House
File
205
-
Introduced
HOUSE
FILE
205
BY
HUNTER
A
BILL
FOR
An
Act
relating
to
open
records
and
public
meetings,
including
1
the
creation
of
the
Iowa
public
information
board.
2
BE
IT
ENACTED
BY
THE
GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
OF
THE
STATE
OF
IOWA:
3
TLSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
H.F.
205
Section
1.
Section
8A.341,
subsection
2,
Code
2011,
is
1
amended
to
read
as
follows:
2
2.
If
money
is
appropriated
for
this
purpose,
by
November
1
3
of
each
year
supply
a
report
which
contains
the
name,
gender,
4
county,
or
city
of
residence
when
possible,
official
title,
5
salary
received
during
the
previous
fiscal
year,
base
salary
as
6
computed
on
July
1
of
the
current
fiscal
year,
and
traveling
7
and
subsistence
expense
of
the
personnel
of
each
of
the
8
departments,
boards,
and
commissions
of
the
state
government
9
except
personnel
who
receive
an
annual
salary
of
less
than
one
10
thousand
dollars.
The
number
of
the
personnel
and
the
total
11
amount
received
by
them
shall
be
shown
for
each
department
in
12
the
report.
All
employees
who
have
drawn
salaries,
fees,
or
13
expense
allowances
from
more
than
one
department
or
subdivision
14
shall
be
listed
separately
under
the
proper
departmental
15
heading.
On
the
request
of
the
director,
the
head
of
each
16
department,
board,
or
commission
shall
furnish
the
data
17
covering
that
agency.
The
report
shall
be
distributed
upon
18
request
without
charge
in
an
electronic
medium
to
each
caucus
19
of
the
general
assembly,
the
legislative
services
agency,
the
20
chief
clerk
of
the
house
of
representatives,
and
the
secretary
21
of
the
senate.
Copies
of
the
report
shall
be
made
available
to
22
other
persons
in
an
electronic
medium
upon
payment
of
a
fee,
23
which
shall
not
exceed
the
cost
of
providing
the
copy
of
the
24
report.
Sections
22.2
through
22.6
22.5
apply
to
the
report.
25
All
funds
from
the
sale
of
the
report
shall
be
deposited
in
the
26
printing
revolving
fund
established
in
section
8A.345
.
27
Sec.
2.
Section
8E.202,
subsection
1,
unnumbered
paragraph
28
1,
Code
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
29
The
department
and
each
agency
shall
provide
for
the
widest
30
possible
dissemination
of
information
between
agencies
and
the
31
public
relating
to
the
enterprise
strategic
plan
and
agency
32
strategic
plans,
including
but
not
limited
to
internet
access.
33
This
section
does
not
require
the
department
or
an
agency
to
34
release
information
which
is
classified
as
a
confidential
35
-1-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
1/
29
H.F.
205
record
under
this
Code
,
including
but
not
limited
to
section
1
22.7
.
2
Sec.
3.
Section
8E.202,
subsection
3,
Code
2011,
is
amended
3
to
read
as
follows:
4
3.
A
record
which
is
confidential
under
this
Code
,
including
5
but
not
limited
to
section
22.7
,
shall
not
be
released
to
the
6
public
under
this
section
.
7
Sec.
4.
Section
21.4,
subsections
1
and
3,
Code
2011,
are
8
amended
to
read
as
follows:
9
1.
A
Except
as
provided
in
subsection
3,
a
governmental
10
body
,
except
township
trustees,
shall
give
notice
of
the
time,
11
date,
and
place
of
each
meeting
including
a
reconvened
meeting
12
of
the
governmental
body
,
and
its
the
tentative
agenda
of
the
13
meeting
,
in
a
manner
reasonably
calculated
to
apprise
the
14
public
of
that
information.
Reasonable
notice
shall
include
15
advising
the
news
media
who
have
filed
a
request
for
notice
16
with
the
governmental
body
and
posting
the
notice
on
a
bulletin
17
board
or
other
prominent
place
which
is
easily
accessible
to
18
the
public
and
clearly
designated
for
that
purpose
at
the
19
principal
office
of
the
body
holding
the
meeting,
or
if
no
such
20
office
exists,
at
the
building
in
which
the
meeting
is
to
be
21
held.
22
3.
Subsection
1
does
not
apply
to
any
of
the
following:
23
a.
A
meeting
reconvened
within
four
hours
of
the
start
of
24
its
recess,
where
an
announcement
of
the
time,
date,
and
place
25
of
the
reconvened
meeting
is
made
at
the
original
meeting
in
26
open
session
and
recorded
in
the
minutes
of
the
meeting
and
27
there
is
no
change
in
the
agenda.
28
b.
A
meeting
held
by
a
formally
constituted
subunit
of
a
29
parent
governmental
body
may
conduct
a
meeting
without
notice
30
as
required
by
this
section
during
a
lawful
meeting
of
the
31
parent
governmental
body
,
or
during
a
recess
in
that
meeting
32
of
up
to
four
hours
,
or
a
meeting
of
that
subunit
immediately
33
following
that
the
meeting
of
the
parent
governmental
body
,
if
34
the
meeting
of
the
that
subunit
is
publicly
announced
in
open
35
-2-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
2/
29
H.F.
205
session
at
the
parent
meeting
and
the
subject
of
the
meeting
1
reasonably
coincides
with
the
subjects
discussed
or
acted
upon
2
by
the
parent
governmental
body.
3
Sec.
5.
Section
21.5,
subsection
1,
paragraph
j,
Code
2011,
4
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
5
j.
To
discuss
the
purchase
of
particular
real
estate
only
6
where
premature
disclosure
could
be
reasonably
expected
to
7
increase
the
price
the
governmental
body
would
have
to
pay
for
8
that
property.
The
minutes
and
the
tape
audio
recording
of
9
a
session
closed
under
this
paragraph
shall
be
available
for
10
public
examination
when
the
transaction
discussed
is
completed.
11
Sec.
6.
Section
21.5,
subsection
4,
Code
2011,
is
amended
12
to
read
as
follows:
13
4.
A
governmental
body
shall
keep
detailed
minutes
of
all
14
discussion,
persons
present,
and
action
occurring
at
a
closed
15
session,
and
shall
also
tape
audio
record
all
of
the
closed
16
session.
The
detailed
minutes
and
tape
audio
recording
of
a
17
closed
session
shall
be
sealed
and
shall
not
be
public
records
18
open
to
public
inspection.
However,
upon
order
of
the
court
19
in
an
action
to
enforce
this
chapter
,
the
detailed
minutes
20
and
tape
audio
recording
shall
be
unsealed
and
examined
by
21
the
court
in
camera.
The
court
shall
then
determine
what
22
part,
if
any,
of
the
minutes
should
be
disclosed
to
the
23
party
seeking
enforcement
of
this
chapter
for
use
in
that
24
enforcement
proceeding.
In
determining
whether
any
portion
of
25
the
minutes
or
recording
shall
be
disclosed
to
such
a
party
for
26
this
purpose,
the
court
shall
weigh
the
prejudicial
effects
27
to
the
public
interest
of
the
disclosure
of
any
portion
of
28
the
minutes
or
recording
in
question,
against
its
probative
29
value
as
evidence
in
an
enforcement
proceeding.
After
such
a
30
determination,
the
court
may
permit
inspection
and
use
of
all
31
or
portions
of
the
detailed
minutes
and
tape
audio
recording
by
32
the
party
seeking
enforcement
of
this
chapter
.
A
governmental
33
body
shall
keep
the
detailed
minutes
and
tape
audio
recording
34
of
any
closed
session
for
a
period
of
at
least
one
year
from
the
35
-3-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
3/
29
H.F.
205
date
of
that
meeting
,
except
as
otherwise
required
by
law
.
1
Sec.
7.
Section
21.6,
subsection
3,
paragraph
a,
Code
2011,
2
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
3
a.
Shall
assess
each
member
of
the
governmental
body
who
4
participated
in
its
violation
damages
in
the
amount
of
not
more
5
than
five
hundred
dollars
nor
and
not
less
than
one
hundred
6
dollars.
However,
if
a
member
of
a
governmental
body
knowingly
7
participated
in
such
a
violation,
damages
shall
be
in
the
8
amount
of
not
more
than
two
thousand
five
hundred
dollars
9
and
not
less
than
one
thousand
dollars.
These
damages
shall
10
be
paid
by
the
court
imposing
it
to
the
state
of
Iowa,
if
11
the
body
in
question
is
a
state
governmental
body,
or
to
the
12
local
government
involved
if
the
body
in
question
is
a
local
13
governmental
body.
