary or other evidence 2 10 relevant to a matter under review. The review board or its 2 11 designee may administer oaths to persons giving testimony 2 12 before the review board. If a witness fails or refuses to 2 13 obey a subpoena issued by the review board, the review board 2 14 may petition the district court for an order directing 2 15 obedience to the subpoena. If the court finds that the 2 16 subpoena should be obeyed, the court shall enter an order 2 17 requiring obedience to the subpoena, and refusal to obey the 2 18 court order is subject to punishment for contempt. 2 19 4. An appropriate subject for investigation by the review 2 20 board includes all of the following: 2 21 a. A law enforcement action related to a death or serious 2 22 injury of a person as a result of an administrative action by 2 23 an officer. 2 24 b. Report of a law enforcement action received upon 2 25 referral from a state or local civil or human rights agency. 2 26 c. Report of a law enforcement action received upon 2 27 referral from a chief of police. 2 28 d. Report of a law enforcement action received from an 2 29 interested person who is dissatisfied with the response to a 2 30 complaint or concern that has been reviewed by a police 2 31 department or chief of police. 2 32 5. The review board shall conduct a review of the 2 33 administrative actions complained of unless the review board 2 34 finds any of the following: 2 35 a. A review by the review board would materially impede an 3 1 ongoing criminal investigation. 3 2 b. The complainant has another remedy or channel of 3 3 complaint which the complainant could reasonably be expected 3 4 to use. 3 5 c. The complaint pertains to a matter outside the review 3 6 board's authority. 3 7 d. The complainant has no substantive or procedural 3 8 interest which is directly affected by the matter complained 3 9 about. 3 10 e. The complaint is frivolous or not made in good faith. 3 11 f. The review board's resources are insufficient for 3 12 adequate investigation. 3 13 g. The complaint has been delayed too long to justify 3 14 present examination of its merit. 3 15 6. The review board may decline to review a complaint, but 3 16 shall not be prohibited from inquiring into the matter 3 17 complained of or into related problems at some future time. 3 18 If the review board decides not to review the complaint, the 3 19 complainant shall be informed of the reasons for the decision. 3 20 If the review board decides to review the complaint, the 3 21 police department shall be notified of the decision. After 3 22 completing a review, the review board shall without delay 3 23 inform the complainant of the fact and, if appropriate, shall 3 24 inform the police department involved. 3 25 7. Before announcing a conclusion or recommendation that 3 26 criticizes a police department, a police officer, or an 3 27 employee of a police department, the review board shall 3 28 consult with that department, officer, or employee and shall 3 29 attach to every report sent or made under this section, unless 3 30 excused, a copy of any unedited comments made by or on behalf 3 31 of the department, officer, or employee. 3 32 8. The review board may publish a report, conclusion, or 3 33 recommendation in the performance of the review board's 3 34 responsibilities and transmit the report, conclusion, or 3 35 recommendation to the mayor, the city attorney, or the city 4 1 council. A conclusion, recommendation, or report so published 4 2 may be released to any interested persons at that time. 4 3 9. A civil action or proceeding, except removal from 4 4 office, shall not be commenced against a member of the review 4 5 board for an act or omission performed pursuant to this 4 6 chapter, unless the act or omission is with malice or is 4 7 grossly negligent. A member of the review board shall not be 4 8 compelled to testify in court with respect to any matter 4 9 involving the exercise of the review board's official duties, 4 10 except as may be necessary to enforce this section. The 4 11 review board may keep all matters confidential, including the 4 12 identities of complainants, witnesses, or police departments 4 13 and police officers under review until the review is 4 14 completed, except that the review board shall report any 4 15 findings of illegal actions by police departments or police 4 16 officers to the county attorney. 4 17 Sec. 2. STATE MANDATE APPLICABILITY. Section 25B.2, 4 18 subsection 3, shall not apply to this Act. 4 19 EXPLANATION 4 20 This bill provides for the establishment of a law 4 21 enforcement review board in cities having a population of 4 22 45,000 or more. The board is to investigate upon request or 4 23 referral, or upon its own motion, the actions or inactions of 4 24 police departments and police officers. The review board is 4 25 to make reports and recommendations concerning its findings to 4 26 the mayor, city attorney, and city council. Members are to be 4 27 appointed for four=year terms. 4 28 The bill may include a state mandate as defined in Code 4 29 section 25B.3. The bill makes inapplicable Code section 4 30 25B.2, subsection 3, which would relieve a political 4 31 subdivision from complying with a state mandate if funding for 4 32 the cost of the state mandate is not provided or specified. 4 33 Therefore, political subdivisions are required to comply with 4 34 any state mandate included in the bill. 4 35 LSB 2315HH 81 5 1 jm:rj/sh/8