A
member
of
a
governmental
body
found
to
14
have
violated
this
chapter
shall
not
be
assessed
such
damages
15
if
that
member
proves
that
the
member
did
any
of
the
following:
16
(1)
Voted
against
the
closed
session.
17
(2)
Had
good
reason
to
believe
and
in
good
faith
believed
18
facts
which,
if
true,
would
have
indicated
compliance
with
all
19
the
requirements
of
this
chapter
.
20
(3)
Reasonably
relied
upon
a
decision
of
a
court
,
or
a
21
formal
opinion
of
the
Iowa
public
information
board,
the
22
attorney
general
,
or
the
attorney
for
the
governmental
body
,
23
given
in
writing,
or
as
memorialized
in
the
minutes
of
the
24
meeting
at
which
a
formal
oral
opinion
was
given,
or
an
25
advisory
opinion
of
the
Iowa
public
information
board,
the
26
attorney
general,
or
the
attorney
for
the
governmental
body,
27
given
in
writing
.
28
Sec.
8.
Section
21.6,
subsection
3,
paragraph
d,
Code
2011,
29
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
30
d.
Shall
issue
an
order
removing
a
member
of
a
governmental
31
body
from
office
if
that
member
has
engaged
in
a
prior
32
violation
of
this
chapter
for
which
damages
were
assessed
33
against
the
member
during
the
member’s
term.
In
making
this
34
determination,
the
court
shall
recognize
violations
for
which
35
-4-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
4/
29
H.F.
205
damages
were
assessed
by
the
Iowa
public
information
board
1
created
in
section
23.3.
2
Sec.
9.
NEW
SECTION
.
22.01
Purpose.
3
The
purpose
of
this
chapter
is
to
provide
as
much
4
transparency
in
government
operations
as
possible
consistent
5
with
the
need
to
avoid
undue
invasions
of
personal
privacy
and
6
the
need
to
avoid
significant
interference
with
the
achievement
7
of
other
important
and
legitimate
state
objectives.
8
Sec.
10.
NEW
SECTION
.
22.2A
Record
requests
——
time
9
limits.
10
1.
Upon
receipt
of
an
oral
or
written
request
to
examine
or
11
copy
a
public
record,
the
lawful
custodian
shall,
if
feasible
12
in
the
ordinary
course
of
business,
permit
such
examination
13
or
copying
at
the
time
of
the
request.
If
it
is
not
feasible
14
in
the
ordinary
course
of
business
to
permit
examination
or
15
copying
of
the
public
record
at
the
time
of
the
request,
16
the
lawful
custodian
shall
immediately
notify
the
requester,
17
orally
or
in
writing,
when
such
examination
or
copying
may
take
18
place,
which
shall
be
no
later
than
five
business
days
from
19
the
time
of
the
request
unless
there
is
good
cause
for
further
20
delay.
If
further
delay
is
necessary
because
of
good
cause
21
in
responding
to
a
request
to
examine
or
copy
a
record
the
22
lawful
custodian
knows
is
a
public
record,
the
lawful
custodian
23
shall
provide
the
requester
with
a
written
statement
detailing
24
the
reason
or
reasons
for
the
delay
and
the
date
by
which
the
25
request
will
be
satisfied.
26
2.
If
the
lawful
custodian
is
in
doubt
as
to
whether
the
27
record
requested
is
a
public
record
or
whether
the
requester
28
should
be
permitted
to
examine
or
copy
a
public
record
29
specified
in
section
22.7,
the
lawful
custodian
shall
make
30
that
determination
within
ten
business
days
from
the
date
of
31
the
request
unless
further
delay
is
necessary
because
of
a
32
pending
request
by
the
lawful
custodian
to
the
Iowa
public
33
information
board
for
an
opinion
regarding
the
status
of
the
34
record
requested,
or
other
good
cause,
which
is
communicated
35
-5-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
5/
29
H.F.
205
in
writing
to
the
requester.
Examination
or
copying
of
the
1
government
record
shall
be
allowed
within
five
business
days
2
from
the
date
the
lawful
custodian
makes
the
determination
3
in
such
circumstances
to
permit
examination
or
copying
of
4
the
record
unless
there
is
good
cause
for
further
delay
in
5
fulfilling
the
request
as
provided
in
subsection
1.
6
3.
If
the
lawful
custodian
denies
a
request
to
examine
or
7
copy
a
public
record,
the
custodian
must
provide
the
requester
8
at
the
time
of
the
denial
a
written
statement
denying
the
9
request
and
detailing
the
specific
reason
or
reasons
for
the
10
denial.
11
4.
If
the
lawful
custodian
does
not
fulfill
a
request
to
12
examine
or
copy
a
public
record
within
the
times
prescribed
13
in
this
section,
the
request
shall
be
deemed
denied
and
the
14
requester
shall
be
entitled
to
file
a
complaint
with
the
Iowa
15
public
information
board
pursuant
to
section
23.7
or
file
a
16
lawsuit
against
the
lawful
custodian
pursuant
to
section
22.10.
17
Sec.
11.
Section
22.7,
subsection
7,
Code
2011,
is
amended
18
to
read
as
follows:
19
7.
Appraisals
or
appraisal
information
concerning
the
20
purchase
of
real
or
personal
property
for
public
purposes,
21
prior
to
public
announcement
of
a
project
the
submission
of
the
22
appraisal
to
the
property
owner
or
other
interest
holders
as
23
provided
in
section
6B.45
.
24
Sec.
12.
Section
22.7,
subsection
10,
Code
2011,
is
amended
25
by
striking
the
subsection.
26
Sec.
13.
Section
22.7,
subsection
11,
Code
2011,
is
amended
27
to
read
as
follows:
28
11.
a.
Personal
information
in
confidential
personnel
29
records
of
public
government
bodies
including
but
not
limited
30
to
cities,
boards
of
supervisors
and
school
districts.
relating
31
to
identified
or
identifiable
individuals
who
are
officials,
32
officers,
or
employees
of
the
government
bodies.
However,
the
33
following
information
relating
to
such
individuals
contained
in
34
personnel
records
shall
be
public
records:
35
-6-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
6/
29
H.F.
205
(1)
The
name
and
compensation
of
the
individual
including
1
any
written
agreement
establishing
compensation
or
any
other
2
terms
of
employment
excluding
any
information
otherwise
3
excludable
from
public
information
pursuant
to
this
section
or
4
any
other
applicable
provision
of
law.
For
purposes
of
this
5
subparagraph,
“compensation”
means
payment
of,
or
agreement
6
to
pay,
any
money,
thing
of
value,
or
financial
benefit
7
conferred
in
return
for
labor
or
services
rendered
by
an
8
officer,
employee,
or
other
person
plus
the
value
of
benefits
9
including
but
not
limited
to
casualty,
disability,
life,
or
10
health
insurance;
other
health
or
wellness
benefits;
vacation,
11
holiday,
and
sick
leave;
severance
payments;
retirement
12
benefits;
and
deferred
compensation.
13
(2)
The
date
the
individual
was
employed
by
the
government
14
body.
15
(3)
The
positions
the
individual
holds
or
has
held
with
the
16
government
body.
17
(4)
The
educational
institutions
attended
by
the
18
individual,
including
any
diplomas
and
degrees
earned,
and
19
the
names
of
the
individual’s
previous
employers,
positions
20
previously
held,
and
dates
of
previous
employment.
21
(5)
Any
final
disciplinary
action
taken
against
the
22
individual
that
resulted
in
the
individual’s
discharge.
23
b.
Personal
information
in
confidential
personnel
records
of
24
government
bodies
relating
to
student
employees
shall
only
be
25
released
pursuant
to
20
U.S.C.
§
1232g.
26
Sec.
14.
Section
22.7,
subsection
18,
Code
2011,
is
amended
27
to
read
as
follows:
28
18.
a.
Communications
not
required
by
law,
rule,
procedure,
29
or
contract
that
are
made
to
a
government
body
or
to
any
of
its
30
employees
by
identified
persons
outside
of
government,
to
the
31
extent
that
the
government
body
receiving
those
communications
32
from
such
persons
outside
of
government
could
reasonably
33
believe
that
those
persons
would
be
discouraged
from
making
34
them
to
that
government
body
if
they
were
available
for
general
35
-7-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
7/
29
H.F.
205
public
examination.
As
used
in
this
subsection
,
“persons
1
outside
of
government”
does
not
include
persons
or
employees
2
of
persons
who
are
communicating
with
respect
to
a
consulting
3
or
contractual
relationship
with
a
government
body
or
who
are
4
communicating
with
a
government
body
with
whom
an
arrangement
5
for
compensation
exists.
Notwithstanding
this
provision:
6
a.
(1)
The
communication
is
a
public
record
to
the
extent
7
that
the
person
outside
of
government
making
that
communication
8
consents
to
its
treatment
as
a
public
record.
9
b.
(2)
Information
contained
in
the
communication
is
a
10
public
record
to
the
extent
that
it
can
be
disclosed
without
11
directly
or
indirectly
indicating
the
identity
of
the
person
12
outside
of
government
making
it
or
enabling
others
to
ascertain
13
the
identity
of
that
person.
14
c.
(3)
Information
contained
in
the
communication
is
a
15
public
record
to
the
extent
that
it
indicates
the
date,
time,
16
specific
location,
and
immediate
facts
and
circumstances
17
surrounding
the
occurrence
of
a
crime
or
other
illegal
act,
18
except
to
the
extent
that
its
disclosure
would
plainly
and
19
seriously
jeopardize
a
continuing
investigation
or
pose
a
20
clear
and
present
danger
to
the
safety
of
any
person.
In
any
21
action
challenging
the
failure
of
the
lawful
custodian
to
22
disclose
any
particular
information
of
the
kind
enumerated
in
23
this
paragraph,
the
burden
of
proof
is
on
the
lawful
custodian
24
to
demonstrate
that
the
disclosure
of
that
information
would
25
jeopardize
such
an
investigation
or
would
pose
such
a
clear
and
26
present
danger.
27
b.
This
subsection
does
not
apply
to
information
relating
to
28
applications
to
a
government
body
for
employment.
29
Sec.
15.
Section
22.7,
subsections
40,
43,
and
48,
Code
30
2011,
are
amended
to
read
as
follows:
31
40.
The
portion
of
a
record
request
that
contains
an
32
internet
protocol
number
which
identifies
the
computer
from
33
which
a
person
requests
a
record,
whether
the
person
using
34
such
computer
makes
the
request
through
the
IowAccess
network
35
-8-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
8/
29
H.F.
205
or
directly
to
a
lawful
custodian
.
However,
such
record
may
1
be
released
with
the
express
written
consent
of
the
person
2
requesting
the
record.
3
43.
Information
obtained
by
the
commissioner
of
insurance
4
pursuant
to
section
502.607
,
subsection
2
.
5
48.
Sex
offender
registry
records
under
chapter
692A
,
6
except
shall
only
be
released
as
provided
in
section
692A.121
.
7
Sec.
16.
Section
22.7,
subsection
52,
paragraphs
a
and
c,
8
Code
2011,
are
amended
to
read
as
follows:
9
a.
The
following
records
relating
to
a
charitable
donation
10
made
to
a
foundation
acting
solely
for
the
support
of
an
11
institution
governed
by
the
state
board
of
regents,
to
a
12
foundation
acting
solely
for
the
support
of
an
institution
13
governed
by
chapter
260C
,
to
a
private
foundation
as
defined
14
in
section
509
of
the
Internal
Revenue
Code
organized
for
the
15
support
of
a
government
body,
or
to
an
endow
Iowa
qualified
16
community
foundation,
as
defined
in
section
15E.303
,
organized
17
for
the
support
of
a
government
body
:
18
(1)
Portions
of
records
that
disclose
a
donor’s
or
19
prospective
donor’s
personal,
financial,
estate
planning,
or
20
gift
planning
matters.
21
(2)
Records
received
from
a
donor
or
prospective
donor
22
regarding
such
donor’s
prospective
gift
or
pledge.
23
(3)
Records
containing
information
about
a
donor
or
a
24
prospective
donor
in
regard
to
the
appropriateness
of
the
25
solicitation
and
dollar
amount
of
the
gift
or
pledge.
26
(4)
Portions
of
records
that
identify
a
prospective
donor
27
and
that
provide
information
on
the
appropriateness
of
the
28
solicitation,
the
form
of
the
gift
or
dollar
amount
requested
29
by
the
solicitor,
and
the
name
of
the
solicitor.
30
(5)
Portions
of
records
disclosing
the
identity
of
a
donor
31
or
prospective
donor,
including
the
specific
form
of
gift
32
or
pledge
that
could
identify
a
donor
or
prospective
donor,
33
directly
or
indirectly,
when
such
donor
has
requested
anonymity
34
in
connection
with
the
gift
or
pledge.
This
subparagraph
does
35
-9-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
9/
29
H.F.
205
not
apply
to
a
gift
or
pledge
from
a
publicly
held
business
1
corporation.
2
c.
Except
as
provided
in
paragraphs
“a”
and
“b”
,
portions
3
of
records
relating
to
the
receipt,
holding,
and
disbursement
4
of
gifts
made
for
the
benefit
of
regents
institutions
and
5
made
through
foundations
established
for
support
of
regents
6
institutions,
including
but
not
limited
to
written
fund-raising
7
policies
and
documents
evidencing
fund-raising
practices,
shall
8
be
subject
to
this
chapter
.
Unless
otherwise
provided,
the
9
lawful
custodian
of
all
records
subject
to
this
paragraph
is
10
the
regents
institution
to
be
benefited
by
such
gifts.
11
Sec.
17.
Section
22.7,
Code
2011,
is
amended
by
adding
the
12
following
new
subsection:
13
NEW
SUBSECTION
.
66.
Public
employment
applications.
14
a.
The
identity
and
qualifications
of
an
applicant
for
15
employment
by
a
government
body
if
the
applicant
requests
16
anonymity
in
writing
and
the
government
body
determines
that
17
anonymity
is
necessary
to
induce
the
applicant
to
apply
for
the
18
employment
position.
Such
information
shall
be
exempt
from
19
disclosure
until
an
applicant
is
considered
by
the
government
20
body
to
be
a
finalist
for
the
position.
For
purposes
of
this
21
subsection,
“finalist”
means
any
applicant
who
is
determined
22
to
be
among
those
who
are
under
final
consideration
for
23
the
position,
and
at
least
includes
the
five
most
qualified
24
applicants
as
determined
by
the
recommending
or
selecting
25
authority.
If
there
are
five
or
fewer
applicants
for
the
26
particular
position,
all
of
the
applicants
shall
be
considered
27
finalists
for
purposes
of
this
subsection.
The
identities
and
28
qualifications
of
the
finalists
shall
be
made
available
for
29
public
inspection
at
least
three
business
days
prior
to
a
final
30
employment
decision.
31
b.
Documents
relating
to
a
government
body’s
evaluation
of
32
the
qualifications
and
merits
of
an
applicant
for
employment
33
by
that
government
body.
34
Sec.
18.
Section
22.10,
subsection
3,
paragraph
b,
Code
35
-10-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
10/
29
H.F.
205
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
1
b.
Shall
assess
the
persons
who
participated
in
its
2
violation
damages
in
the
amount
of
not
more
than
five
hundred
3
dollars
nor
and
not
less
than
one
hundred
dollars.
However,
if
4
a
member
of
a
government
body
knowingly
participated
in
such
a
5
violation,
damages
shall
be
in
the
amount
of
not
more
than
two
6
thousand
five
hundred
dollars
and
not
less
than
one
thousand
7
dollars.
These
damages
shall
be
paid
by
the
court
imposing
8
them
to
the
state
of
Iowa
if
the
body
in
question
is
a
state
9
government
body,
or
to
the
local
government
involved
if
the
10
body
in
question
is
a
local
government
body.
A
person
found
to
11
have
violated
this
chapter
shall
not
be
assessed
such
damages
12
if
that
person
proves
that
the
person
either
voted
did
any
of
13
the
following:
14
(1)
Voted
against
the
action
violating
this
chapter
,
15
refused
to
participate
in
the
action
violating
this
chapter
,
or
16
engaged
in
reasonable
efforts
under
the
circumstances
to
resist
17
or
prevent
the
action
in
violation
of
this
chapter
;
had
.
18
(2)
Had
good
reason
to
believe
and
in
good
faith
believed
19
facts
which,
if
true,
would
have
indicated
compliance
with
the
20
requirements
of
this
chapter
;
or
reasonably
.
21
(3)
Reasonably
relied
upon
a
decision
of
a
court
or
an
,
22
a
formal
opinion
of
the
Iowa
public
information
board,
the
23
attorney
general
,
or
the
attorney
for
the
government
body
,
24
given
in
writing,
or
as
memorialized
in
the
minutes
of
the
25
meeting
at
which
a
formal
oral
opinion
was
given,
or
an
26
advisory
opinion
of
the
Iowa
public
information
board,
the
27
attorney
general,
or
the
attorney
for
the
government
body,
28
given
in
writing
.
29
Sec.
19.
Section
22.10,
subsection
3,
paragraph
d,
Code
30
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
follows:
31
d.
Shall
issue
an
order
removing
a
person
from
office
if
32
that
person
has
engaged
in
a
prior
violation
of
this
chapter
33
for
which
damages
were
assessed
against
the
person
during
the
34
person’s
term.
In
making
this
determination,
the
court
shall
35
-11-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
11/
29
H.F.
205
recognize
violations
for
which
damages
were
assessed
by
the
1
Iowa
public
information
board
created
in
section
23.3.
2
Sec.
20.
Section
22.10,
subsection
5,
Code
2011,
is
amended
3
by
striking
the
subsection.
4
Sec.
21.
Section
22.13,
Code
2011,
is
amended
to
read
as
5
follows:
6
22.13
Settlements
——
governmental
government
bodies.
7
1.
A
written
summary
of
the
terms
of
settlement,
including
8
amounts
of
payments
made
to
or
through
a
claimant,
or
9
other
disposition
of
any
claim
for
damages
made
against
a
10
governmental
government
body
or
against
an
employee,
officer,
11
or
agent
of
a
governmental
governnment
body,
by
an
insurer
12
pursuant
to
a
contract
of
liability
insurance
issued
to
13
the
governmental
government
body,
shall
be
filed
with
the
14
governmental
government
body
and
shall
be
a
public
record.
15
2.
A
final
binding
settlement
agreement
between
any
16
government
body
of
this
state
or
unit
or
official
of
such
a
17
government
body
that
resolves
a
legal
dispute
between
such
a
18
government
body
and
another
person
or
entity
shall
be
filed
19
with
the
government
body.
For
each
such
settlement
agreement,
20
the
government
body
shall
prepare
and
file,
together
with
21
the
settlement
agreement,
a
brief
summary
indicating
the
22
identity
of
the
parties
involved,
the
nature
of
the
dispute,
23
any
underlying
relevant
facts,
and
the
terms
of
the
settlement.
24
The
settlement
agreement
and
summary
shall
be
available
for
25
public
inspection.
26
Sec.
22.
Section
22.14,
subsection
3,
Code
2011,
is
amended
27
to
read
as
follows:
28
3.
If
a
fiduciary
or
other
third
party
with
custody
of
29
public
investment
transactions
records
fails
to
produce
public
30
records
within
a
reasonable
period
of
time
as
requested
by
31
the
public
government
body,
the
public
government
body
shall
32
make
no
new
investments
with
or
through
the
fiduciary
or
other
33
third
party
and
shall
not
renew
existing
investments
upon
their
34
maturity
with
or
through
the
fiduciary
or
other
third
party.
35
-12-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
12/
29
H.F.
205
The
fiduciary
or
other
third
party
shall
be
liable
for
the
1
penalties
imposed
under
section
22.6
statute,
common
law,
or
2
contract
due
to
the
acts
or
omissions
of
the
fiduciary
or
other
3
third
party
and
any
other
remedies
available
under
statute,
4
common
law,
or
contract
.
5
Sec.
23.
NEW
SECTION
.
22.15
Judicial
branch
——
rules.
6
This
chapter
does
not
apply
to
government
records
owned,
7
created,
possessed,
or
under
the
control
of
the
judicial
branch
8
related
to
the
performance
by
the
courts
of
their
judicial
9
functions.
The
supreme
court
shall
prescribe
rules
governing
10
access
to
such
records
consistent
with
the
purposes
of
this
11
chapter.
12
Sec.
24.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.1
Citation
and
purpose.
13
This
chapter
may
be
cited
as
the
“Iowa
Public
Information
14
Board
Act”
.
The
purpose
of
this
chapter
is
to
provide
15
an
alternative
means
by
which
to
secure
compliance
with
16
and
enforcement
of
the
requirements
of
chapters
21
and
22
17
through
the
provision
by
the
Iowa
public
information
board
18
to
all
interested
parties
of
an
efficient,
informal,
and
19
cost-effective
process
for
resolving
disputes.
20
Sec.
25.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.2
Definitions.
21
1.
“Board”
means
the
Iowa
public
information
board
created
22
in
section
23.3.
23
2.
“Complainant”
means
a
person
who
files
a
complaint
with
24
the
board.
25
3.
“Complaint”
means
a
written
and
signed
document
filed
26
with
the
board
alleging
a
violation
of
chapter
21
or
22.
27
4.
“Custodian”
means
a
government
body,
government
official,
28
or
government
employee
designated
as
the
lawful
custodian
of
a
29
government
record
pursuant
to
section
22.1.
30
5.
“Government
body”
means
the
same
as
defined
in
section
31
22.1.
32
6.
“Person”
means
an
individual,
partnership,
association,
33
corporation,
legal
representative,
trustee,
receiver,
34
custodian,
government
body,
or
official,
employee,
agency,
or
35
-13-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
13/
29
H.F.
205
political
subdivision
of
this
state.
1
7.
“Respondent”
means
any
agency
or
other
unit
of
state
or
2
local
government,
custodian,
government
official,
or
government
3
employee
who
is
the
subject
of
a
complaint.
4
Sec.
26.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.3
Board
appointed.
5
1.
An
Iowa
public
information
board
is
created
consisting
of
6
five
members
appointed
by
the
governor,
subject
to
confirmation
7
by
the
senate.
Membership
shall
be
balanced
as
to
political
8
affiliation
as
provided
in
section
69.16
and
gender
as
provided
9
in
section
69.16A.
Members
appointed
to
the
board
shall
serve
10
staggered,
four-year
terms,
beginning
and
ending
as
provided
by
11
section
69.19.
A
quorum
shall
consist
of
three
members.
12
2.
A
vacancy
on
the
board
shall
be
filled
by
the
governor
by
13
appointment
for
the
unexpired
part
of
the
term.
A
board
member
14
may
be
removed
from
office
by
the
governor
for
good
cause.
15
The
board
shall
select
one
of
its
members
to
serve
as
chair
16
and
shall
employ
a
director
who
shall
serve
as
the
executive
17
officer
of
the
board.
18
Sec.
27.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.4
Compensation
and
expenses.
19
Board
members
shall
be
paid
a
per
diem
as
specified
in
20
section
7E.6
and
shall
be
reimbursed
for
actual
and
necessary
21
expenses
incurred
while
on
official
board
business.
Per
diem
22
and
expenses
shall
be
paid
from
funds
appropriated
to
the
23
board.
24
Sec.
28.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.5
Election
of
remedies.
25
1.
An
aggrieved
person,
any
taxpayer
to
or
citizen
of
26
this
state,
the
attorney
general,
or
any
county
attorney
may
27
seek
enforcement
of
the
requirements
of
chapters
21
and
22
by
28
electing
either
to
file
an
action
pursuant
to
section
17A.19,
29
21.6,
or
22.10,
whichever
is
applicable,
or
in
the
alternative,
30
to
file
a
timely
complaint
with
the
board.
31
2.
If
more
than
one
person
seeks
enforcement
of
chapter
21
32
or
22
with
respect
to
the
same
incident
involving
an
alleged
33
violation,
and
one
or
more
of
such
persons
elects
to
do
so
by
34
filing
an
action
under
section
17A.19,
21.6,
or
22.10,
and
one
35
-14-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
14/
29
H.F.
205
or
more
of
such
persons
elects
to
do
so
by
filing
a
timely
1
complaint
with
the
board,
the
court
in
which
the
action
is
2
filed
shall
dismiss
the
action
without
prejudice,
authorizing
3
the
complainant
to
file
a
complaint
with
respect
to
the
same
4
incident
with
the
board
without
regard
to
the
timeliness
of
5
the
filing
of
the
complaint
at
the
time
the
action
in
court
is
6
dismissed.
7
3.
If
a
person
files
an
action
pursuant
to
section
22.8
8
seeking
to
enjoin
the
inspection
of
a
public
record,
the
9
respondent
or
person
requesting
access
to
the
record
which
10
is
the
subject
of
the
request
for
injunction
may
remove
the
11
proceeding
to
the
board
for
its
determination
by
filing,
within
12
thirty
days
of
the
commencement
of
the
judicial
proceeding,
a
13
complaint
with
the
board
alleging
a
violation
of
chapter
22
in
14
regard
to
the
same
matter.
15
Sec.
29.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.6
Board
powers
and
duties.
16
The
board
shall
have
all
of
the
following
powers
and
duties:
17
1.
Employ
such
employees
as
are
necessary
to
execute
its
18
authority,
including
administrative
law
judges,
and
attorneys
19
to
prosecute
respondents
in
proceedings
before
the
board
20
and
to
represent
the
board
in
proceedings
before
a
court.
21
Notwithstanding
section
8A.412,
all
of
the
board’s
employees,
22
except
for
the
executive
director
and
attorneys,
shall
be
23
employed
subject
to
the
merit
system
provisions
of
chapter
8A,
24
subchapter
IV.
25
2.
Adopt
rules
with
the
force
of
law
pursuant
to
chapter
26
17A
calculated
to
implement,
enforce,
and
interpret
the
27
requirements
of
chapters
21
and
22
and
to
implement
any
28
authority
delegated
to
the
board
by
this
chapter.
29
3.
Issue,
consistent
with
the
requirements
of
section
30
17A.9,
declaratory
orders
with
the
force
of
law
determining
31
the
applicability
of
chapter
21
or
22
to
specified
fact
32
situations
and
issue
informal
advice
to
any
person
concerning
33
the
applicability
of
chapters
21
and
22.
34
4.
Receive
complaints
alleging
violations
of
chapter
21
35
-15-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
15/
29
H.F.
205
or
22,
seek
resolution
of
such
complaints
through
informal
1
assistance
or
through
mediation
and
settlement,
formally
2
investigate
such
complaints,
decide
after
such
an
investigation
3
whether
there
is
probable
cause
to
believe
a
violation
of
4
chapter
21
or
22
has
occurred,
and
if
probable
cause
has
been
5
found
prosecute
the
respondent
before
the
board
in
a
contested
6
case
proceeding
conducted
according
to
the
provisions
of
7
chapter
17A.
8
5.
Request
and
receive
from
a
government
body
assistance
9
and
information
as
necessary
in
the
performance
of
its
duties.
10
The
board
may
examine
a
record
of
a
government
body
that
is
11
the
subject
matter
of
a
complaint,
including
any
record
that
12
is
confidential
by
law.
Confidential
records
provided
to
13
the
board
by
a
governmental
body
shall
continue
to
maintain
14
their
confidential
status.
Any
member
or
employee
of
the
15
board
is
subject
to
the
same
policies
and
penalties
regarding
16
the
confidentiality
of
the
document
as
an
employee
of
the
17
government
body.
18
6.
Issue
subpoenas
enforceable
in
court
for
the
purpose
of
19
investigating
complaints
and
to
facilitate
the
prosecution
and
20
conduct
of
contested
cases
before
the
board.
21
7.
After
appropriate
board
proceedings,
issue
orders
22
with
the
force
of
law,
determining
whether
there
has
been
23
a
violation
of
chapter
21
or
22,
requiring
compliance
with
24
specified
provisions
of
those
chapters,
imposing
civil
25
penalties
equivalent
to
and
to
the
same
extent
as
those
damages
26
provided
for
in
section
21.6
or
22.10,
as
applicable,
on
a
27
respondent
who
has
been
found
in
violation
of
chapter
21
or
28
22,
and
imposing
any
other
appropriate
remedies
calculated
29
to
declare,
terminate,
or
remediate
any
violation
of
those
30
chapters.
31
8.
Represent
itself
in
judicial
proceedings
to
enforce
or
32
defend
its
orders
and
rules
through
attorneys
on
its
own
staff,
33
through
the
office
of
the
attorney
general,
or
through
other
34
attorneys
retained
by
the
board,
at
its
option.
35
-16-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
16/
29
H.F.
205
9.
Make
training
opportunities
available
to
lawful
1
custodians,
government
bodies,
and
other
persons
subject
to
2
the
requirements
of
chapters
21
and
22
and
require,
in
its
3
discretion,
appropriate
persons
who
have
responsibilities
in
4
relation
to
chapters
21
and
22
to
receive
periodic
training
5
approved
by
the
board.
6
10.
Disseminate
information
calculated
to
inform
members
7
of
the
public
about
the
public’s
right
to
access
government
8
information
in
this
state
including
procedures
to
facilitate
9
this
access
and
including
information
relating
to
the
10
obligations
of
government
bodies
under
chapter
21
and
lawful
11
custodians
under
chapter
22
and
other
laws
dealing
with
this
12
subject.
13
11.
Prepare
and
transmit
to
the
governor
and
to
the
general
14
assembly,
at
least
annually,
reports
describing
complaints
15
received,
board
proceedings,
investigations,
hearings
16
conducted,
decisions
rendered,
and
other
work
performed
by
the
17
board.
18
12.
Make
recommendations
to
the
general
assembly
proposing
19
legislation
relating
to
public
access
to
government
information
20
deemed
desirable
by
the
board
in
light
of
the
policy
of
21
this
state
to
provide
as
much
public
access
as
possible
22
to
government
information
as
is
consistent
with
the
public
23
interest
and
the
need
to
protect
individuals
against
undue
24
invasions
of
personal
privacy.
25
Sec.
30.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.7
Filing
of
complaints
with
the
26
board.
27
1.
The
board
shall
adopt
rules
with
the
force
of
law
28
and
pursuant
to
chapter
17A
providing
for
the
timing,
form,
29
content,
and
means
by
which
any
aggrieved
person,
any
taxpayer
30
to
or
citizen
of
this
state,
the
attorney
general,
or
any
31
county
attorney
may
file
a
complaint
with
the
board
alleging
32
a
violation
of
chapter
21
or
22.
The
complaint
must
be
filed
33
within
sixty
days
from
the
time
the
alleged
violation
occurred
34
or
the
complainant
could
have
become
aware
of
the
violation
35
-17-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
17/
29
H.F.
205
with
reasonable
diligence.
All
complaints
filed
with
the
board
1
shall
be
public
records.
2
2.
All
board
proceedings
in
response
to
the
filing
of
a
3
complaint
shall
be
conducted
as
expeditiously
as
possible.
4
3.
The
board
shall
not
charge
a
complainant
any
fee
in
5
relation
to
the
filing
of
a
complaint,
the
processing
of
a
6
complaint,
or
any
board
proceeding
or
judicial
proceeding
7
resulting
from
the
filing
of
a
complaint.
8
Sec.
31.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.8
Initial
processing
of
9
complaint.
10
Upon
receipt
of
a
complaint
alleging
a
violation
of
chapter
11
21
or
22,
the
board
shall
do
either
of
the
following:
12
1.
Determine
that,
on
its
face,
the
complaint
is
within
13
the
board’s
jurisdiction,
appears
legally
sufficient,
and
14
could
have
merit.
In
such
a
case
the
board
shall
accept
15
the
complaint,
and
shall
notify
the
parties
of
that
fact
in
16
writing.
17
2.
Determine
that,
on
its
face,
the
complaint
is
outside
18
its
jurisdiction,
is
legally
insufficient,
is
frivolous,
19
is
without
merit,
involves
harmless
error,
or
relates
to
a
20
specific
incident
that
has
previously
been
finally
disposed
of
21
on
its
merits
by
the
board
or
a
court.
In
such
a
case
the
board
22
shall
decline
to
accept
the
complaint.
If
the
board
refuses
23
to
accept
a
complaint,
the
board
shall
provide
the
complainant
24
with
a
written
order
explaining
its
reasons
for
the
action.
25
Sec.
32.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.9
Informal
assistance
——
mediation
26
and
settlement.
27
1.
After
accepting
a
complaint,
the
board
shall
promptly
28
work
with
the
parties
through
its
employees
to
reach
an
29
informal,
expeditious
resolution
of
the
complaint.
If
an
30
informal
resolution
satisfactory
to
the
parties
cannot
be
31
reached,
the
board
or
the
board’s
designee
shall
offer
the
32
parties
an
opportunity
to
resolve
the
dispute
through
mediation
33
and
settlement.
34
2.
The
mediation
and
settlement
process
shall
enable
the
35
-18-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
18/
29
H.F.
205
complainant
to
attempt
to
resolve
the
dispute
with
the
aid
of
1
a
neutral
mediator
employed
and
selected
by
the
board,
in
its
2
discretion,
from
either
its
own
staff
or
an
outside
source.
3
3.
Mediation
shall
be
conducted
as
an
informal,
4
nonadversarial
process
and
in
a
manner
calculated
to
help
5
the
parties
reach
a
mutually
acceptable
and
voluntary
6
settlement
agreement.
The
mediator
shall
assist
the
parties
in
7
identifying
issues
and
shall
foster
joint
problem
solving
and
8
the
exploration
of
settlement
alternatives.
9
Sec.
33.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.10
Enforcement.
10
1.
If
any
party
declines
mediation
or
settlement
or
if
11
mediation
or
settlement
fails
to
resolve
the
matter
to
the
12
satisfaction
of
all
parties,
the
board
shall
initiate
a
formal
13
investigation
concerning
the
facts
and
circumstances
set
forth
14
in
the
complaint.
The
board
shall,
after
an
appropriate
15
investigation,
make
a
determination
as
to
whether
the
complaint
16
is
within
the
board’s
jurisdiction
and
whether
there
is
17
probable
cause
to
believe
that
the
facts
and
circumstances
18
alleged
in
the
complaint
constitute
a
violation
of
chapter
21
19
or
22.
20
2.
If
the
board
finds
the
complaint
is
outside
the
board’s
21
jurisdiction
or
there
is
no
probable
cause
to
believe
there
22
has
been
a
violation
of
chapter
21
or
22,
the
board
shall
23
issue
a
written
order
explaining
the
reasons
for
the
board’s
24
conclusions
and
dismissing
the
complaint,
and
shall
transmit
25
a
copy
to
the
complainant
and
to
the
party
against
whom
the
26
complaint
was
filed.
27
3.
a.
If
the
board
finds
the
complaint
is
within
the
28
board’s
jurisdiction
and
there
is
probable
cause
to
believe
29
there
has
been
a
violation
of
chapter
21
or
22,
the
board
30
shall
issue
a
written
order
to
that
effect
and
shall
commence
31
a
contested
case
proceeding
under
chapter
17A
against
32
the
respondent.
An
attorney
selected
by
the
director
of
33
the
board
shall
prosecute
the
respondent
in
the
contested
34
case
proceeding.
At
the
termination
of
the
contested
case
35
-19-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
19/
29
H.F.
205
proceeding
the
board
shall,
by
a
majority
vote
of
its
members,
1
render
a
final
decision
as
to
the
merits
of
the
complaint.
If
2
the
board
finds
that
the
complaint
has
merit,
the
board
may
3
issue
any
appropriate
order
to
ensure
enforcement
of
chapter
21
4
or
22
including
but
not
limited
to
an
order
requiring
specified
5
action
or
prohibiting
specified
action
and
any
appropriate
6
order
to
remedy
any
failure
of
the
respondent
to
observe
any
7
provision
of
those
chapters.
8
b.
If
the
board
determines,
by
a
majority
vote
of
its
9
members,
that
the
respondent
has
violated
chapter
21
or
22,
the
10
board
may
also
do
any
or
all
of
the
following:
11
(1)
Require
the
respondent
to
pay
damages
as
provided
for
12
in
section
21.6
or
22.10,
whichever
is
applicable,
to
the
13
extent
that
provision
would
make
such
damages
payable
if
the
14
complainant
had
sought
to
enforce
a
violation
in
court
instead
15
of
through
the
board.
16
(2)
Void
any
action
taken
in
violation
of
chapter
21
if
a
17
court
would
be
authorized
to
do
so
in
similar
circumstances
18
pursuant
to
section
21.6.
19
c.
The
board
shall
not
have
the
authority
to
remove
a
person
20
from
public
office
for
a
violation
of
chapter
21
or
22.
The
21
board
may
file
an
action
under
chapter
21
or
22
to
remove
a
22
person
from
office
for
violations
that
would
subject
a
person
23
to
removal
under
those
chapters.
24
d.
A
final
board
order
resulting
from
such
proceedings
may
25
be
enforced
by
the
board
in
court
and
is
subject
to
judicial
26
review
pursuant
to
section
17A.19.
27
Sec.
34.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.11
Defenses
in
a
contested
case
28
proceeding.
29
A
respondent
may
defend
against
a
proceeding
before
the
30
board
charging
a
violation
of
chapter
21
or
22
on
the
grounds
31
that
if
such
a
violation
occurred
it
was
only
harmless
error
or
32
that
clear
and
convincing
evidence
demonstrated
that
grounds
33
existed
to
justify
a
court
to
issue
an
injunction
against
34
disclosure
pursuant
to
section
22.8.
35
-20-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
20/
29
H.F.
205
Sec.
35.
NEW
SECTION
.
23.12
Jurisdiction.
1
The
board
shall
not
have
jurisdiction
over
the
judicial
2
or
legislative
branches
of
state
government
or
any
entity,
3
officer,
or
employee
of
those
branches,
or
over
the
governor
4
or
the
office
of
the
governor.
5
Sec.
36.
Section
455K.4,
subsection
4,
Code
2011,
is
amended
6
to
read
as
follows:
7
4.
Information
that
is
disclosed
under
subsection
2
,
8
paragraph
“b”
,
is
confidential
and
is
not
subject
to
disclosure
9
under
chapter
22
.
A
governmental
entity,
governmental
10
employee,
or
governmental
official
who
discloses
information
in
11
violation
of
this
subsection
is
subject
to
the
penalty
provided
12
in
section
22.6
.
13
Sec.
37.
REPEAL.
Section
22.6,
Code
2011,
is
repealed.
14
EXPLANATION
15
This
bill
relates
to
Iowa’s
Open
Meetings
Law
(Code
chapter
16
21)
and
Iowa’s
Open
Records
Law
(Code
chapter
22)
and
creates
17
the
Iowa
public
information
board.
18
MEETINGS.
The
bill
provides
that
except
as
otherwise
19
provided,
a
reconvened
meeting
of
a
governmental
body
is
also
20
subject
to
the
meeting
notice
requirements
pursuant
to
Code
21
section
21.4.
This
requirement
does
not
apply
to
a
meeting
of
22
a
governmental
body
that
is
reconvened
within
four
hours
of
the
23
start
of
its
recess,
where
an
announcement
of
the
time,
date,
24
and
place
of
the
reconvened
meeting
is
made
at
the
original
25
meeting
in
open
session
and
recorded
in
the
minutes
of
the
26
meeting
and
there
is
no
change
in
the
agenda.
The
notice
27
requirement
also
does
not
apply
to
a
meeting
held
by
a
formally
28
constituted
subunit
of
a
parent
governmental
body
during
a
29
lawful
meeting
of
the
parent
governmental
body
or
during
a
30
recess
in
that
meeting
of
up
to
four
hours,
or
a
meeting
of
31
that
subunit
immediately
following
the
meeting
of
the
parent
32
governmental
body,
if
the
meeting
of
the
subunit
is
publicly
33
announced
in
open
session
at
the
parent
meeting
and
the
subject
34
of
the
meeting
reasonably
coincides
with
the
subjects
discussed
35
-21-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
21/
29
H.F.
205
or
acted
upon
by
the
parent
governmental
body.
The
bill
also
1
changes
all
references
relating
to
“tape”
recordings
of
closed
2
meetings
to
“audio”
recordings.
3
CIVIL
AND
CRIMINAL
PENALTY
PROVISIONS.
The
bill
increases
4
the
civil
penalty
damage
amounts
for
violations
of
the
open
5
meetings
and
public
records
laws
for
each
member
of
the
6
governmental
body
or
each
person
who
knowingly
participated
in
7
the
violation
from
not
less
than
$100
and
not
more
than
$500
to
8
not
less
than
$1,000
and
not
more
than
$2,500
subject
to
the
9
existing
defenses
contained
in
Code
sections
21.6
and
22.10.
10
The
bill
retains
the
current
civil
penalty
damage
amounts
for
11
such
violations
for
each
member
of
the
governmental
body
or
12
each
person
who
participated
in
the
violation
($100
to
$500).
13
The
bill
repeals
the
criminal
penalty
provision
for
knowing
14
violations
or
attempts
to
violate
any
provisions
of
the
public
15
records
law.
16
OPEN
RECORDS
——
CHAPTER
PURPOSE.
The
bill
provides
a
purpose
17
provision
in
the
open
records
chapter.
The
bill
provides
that
18
the
purpose
of
the
open
records
law
is
to
provide
as
much
19
transparency
in
government
operations
as
possible
consistent
20
with
the
need
to
avoid
undue
invasions
of
personal
privacy.
21
RECORDS
REQUESTS
——
TIME
LIMITS.
The
bill
provides
that
22
upon
receipt
of
an
oral
or
written
request
to
examine
or
copy
23
a
public
record,
the
lawful
custodian
shall,
if
feasible
in
24
the
ordinary
course
of
business,
permit
such
examination
or
25
copying
at
the
time
of
the
request.
If
it
is
not
feasible
26
in
the
ordinary
course
of
business
to
permit
examination
or
27
copying
of
the
public
record
at
the
time
of
the
request,
the
28
lawful
custodian
shall
immediately
notify
the
requester,
orally
29
or
in
writing,
when
such
examination
or
copying
may
take
place
30
which
shall
be
no
later
than
five
business
days
from
the
time
31
of
the
request
unless
there
is
good
cause
for
further
delay.
32
If
further
delay
is
necessary
because
of
good
cause,
the
lawful
33
custodian
shall
provide
the
requester
with
a
written
statement
34
detailing
the
reason
or
reasons
for
the
delay
and
the
date
by
35
-22-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
22/
29
H.F.
205
which
the
request
will
be
satisfied.
If
the
lawful
custodian
1
is
in
doubt
as
to
whether
the
record
requested
is
a
public
2
record
or
whether
the
requester
should
be
permitted
to
examine
3
or
copy
a
record
specified
in
Code
section
22.7,
the
lawful
4
custodian
shall
make
that
determination
within
10
business
days
5
from
the
date
of
the
request
unless
further
delay
is
necessary.
6
Examination
or
copying
of
the
record
shall
be
allowed
within
7
five
business
days
from
the
date
the
lawful
custodian
makes
8
the
decision
to
permit
examination
or
copying
of
the
record
9
unless
there
is
good
cause
for
further
delay
in
fulfilling
the
10
request.
If
the
lawful
custodian
denies
a
request
to
examine
11
or
copy
a
record,
the
custodian
must
provide
the
requester
at
12
the
time
of
the
denial
a
written
statement
denying
the
request
13
and
detailing
the
specific
reason
or
reasons
for
the
denial.
14
If
the
lawful
custodian
does
not
fulfill
a
request
to
examine
15
or
copy
a
public
record
within
the
time
frames
prescribed,
16
the
request
shall
be
deemed
denied
and
the
requester
shall
be
17
entitled
to
file
a
complaint
with
the
Iowa
public
information
18
board
created
in
Code
section
23.7
or
may
file
a
lawsuit
19
against
the
lawful
custodian
pursuant
to
Code
section
22.10.
20
APPRAISAL
INFORMATION.
Current
law
provides
that
appraisal
21
or
appraisal
information
concerning
the
purchase
of
real
22
or
personal
property
for
public
purposes,
prior
to
public
23
announcement
of
a
project,
shall
be
confidential.
The
bill
24
amends
this
law
to
provide
that
such
information
shall
remain
25
confidential
prior
to
the
submission
of
the
appraisal
to
the
26
property
owner
or
other
interest
holders
as
provided
in
Code
27
section
6B.45.
28
PERSONAL
INFORMATION
IN
CONFIDENTIAL
PERSONNEL
RECORDS.
29
Current
law
provides
that
personal
information
in
confidential
30
personnel
records
of
government
bodies
shall
be
confidential,
31
unless
otherwise
ordered
by
a
court,
by
the
lawful
custodian,
32
or
by
another
duly
authorized
person
to
release
such
33
information.
The
bill
specifies
that
the
name
and
compensation
34
of
the
individual,
the
date
the
individual
was
employed
by
the
35
-23-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
23/
29
H.F.
205
government
body,
the
positions
the
individual
holds
or
has
held
1
with
the
government
body,
the
individual’s
qualifications
for
2
the
position
that
the
individual
holds
or
has
held
including
3
but
not
limited
to
educational
background
and
work
experience,
4
and
any
final
disciplinary
action
taken
against
the
individual
5
that
resulted
in
the
individual’s
discharge
shall
be
public
6
records.
7
PUBLIC
EMPLOYMENT
APPLICATIONS.
The
bill
provides
that
8
identity
and
qualifications
of
an
applicant
for
employment
by
a
9
government
body
if
the
applicant
requests
anonymity
in
writing
10
and
the
government
body
determines
that
anonymity
is
necessary
11
to
induce
the
applicant
to
apply
for
the
public
employment
12
position
shall
be
confidential
unless
otherwise
ordered
by
a
13
court,
by
the
lawful
custodian,
or
by
another
duly
authorized
14
person.
Such
information
shall
be
exempt
from
disclosure
15
until
an
applicant
is
considered
by
the
government
body
to
be
16
a
finalist
for
a
position
in
public
employment.
“Finalist”
17
means
a
person
who
is
one
of
five
or
fewer
applicants
under
18
final
consideration
for
a
public
employment
position.
If
there
19
are
five
or
fewer
applicants
for
the
particular
position,
20
all
of
the
applicants
shall
be
considered
finalists.
The
21
identities
and
qualifications
of
the
finalists
shall
be
made
22
available
for
public
inspection
at
least
three
business
days
23
prior
to
the
final
employment
decision.
Documents
relating
24
to
a
government
body’s
evaluation
of
the
qualifications
and
25
merits
of
an
applicant
for
employment
by
a
government
body
are
26
also
confidential
records
unless
otherwise
released
by
the
27
appropriate
person.
28
SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENTS.
Code
chapter
22
currently
provides
29
that
a
written
summary
of
the
terms
of
settlement
or
other
30
disposition
of
any
claim
for
damages
made
against
any
31
government
body
or
against
an
employee,
officer,
or
agent
of
32
a
government
body,
by
an
insurer
pursuant
to
a
contract
of
33
liability
insurance
issued
to
the
government
body,
shall
be
34
filed
with
the
government
body
and
shall
be
a
public
record.
35
-24-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
24/
29
H.F.
205
The
bill
provides
that
all
final
binding
settlement
agreements
1
between
any
government
body
of
this
state
or
other
unit
or
2
official
of
such
a
government
body
that
resolves
a
legal
3
dispute
between
such
a
government
body
and
another
person
or
4
entity
shall
be
filed
with
the
government
body
together
with
a
5
brief
summary
indicating
the
identity
of
the
parties
involved,
6
the
nature
of
the
dispute,
any
underlying
relevant
facts,
and
7
the
terms
of
the
settlement.
The
settlement
agreement
and
8
summary
shall
be
available
for
public
inspection.
9
JUDICIAL
BRANCH
——
RULES.
The
bill
provides
that
Code
10
chapter
22
does
not
apply
to
government
records
owned,
created,
11
possessed,
or
under
the
control
of
the
judicial
branch
related
12
to
the
performance
by
the
courts
of
their
judicial
functions.
13
The
bill
provides
that
the
supreme
court
shall
prescribe
rules
14
governing
access
to
such
records
consistent
with
the
purposes
15
of
Code
chapter
22.
16
IOWA
PUBLIC
INFORMATION
BOARD.
The
bill
creates
the
Iowa
17
public
information
board
to
provide
an
alternative
means
18
by
which
to
secure
compliance
with
and
enforcement
of
the
19
requirements
of
Code
chapters
21
and
22,
to
consist
of
five
20
members
appointed
by
the
governor,
subject
to
confirmation
by
21
the
senate,
to
serve
four-year
staggered
terms.
The
board
22
shall
be
balanced
as
to
political
affiliation
and
gender.
23
Vacancies
on
the
board
shall
be
filled
by
the
governor
by
24
appointment
for
the
unexpired
part
of
the
term
of
the
vacancy.
25
Any
board
member
may
be
removed
from
office
by
the
governor
26
for
good
cause.
The
board
shall
select
one
of
its
members
to
27
serve
as
chair
and
shall
hire
a
director
who
shall
serve
as
the
28
executive
officer
of
the
board.
Board
members
shall
be
paid
29
a
per
diem
and
shall
be
reimbursed
for
actual
and
necessary
30
expenses
incurred
while
on
official
board
business.
All
per
31
diem
and
expense
moneys
paid
to
board
members
shall
be
paid
32
from
funds
appropriated
to
the
board.
The
board
shall
not
33
have
jurisdiction
over
the
judicial
or
legislative
branches
of
34
state
government
or
any
entity,
officer,
or
employee
of
those
35
-25-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
25/
29
H.F.
205
branches,
or
over
the
governor
or
the
office
of
the
governor,
1
but
the
bill
does
not
alter
the
current
applicability
of
Code
2
chapter
22
and
the
enforcement
mechanisms
provided
in
Code
3
chapter
22
to
the
office
of
the
governor.
4
The
bill
provides
that
any
aggrieved
person,
any
taxpayer
to
5
or
citizen
of
the
state
of
Iowa,
the
attorney
general,
or
any
6
county
attorney,
may
seek
enforcement
of
the
requirements
of
7
Code
chapters
21
and
22
by
electing
either
to
file
an
action
8
pursuant
to
Code
section
17A.19,
21.6,
or
22.9,
whichever
is
9
applicable,
or
in
the
alternative,
to
file
a
timely
complaint
10
with
the
board.
If
more
than
one
person
seeks
enforcement
11
of
Code
chapter
21
or
22
with
respect
to
the
same
incident
12
involving
an
alleged
violation,
and
one
or
more
of
such
persons
13
elects
to
do
so
by
filing
an
action
under
Code
section
17A.19,
14
21.6,
or
22.9,
and
one
or
more
of
such
persons
elects
to
do
15
so
by
filing
a
timely
complaint
with
the
board,
the
court
in
16
which
the
action
was
filed
shall
dismiss
the
action
without
17
prejudice
authorizing
the
complainant
to
file
a
complaint
18
with
respect
to
that
same
incident
with
the
board
without
19
regard
to
the
timeliness
of
the
filing
of
that
complaint
at
20
the
time
the
action
in
court
is
dismissed.
If
a
person
files
21
an
action
seeking
to
enjoin
the
inspection
of
a
public
record,
22
the
respondent
or
person
requesting
access
to
the
record
which
23
is
the
subject
of
the
request
for
injunction,
may
remove
the
24
proceeding
to
the
board
for
its
determination
by
filing,
within
25
30
days
of
the
commencement
of
that
judicial
proceeding,
a
26
complaint
with
the
board
alleging
a
violation
of
Code
chapter
27
22
in
regard
to
the
same
matter.
28
The
bill
provides
that
the
board
shall
have
the
authority
29
to
employ
such
employees
as
are
necessary
to
execute
its
30
authority,
adopt
rules
with
the
force
of
law,
interpret
31
the
requirements
of
Code
chapters
21
and
22,
implement
any
32
authority
delegated
to
the
board,
issue
declaratory
orders
33
with
the
force
of
law,
issue
informal
advice
to
anyone
34
concerning
the
applicability
of
Code
chapters
21
and
22,
35
-26-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
26/
29
H.F.
205
receive
complaints
alleging
violations
of
Code
chapter
21
1
or
22,
seek
resolution
of
such
complaints
through
mediation
2
and
settlement,
formally
investigate
such
complaints,
decide
3
after
such
an
investigation
whether
there
is
probable
cause
4
to
believe
a
violation
of
Code
chapter
21
or
22
has
occurred,
5
and
if
probable
cause
has
been
found,
prosecute
the
respondent
6
before
the
board
in
a
contested
case
proceeding
conducted
7
according
to
the
provisions
of
Code
chapter
17A.
The
board
8
shall
also
have
the
authority
to
issue
subpoenas
enforceable
in
9
court,
issue
orders
with
the
force
of
law,
represent
itself
in
10
judicial
proceedings,
make
training
opportunities
available,
11
disseminate
information
to
inform
the
public
about
the
public’s
12
right
to
access
government
information,
prepare
and
transmit
13
reports
to
the
governor
and
the
general
assembly,
at
least
14
annually,
describing
complaints
received,
board
proceedings,
15
investigations,
hearings
conducted,
decisions
rendered,
and
16
other
work
performed
by
the
board,
and
make
recommendations
to
17
the
general
assembly
concerning
legislation
relating
to
public
18
information
access.
19
The
bill
provides
that
a
complaint
must
be
filed
within
20
60
days
from
the
time
the
alleged
violation
occurred
or
21
the
complainant
could
have
become
aware
of
the
violation
22
with
reasonable
diligence.
All
complaints
filed
with
the
23
board
shall
be
public
records.
The
board
shall
not
charge
a
24
complainant
any
fee
in
relation
to
the
filing
of
a
complaint,
25
the
processing
of
a
complaint,
or
any
board
proceeding
or
26
judicial
proceeding
resulting
from
the
filing
of
a
complaint.
27
The
bill
provides
that
upon
receipt
of
a
complaint,
the
28
board
shall
either
make
a
determination
that,
on
its
face,
the
29
complaint
is
within
the
board’s
jurisdiction,
appears
legally
30
sufficient,
and
could
have
merit,
in
which
case
the
board
shall
31
accept
the
complaint,
or
make
a
determination
that,
on
its
32
face,
the
complaint
is
outside
the
board’s
jurisdiction,
is
33
legally
insufficient,
is
frivolous,
is
without
merit,
involves
34
harmless
error,
or
relates
to
a
specific
incident
that
has
35
-27-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
27/
29
H.F.
205
previously
been
finally
disposed
of
on
its
merits
by
the
board
1
or
a
court,
in
which
case
the
board
shall
decline
to
accept
the
2
complaint.
If
the
board
declines
to
accept
the
complaint,
the
3
board
shall
provide
the
complainant
with
a
written
statement
4
detailing
the
reasons
for
the
denial.
5
After
accepting
a
complaint,
and
upon
the
board’s
6
determination
that
the
matter
is
unlikely
to
be
resolved
with
7
the
prompt
informal
assistance
of
a
board
employee,
the
board
8
shall
offer
the
parties
the
opportunity
to
resolve
the
dispute
9
through
mediation
and
settlement
which
shall
provide
the
10
complainant
the
opportunity
to
resolve
the
dispute
with
the
aid
11
of
a
neutral
mediator
employed
and
selected
by
the
board.
12
If
any
party
declines
mediation
or
settlement
or
if
13
mediation
or
settlement
fails
to
resolve
the
matter
to
the
14
satisfaction
of
all
parties,
the
board
shall
initiate
a
formal
15
investigation
concerning
the
facts
and
circumstances
set
forth
16
in
the
complaint.
After
investigation,
the
board
shall
make
17
a
determination
as
to
whether
the
complaint
is
within
the
18
board’s
jurisdiction
and
whether
there
is
probable
cause
to
19
believe
that
the
complaint
states
a
violation
of
Code
chapter
20
21
or
22
and
if
the
board
finds
the
complaint
is
outside
the
21
board’s
jurisdiction
or
there
is
not
probable
cause
to
believe
22
there
has
been
a
violation,
the
board
shall
issue
a
written
23
order
explaining
the
reasons
for
the
board’s
conclusions
and
24
dismissing
the
complaint.
If
the
board
finds
the
complaint
is
25
within
the
board’s
jurisdiction
and
there
is
probable
cause
26
to
believe
there
has
been
a
violation,
the
board
shall
issue
27
a
written
order
to
that
effect
and
shall
commence
a
contested
28
case
proceeding
against
the
respondent.
An
attorney
selected
29
by
the
director
of
the
board
shall
prosecute
the
respondent
30
in
the
contested
case
proceeding.
At
the
termination
of
the
31
contested
case
proceeding
the
board
shall,
by
a
majority
vote
32
of
its
members,
render
a
final
decision
as
to
the
merits
of
the
33
complaint
and
issue
any
appropriate
order
to
ensure
enforcement
34
of
Code
chapter
21
or
22
or
to
remedy
any
failure
of
the
35
-28-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
28/
29
H.F.
205
respondent
to
observe
any
provision
of
those
Code
chapters.
If
1
the
board
determines,
by
a
majority
vote
of
its
members,
that
2
the
respondent
has
violated
Code
chapter
21
or
22,
the
board
3
may
also
require
the
respondent
to
pay
damages
if
such
damages
4
would
be
warranted
under
either
Code
chapter
and
may
void
5
any
action
taken
in
violation
of
Code
chapter
21.
The
board
6
does
not
have
the
authority
to
remove
a
person
from
public
7
office
for
a
violation
of
Code
chapter
21
or
22
but
may
file
8
an
action
under
either
Code
chapter
to
remove
a
person
from
9
office
for
violations
that
would
subject
a
person
to
removal
10
under
those
Code
chapters.
A
final
board
order
resulting
from
11
such
proceedings
may
be
enforced
by
the
board
in
court
and
is
12
subject
to
judicial
review
pursuant
to
Code
section
17A.19.
13
-29-
LSB
1739HH
(4)
84
rh/rj
29/
29